This article applies a systematic analysis of everyday moral decision making to the controversy surrounding the use of aversive treatments for people with severe mental retardation. The authors' aim is to provide a framework for analyzing the issue, and they take a position against the use of aversive procedures. The analysis adds some new ideas to the debate. It provides a definition of aversive procedures based upon common moral rules. The concept of protection by the moral rules is discussed and the case made that people with severe mental retardation deserve the protection of the moral rules and that this right is historically new and tenous. The importance of symbols of dehumanization is discussed in light of this tenous condition. The idea of moral agency is applied in order to clarify the kinds of societal sanctions that are and are not appropriate when a person with severe mental retardation violates a moral rule. The authors argue that data are always relevant to moral decision making and that a mounting body of evidence indicates that nonaversive alternatives are available and can replace aversive procedures in all but a very small number of highly unusual cases.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
The Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps. (1991). Resolution on the cessation of intrusive interventions, 1986 revision. In L. H. Meyers, C. A. Peck, & L. Brown (Eds.), Critical issues in the lives of people with severe disabilities. Baltimore: Brookes.
2.
Azrin, N.H., & Holz, W.C. (1966). Punishment. In W. K. Honig (Ed.), Operant behavior: Areas of research and application (pp. 380-447). New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts .
3.
Azrin, N.H., Hutchinson, R.R., & Hake, D.F. (1967). Attack, avoidance, and escape reactions to aversive shock. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 10(2), 131-148.
4.
Bihm, E.M., & Sigelman, C.K. (1991). Effects of behavioral treatment, treatment setting, and client IQ on person to person perception. Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 12, 341-355.
5.
Bihm, E.M., Sigelman, C.K., & Westbrook, J.P. (1997). Social implications of behavioral interventions for persons with mental retardation. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 101, 567-578.
6.
Blacher, J. (1994). Placement and its consequences. In J. Blacher (Ed.), When there's no place like home: Options for children living apart from their natural families (pp. 213-244). Baltimore: Brookes.
7.
Blatt, B. (1973). Souls in extremis: An anthology on victims and victimizers. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
8.
Bogdan, R.C. (1986). Exhibiting mentally retarded people for amusement and profit, 1850-1940. American Journal of Mental Deficiency , 91(2) 120-126.
9.
Bowman, L.G., Fisher, W.W., Thompson, R.H., & Piazza, C.C. (1997). On the relation of mands and the function of destructive behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 30, 251-265.
10.
Carr, E.G., & Durand, V.M. (1985). Reducing behavior problems through functional communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis , 18(2),111-126.
11.
Carr, E.G., Horner, R.H., Turnbull, A.P., Marquis, J.E., Magito McLaughlin, D., McAtee, M.L., Smith, C.E., Anderson Ryan, K., Ruef, M.B., & Doolabh, A. (in press). Positive behavior support in people with developmental disabilities: A research synthesis. [Monograph]. Washington, DC: American Association on Mental Retardation.
12.
Carr, E.G., Levin, L., McConnachie, G., Carlson, J.I., Kemp, D.C., and Smith, C.E. (1994). Communication based intervention for problem behavior: A user's guide for producing positive change. Baltimore : Brookes
13.
Ducharme, J.M., Pontes, E., Guger, S., & Crozier, K. (1994). Errorless compliance to parental requests: II. Increasing clinical practicality through abbreviation of treatment parameters . Behavior Therapy, 25, 469-487.
14.
Ducharme, J.M., Popynick, M., Pontes, E., & Steele, S. (1996). Errorless compliance to parental requests III: Group parent training with parent observational data and long-term follow-up . Behavior Therapy, 27, 353-372.
15.
Dunlap, G., Kern-Dunlap, L., Clarke, S., & Robbins, F.R. (1991). Functional assessment, curricular revision, and severe behavior problems. Special issue: Social validity: Multiple perspectives . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 24, 387-397.
16.
Durand, V.M. (1993). Functional communication training using assistive devices: Effects on challenging behavior and affect. Augmentative & AlternativeCommunication, 9, 168-176.
