Matusov distinguishes two usually counterposed modern schools of psychology that stem
from Vygotsky's theory, the sociocultural and cultural-historical. I suggest that
the sociocultural approach is fundamentally deficient in ignoring a need for
cognitive analysis and not taking seriously the notion of hierarchical development.
Problems that arise from the acognitive-adevelopmental position of the sociocultural
approach are analyzed in respect of three issues: ethnocentrism, the
natural-cultural line of development, and testing in education. The
cultural-historical approach, in turn, is deficient in ignoring cultural diversity
and the content of the psyche. The superficially opposed sociocultural and
cultural-historical Vygotskian schools complement each other if it is realized that
both schools represent different levels of analysis.
Cole, M.
(1996). Cultural psychology. A once and future
discipline . Cambridge, MA: The
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
2.
Cole, M.
, &
Scribner, S.
(1974). Culture and thought: A psychological
introduction . New York:
Wiley.
3.
James, W.
(1950). The principles of psychology (2 vols.).
New York:
Dover. (Original work published
1890)
4.
Kikas, E.
(2003). Constructing knowledge beyond senses: Worlds too big
and too small to see. In
A. Toomela
(Ed.), Cultural guidance in the development of the human mind (pp.
211—227). Westport,
CT: Ablex.
5.
Lotman, J.M.
(1978).
Dinamicheskaya model' semioticheskoi sistemy
. Acta et Commentationes Universitatis Tartuensis,
464,
18—33.
Matusov, E.
(2008).
Applying a sociocultural approach to Vygotskian academia: `Our tsar isn't
like yours, and yours isn't like ours'
. Culture & Psychology, 14(1),
5—35.
12.
Nelson, K.
(2003). Making sense in a world of symbols. In
A. Toomela
(Ed.), Cultural guidance in the development of the human mind (pp.
139—161). Westport,
CT: Ablex.
13.
Tomasello, M.
(1996).
The child's contribution to culture: A commentary on Toomela
. Culture & Psychology, 2,
307—318.
14.
Toomela, A.
(1996a).
How culture transforms mind: A process of internalization
. Culture & Psychology, 2,
285—305.
15.
Toomela, A.
(1996b).
What characterizes language that can be internalized: A reply to
Tomasello
. Culture & Psychology, 2,
319—322.
16.
Toomela, A.
(2000a).
Activity theory is a dead end for cultural-historical psychology
. Culture & Psychology, 6,
353—364.
17.
Toomela, A.
(2000b).
Stages of mental development: Where to look? Trames: Journal of the
Humanities andSocial Sciences, 4,
21—52.
18.
Toomela, A.
(2003a). Afterword: Animals, brain, culture, and
children—The emerging picture from complementary perspectives.
In
A. Toomela
(Ed.), Cultural guidance in the development of the human mind (pp.
229—241). Westport,
CT: Ablex.
19.
Toomela, A.
(2003b). Culture as a semiosphere: On the role of culture in
the culture—individual relationship. In
I.E. Josephs
(Ed.), Dialogicality in development (pp.
129—163). Westport,
CT: Praeger.
20.
Toomela, A.
(2003c). Development of symbol meaning and the emergence of
the semiotically mediated mind. In
A. Toomela
(Ed.), Cultural guidance in the development of the human mind (pp.
163—209). Westport,
CT: Ablex.
21.
Toomela, A.
(2003d). Hoiakud alkoholi ja narkootikumide tarbimise suhtes
kutsealustel ja Eesti kaitseväelastel: Hoiakute muutmise
võimalused. Rahvatervisealane teadus- ja arendustegevuse riiklik
sihtprogramm: Ülevaade 1999—2002. aasta tulemustest.
Tallinn: OÜ Lege
Artis.
22.
Toomela, A.
(2007).
Culture of science: Strange history of the methodological thinking in
psychology
. Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science,
41,
6—20.
23.
Tulviste, P.
(1988). Kul'turno-istoricheskoje razvitije verbal'nogo
myshlenija. Tallinn:
Valgus.
24.
Vygotsky, L.S.
(1956a). K probleme psikhologii shizophrenii. In
L.S. Vygotsky.Izbrannyje psikhologicheskije issledovanija (pp.
481—496).
Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Akademii
Pedagogicheskih Nauk RSFSR. (Original work published
1932)
25.
Vygotsky, L.S.
(1956b). Razvitije vyshikh form vnimanija v detskom
vozraste . In
L.S. Vygotsky.Izbrannyje psikhologicheskije issledovanija (pp.
389—425).
Moscow : Izdatel'stvo Akademii
Pedagogicheskih Nauk RSFSR . (Original work published
1929)
26.
Vygotsky, L.S.
(1960). Lekcii po psikhologii. In
L.S. Vygotsky.Razvitie vyshikh psikhicheskih funkcii. Iz neopublikovannykh trudov (pp.
233—363).
Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Akademii
Pedagogicheskih nauk. (Originally published as lectures
in 1932)
27.
Vygotsky, L.S.
(1983). K voprosu o kompensatornykh processah v razvitii
umstvenno otstalogo rebjonka. In
A.V. Zaporozhec
(Ed.),
L. S. Vygotsky.Sobranije sochinenii: Tom 5. Osnovy defektologii (pp.
115—136).
Moscow:
Pedagogika. (Original work written
1931)
28.
Vygotsky, L.S.
(1996). Myshlenije i rech.
Moscow: Labirint.
(Original work published 1934.)
Vygotsky, L.S.
, &
Luria, A.
(1994). Tool and symbol in child development. In
R. van der Veer
&
J. Valsiner
(Eds.), The Vygotsky reader (pp.
99—174). Oxford:
Blackwell. (Original work written
1930)
