Only a few studies of the lower federal court confirmation process consider the role of the race/gender of nominees in that process and none consider the intersection of party politics with those characteristics. We address this deficiency, arguing that the different electoral incentive structures of the two major parties have consequences for the treatment of minority and female nominees. The levels of minority and female support enjoyed by the Democratic Party, as well as the Republican Party’s desire to shed its reputation as being insensitive to issues of importance to those constituencies, lead us to expect that the nominations of minorities and women will be handled most expeditiously under conditions of unified Republican control, followed by unified Democratic control, divided control with a Republican president and divided control with a Democratic president. Our empirical analysis provides partial support for this hierarchy and demonstrates the importance of considering the conditioning effect of partisan politics.
Alesina, Alberto and Howard Rosenthal (1995) Partisan Politics, Divided Government, and the Economy. New York: Cambridge University Press .
2.
Allison, Garland W. (1996) ‘Delay in the Senate Confirmation of Federal Court Nominees’ , Judicature80: 8-15 .
3.
American Bar Association (1997) An Independent Judiciary: Report of the ABA Commission on Separation of Powers and Judicial Independence. Available at http://www.abanet.org/govaffairs/judiciary/home.html.
4.
Beck, Paul Allen and Frank J. Sorauf (1992) Party Politics in America, 7th edn. New York: Harper Collins Publishers .
5.
Bell, Lauren Cohen (2002a) ‘Senatorial Discourtesy: The Senate’s Use of Delay to Shape the Federal Judiciary’ , Political Research Quarterly55: 589-607 .
6.
Bell, Lauren Cohen (2002b) Warring Factions: Interest Groups, Money and the New Politics of Senate Confirmation. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press .
7.
Berelson, Bernard R. , Paul F. Lazarsfeld and William N. McPhee (1954) Voting: A Study of Opinion Formation in a Presidential Campaign. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
8.
Bibby, John F. (2000) Politics, Parties, and Elections in America, 4th edn.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth .
9.
Binder, Sarah A. and Forrest Maltzman (2002) ‘Senatorial Delay in Confirming Judges, 1947-1998’ , American Journal of Political Science46: 190-199 .
10.
Black, Merle (1979) ‘Regional and Partisan Bases of Congressional Support for the Changing Agenda of Civil Rights Legislation’ , Journal of Politics41: 665-679 .
11.
Bond, Jon R. and Richard Fleisher (1990) The President in the Legislative Arena. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
12.
Bond, Jon R. and Richard Fleisher (2000) Polarized Politics: Congress and the President in a Partisan Era. Washington DC: CQ Press .
13.
Box-Steffensmeier, Janet M. and Bradford S. Jones (1997) ‘Time is of the Essence: Event History Models in Political Science’ , American Journal of Political Science41: 1414-1461 .
14.
Box-Steffensmeier, Janet M. , Laura W. Arnold and Christopher J. W. Zorn (1997) ‘The Strategic Timing of Position Taking in Congress: A Study of the American Free Trade Agreement’ , American Political Science Review91: 324-338 .
15.
Box-Steffensmeier, Janet M. and Christopher J. W. Zorn (2001) ‘Duration Models and Proportional Hazards in Political Science’ , American Journal of Political Science45: 951-967 .
16.
Bratton, Kathleen A. and Kerry L. Haynie (1999) ‘Agenda Setting and Legislative Success in State Legislatures: The Effects of Gender and Race’ , Journal of Politics61: 658-679 .
17.
Bratton, Kathleen A. and Rorie L. Spill (2002) ‘Existing Diversity and Judicial Selection: The Role of the Appointment Method in Establishing Gender Diversity in State Supreme Courts’ , Social Science Quarterly83: 504-518 .
18.
Calvert, Randall L. and Richard F. Fenno, Jr. (1994) ‘Strategy and Sophisticated Voting in the Senate’ , Journal of Politics56: 349-376 .
19.
Cameron, Charles M. and Jeffrey A. Segal (1999) ‘The Politics of Scandals: The Case of Supreme Court Nominations, 1877-1994’ . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, 15 to 17 April.
20.
Campbell, Angus (1966) ‘Surge and Decline: A Study of Electoral Change’, in Angus Campbell , Philip E. Converse , Warren E. Miller and Donald E. Stokes (eds) Elections and the Political Order, pp. 40-62. New York: Wiley .
