On the Origin of Beliefs about the Sexual Orientation and Gender-role Development of Children Raised by Gay-male and Heterosexual Parents: An Italian Study
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online August, 2020
On the Origin of Beliefs about the Sexual Orientation and Gender-role Development of Children Raised by Gay-male and Heterosexual Parents: An Italian Study
In three studies, heterosexual participants were presented with descriptions of heterosexual and gay-male parents. Importantly, the level of gender-role conformity of the gay-male parents was experimentally manipulated, resulting in their level of gender-role conformity ranging from high to low. Compared to the son of a heterosexual couple, the son of all gay-male couples had a lower expected likelihood of developing as heterosexual. This result was independent of the level of gender-role conformity of the gay-male couples (study 1–3). The beliefs about the gender-role development of the son, in terms of anticipated masculinity (study 1), gender stereotyping (study 2), and affective adjustment (study 3), mapped onto the level of gender-role conformity of the parents, regardless of their sexual orientation. Also, heterosexual parents were consistently judged more positively than gay-male parents, independently of their level of gender-role conformity (study 1–3). Results were discussed within the theoretical framework of stereotypes about gay-male parenting.
AllenMikeBurrellNancy. 2002. “Sexual Orientation of the Parent: The Impact on the Child.” In Interpersonal Communication Research: Advances through Meta-analysis, edited by AllenMikePreissRaymond W.GayleBarbara MaeBurrellNancy, 125–43. Mahwah, NJ: USum Associates.
2.
BaileyApril H.LaFranceMarianne. 2017. “Who Counts as Human? Antecedents to Androcentric Behavior.” Sex Roles76 (11–12): 682–93.
3.
BaioccoRobertoNardelliNicolaPezzutiLinaLingiardiVittorio. 2013. “Attitudes of Italian Heterosexual Older Adults towards Lesbian and Gay Parenting.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy10 (4): 285–92.
4.
BiblarzTimothy J.StaceyJudith. 2010. “How does the Gender of Parents Matter?” Journal of Marriage and Family72 (1): 3–22.
5.
BignerJerry J.1999. “Raising Our Sons: Gay Men as Fathers.” Journal of Gay and Lesbian Social Services10 (1): 61–77.
6.
BlashillAaron J.PowlishtaKimberly K.2009. “Gay Stereotypes: The Use of Sexual Orientation as a Cue for Gender-related Attributes.” Sex Roles61 (11–12): 783–93.
7.
BossonJennifer K.MichniewiczKenneth S.2013. “Gender Dichotomization at the Level of Ingroup Identity: What It Is, and Why Men Use It More Than Women.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology105 (3): 425–42.
8.
CadinuMaraLatrofaMarcellaCarnaghiAndrea. 2013. “Comparing Self-stereotyping with In-group-stereotyping and Out-group-stereotyping in Unequal-status Groups: The Case of Gender.” Self and Identity12 (6): 582–96.
9.
CamilleriPriscillaRyanMartin. 2006. “Social Work Students’ Attitudes toward Homosexuality and Their Knowledge and Attitudes toward Homosexual Parenting as an Alternative Family Unit: An Australian Study.” Social Work Education25 (3): 288–304.
10.
CarnaghiAndreaMaassAnne. 2007. “In-group and Out-group Perspectives in the Use of Derogatory Group Labels: Gay Versus Fag.” Journal of Language and Social Psychology26 (2): 142–56.
11.
CaroneNicolaBaioccoRobertoIovernoSalvatoreChirumboloAntonioLingiardiVittorio. 2017. “Same-sex Parent Families in Italy: Validation of the Coparenting Scale-revised for Lesbian Mothers and Gay Fathers.” European Journal of Developmental Psychology14 (3): 367–79.
12.
ClarkeVictoria. (2001). “What about the Children? Arguments against Lesbian and Gay Parenting.” Women’s Studies International Forum24 (5): 555–70.
13.
CorleyTammy J.PollackRobert H.1997. “Do Changes in the Stereotypic Depiction of a Lesbian Couple Affect Heterosexuals’ Attitudes toward Lesbianism?” Journal of Homosexuality32 (2): 1–17.
14.
CrawfordIsiaahMcLeodAndrewZamboniBrian D.JordanMichael B.1999. “Psychologists’ Attitudes toward Gay and Lesbian Parenting.” Professional Psychology: Research and Practice30 (4): 394–401.
15.
CrawfordIsiaahSollidayElizabeth. 1996. “The Attitudes of Undergraduate College Students toward Gay Parenting.” Journal of Homosexuality30 (4): 63–77.
16.
EaglyAlice H.SteffenValerie J.1984. “Gender Stereotypes Stem from the Distribution of Women and Men into Social Roles.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46 (4): 735–54.
17.
EleuteriStefanoLingiardiVittorio. 2008. “Mascolinità e omosessualità maschile: nuove frontiere e nuovi limiti.” Rivista di Sessuologia Clinica13 (1): 29–45.
FedewaAlicia L.BlackWhitney W.AhnSoyeon. 2015. “Children and Adolescents with Same-gender Parents: A Meta-analytic Approach in Assessing Outcomes.” Journal of GLBT Family Studies11 (1): 1–34.
