In this paper I present an approach to understanding the dialogical self that
considers the role that social, cultural and institutional dynamics of domination
and subordination, and structures of power of privilege, play in the development of
identity. To accomplish this I expand Penuel and Wertsch’s (1995)
‘mediated action’ approach to identity development to include a
dialogical process of what Mikhail Bakhtin (1981) calls ‘ideological
becoming’. Using the Autobiography of Malcolm X as an
illustrative example, I argue that the development of Malcolm’s identity,
via the process of ideological becoming, is influenced in profound ways by his
experience of subordination and oppression, and his lack of power and privilege,
growing up as a black man in the United States in the first half of the 20th
century. Thus the ‘politics of ideological becoming’
refers to the degree to which the process of identity formation is necessarily
different for persons from different social locations, who stand in different
relationship to structures and systems of power, privilege and authority.
Arievitch, I.
, &
van der Veer, R.
(1995).
Furthering the internalization debate: Gal’perin’s contribution
. Human Development, 38,
113–126
.
2.
Bakhtin, M.
(1981). The dialogic imagination (
M. Holquist
, Ed.; C. Emerson & M. Holquist, Trans.).
Austin: University of Texas Press
.
3.
Bakhtin, M.
(1984). Problems of Dostoevsky’s poetics (
C. Emerson
, Ed. & Trans.).
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
.
4.
Bartky, S.
(1990). Femininity and domination.
New York: Routledge
.
5.
Bellamy, E.
(1998).
‘Intimate enemies:’ Psychoanalysis, Marxism, and
postcolonial affect
. South Atlantic Quarterly, 97(2),
341–359
.
6.
Bhatia, S.
(2002).
Acculturation, dialogical voices and the construction of the diasporic self
. Theory & Psychology, 12,
55–77
.
7.
Bhatia, S.
, &
Ram, A.
(2001a).
Locating the dialogical self in the age of transnational migrations, border
crossings and diasporas
. Culture & Psychology, 7,
297–309
.
8.
Bhatia, S.
, &
Ram, A.
(2001b).
Rethinking ‘acculturation’ in relation to diasporic
cultures and postcolonial identities
. Human Development, 44,
1–17
.
9.
Blasi, A.
(1984). Moral identity: Its role in moral
functioning. In
W. Kurtines
&
J. Gewirtz
(Eds.), Morality, moral behavior, and moral development (pp.
128–139).
New York: Wiley
.
10.
Brantlinger, E.
(2003). Dividing classes: How the middle class negotiates and
rationalizes school advantage.
New York: Routledge Falmer
.
11.
Brown, L.
(1998). Raising their voices: The politics of
girls’ anger.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
12.
Bruner, J.
(1990). Acts of meaning.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
13.
Burke, K.
(1966). Language as symbolic action: Essays on life,
literature, and method.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
14.
Burke, K.
(1969). A grammar of motives.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
15.
Butler, J.
(1991). Imitation and gender insubordination. In
D. Fuss
(Ed.), Inside/out: Lesbian theories, gay theories (pp.
637–648).
New York: Routledge
.
16.
Chandler, M.
(2002, October).
Reconstructing the self in the face of cultural loss: Suicide and the
construction of life trajectories in Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal youth
. Paper presented at the Second International Conference on the
Dialogical Self, Ghent, Belgium.
17.
Cole, M.
(1996). Cultural psychology: A once and future
discipline.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
18.
Cross, W.
(1991). Shades of black: Diversity in African-American
identity.
Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
.
19.
Day, J.
(1991). The moral audience: On the narrative mediation of
moral ‘judgment’ and moral
‘action’. In
M. Tappan
&
M. Packer
(Eds.), Narrative and storytelling: Implications for understanding moral
development (New directions for child development, No. 54, pp.
27–42).
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
.
20.
Day, J.
, &
Tappan, M.
(1996).
The narrative approach to moral development: From the epistemic subject to
dialogical selves
. Human Development, 32,
67–82
.
21.
Du Bois, W.E.B.
(1995). The souls of black folks.
New York: New American Library
. (Original work published 1903.)
22.
Dyson, M.
(1995). Making Malcolm: The myth and meaning of Malcolm
X.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
23.
Eagleton, T.
(1990). The ideology of the aesthetic.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
24.
Emerson, C.
(1986). The outer word and inner speech: Bakhtin,
Vygotsky, and the internalization of language. In
G. Morson
(Ed.), Bakhtin: Essays and dialogues on his work (pp.
21–40).
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
25.
Erikson, E.
(1968). Identity: Youth and crisis.
New York: Norton
.
26.
Fanon, F.
