The International Whaling Commission's moratorium on commercial whaling took effect in 1986, seemingly marking the adoption of a new norm, that commercial whaling was no longer acceptable. But this norm has failed to become institutionalized. This article uses the norm life-cycle approach as developed by Finnemore and Sikkink (1998) to account for this failure. The effort ran aground because the norm proved unexpectedly ambiguous, a supporting epistemic community failed to emerge, the norm conflicted with other powerful norms, the prestige of the key anti-whaling states declined relative that of whaling states, and NGO tactics failed to win over the publics in key whaling states and instead created a counter-boomerang effect. The attempt may have resulted in the emergence of an alternative norm, but actors must act now to institutionalize it.
ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation, Radio Australia) (2005) `Whaling and the Pacific Vote'; accessed 2 February 2007 at: http://www.abc.net.au/ra/news/infocus/s1400056.htm.
Andresen, Steinar (2001) `The Whaling Regime: "Good" Institutions but "Bad" Politics?', in Robert L. Friedheim (ed.) Toward a Sustainable Whaling Regime, pp. 235-65. Seattle , London and Edmonton: University of Washington and Canadian Circumpolar Institute.
4.
Andresen, Steinar (1998) `The Making and Implementation of Whaling Policies: Does Participation Make a Difference?', in David G. Victor, Kal Raustiala and Eugene B. Skolnikoff (eds) The Implementation and Effectiveness of International Environmental Commitments: Theory and Practice, pp. 431-74. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press and International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis.
5.
Aron, William (2001) `Science and the IWC', in Robert L. Friedheim (ed.) Toward a Sustainable Whaling Regime , pp. 105-23. Seattle, London and Edmonton : University of Washington and Canadian Circumpolar Institute.
6.
Bailey, Jennifer (2005) `Liberalism vs Statist Individualism: A Study of American and Norwegian NGOs on the Issue of Commercial Whaling', paper presented at the 46th Annual International Studies Association Convention, 1-5 March 2005, Honolulu, Hawaii.
7.
Brulle, Robert J. (2000) Agency, Democracy and Nature: The US Environmental Movement from a Critical Theory Perspective. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
8.
Burke, William T. (2001) `A New Whaling Agreement and International Law' , in Robert L. Friedheim (ed.) Toward a Sustainable Whaling Regime, pp. 51-80. Seattle , London and Edmonton: University of Washington and Canadian Circumpolar Institute.
9.
Callicott, J. Baird (1997) `Whaling in Sand County: A Dialectical Hunt for Land Ethical Answers to Questions About the Morality of Norwegian Minke Whale Catching', Colorado Journal of International Environmental Law and Policy8(1): 1-30.
10.
Chayes, Abram and Antonia Handler Chayes (1993) `On Compliance', International Organization47(2): 175-205.
11.
Cherfas, Jeremy (1989) The Hunting of the Whale. London : Penguin Books.
12.
Clapham, Phillip J. and C. Scott Baker (2002) `Whaling, Modern', in W.F. Perrin, B. Würsig and J.G.M. Thewisssen (eds) Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, pp 1328-32. New York: Academic Press.
13.
Cronkite, Walter (1978) `Radio address', reprinted in The Whale Watcher12(4/Fall): 12.
14.
D'Amato, Anthony and Sudhir K. Chopra (1991) `Whales: Their Emerging Right to Life', The American Journal of International Law85(1): 21-62.
15.
Day, David (1987) The Whale War. San Francisco, CA: The Sierra Club Books.
16.
DeSombre, Elizabeth (2000) Domestic Sources of International Environmental Policy: Industry, Environmentalists, and US Power. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
17.
ECO (2006) `St Kitts Declaration Concocted in Private', ECOLVIII (5): 1; accessed 2 February 2007 at: http://www.earthisland.org/IMMP/index.htm .
18.
Economist (2006) `Whaling and Gnashing of Teeth', 379(8483): 94.
19.
Esty, Daniel C., Mark Levy, Tanja Srebotnjak and Alexander de Sherbinin (2005) 2005 Environmental Sustainability Index: Benchmarking National Environmental Stewardship. New Haven, CT: Yale University/ Yale Center for Environmental Law and Policy. The 2005 Environmental Sustainability Index Report is available online at www.yale.edu/esi .
20.
Feraru, Anne Thompson (1974) `Transnational Political Interests and the Global Environment', International Organization28(1): 31-60.
21.
Finnemore, Martha and Kathryn Sikkink (1998) `International Norm Dynamics and Political Change', International Organization52(4): 887-917.
22.
Fiskaren (1997) `Fangere trues med sabotasje', 8 December.
23.
Florini, Ann (1996) `The Evolution of International Norms', International Studies Quarterly (Special Issue: Evolutionary Paradigms in the Social Sciences) : 40(3): 363-89.
24.
FOE (Friends of the Earth) (1978a) The Whale Manual. San Francisco, CA: Friends of the Earth.
25.
FOE (Friends of the Earth) (1978b) `In London, No News is Bad News for the Whales', Not Man Apart (Mid-August/September): 2-3.
26.
FOE (Friends of the Earth) (1979) `Pirate Whaler is Hunted', Not Man Apart (September).
27.
FOE (Friends of the Earth) (1997) `IWC Cuts Quotas; The Wait is On', Not Man Apart (Mid July-August): 9-10.
28.
FOE & PJ (Friends of the Earth & Project Jonah) (1973) A Report on Whaling and Australia's Role in the Slaughter of Whales. Melbourne: Friends of the Earth.
29.
Franck, Thomas (1992) `The Emerging Right to Democratic Governance', American Journal of International Law86(1): 46-91.
30.
Haas, Peter M. (1989) `Do Regimes Matter? Epistemic Communities and Mediterranean Pollution Control', International Organization43(3): 377-99.
