The perceived legitimacy of US foreign policy plummeted in the wake of the US-led
2003 invasion of Iraq. Most commentators would agree that international law, or at
least US actions in relation to international law, had something to do with this
decline. But, what the recent debate as to how best to restore US legitimacy has
starkly revealed, is that we know little as to just how international law accords
legitimacy to certain foreign policy endeavours. While the legality of the action
may have much to do with it, the relationship between international law, foreign
policy and legitimacy appears to be more complex than is suggested by a
straightforward legal–illegal categorization of behaviour. A theorization
of international law as ideology can provide an overall explanation of the role of
international law in the decline in US foreign policy legitimacy following the
invasion of Iraq.
Bennett, Drake
and
Heidi Pauken
(2003)
‘All the President's Lies’
, The American Prospect14(5); online at http://www.prospect.org/print-friendly/print/V14/5/bennett-d.html>.
2.
Betts, Richard K.
(2005)
‘The Political Support System for American Primacy’
, International Affairs81(1):
1–14
.
3.
Bush, George W. (2002) UN General Assembly in New York City Address, 12 September;<http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/09/20020912–1.html>.
4.
Clarke, R.A.
(2004) Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on
Terror.
New York: RAC Enterprises
.
5.
Claude, Inis L. Jr
(1966)
‘Collective Legitimization as a Political Function of the United Nations’
, International Organization20(3):
367–379
.
6.
Clinton, William J.
(1999) ‘Speech by the President to the Nation on
Kosovo’, 24 March; <http://www.clintonfoundation.org/legacy/032499-speech-by-the-president-to-the-nation-on-kosovo.htm>.
7.
Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment
or Punishment 23International Legal Materials1027.
8.
Cook, Robin
and
Menzies Campbell
(2000) ‘Revised Role in Humanitarian
Tragedies’; <http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/peacekpg/lessons/cook.htm>.
9.
Crook, C.
(2004)
‘The War in Iraq and the Wisdom of Hindsight’
, National Journal36(22), available at <http://nationaljournal.com/>.
10.
The Economist (2004)
‘The Weapons that Weren't — Intelligence Failures’
, 372(8384):
23–26
.
11.
Gowlland-Debbas, V.
(2000)
‘The Limits of Unilateral Enforcement of Community Objectives in
the Framework of UN Peace Maintenance’
, European Journal of International Law11(2):
361–383
.
12.
Greenberg, Karen J.
and
Joshua L. Dratel
(eds) (2005) The Torture Papers: The Road to Abu
Ghraib.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
13.
Ikenberry, G. John
(2002)
‘America's Imperial Ambition’
, Foreign Affairs81:
44–60
.
14.
Independent International Commission on Kosovo
(2000) The Kosovo Report: Conflict, International Response,
Lessons Learned.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
15.
Kagan, Robert
(2004)
‘America's Crisis of Legitimacy’
, Foreign Affairs83(2):
65–76
.
16.
Kagan, Robert
(2005)
‘A Matter of Record: Security, Not Law, Established American Legitimacy’
, Foreign Affairs84(1):
170–173
.
17.
McAllister, Ian
(2003)
‘Border Protection, the 2001 Australian Election and the
Coalition Victory’
, Australian Journal of Political Science38:3:
445–463
.
18.
Mearsheimer, John J.
(2004)
‘Lying in International Politics’
, paper prepared for delivery at the 2004 Annual Meeting of the
American Political Science Association, 2–5
September 2004; <http://www.learnedhand.com/mearsheimer_lying.htm>.
19.
Murphy, S.D.
(ed.) (2003)
‘Contemporary Practice of the United States Relating to
International Law’
, The American Journal of International Law97(2):
419–445
.
20.
Murphy, S.D.
(2004)
‘US Abuse of Iraqi Detainees at Abu Ghraib Prison’
, The American Journal of International Law98(3):
591–596
.
21.
Nye, Joseph S. Jr
(2004a)
‘The Decline of America's Soft Power. Why Washington Should Worry’
, Foreign Affairs83(3):
16–20
.
22.
Nye, Joseph S. Jr
(2004b) Soft Power: The Means to Success in World
Politics.
New York: Public Affairs
.
23.
O'Connell, Mary Ellen
(2002)
‘Lawful Self-defense to Terrorism’
, University of Pittsburgh Law Review63:
889–908
.
24.
Powell, Colin
(2002a) ‘Text: Powell Says Iraq's Non-compliance
with UN Rulings Concerns All’; <http://Canberra.usembassy.gov/hyper/2002/0905/epf402.htm>.
