Hyperlocal media ecosystems have attracted increasing academic interest due to the impact of the Internet and social networks, and even more so due to concerns about the vitality of journalism in contexts of press decline with a clear lack of availability and quality of information. This study reviews the field of ‘news deserts’ from the perspective of ‘hyperlocal journalism’ until earlier 2023 in major scientific databases to identify the main fronts, challenges and opportunities. This emerging concept indicates a growing global concern about the disappearance of local media, leaving areas isolated in informational, social and cultural dimensions. The study shows the United States, United Kingdom and Australia with the largest presence, followed by Spain and Scandinavia, while it is beginning to set the public and media agenda in Latin America. We found six research fronts: Studies on audiences, Citizen journalism, Enterprise and business models, Hyperlocal media stage, News deserts and Methodological proposals.
BackhausB (2023) Connections, community, coconuts: exploring the history of regional community radio. Media International Australia: 1329878X2311546, Onlinefirst, February 8, 2023
8.
BarclaySBarnettSMooreM, et al. (2022) Local News Deserts in the UK: What effect is the decline in provision of local news and information having on communities? Report, Charitable Trust and Charitable Journalism Project, UK, June.
9.
BarnesRDugmoreHEnglishP, et al. (2022) ‘This is ridiculous – I need to start a paper horizontal ellipsis’: an exploration of aims and intentions of regional print proprietors of post-COVID start-up newspapers. Media International Australia184(1): 21–34.
10.
BarnettSTownendJ (2015) Plurality, policy and the local: can hyperlocals fill the gap?Journalism Practice9(3): 332–349.
11.
BergerG (2009) How the internet impacts on exploring paradoxes of the most global Medium in a time of ‘hyperlocalism’. The International Communication Gazette71(5): 355–371.
12.
BoothASuttonAPapaioannouD (2016) Systematic Approaches to a Successful Literature Review, 2nd ed.London: Sage Publications Ltd.
13.
Borges-ReyE (2020) Towards an epistemology of data journalism in the devolved nations of the United Kingdom: changes and continuities in materiality, performativity and reflexivity. Journalism21(7): 915–932.
14.
CarsonAMullerDMartinJ, et al. (2016) A new symbiosis? Opportunities and challenges to hyperlocal journalism in the digital age. Media International Australia161(1): 132–146.
15.
CasaresA (2021) La hora del periodismo constructivo. Navarre: Ediciones Universidad de Navarra.
16.
Castells-FosLPont-SorribesCCodinaL (2022) La sostenibilidad de los medios a través de los conceptos de engagement y relevancia: scoping review. Doxa Comunicación35: 19–38.
17.
CodinaLLopezosaCFreixaP (2022) Scoping reviews en trabajos académicos en comunicación: frameworks y fuentes Créditos. In: Larrondo-UretaAMeso-AyerdiKPeña-FernándezS (eds) XIII Congreso Internacional de Ciberperiodismo. Biscay: Universidad del País Vasco, 67–85.
18.
CraftSDavisCN (2021) Principles of American journalism: An Introduction, 3rd edNew York: Routledge.
19.
CrittendenLHaywoodA (2020) Revising legacy media practices to serve hyperlocal information needs of marginalized populations. Journalism Practice14(5): 608–625.
20.
De MendonçaTBrito-BatistaPC (2021) Local radio without borders: the experiment of a small Portuguese broadcaster on the internet. Brazilian Journalism Research17(2): 376–401.
21.
DownmanSMurrayR (2018) Hyperlocal Journalism and Digital Disruptions: The Journalism Change Agents in Australia and New Zealand. New York: Routledge.
22.
El-DamanhouryKCoppiniDJohnsonB, et al. (2022) Local news in Colorado: comparing journalism quality across four counties. Journalism Practice 18(5): 1059–1080.
23.
FerrierMSinhaGOutrichM (2016) Media deserts: Monitoring the changing Media ecosystem. In: LloydMFriedlandLA (eds) The Communication Crisis in America, and How to Fix It. New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, 215–232.
24.
FinnemanTHeckmanMWalckPE (2022) Reimagining journalistic roles: how student journalists are taking on the U.S. News desert crisis. Journalism Studies23(3): 338–355.
25.
FirmstoneJ (2016) Mapping changes in local news. Journalism Practice10(7): 928–938.
GilliganE (2011) Online publication expands reach of community journalism. Newspaper Research Journal32(1): 63–70.