21.
FisherA. D.CastelliniGiovanniRistoriJiskaCasaleHelenGiovanardiGuidoCaroneNicolaFanniEgidiaMosconiM.CioccaG.JanniniE. A.RiccaV.LingiardiV.MaggiM.2017. “Who Has the Worst Attitudes toward Sexual Minorities? Comparison of Transphobia and Homophobia Levels in Gender Dysphoric Individuals, the General Population and Health Care Providers.” Journal of Endocrinological Investigation40 (3): 263–73.
22.
FiskeSusan T.NeubergSteven L.1990. “A Continuum of Impression Formation, from Category-based to Individuating Processes: Influences of Information and Motivation on Attention and Interpretation.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology23: 1–74.
23.
FolgerøTor. 2008. “Queer Nuclear Families? Reproducing and Transgressing Heteronormativity.” Journal of Homosexuality54 (1–2): 124–49.
24.
Frias-NavarroDoloresMonterde-i-BortHector. 2012. “A Scale on Beliefs about Children’s Adjustment in Same-sex Families: Reliability and Validity.” Journal of Homosexuality59 (9): 1273–88.
25.
GatoJorgeFontaineAnne Marie. 2013. “Anticipation of the Sexual and Gender Development of Children Adopted by Same-sex Couples.” International Journal of Psychology48 (3): 244–53.
26.
GatoJorgeFontaineAnne Marie. 2016. “Predicting Portuguese Psychology Students’ Attitudes toward the Psychological Development of Children Adopted by Lesbians and Gay Men.” Journal of Homosexuality63 (11): 1464–480.
27.
GlickPeterGanglCandiceGibbSamanthaKlumpnerSusanWeinbergEmily. 2007. “Defensive Reactions to Masculinity Threat: More Negative Affect toward Effeminate (but not masculine) Gay Men.” Sex Roles57 (1–2): 55–9.
28.
GlickPeterWilkersonMariahCuffeMarshall. 2015. “Masculine Identity, Ambivalent Sexism, and Attitudes toward Gender Subtypes.” Social Psychology46 (4): 210–17.
29.
GottmanJulie Schwartz. 1990. “Children of Gay and Lesbian Parents.” In Homosexuality and Family Relation, edited by BozettFrederick W.SussmanMarvin B., 177–96. New York: Haworth Press.
30.
HaslamNickLevySheri R.2006. “Essentialist Beliefs about Homosexuality: Structure and Implications for Prejudice.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin32 (4): 471–85.
31.
HegartyPeterPrattoFelicia. 2001. “Sexual Orientation Beliefs: Their Relationship to Anti-gay Attitudes and Biological Determinist Arguments.” Journal of Homosexuality41 (1): 121–35.
32.
HollekimRagnhildSlaattenHildeAnderssenNorman. 2012. “A nationwide Study of Norwegian Beliefs about Same-sex Marriage and Lesbian and Gay Parenthood.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy9 (1): 15–30.
33.
HuntChristopher J.FasoliFabioCarnaghiAndreaCadinuMara. 2016. “Masculine Self-presentation and Distancing from Femininity in Gay Men: An Experimental Examination of the Role of Masculinity Threat.” Psychology of Men & Masculinity17 (1): 108–12.
34.
International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (ILGA). 2017. “State-Sponsored Homophobia 2017: A World Survey of Sexual Orientation Laws: Criminalisation, Protection and Recognition.” Accessed March, 2018. http://ilga.org/state-sponsored-homophobia-report.
35.
IovernoSalvatoreCaroneNicolaLingiardiVittorioNardelliNicolaPagonePaoloPistellaJessicaSalvatiMarcoSimonelliAlessandraBaioccoRoberto. 2018. “Assessing Prejudice toward Two-father Parenting and Two-mother Parenting: The Beliefs on Same-sex Parenting Scale.” The Journal of Sex Research55 (4–5): 654–55.
36.
Istituto Nazionale di Statistica. 2012. “La Popolazione Omosessuale nella Società Italiana” [The Homosexual Population in the Italian Society]. Accessed June, 2017. http://www.istat.it/it/archivio/62168.
37.
KawakamiKerryDovidioJohn F.DijksterhuisAp. 2003. “Effect of Social Category Priming on Personal Attitudes.” Psychological Science14 (4): 315–19.
38.
KiteMary E.DeauxKay. 1987. “Gender Belief Systems: Homosexuality and the Implicit Inversion Theory.” Psychology of Women Quarterly11 (1): 83–96.
39.
KitzingerCelia. 2005. “Heteronormativity in Action: Reproducing the Heterosexual Nuclear Family in After-hours Medical Calls.” Social Problems52 (4): 477–98.
40.
LingiardiVittorioCaroneNicola. 2016a. “Madri lesbiche, padri gay: genitori de-generati.” Giornale Italiano di Psicologia43(1–2): 57–59.
41.
LingiardiVittorioCaroneNicola. 2016b. “Famiglie contemporanee: nuove concezioni, vecchi pregiudizi. Risposta ai commenti.” Giornale Italiano di Psicologia43 (1–2): 181–94.