25.
Powell, Colin
(2002b) Press Conference on Iraq Declaration; online at <http://www.state.gov/secretary/former/powell/remarks/2002/16123.htm>.
26.
Powell, Colin (2003) ‘Address to the UN Security Council’
(5 February 2003); available at <http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/02/20030205–1.html>.
27.
Pyrich, A.
(1991)
‘United Nations: Authorizations to Use Force — Security
Council Resolution 665, August 25, 1950, and Security Council Resolution
678, November 29, 1990’
, Harvard International Law Journal32:
265–274
.
28.
Riecke, Henning
(2003–4)
‘Making the Best of Difference: A New Start for Transatlantic Relations’
, International Journal59:
1–26
.
29.
Rubin, James P. (1999) US Department of State Press Briefing, (16 March);
available at <http://secretary.state.gov/www/briefings/9903/990316db.html>.
30.
Sands, Philippe
(2005) Lawless World: America and the Making and Breaking of
Global Rules.
Melbourne: Allen Lane
.
31.
Scott, S.V.
(1994)
‘International Law as Ideology: Theorizing the Relationship
between International Law and International Politics’
,European Journal of International Law5:
313–325
.
32.
Scott, S.V.
(1998) ‘Beyond “Compliance”:
Reconceiving the International Law–Foreign Policy
Dynamic’, The Australian Year Book of International Law
1998: 35–48.
33.
Scott, S.V.
(2004a)
‘Is There Room for International Law in Realpolitik?: Accounting
for the US “Attitude” towards International Law’
, Review of International Studies30:
71–88
.
34.
Scott, S.V.
(2004b) International Law in World Politics: An
Introduction.
Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner
.
35.
Scott, S.V.
and
R. Withana
(2004)
‘The Relevance of International Law for Foreign Policy
Decision-making When National Security is at Stake: Lessons from the Cuban
Missile Crisis’
, The Chinese Journal of International Law3(1):
163–188
.
36.
Simma, Bruno
(1999)
‘NATO, the UN, and the Use of Force: Legal Aspects’
, European Journal of International Law10:
1–22
.
37.
Stahn, C.
(2003)
‘Enforcement of the Collective Will after Iraq’
, The American Journal of International Law97(4):
804–823
.
38.
Stromseth, J.E.
(2003)
‘Law and Force after Iraq: A Transitional Moment’
, The American Journal of International Law97(3):
628–642
.
39.
Thompson, J.
(1984) Studies in the Theory of Ideology.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
40.
Tucker, Robert W.
and
David C. Hendrickson
(2004)
‘The Sources of American Legitimacy’
, Foreign Affairs83:
18–32
.
41.
Tucker, Robert W.
and
David C. Hendrickson
(2005)
‘The Flip Side of the Record: The Commitment to Law is Key to US Legitimacy’
, Foreign Affairs84:2:
139–141
.
42.
UK House of Commons Select Committee on Foreign Affairs (2000) Fourth Report;
available at <http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199900/cmselect/cmfaff/28/2813.htm%23a34>.
43.
UN
(2003) Press Release SG/SM/8600, 10 February,
‘Secretary-General Says United Nations Has Duty to Exhaust All
Possibilities of Peaceful Settlement Before Resorting to Use of
Force’; at <http://www.un.org>.
44.
UN News Centre
(2004) ‘Lessons of Iraq Underscore Importance of
the UN Charter’ (16 September); available at <http://www.un.org>.
45.
US House of Representatives Committee on Government Reform –
Minority Staff Special Investigations Division
(2004) Iraq on the Record: The Administration's Public
Statements on Iraq; <http://democrats.reform.house.gov/IraqOnTheRecord>.
46.
US Senate Committee on Intelligence
(2004) Report on the US Intelligence Community's Prewar
Intelligence Assessments on Iraq: Conclusions; <http://intelligence.senate.gov/>.
47.
Wedgwood, Ruth
(2003)
‘The Fall of Saddam Hussein: Security Council Mandates and
Preemptive Self-Defense’
, American Journal of International Law97:
576–585
.
48.
White House (2002) ‘Vice President speaks at VFW 103rd National
Convention. Remarks by the Vice President to the Veterans of Foreign Wars 103rd
National Convention’ (26 August); available at <http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/08/20020826.html>
49.
Yoo, John
(2003)
‘International Law and the War in Iraq’
, The American Journal of International Law97:
563–576
.
