This article seeks to examine how gender and sexual identities shape sex work experiences among men, two spirit, and/or trans people in Vancouver.
Methods:
In-depth, semistructured interviews were conducted with men and trans people in Metro Vancouver from Community Health Assessment of Men Who Purchase and Sell Sex. An intersectional critical feminist perspective guided the thematic analysis of interview transcripts, and ATLAS.ti 7 was used to manage data analysis.
Results:
Three themes emerged from the data: (1) the diversity of sexual and gender identities among sex workers and clients, (2) the expression and exploration of sexual and gender identities through sex work, and (3) the migration of sexual and gender minorities to urban centers to escape discrimination in their places of origin.
Discussion:
These findings complicate existing narratives of sex work, demonstrating the need for policies and services that reflect the diversity of sex work experiences.
AbramovichEvelyn. 2005. “Childhood Sexual Abuse as a Risk Factor for Subsequent Involvement in Sex Work.” Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality17:131–46.
2.
AllmanDan. 1999. M is for Mutual, A is for Acts: Male Sex Work and AIDS in Canada. Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto, HIV Social, Behavioural and Epidemiological Studies Unit.
AsthanaSheenaOostvogelsRobert. 1996. “Community Participation in HIV Prevention: Problems and Prospects for Community-based Strategies among Female Sex Workers in Madras.” Social Science & Medicine43:133–48.
5.
BallesterRafaelSalmerónPedroGilMaria DoloresGiménezCristina. 2004. “Sexual Behaviors in Male Sex Workers in Spain: Modulating Factors.” Journal of Health Psychology19:207–17.
6.
BallesterRafaelSalmerónPedroGilMaria DoloresGiménezCristina. 2013. “The Influence of Drug Consumption on Condom Use and Other Aspects Related to HIV Infection Among Male Sex Workers in Spain.” AIDS and Behavior17:536–42.
7.
BaralStefan DavidReuel FriedmanM.GeibelScottRebeKevinBozhinovBorcheDioufDaoudaSabinKeithHollandClaire E.ChanRoyCáceresCarlos F.2015. “Male Sex Workers: Practices, Contexts, and Vulnerabilities for HIV Acquisition and Transmission.” The Lancet385:260–73.
8.
BasuIshikaJanaSmarajitRotheram-BorusMary JaneSwendemanDallasLeeSung-JaeNewmanPeterWeissRobert. 2004. “HIV Prevention among Sex Workers in India.” Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes36:845–52.
9.
BeattieTara S. H.BhattacharjeeParinitaRameshB. M.GurnaniVandanaAnthonyJohnIsacShajyMohanH. L.RamakrishnanAparajitaWheelerTishaBradleyJanetBlanchardJames F.MosesStephen. 2010. “Violence against Female Sex Workers in Karnataka State, South India: Impact on Health, and Reductions in Violence Following an Intervention Program.” BMC Public Health10:476.
10.
BhattacharjyaManjimaFuluEmmaMurthyLaxmiSeshuMeena SaraswathiCabassiJuliaVallejo-MestresMarta. 2015. The Rights(s) Evidence—Sex Work, Violence and HIV in Asia: A Multi-country Qualitative Study. Bangkok, Thailand: UNFPA, UNDP, and APNSW (CASAM).
11.
BimbiDavid S.2007. “Male Prostitution: Pathology, Paradigms and Progress in Research.” Journal of Homosexuality53 (1–2): 7–35.
12.
BloorMichael J.BarnardMarina A.FinlayAndrewMcKeganeyNeil P.1993. “HIV-related Risk Practices among Glasgow Male Prostitutes: Reframing Concepts of Risk Behavior.” Medical Anthropology Quarterly7:152–69.
13.
BrowneJanMinichielloVictor. 1995. “The Social Meanings behind Male Sex Work: Implications for Sexual Interactions.” The British Journal of Sociology46:598–622.
14.
BrowneJanMinichielloVictor. 1996. “Research Directions in Male Sex Work.” Journal of Homosexuality31:29–56.
15.
CampbellCatherineMzaidumeZodwa. 2001. “Grassroots Participation, Peer Education, and HIV Prevention by Sex Workers in South Africa.” American Journal of Public Health91:1978–86.
16.
CohnTracy J.LeakeValerie S.2012. “Affective Distress among Adolescents Who Endorse Same-sex Sexual Attraction: Urban versus Rural Differences and the Role of Protective Factors.” Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental Health16:291–305.
17.
ConnellR. W.2002. “Studying Men and Masculinity.” Resources for Feminist Research29 (1): 43–55.
CornishFlora. 2006. “Challenging the Stigma of Sex Work in India: Material Context and Symbolic Change.” Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology16:462–71.
20.
CrosbyRichard A.PittsNicole L.2007. “Caught between Different Worlds: How Transgendered Women May Be ‘Forced’ Into Risky Sex.” The Journal of Sex Research44:43–48.
21.
DeeringKathleen N.AminAvniShovellerJeanNesbittArielGarcia-MorenoClaudiaDuffPutuArgentoElenaShannonKate. 2014. “A Systematic Review of the Correlates of Violence against Sex Workers.” American Journal of Public Health104:e42–54.
22.
DiamondLisa M.ButterworthMolly, 2008. “Questioning Gender and Sexual Identity: Dynamic Links over Time.” Sex Roles59:365–76.
23.
DiClementeR. J.SalazarL. F.CrosbyR. A.RosenthalS. L.2005. “Prevention and Control of Sexually Transmitted Infections among Adolescents: The Importance of a Socio-ecological Perspective—A Commentary.” Public Health119:825–36.
24.
DriskillQwo-Li. 2004. Stolen From Our Bodies: First Nations Two-spirits/Queers and the Journey to a Sovereign Erotic. Studies in American Indian Literatures16:50–64.