21.
Canes-Wrone, Brandice and Scott de Marchi (2002) ‘The President’s Ability to Capitalize on Approval for Legislative Success’ , Journal of Politics64: 491-509 .
22.
Carmines, Edward G. and James A. Stimson (1989) Issue Evolution: Race and the Transformation of American Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
23.
Chaney, Carole Kennedy, R.Michael Alvarez and Jonathan Nagler (1998) ‘Explaining the Gender Gap in U.S. Presidential Elections, 1980-1992’ , Political Research Quarterly51: 311-339 .
24.
Chase, Harold (1972) Federal Judges: The Appointing Process. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press .
25.
Citizens for Independent Courts (2000) Uncertain Justice: Politics and America’s Courts. New York: Century Foundation Press .
26.
Cole, Kenneth (1937) ‘Mr. Justice Black and “Senatorial Courtesy”’ , American Political Science Review31: 1113-1115 .
27.
Cronin, Thomas (1975) The State of the Presidency. Boston, MA: Little, Brown .
28.
Edwards, III , George C. (1980) Presidential Influences in Congress. San Francisco, CA: Freeman .
29.
Fleisher, Richard and Jon R. Bond (2001) ‘Evidence of Increasing Polarization Among Ordinary Citizens’, in Jeffrey E. Cohen , Richard Fleisher and Paul Kantor (eds) American Political Parties: Decline or Resurgence?, pp. 55-77. Washington DC: CQ Press .
30.
Giles, Michael W. , Virginia A. Hettinger and Todd Peppers (2001) ‘Picking Federal Judges: A Note on Policy and Partisan Selection Agendas’ , Political Research Quarterly54: 623-641 .
31.
Goldman, Sheldon (1966) ‘Voting Behavior on the United States Courts of Appeals, 1961-64’ , American Political Science Review60: 374-383 .
32.
Goldman, Sheldon (1967) ‘Judicial Appointments to the United States Courts of Appeals’ , Wisconsin Law Review86: 186-214 .
33.
Goldman, Sheldon (1997) Picking Federal Judges. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
34.
Grofman, Bernard , Samuel Merrill , Thomas L. Brunell and William Koetzle (1999) ‘The Potential Electoral Disadvantages of a Catch-all Party - Ideological Variance Among Republicans and Democrats in the 50 U.S. States’ , Party Politics5: 199-210 .
35.
Grofman, Bernard , Thomas L. Brunell and William Koetzle (1998) ‘Why Gain in the Senate But Midterm Loss in the House? Evidence from a Natural Experiment’ , Legislative Studies Quarterly23: 79-89 .
36.
Gryski, Gerard S. , Gary Zuk and Deborah J. Barrow (1994) ‘A Bench that Looks Like America? Representation of African Americans and Latinos on the Federal Courts’ , Journal of Politics56: 1076-1086 .
37.
Hartley, Roger E. (2001) ‘A Look at Race, Gender, and Experience’ , Judicature84: 191-197 .
38.
Hartley, Roger E. and Lisa Holmes (1997) ‘Increasing Senate Scrutiny of Lower Federal Court Nominees’ , Judicature80: 274-278 .
39.
Hartley, Roger E. and Lisa Holmes (2002) ‘The Increasing Senate Scrutiny of Lower Federal Court Nominees’ , Political Science Quarterly117: 259-278 .
40.
Hibbs, Douglas (1977) ‘Political Parties and Macroeconomic Policy’ , American Political Science Review71: 1467-1487 .
41.
Huckfeldt, Robert and Carol W. Kohfeld (1989) Race and the Decline of Class in American Politics. Urbana: University of Illinois Press .
42.
Kernell, Samuel (1986) Going Public: New Strategies of Presidential Leadership. Washington, DC: CQ Press .
43.
Krislov, Samuel (1974) Representative Bureaucracy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .
44.
Krutz, Glen S. , Richard Fleisher and Jon R. Bond (1998) ‘From Abe Fortas to Zoë Baird: Why Some Presidential Nominations Fail in the Senate’ , American Political Science Review92: 871-881 .
45.
Mansbridge, Jane (1999) ‘Should Blacks Represent Blacks and Women Represent Women? A Contingent “Yes”’ , Journal of Politics61: 628-657 .