17.
Ferguson, P.M. (1994). Abandoned to their fate: Social policy and practice toward severely retarded people in America, 1820-1920. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
18.
Foxx, R.M. (1990). "Harry": A ten year follow-up of the successful treatment of a self-injurious man. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 11(1), 67-76.
19.
Gert, B. (Ed.). (1996). Morality and the new genetics: A guide for students and health care providers . Boston: Jones and Barlett.
20.
Gert, B. (1998). Morality: Its nature and justification. New York: Oxford University Press.
21.
Gert. B., Culver, C.M., & Clouser, K.D. (1997). Bioethics: A return to fundamentals. New York: Oxford University Press.
22.
Guess, D., Turnbull, H.R., & Helmstetter, E. (1990). Science, paradigms, and values: A response to Mulick. American Journal on Mental Retardation , 95(2), 157-163.
23.
Hanley, G.P., Piazza, C.C., & Fisher, W.W. (1997). Noncontingent presentation of attention and alternative stimuli in the treatment of attention-maintained destructive behavior. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 30, 229-237.
24.
Hastings, R.P., & Remington, B. (1994). Rules of engagement: Toward an analysis of staff responses to challenging behavior. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 15(4), 279-298.
25.
Horner, R. (1990). Ideology, technology, and typical community settings: Use of severe aversive stimuli. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 95(2), 166-168.
26.
Horner, R.H., & Albin, R.W. (1988). Research on general-case procedures for learners with severe disabilities. Special issue: Direct instruction: A general case for teaching the general case. Education and Treatment of Children, 11(4), 375-388.
27.
Horner, R., Close, D., Fredericks, H.D., O'Neill, R., Albin, R., Sprague, J., Kennedy, C., Flannery, K.B., & Tuesday-Heathfield, L. (1996). Supported living for people with profound disabilities and severe problem behaviors. In D. Lehr & F. Brown (Eds.), People with disabilities who challenge the system (pp. 209-242). Baltimore: Brookes .
28.
Horner, R.H., Day, H.M., Sprague, J.R., O'Brien, M., &Heathfield, L.T. (1991). Interspersed requests: A nonaversive procedure for reducing aggression and self-injury during instruction . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 24, 265-278.
29.
Horner, R.H., Dunlap, G., Koegel, R.L., Carr, E.G., Sailor, W., Andersen, J., Albin, R.W., & O'Neill, R.E. (1990). Toward a technology of "nonaversive" behavioral support. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 15(3), 125-132.
30.
Karsh, K.G., Repp, A.C., Dahlquist, C.M., & Munk, D. (1995). In vivo functional assessment and multi-element interventions for problem behaviors of students with disabilities in classroom settings. Special issue: Tom Haring memorial issue. Journal of BehavioralEducation, 5(2), 189-210.
31.
Kehle, T.J., Clark, E., Jenson, W.R., & Wampold, B.E. (1986). Effectiveness of self-observation with behavior disordered elementary school children. School Psychology Review , 15(2), 289-295.
32.
Kemp, D.C., & Carr, E.G. (1995). Reduction of severe problem behavior in community employment using an hypothesis-driven multicomponent intervention approach . Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps , 20, 229-247.
33.
Kennedy, C.H., & Souza, G. (1995). Functional analysis and treatment of eye poking . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 28(1), 27-37.
34.
Knapczyk, D.R. (1988). Reducing aggressive behaviors in special and regular class settings by training alternative social responses. Behavioral Disorders, 14(1), 27-39.
35.
Knobbe, C.A., Carey, S.P., Rhodes, L., & Horner, R.H. (1995). Benefit-cost analysis of community residential versus institutional services for adults with severe mental retardation and challenging behaviors. American Journal on Mental Retardation , 99(5), 533-541.
36.
