In this paper, a theoretical analysis method for leakage rate and dynamic characteristics of herringbone-grooved liquid seals is proposed. Steady-state velocities and leakage rate are figured out first with the inertia term of the fluid combined with mass conservation within the seals. Subsequently, the rotordynamic coefficients are solved based on the investigation of Iwatsubo and Childs. Laboratory tests were performed on a specially designed test rig. Detailed comparisons between the experimental results and theoretical predictions show a good agreement on the leakage rate and hydraulic forces for five model seals, which provide an evidence of validation of the analysis method developed in this paper. Moreover, the influence of rotational speed and pressure difference on the leakage rate and rotordynamic coefficients of herringbone-grooved seals is discussed. The results show that the operating conditions and seal structures greatly influence the sealing and rotordynamic performances, which is helpful for designing herringbone-grooved seals.
ChildsDW. Turbomachinery rotordynamics: Phenomena, modeling, and analysis, New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1993.
2.
Iwatsubo T, Yang B and Ibaraki R. Static and dynamic characteristics of parallel-grooved seals. In: Proceedings of rotordynamic instability problems in high performance turbomachinery, NASA CP-2443, Texas A&M University, USA, 1986, pp.99–127.
3.
Iwatsubo T, Yang B and Ibaraki R. Theoretical approach to obtaining dynamic characteristics of noncontacting spiral-grooved seals. In: Proceedings of rotordynamic instability problems in high performance turbomachinery, NASA CP-2443, Texas A&M University, USA, 1986, pp.155–188.
4.
Iwatsubo H, Nishino T and Ishimaru H. A study on dynamic characteristics of double spiral grooved seals. In: Proceedings of rotordynamic instability problems in high performance turbomachinery, NASA CP-3344, Texas A&M University, USA, 1996, pp.113–134.
5.
ChildsDWScharrerJK. An Iwatsubo-based solution for labyrinth seals: Comparison to experimental results. ASME J Eng Gas Turbines Power1986; 108(2): 325–331.
6.
KimCHChildsDW. Analysis for rotordynamic coefficients of spiral-grooved turbulent annular seals. ASME J Tribol1987; 109(1): 136–143.
7.
Fleming DP. Gas seal pad with herringbone-grooved rotor—stiffness and load capacity. NASA Technical Memorandum, 2006, 2006-214133.
8.
KanemoriYIwatsuboT. Experimental study of dynamic fluid forces and moments for a long annular seal. ASME J Tribol1992; 114(4): 773–778.
9.
ChildsDHaleK. A test apparatus and facility to identify the rotordynamic coefficients of high-speed hydrostatic bearings. ASME J Tribol1994; 116(2): 337–343.
10.
KankiHKawakamiT. Experimental study on the static and dynamic characteristics of screw grooved seals. ASME J Vib Acoust1988; 110(3): 326–331.
11.
Iwatsubo T, Sheng BC and Ono M. Experiment of static and dynamic characteristics of spiral grooved seals. In: Proceedings of the sixth workshop on rotordynamic instability problems in high-performance turbomachinery, Texas, USA, 1990, pp.223–233.
12.
Childs DW. SSME seal test program: Leakage tests for helically-grooved seals. NASA Progress Report, 1983, No. 8-33716.
13.
ChildsDWNolanSAKilgoreJJ. Test results for turbulent annular seals, using smooth rotors and spiral grooved stators. ASME J Tribol1990; 112(2): 254–258.
14.
Proctor MP and Delgado IR. Preliminary test results of a non-contacting finger seal on a herringbone-grooved rotor. NASA Technical Memorandum, 2008, 2008-215475.
15.
KangKRhimYSungK. A study of the oil-lubricated herringbone-grooved journal bearing-part 1: Numerical analysis. ASME J Tribol1996; 118: 906–911.
16.
ZirkelbackNAndresSL. Finite element analysis of herringbone groove journal bearings: A parametric study. ASME J Tribol1998; 120(2): 234–240.
17.
JangGHYoonJW. Nonlinear dynamic analysis of a hydrodynamic journal bearing considering the effect of a rotating or stationary herringbone groove. ASME J Tribol2002; 124(2): 297–304.
18.
WinotoSHHouZQOngSK. Effects of herringbone groove patterns on performance of vertical hydrodynamic journal bearings. ASME J Tribol2002; 45(3): 318–323.
19.
WangYYangHAWangJ. Theoretical analyses and field applications of gas-film lubricated mechanical face seals with herringbone spiral grooves. ASME Tribol Trans2009; 52(6): 800–806.
20.
ZhuHTDingQ. Numerical analysis of static characteristics of herringbone grooved hydrodynamic journal bearing. Appl Mech Mater2012; 105: 2259–2262.
21.
GadAMNematMMKhalilAA. On the optimum groove geometry for herringbone grooved journal bearings. ASME J Tribol2006; 128(3): 585–593.
22.
LiuJMochimaruY. The effects of trapezoidal groove on a self-acting fluid-lubricated herringbone grooves journal bearing. ISRN Tribol2013; 2013: 24023901–24023907.
23.
JangGHChangDI. Analysis of a hydrodynamic herringbone grooved journal bearing considering cavitation. ASME J Tribol2000; 122(1): 103–109.
24.
JunmeiWLeeTSShuC. A numerical study of cavitation foot-prints in liquid-lubricated asymmetrical herringbone grooved journal bearings. Int J Heat Fluid Flow2002; 12(5): 518–540.
YanXLiJFengZ. Investigations on the rotordynamic characteristics of a hole-pattern seal using transient CFD and periodic circular orbit model. ASME J Sound Vib2011; 133(4): 041007–041007.
27.
UntaroiuAUntaroiuCDWoodHG. Numerical modeling of fluid-induced rotordynamic forces in seals with large aspect ratios. ASME J Eng Gas Turbines Power2013; 135(1): 012501–012501.
28.
GaoRKirkG. CFD study on stepped and drum balance labyrinth seal. ASME Tribol Trans2013; 56(4): 663–671.
29.
NielsenKKJønckKUnderbakkeH. Hole-pattern and honeycomb seal rotordynamic forces: Validation of CFD-based prediction techniques. ASME J Eng Gas Turbines Power2012; 134(12): 122505–122505.
30.
ChildsDW. Finite-length solutions for rotordynamic coefficients of turbulent annular seals. J Lubric Technol1983; 105(3): 437–444.
31.
VohrJHChowCY. Theoretical analysis of spiral-grooved screw seal for turbulent operation. J Lubric Technol1969; 91(4): 675–686.
32.
HirsGG. A systematic study of turbulent film flow. J Lubric Technol1974; 96(1): 118–126.
33.
Storteig E. Dynamic characteristics and leakage performance of liquid annular seals in centrifugal pumps. PhD Thesis, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway, 1999.