46.
Martinek, Wendy L. (2001) Lower Federal Court Confirmation Database, 1977-2000. Computer File: http://www.polisci.msu.edu/pljp/databases.html.
47.
Martinek, Wendy L. , Mark Kemper and Steven R. Van Winkle (2002) ‘To Advise and Consent: The Senate and Lower Federal Court Nominations, 1977-1998’ , Journal of Politics64: 337-361 .
48.
Massie, Tajuana , Thomas G. Hansford and Donald R. Songer (2004) ‘The Timing of Presidential Nominations to the Lower Federal Courts’ , Political Research Quarterly57: 145-154 .
49.
McCarty, Nolan and Rose Razaghian (1999) ‘Advice and Consent: Senate Response to Executive Branch Nominations 1885-1996’ , American Journal of Political Science43: 1122-1143 .
50.
Merrill, Samuel , Bernard Grofman , Thomas L. Brunell and William Koetzle (1999) ‘The Power of Ideologically Concentrated Minorities’ , Journal of Theoretical Politics11: 57-74 .
51.
Moraski, Bryon J. and Charles R. Shipan (1999) ‘The Politics of Supreme Court Nominations: A Theory of Institutional Constraints and Choices’ , American Journal of Political Science43: 1069-1095 .
52.
Mueller, Carol M. (1988) ‘The Empowerment of Women: Polling and the Women’s Voting Bloc’, in Carol M. Mueller (ed.) The Politics of Gender: The Social Construction of Political Influence, pp. 16-36. Newbury Park, CA: Sage .
53.
Neustadt, Richard (1960) Presidential Power. New York: Wiley .
54.
Nixon, David C. and David L. Goss (2001) ‘Confirmation Delay for Vacancies on the Circuit Courts of Appeals’ , American Politics Research29: 246-274 .
55.
Norrander, Barbara (1999) ‘The Evolution of the Gender Gap’ , Public Opinion Quarterly63: 566-576 .
56.
Peltason, Jack (1955) Federal Courts in the Political Process. Garden City, NY: Doubleday .
57.
Peterson, Mark (1990) Legislating Together: The White House and Capitol Hill from Eisenhower to Reagan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
58.
Pitkin, Hanna (1967) The Concept of Representation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press .
59.
Poole, Keith (1998) ‘Recovering a Basic Space From a Set of Issue Scales’ , American Journal of Political Science42: 954-993 .
60.
Robinson, Pearl (1982) ‘Whither the Future of Blacks in the Republican Party?’ , Political Science Quarterly97: 207-231 .
61.
Shipan, Charles R. and Megan L. Shannon (2001) ‘Delaying Justice(s): A Duration Analysis of Supreme Court Confirmations’ . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, San Francisco, 30 August to 2 September 2001.
62.
Songer, Donald R. and Sue Davis (1990) ‘The Impact of Party and Region on Voting Decisions in the United States Courts of Appeals, 1955-1986’ , Western Political Quarterly43: 317-334
63.
Songer, Donald R. and Susan Haire (1992) ‘Integrating Alternative Approaches to the Study of Judicial Voting: Obscenity Cases in the U.S. Courts of Appeals’ , American Journal of Political Science36: 963-982 .
64.
Songer, Donald R. , Sue Davis and Susan Haire (1994) ‘A Reappraisal of Diversification in the Federal Courts: Gender Effects in the Courts of Appeals’ , Journal of Politics56: 425-439 .
65.
Uhlman, Thomas M. (1977) ‘Race, Recruitment, and Representation: Background Differences Between Black and White Trial Court Judges’ , Western Political Quarterly30: 457-470 .
66.
Uhlman, Thomas M. (1978) ‘Black Elite Decision Making: The Case of Trial Judges’ , American Journal of Political Science22: 884-895 .
67.
Walker, Thomas G. and Deborah J. Barrow (1985) ‘The Diversification of the Federal Bench: Policy and Process Ramifications’ , Journal of Politics47: 596-617 .
68.
Weisburg, Herbert (1987) ‘The Demographics of a New Voting Gap: Marital Differences in American Voting’ , Public Opinion Quarterly51: 335-343 .
69.
Yates, Jeff (2003) Popular Justice: Presidential Prestige and Executive Success in the Supreme Court. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press .