42.
LingiardiVittorioNardelliNicolaIovernoSalvatoreFalangaSimonaChiacchioCarlo DiTanzilliAnnalisaBaioccoRoberto. 2016. “Homonegativity in Italy: Cultural Issues, Personality Characteristics, and Demographic Correlates with Negative Attitudes toward Lesbians and Gay Men.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy13 (2): 95–108.
43.
MartinCarol Lynn. 1990. “Attitudes and Expectations about Children with Nontraditional and Traditional Gender Roles.” Sex Roles22 (3–4): 151–66.
44.
MartinCarol Lynn. 1995. “Stereotypes about Children with Traditional and Nontraditional Gender Roles.” Sex Roles33 (11): 727–51.
45.
McLeodAndrew C.CrawfordIsiaahZechmeisterJeanne. 1999. “Heterosexual Undergraduates’ Attitudes toward Gay Fathers and Their Children.” Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality11 (1): 43–62.
46.
MillerBenjamin GrahamKorsStephanieMacfieJenny. 2017. “No Differences? Meta-analytic Comparisons of Psychological Adjustment in Children of Gay Fathers and Heterosexual Parents.” Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity4 (1): 14–22.
47.
MorseCharmaine N.McLarenSuzanneMcLachlanAngus J.. 2008. “The Attitudes of Australian Heterosexuals toward Same-sex Parents.” Journal of GLBT Family Studies3 (4): 425–55.
48.
O’ConnorCliodhna. 2017. “‘Appeals to Nature’ in Marriage Equality Debates: A Content Analysis of Newspaper and Social Media Discourse.” British Journal of Social Psychology56 (3): 493–514.
49.
PageStewartYeeMary. 1986. “Conception of Male and Female Homosexual Stereotypes among University Undergraduates.” Journal of Homosexuality12 (1): 109–18.
50.
Pascual-SolerMarcosFrias-NavarroDoloresBarrientos-DelgadoJaimeBadenes-RiberaLauraMonterde-i-BortHectorCárdenas-CastroManuelBerrios-RiquelmeJosé. 2017. “Factorial Invariance of the Scale Beliefs about Children’s Adjustment in Same-sex Families in Spanish, Chilean, and Hispanic University Students.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences39 (2): 238–62.
51.
PattersonCharlotte J.2017. “Parents’ Sexual Orientation and Children’s Development.” Child Development Perspectives11 (1): 45–49.
52.
PenningtonJarredKnightTess. 2011. “Through the Lens of Hetero-normative Assumptions: Re-thinking Attitudes towards Gay Parenting.” Culture, Health and Sexuality13 (1): 59–72.
53.
RickettsWendellAchtenbergRoberta. 1989. “Adoption and Foster Parenting for Lesbians and Gay Men: Creating New Traditions in Family.” Marriage and Family Review14 (3–4): 83–118.
54.
RiggsDamien W.2006. “Developmentalism and the Rhetoric of Best Interests of the Child: Challenging Heteronormative Constructions of Families and Parenting in Foster Care.” Journal of GLBT Family Studies2 (2): 57–73.
55.
RowlandsIngridLeeChristina. 2006. “Choosing to Have Children or Choosing to Be Childfree: Australian Students’ Attitudes towards the Decisions of Heterosexual and Lesbian Women.” Australian Psychologist41 (1): 55–59.
56.
RudmanLaurie A.GreenwaldAnthony G.McGheeDebbie. 2001. “Implicit Self-concept and Evaluative Implicit Gender Stereotypes: Self and Ingroup Share Desirable Traits.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27 (9): 1164–78.
57.
SalvatiMarcoIovernoSalvatoreGiacomantonioMauroBaioccoRoberto. 2016. “Attitude toward Gay Men in an Italian Sample: Masculinity and Sexual orientation Make a Difference.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy13 (2): 109–18.
58.
SalvatiMarcoPistellaJessicaIovernoSalvatoreGiacomantonioMauroBaioccoRoberto. 2017. “Attitude of Italian Gay Men and Italian Lesbian Women towards Gay and Lesbian Gender-typed Scenarios.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy. doi: 10.1007/s13178-017-0296-7.
59.
TestaRonald J.KinderBill N.IronsonGail. 1987. “Heterosexual Bias in the Perception of Loving Relationships of Gay Males and Lesbians.” Journal of Sex Research23 (2): 163–72.
60.
TuschererTaylorHugenbergKurt. 2014. “What’s Love Got to Do with It? Sexual Prejudice Predicts Unitization of Men in Same-sex Romantic Relationships.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology52: 9–14.
61.
WebbStephanie N.ChonodyJill M.KavanaghPhillip S.2017. “Attitudes toward Same-sex Parenting: An Effect of Gender.” Journal of Homosexuality64 (11): 1583–95.
62.
WorthenMeredith G. F.LingiardiVittorioCaristoChiara. 2017. “The Roles of Politics, Feminism, and Religion in Attitudes toward LGBT Individuals: A Cross-cultural Study of College Students in the USA, Italy, and Spain.” Sexuality Research and Social Policy14 (3): 241–58.