(1963). The wretched of the earth.
New York: Grove
.
27.
Fanon, F.
(1967). Black skin, white masks.
New York: Grove
.
28.
Fine, M.
(1997). Witnessing whiteness. In
M. Fine
,
L. Weiss
,
L. Powell
, &
L.M. Wong
(Eds.), Off white: Readings on race, power, and society (pp.
57–65).
New York: Routledge
.
29.
Foster, D.
(1993). The mark of oppression? Racism and psychology
reconsidered. In
L. Nicholas
(Ed.), Psychology and oppression: Critiques and proposals (pp.
129–141).
Johannesburg: Scotaville
.
30.
Freire, P.
(1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed.
New York: Continuum
.
31.
Garz, D., & Tappan, M. (2001). Das kompetente und das dialogische
moralische Selbst. Handlung–Kultur–Interpretation,
10, 246–272.
32.
Gilligan, C.
(1982). In a different voice.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
33.
Gramsci, A.
(1971). Selections from the prison notebooks. (
Q. Hoare
&
G.N. Smith
, Eds.).
New York: International
.
34.
Harvey, J.
(1999). Civilized oppression.
New York: Routledge
.
35.
Hasselbach, I.
(1996). Fuhrer-ex: Memoirs of a former neo-Nazi.
New York: Random House
.
36.
Helms, J.
(1993). Black and white racial identity: Theory, research,
and practice.
Westport, CT: Praeger
.
37.
Hermans, H.
(1996).
Voicing the self: From information processing to dialogical interchange
. Psychological Bulletin, 119,
31–50
.
38.
Hermans, H.
(2001).
The dialogical self: Toward a theory of personal and cultural positioning
. Culture & Psychology, 7,
243–281
.
39.
Hermans, H.
, &
Kempen, H.
(1993). The dialogical self: Meaning as movement.
New York: Academic Press
.
40.
Hermans, H.
, &
Kempen, H.
(1998).
Moving cultures: The perilous problems of cultural dichotomies in a
globalizing society
. American Psychologist, 53,
1111–1120
.
41.
Hermans, H.
,
Kempen, H.
, &
van Loon, R.
(1992).
The dialogical self: Beyond individualism and rationalism
. American Psychologist, 47,
23–33
.
42.
Holland, D.
,
Lachicotte, W.
,
Skinner, D.
, &
Cain, C.
(1998). Identity and agency in cultural worlds.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
43.
James, W.
(1958). The varieties of religious experience.
New York: New American Library
. (Original work published 1902.)
44.
Kardiner, A.
, &
Ovesey, L.
(1951). The mark of oppression: A psychological study of the
American Negro.
Cleveland, OH: World
.
45.
Kimmel, M.
, &
Ferber, A.
(Eds.). (2003). Privilege.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
46.
Lawrence, J.
, &
Valsiner, J.
(1993).
Conceptual roots of internalization: From transmission to transformation
. Human Development, 36,
150–167
.
47.
Lightfoot, C.
(1997). The culture of adolescent risk taking.
New York: Guilford
.
48.
Malcolm X.
(1964). The autobiography of Malcolm X.
New York: Ballantine
.
49.
Memmi, A.
(1967). The colonizer and the colonized.
Boston, MA: Beacon
.
50.
Miller, J.B.
(1976). Toward a new psychology of women.
Boston, MA: Beacon
.
51.
Packer, M.
(1993). Away from internalization. In
E. Forman
,
N. Minick
, &
C.A. Stone
(Eds.), Contexts for learning: Sociocultural dynamics in
children’s development (pp.
254–265).
New York: Oxford University Press
.
52.
Packer, M.
, &
Tappan, M.
(Eds.). (2001). Cultural and critical perspectives on human
development.
Albany: State University of New York Press
.
53.
Penuel, W.
, &
Wertsch, J.
(1995).
Vygotsky and identity formation: A sociocultural approach
. Educational Psychologist, 30,
83–92
.
54.
Perry, B.
(1991). Malcolm: The life of a man who changed black
America.
New York: Station Hill
.
55.
Pharr, S.
(1988). Homophobia: A weapon of sexism.
Little Rock, AR: Chardon Press
.
56.
Pheterson, G.
(1990). Alliances between women: Overcoming internalized
oppression and internalized domination. In
L. Albrecht
&
R. Brewer
(Eds.), Bridges of power: Women’s multicultural
alliances (pp. 34–48).
Philadelphia, PA: New Society Publishers
.
57.
Roberts, S.
(1983, July). Oppressed group behavior: Implications for
nursing. Advances in Nursing Science, pp. 21–30.
58.
Rogoff, B.