31.
Hammond, Philip (1992) `Letter of Resignation'; downloaded 21 September 2006 from the High North Alliance website at: http://www.highnorth.no/Library/Management_Regimes/IWC/le-fr-th.htm .
32.
HNA (High North Alliance) (1996) `Greenpeace Actions Provoke Violence!', The International Harpoon2, 15 June; accessed 4 June 2006 at: http://www.high-north.no/Library/Movements/Greenpeace/gr-ac-pr.htm .
33.
HNA (High North Alliance) (1998) `Iceland Non-Lethal Whaling Again', International Harpoon4, 20 May.
34.
HNA (High North Alliance) (1999a) `Greenpeace Boat Shot in the Bow; Safety Zones Exist for a Reason, Says Whaler' , High North News 13 July; accessed 4 June 2006 at: http://www.highnorth.no/news/nedit.asp?which=230 .
35.
HNA (High North Alliance) (1999b) `Norway's Whaling Season Over; Whale Hunters and Watchers Hit by Bad Weather' , High North News 3 August; accessed 4 June 2006 at: http://www.highnorth.no/news/nedit.asp?which=231 .
ICR (Institute of Creation Research) (1994 ) Public Perception of Whaling. Tokyo: ICR.
38.
ICRW (International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling).Washington, 2 December 1946; available at: http://www.iwcoffice.org/commission/convention.htm.
39.
Keck, Margaret E. and Kathryn Sikkink (1998) Activists beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics. Ithaca, NY : Cornell Paperbacks/Cornell University Press.
40.
Lilly, John (1969) The Mind of the Dolphin: A Nonhuman Intelligence . New York: Discus Books Avon.
41.
Lynge, Aqqaluk (1992) `Inuit Culture and International Policy', in Franklyn Griffiths (ed.) Arctic Alternatives: Civility or Militarism in the Circumpolar North, pp. 94-9. Canadian Papers in Peace Studies No. 3. Toronto: Science for Peace Studies.
42.
McHugh, J.A. (1974) `The Role and History of the International Whaling Commission', in William E. Schevill, G. Carlton Ray and Kenneth S. Norris (eds) The Whale Problem, pp. 305-35. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
43.
McIntyre, Joan (ed.) (1974) Mind in the Waters: A Book to Celebrate the Consciousness of Whales and Dolphins . Toronto: McClelland and Stewart .
44.
NRDC (National Resources Defense Council) ( 2005) `Opening Statement' to annual meeting of the IWC, Ulsan Republic of Korea. Private communication from NRDC.
Ofstad, Solveig Lunke (2006) `Bærekraftig Utviklings Internasjonale `Livssyklus' . Master's Thesis in Political Science, Department of Sociology and Political Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology , June.
47.
Schoell, Mark (1999) `The Marine Mammal Protection Act and its Role in the Decline of San Diego's Tuna Fishing Industry', The Journal of San Diego History45(1). Net version ( http://www.sandiegohistory.org/journal/journal.htm), no page numbers available.
48.
Small, George (1971) The Blue Whale. New York: Columbia University Press.
49.
Sørensen, Heidi (1993) `Miljøbevegelsen og vågehvalfangst - Natur og ungdom' , in Nils Chr. Stenseth, Alf Håkon Hoel and Ingunn B. Lid (eds) Vågehvalen - valgets kval, pp. 183-6. Oslo : Ad Notam Gyldendal AS.
50.
SSCS (Sea Shepherd Conservation Society) ( 1997) `Greenpeace Activists Participate in the Slaughter of an Endangered Bowhead Whale', Sea Shepherd Conservation Society Media Release, 10 September.
51.
Stenseth, Nils Chr., Alf Håkon Hoel and Ingunn B. Lid (eds) (1993) Vågehvalen - valgets kval. Oslo: Ad Notam Gyldendal AS.
52.
Stoett, Peter J. (1997) The International Politics of Whaling. Vancouver: UBC Press.
53.
Tanno, Dai and Toshihide Hamazaki (2000) `Is American Opposition to Whaling Anti-Japanese?', Asian Affairs: An American Review27(2): 81-92.
54.
Tønnessen, J.N. and A.O. Johnsen (1982) The History of Modern Whaling. London and Canberra: C. Hurst & Company and Australian National University Press.
55.
Train, Russell E. (2003) Politics, Pollution, and Pandas: An Environmental Memoir. Washington, DC: Island Press /Shearwater Books.
56.
US Department of State (2003) `US Position on International Whaling Issues.'Bureau of Oceans and International Scientific Affairs, Fact Sheet, 16 June; accessed 2 February 2007 at: http://usinfo.state.gov/gi/Archive/2003/Jun/22-826867.html.
57.
US House of Representatives (1971) Hearings before the Subcommittee on International Organizations and Movements of the Committee on Foreign Affairs House of Representatives, 92nd Congress, First Session, 26 July.
58.
US House of Representatives (1985) US Policy with Respect to the International Protection of Whales. Hearing before the Committee on Foreign Affairs, 8 May, 19 June 1985. Washington, DC: USGPO.
59.
WCW (World Council of Whalers) (2005) `WCE Profile', WCW Home page; accessed 26 October 2005 at: www.worldcouncilofwhalers.com .
60.
Westdahl, Paula (1980) `The Nefarious Pirate Whalers', Not Man Apart (July): 15.
61.
WWF (World Wildlife Fund) (1985) `Panda Nytt: Foreløpig stopp I norsk hvalfangst?', Verdens natur (2): 28-30.
62.
WWF (World Wide Fund for Nature) (1996) `WWF's Campaign for Whale Conservation: Save the Whales'; accessed 19 February 1997 at: www.panda.org/research/w-whales/page4.htm .
