Publics of interest and the death of the critic on Australian TV

Abstract

This article charts a turning point in recent Australian broadcast television history, where enduring institutions of media criticism in popular formats rapidly disappeared from screens. We firstly situate media criticism and the roles of the ‘television critic’ within theoretical paradigms of Bourdieusian taste-making and publics of interest, before undertaking a close analysis of three case studies circa 2015. Examining Good Game, The Book Club and Movie Juice demonstrates variations in critical and presentational aims and tones, influenced by such factors as media types and associated cultures (games, literature and film, respectively), network/broadcaster interests, scope of media operations and engagement with online publics. Our assessments of these formats are then placed in their historical context of media production and consumption, whereby we retrospectively find that the retirement of the popular film criticism show At the Movies marked the beginning of the Australian television critic's extinction event.

Keywords

criticism formats critics media criticism publics of interest taste

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABC (2019) About Good Game. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/tv/goodgame/about/ (accessed 8 July 2022).

ABC (2020) About The Book Club. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/tv/firsttuesday/about/ (accessed 8 July 2022).

Ant-Man (2015) motion picture directed by Peyton Reed.

At the Movies (2004) television program, ABC.

Basuroy

Chatterjee

Ravid

(2003) How critical are critical reviews? The box office effects of film critics, star power and budgets. Journal of Marketing 67(4): 103–117.

Bodey

(2014) Pomeranz and Stratton: a critical loss for the Australian film industry. The Australian, 31 October. Available at: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/arts/review/pomeranz-and-stratton-a-critical-loss-for-the-australian-film-industry/news-story/8397aadb97c46784b5405f8af966b898 (accessed 8 July 2022).

Bonner

(2011) Personality Presenters: Television’s Intermediaries with Viewers. GBR: Ashgate Publishing Group.

Bourdieu

(1986) Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste. London and New York: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Downfall (2004) motion picture directed by Oliver Hirschbiegel.

10.

Ebert

(2010) The golden age of movie critics. RogerEbert.com, 1 May. Available at: https://www.rogerebert.com/roger-ebert/the-golden-age-of-movie-critics (accessed 8 July 2022).

11.

Ebert

(2011) Life Itself. New York: Grand Central Publishing.

12.

Gogglebox Australia (2015) television program, Network Ten.

13.

Good Game (2006) television program, ABC.

14.

Good Game: Pocket (2015) online program, ABC iView.

15.

Good Game: Spawn Point (2010) television program, ABC.

16.

Gruen (2008) television program, ABC.

17.

Jennifer Byrne Presents (2007) television program, ABC.

18.

Madame Bovary (2014) motion picture directed by Sophie Barthes.

19.

Movie Juice (2014) television program, Network Ten.

20.

screenPLAY (2017) television program, Channel Seven.

21.

Screen Time (2017) television program, ABC.

22.

Stratton

(2008) I Peed on Fellini – Recollections of a Life in Film. NSW: Random House Australia Pty Ltd.

23.

Symeou

Bantimaroudis

Zyglidopoulos

(2014) Cultural agenda setting and the role of critics: an empirical examination in the market for art-house films. Communication Research 42(5): 732–754.

24.

Taylor

(2011) The problem with film criticism. Dissent 58(4): 81–85.

25.

The Book Club (2006) television program, ABC.

26.

The Critics (2015) online program, ABC iView.

27.

The Dressmaker (2015) motion pictured directed by Jocelyn Moorhouse.

28.

The Jammed (2007) motion picture directed by Dee McLachlan.

29.

Turner

(2006) The mass production of celebrity: ‘celetoids’, reality TV and the ‘demotic turn’. International Journal of Cultural Studies 9(2): 153–165.

30.

Unity (2015) documentary film directed by Shaun Monson.

31.

Warner

(2002) Publics and counterpublics (abbreviated version). Quarterly Journal of Speech 88(4): 413–425.

32.

Wonderland (2013) television program, Network Ten.

33.

Yeo

(2017) Good Game Has Been Cancelled. Kotaku, 31 January. Available at: https://www.kotaku.com.au/2017/01/good-game-has-been-cancelled/ (accessed 8 July 2022).