(1990). Apprenticeship in thinking: Cognitive development in
social context.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
59.
Rogoff, B.
(1995). Observing sociocultural activity on three planes:
Participatory appropriation, guided participation, and apprenticeship.
In
J. Wertsch
,
P. del Rio
, &
A. Alvarez
(Eds.), Sociocultural studies of mind (pp.
139–164).
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
60.
Sampson, E.
(1993). Celebrating the other: A dialogical account of human
nature.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
61.
Sennett, R.
, &
Cobb, J.
(1972). The hidden injuries of class.
New York: Vintage
.
62.
Sherover-Marcuse, E.
(1986). Emancipation and consciousness: Dogmatic and
dialectical perspectives in the early Marx.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
63.
Tappan, M.
(1991). Narrative, authorship, and the development of
moral authority. In
M. Tappan
&
M. Packer
(Eds.), Narrative and storytelling: Implications for understanding moral
development (New directions for child development, No. 54).
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
64.
Tappan, M.
(1992). Texts and contexts: Language, culture, and the
development of moral functioning. In
L.T. Winegar
&
J. Valsiner
(Eds.), Children’s development within social contexts:
Metatheoretical, theoretical, and methodological issues (pp.
93–117).
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
.
65.
Tappan, M.
(1997a).
Analyzing stories of moral experience: Narrative, voice, and the dialogical self
. Journal of Narrative and Life History, 7,
379–386
.
66.
Tappan, M.
(1997b).
Language, culture, and moral development: A Vygotskian perspective
. Developmental Review, 17,
78–100
.
67.
Tappan, M.
(1998).
Toward a dialogic conception of human development
. Narrative Inquiry, 8,
391–396
.
68.
Tappan, M.
(1999a).
Authoring a moral self: A dialogical perspective
. Journal of Constructivist Psychology, 12,
117–131
.
69.
Tappan, M.
(1999b). Moral development in a postmodern world.
In
R. Mosher
,
D. Youngman
, &
J. Day
(Eds.), Human development across the life span: Educational and
psychological applications (pp. 23–47).
New York: Praeger
.
70.
Tappan, M.
(2000).
Autobiography, mediated action, and the development of moral identity
. Narrative Inquiry, 10,
1–36
.
71.
Tappan, M. (2004). Internalized oppression and internalized domination: A
sociocultural re-interpretation. Unpublished manuscript, Colby College, ME.
72.
Tatum, B.
(1997). ‘Why are all the Black kids sitting
together in the cafeteria?’New York: Basic Books
.
73.
Thompson, J.
(1990). Ideology and modern culture.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
74.
Valsiner, J.
(1998). The guided mind.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
75.
Vygotsky, L.
(1978). Mind in society: The development of higher
psychological processes (
M. Cole
,
V. John-Steiner
,
S. Scribner
, &
E. Souberman
, Eds.).
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
76.
Vygotsky, L.
(1981). The instrumental method in psychology. In
J. Wertsch
(Ed.), The concept of activity in Soviet psychology (pp.
134–143).
Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe
.
77.
Vygotsky, L.
(1987). The collected works of L.S. Vygotsky, Vol. 1:
Problems of general psychology (
R. Rieber
&
A. Carton
, Eds.; N. Minick, Trans.).
New York: Plenum
.
78.
Werner, H.
(1957). The concept of development from a comparative and
organismic point of view. In
D. Harris
(Ed.), The concept of development.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
.
79.
Werner, H.
, &
Kaplan, B.
(1956).
The developmental approach to cognition: Its relevance to the psychological
interpretation of anthropological and ethnolinguistic data
. American Anthropologist, 58,
866–880
.
80.
Wertsch, J.
(1985). Vygotsky and the social formation of mind.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
81.
Wertsch, J.
(1991). Voices of the mind: A sociocultural approach to
mediated action.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
82.
Wertsch, J.
(1993).
Commentary
. Human Development, 36,
168–171
.
83.
Wertsch, J.
(1995). The need for action in sociocultural
research. In
J. Wertsch
,
P. del Rio
, &
A. Alvarez
(Eds.), Sociocultural studies of mind (pp.
56–74).
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
84.
Wertsch, J.
(1998). Mind as action.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
85.
Willie, S.
(2003). Acting black: College, identity, and the performance
of race.
New York: Routledge
.
86.
Wolfenstein, E.
(1981). The victims of democracy: Malcolm X and the black
revolution.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
87.
Wortham, S.
(2001). Narratives in action: A strategy for research and
analysis.
New York: Teachers College Press
.
88.
Young, I.M.
(1990). Justice and the politics of difference.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