Koegel, R.L., Camarata, S.M., & Koegel, L.K. (1994). Aggression and noncompliance: Behavior modification through naturalistic language remediation. In J. L. Matson (Ed.), Autism in children and adults: Etiology, assessment, and intervention (pp. 165-180). Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/ Cole.
37.
Koegel, R.L., Koegel, L.K., & Dunlap G. (1996). Positive behavioral support: including people with difficult behavior in the community. Baltimore: Brookes.
38.
Lerman, D.C., Iwata, B.A., Smith, R.G., & Vollmer, T.R. (1994). Restraint fading and the development of alternative behaviour in the treatment of self-restraint and self-injury. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 38(2), 135-148.
39.
Lucyshyn, J.M., Albin, R.W., & Nixon, C.D. (1997). Embedding comprehensive behavioral support in family ecology: An experimental, single case analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65, 241-251.
40.
Maguire, K.B., Lange, B., Scherling, M., & Grow, R. (1996). The use of rehearsal and positive reinforcement in the dental treatment of uncooperative patients with mental retardation . Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 8, 167-177.
41.
Mechanic, D., & Rochefort, D.A. (1990). Deinstitutionalization: An appraisal of reform. Annual Review of Sociology, 16, 301-327.
42.
Meyer, L.H., & Evans, I.M. (1989). Nonaversive intervention for behavior problems: A manual for home and community. Baltimore: Brookes.
43.
Milonas v. Williams, 691 F.2d 931 (1982).
44.
O'Brien, F. (1989). The punishment of people with developmental disabilities . In E. Cipani (Ed.), The treatment of severe behavior disorders (pp. 37-58). Washington, DC : American Association on Mental Retardation.
45.
Rennie v. Klein, 452 U.S. 920 (1978).
46.
Root, M. (1993). Philosophy of social science: The methods, ideals, and politics of social inquiry. Oxford, England: Blackwell .
47.
Sanders, M.R., & Plant, K. (1989). Programming for generalization to high and low risk parenting situations in families with oppositional developmentally disabled preschoolers. Behavior Modification, 13, 283-305.
48.
Saunders, R.R., Saunders, M.D., Brewer, A., & Roach, T. (1996). Reduction of self-injury in two adolescents with profound retardation by the establishment of a supported routine. Behavioral Interventions, 11(2), 59-86.
49.
Schopler, E. (1986). Treatment abuse and its reduction. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 16(2), 99-104.
50.
Shelton v. Tucker, 364 U.S. 479 (1960).
51.
Sigafoos, J., Penned, D., & Versluis, J. (1996). Naturalistic assessment leading to effective treatment of self-injury in a young boy with multiple disabilities. Education and Treatment of Children, 19(2), 101-123.
52.
Singer, G.H.S., & Irvin, L.K. (1987). Human rights review of intrusive behavioral treatments for students with severe handicaps. Exceptional Children, 54(1), 46-52.
53.
Smith, M.D., & Coleman, D. (1986). Managing the behavior of adults with autism in the job setting. Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders , 16(2), 145-154.
54.
Steed, S.E., Bigelow, K.M., Huynen, K.B., & Lutzker, J.R. (1995). The effects of planned activities training, low-demand schedule, and reinforcement sampling on adults with developmental disabilities who exhibit challenging behaviors. Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 7(4), 303-316.
55.
Thompson, T., Robinson, J., Dietrich, M., & Farris, M. (1996). Interdependence of architectural features and program variables in community residences for people with mental retardation . American Journal on Mental Retardation, 101(3), 315-327.
56.
Trent, J. (1994). Inventing the feeble mind: A history of mental retardation in the United States. Berkeley: University of California Press.
57.
Van Houten, R., Axelrod, S., Bailey, J.S., Favell, J.E., Foxx, R.M., Iwata, B., & Lovass, O.I. (1988). The right to effective behavioral treatment. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21, 381-384.
58.
Vollmer, T.R., Iwata, B.A., Smith, R.G., & Rodgers, T.A. (1992). Reduction of multiple aberrant behaviors and concurrent development of self-care skills with differential reinforcement. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 13, 287-299.