28.
GrantMJBoothA (2009) A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Information and Libraries Journal26(2): 91–108.
29.
GreenwayATerrettBBrackenM, et al. (2018) Digital Transformation at Scale: Why the Strategy is Delivery. London: London Publishing Partnership.
30.
GrossL (2020) 60 preguntas sobre periodismo de soluciones. In: Fundación Gabo. Available at: bit.ly/liza_gross (accessed 25 March 2024).
31.
GulyasA (2022) Local news deserts. In: HarteDMatthewsR (eds) Reappraising Local and Community News in the UK: Media, Practice, and Policy. London: Taylor and Francis, 16–28.
32.
GulyasAJenkinsJBergstromA (2023) Places and spaces without news: the contested phenomenon of news deserts. Media and Communication11(3): 285–289.
33.
HarteDHowellsRWilliamsA (2019) Hyperlocal Journalism: The Decline of Local Newspapers and the Rise of Online Community News. New York: Routledge.
34.
HarteDWilliamsATurnerJ (2017) Reciprocity and the hyperlocal journalist. Journalism Practice11(2-3): 160–176.
35.
Herrero-SolanaVCastro-CastroC (2022) Telegram channels and bots: a ranking of media outlets based in Spain. Societies12(164): 1–13.
HessKWallerL (2017) Local Journalism in a Digital World, 1st ed.London: Palgrave Macmillan.
38.
KarlssonMRoweEH (2019) Local journalism when the journalists leave town: probing the news gap that hyperlocal media are supposed to fill. Nordicom Review40(S2): 15–29.
Lins da SilvaCEPimentaA (2020) Local news deserts in Brazil: Historical and contemporary perspectives. In: GulyasABainesD (eds) The Routledge Companion to Local Media and Journalism. New York: Taylor and Francis, 44–53.
41.
LopezosaCCodinaLFernández-PlanellsA, et al. (2023) Journalistic innovation: how new formats of digital journalism are perceived in the academic literature. Journalism24(4): 821–838.
42.
LowreyWBrozanaAMackayJB (2008) Toward a measure of community journalism. Mass Communication and Society11(3): 275–299.
43.
MacColloughKCrowellJKNapoliPM (2017) Portrait of the online local news audience. Digital Journalism5(1): 100–118.
44.
MacNamaraJ (2010) Remodelling media: the urgent search for new media business models. Media International Australia137: 20–35.
45.
MagasicMHessK (2021) Mining a news desert: the impact of a local newspaper’s closure on political participation and engagement in the rural Australian town of lightning ridge. Australian Journalism Review43(1): 99–114.
46.
Martin-NeiraJITrillo-DomínguezMOlvera-LoboMD (2023) Social networks as a vehicle for science journalism. Scoping Review. Index.Comunicacion13(1): 105–127.
47.
MathewsN (2022) Life in a news desert: the perceived impact of a newspaper closure on community members. Journalism23(6): 1250–1265.
48.
MetzgarETKurpiusDDRowleyKM (2011) Defining hyperlocal media: proposing a framework for discussion. New Media and Society13(5): 772–787.
49.
MunnZPetersMDJSternC, et al. (2018) Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach. BMC Medical Research Methodology18(143).
50.
NahSChungDS (2020) Understanding Citizen Journalism as Civic Participation. New York: Routledge.
51.
Negreira-ReyMCLópez-GarcíaX (2021) A decade of research on hyperlocal media: an international approach to a new media model. Online Journal of Communication and Media Technologies11(3): e202111.
52.
Negreira-ReyMCVázquez-HerreroJLópez-GarcíaX (2023) No people, no news: news deserts and areas at risk in Spain. Media and Communication11(3): 293–303.
53.
NelsonJL (2021) Imagined Audiences: How Journalists Perceive and Pursue the Public. Oxford University Press.
54.
NewmanNFletcherREddyK, et al. (2023) Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2023. University of Oxford.
55.
NielsenRK (2015) Introduction: The uncertain future of local journalism. In: NielsenRK (ed) Local Journalism: The Decline of Newspapers and the Rise of Digital media. London: I.B Tauris, 1–25.
NygrenGLecknerSTenorC (2018) Hyperlocals and legacy media: media ecologies in transition. Nordicom Review39(1): 33–49.
58.
PhamMTRajićAGreigJD, et al. (2014) A scoping review of scoping reviews: advancing the approach and enhancing the consistency. Research Synthesis Methods5(4): 371–385.
59.
Press and Society Institute of Venezuela (2020) Más de 5 millones de venezolanos viven en desiertos de noticias. Available at: https://ipysvenezuela.org/desierto-de-noticias/ (accessed 2 July 2023).
60.
Rodríguez-UrraCTrillo-DomínguezMHerrero-SolanaV (2023a) Mapa mediático hispanoamericano: una aproximación desde la academia. Revista de Comunicación22(1): 435–452.
61.
Rodríguez-UrraCTrillo-DomínguezMHerrero-SolanaV (2023b) The irruption of digital natives on the Chilean media landscape: analysis of the academic impact in front of web and social networks (2004-2022). Brazilian Journalism Research19(1): e1572.
62.
SchafferJ (2007) Citizen Media: Fad or the Future of News? Report, J-Lab, U.S, February.
63.
SmethersJSMwangiSCBressersB (2021) Signal interruption in Baldwin city: filling a communication vacuum in a small town “news desert.”. Newspaper Research Journal42(3): 379–396.
64.
SmithCCSchiffmanJR (2018) Remaining close to home: small daily newspapers provide (mostly) hyperlocal election news during 2016 elections. Newspaper Research Journal39(4): 420–432.
65.
SpassovOOgnyanovaNDaskalovaN (2024) Bulgaria. In: VerzaSBlagojevTBorgesDKermerJTrevisanMReviglioU (eds) Uncovering News Deserts in Europe Risks and Opportunities for Local and Community Media in the EU. Fiesole: European University Institute, 22–29.
66.
SullivanM (2022) Every week, two more newspapers close – and ‘news deserts’ grow larger. The Washington Post, 29 June.
67.
TenorC (2018) Hyperlocal news and Media accountability. Digital Journalism6(8): 1064–1077.
68.
ToffBPalmerRNielsenRK (2023) Avoiding the News: Reluctant Audiences for Journalism. Columbia University Press.
69.
Trillo-DomínguezMDe-Moya-AnegónF (2022) Map of scientific research on communication in Spain: study fronts and rankings of authors, publications and institutions. Profesional de La Informacion31(1): 1–23.
70.
TurnerJ (2021) “Someone should do something”: exploring public sphere ideals in the audiences of UK hyperlocal Media Facebook pages. Journalism Studies22(16): 2236–2255.
71.
TurnerJHarteD (2022) Where’s the fake news in hyperlocal media? Trust amongst citizen journalists and participatory audiences in local Facebook pages. In: LynchJRiceC (eds) Responsible Journalism in Conflicted Societies. London: Routledge, 44–58.
Van DijckJ (2009) Users like you? Theorizing agency in user-generated content. Media, Culture and Society31(1): 41–58.
74.
Van EckNJWaltmanL (2010) Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics84(2): 523–538.
75.
Van KerkhovenM (2020) I’ve started a hyperlocal, so now what? In: GulyasABainesD (eds) The Routledge Companion to Local Media and Journalism. New York: Taylor and Francis, 248–254.
76.
Van KerkhovenMBakkerP (2015) Hyperlocal with a mission? Motivation, strategy, engagement. In: NielsenRK (ed) Local Journalism: The Decline of Newspapers and the Rise of Digital media. London: I.B Tauris, 185–202.
77.
VerzaSBlagojevTBorgesD, et al. (2024) Uncovering News Deserts in Europe Risks and Opportunities for Local and Community Media in the EU. Fiesole: European University Institute.
78.
WederF (2020) Sparking an interest in local water issues: Social Media as an enabler for (hyper)local community engagement in environmental issues and the role of solution journalism. In: Díaz-PontJMaeseelePSjölanderAEMishraMFoxwell-NortonK (eds) Global Transformations in Media and Communication Research. Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan, 223–245.
79.
WellmanB (2002) Little boxes, glocalization, and networked individualism. In: TanabeMBesselaarPIshidaT (eds) Digital Cities II: Computational and Sociological Approaches. Heidelberg: Springer, 11–25.
80.
WenzelA (2018) Engaged journalism in rural communities. Journalism Practice13(6): 708–722.
81.
ZhangC (2020) Bounding and bonding community: ethnic diversity and the ethic of inclusion in hyperlocal news. Journalism21(9): 1175–1191.