25.
Dysart-GaleDeborah. 2010. “Social Justice and Social Determinants of Health: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgendered, Intersexed, and Queer Youth in Canada.” Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing23:23–28.
26.
EstcourtClaudia S.MarksCaronRohrsheimRichardJohnsonAnne M.DonovanBasilMindelAdrian. 2000. “HIV, Sexually Transmitted Infections, and Risk Behaviors in Male Commercial Sex Workers in Sydney.” Sexually Transmitted Infections76:294–98.
27.
EvansCatrinLambertHelen. 1997. “Health-seeking Strategies and Sexual Health among Female Sex Workers in Urban India: Implications for Research and Service Provision.” Social Science & Medicine44:1791–803.
28.
GalliherRenee VickermanRostoskySharon ScalesHughesHannah K.2004. “School Belonging, Self-esteem, and Depressive Symptoms in Adolescents: An Examination of Sex, Sexual Attraction Status, and Urbanicity.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence33:235–45.
29.
GammonMark A.IsgroKirsten L.2006. “Troubling the Cannon.” Journal of Homosexuality52:159–84.
30.
HallTimothy M.2007. “Rent-boys, Barflies, and Kept Men: Men Involved in Sex with Men for Compensation in Prague.” Sexualities10:457–72.
31.
HallettJonathanBrownGrahamMaycockBruceLangdonPatricia. 2007. “Changing Communities, Changing Spaces: The Challenges of Health Promotion Outreach in Cyberspace.” Promotion & Education19:150–54.
32.
HankivskyOlenaChristoffersenAshlee. 2008. “Intersectionality and the Determinants of Health: A Canadian Perspective.” Critical Public Health18:271–83.
33.
HarcourtChristineBeekIngrid vanHeslopJennyMcMahonMariaDonovanBasil. 2001. “The Health and Welfare Needs of Female and Transgender Street Sex Workers in New South Wales.” Australia and New Zealand Journal of Public Health25:84–89.
34.
HuntSarah. 2013. “Decolonizing Sex Work: Developing an Intersectional Indigenous Approach.” In Selling Sex: Experience, Advocacy, and Research on Sex Work in Canada, edited by van der MeulenEmilyDurisinElya M.LoveVictoria, 82–100. Vancouver, Canada: UBC Press.
35.
JayasreeA. K.2004. “Searching for Justice for Body and Self in a Coercive Environment: Sex Work in Kerala, India.” Reproductive Health Matters12:58–67.
36.
KatsulisYasmina. 2008. Sex Work and the City: The Social Geography of Health and Safety in Tijuana, Mexico. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
37.
KayeKerwin. 2003. “Male Prostitution in the Twentieth Century: Pseudohomosexuals, Hoodlum Homosexuals, and Exploited Teens.” Journal of Homosexuality46:1–77.
38.
KokenJuline A.BimbiDavid S.ParsonsJeffrey T.HalkitisPerry N.2004. “The Experience of Stigma in the Lives of Male Internet Escorts.” Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality16:13–32.
39.
KokenJuline A.ParsonsJeffrey T.SeverinoJosephBimbiDavid S.2005. “Exploring Commercial Sex Encounters in an Urban Community Sample of Gay and Bisexual Men.” Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality17:197–213.
40.
KrüsiAndrea. 2014. “The Social and Structural Production of Violence, Safety, and Sexual Risk Reduction among Street-based Sex Workers.” PhD dissertation, University of British Columbia, Canada.
41.
KrüsiA.PaceyK.BirdL.TaylorC.ChettiarJ.AllanS.BennettD.MontanerJ. S.KerrT.ShannonK.2014. “Criminalisation of Clients: Reproducing Vulnerabilities for Violence and Poor Health among Street-based Sex Workers in Canada—A Qualitative Study.” BMJ open4 (6): e005191.
42.
LevittHeidi M.IppoplitoMaria R.2014. “Being Transgender: Navigating Minority Stressors and Developing Authentic Self-presentation.” Psychology of Women Quarterly38:46–64.
43.
LoganTrevon D.2010. “Personal Characteristics, Sexual Behaviors, and Male Sex Work: A Quantitative Approach.” American Sociological Review75:679–704.
44.
LombardiEmilia. 2009. “Varieties of Transgender/Transsexual Lives and Their Relationship with Transphobia.” Journal of Homosexuality56:977–92.
45.
Longman MarcellinRoxanneBauerGreta R.ScheimAyden I.2013. “Intersecting Impacts of Transphobia and Racism on HIV Risk among Trans Persons of Colour in Ontario, Canada.” Ethnicity and Inequalities in Health and Social Care6 (4): 97–107.
46.
LutnickAlexandraCohanDeborah. 2009. “Criminalization, Legalization or Decriminalization of Sex Work: What Female Sex Workers Say in San Francisco, USA.” Reproductive Health Matters17:38–46.
47.
MillerM.AndréA.EbinJ.BessonovaL.2007. Bisexual Health: An Introduction and Model Practices for HIV/STI Prevention Programming. New York: National Gay and Lesbian Task Force Policy Institute, the Fenway Institute at Fenway Community Health, and BiNet USA.
48.
MinichielloV.MariñoR.KhanM. A.BrowneJ.2003. “Alcohol and Drug Use in Australian Male Sex Workers: Its Relationship to the Safety Outcome of the Sex Encounter.” AIDS Care15:549–61.
49.
MinichielloVictorScottJohnCallanderDenton. 2015. “A New Public Health Context to Understand Male Sex Work.” BMC Public Health15:282.
50.
ParsonsJeffrey T.BimbiDavidHalkitisPerry N.2001. “Sexual Compulsivity among Gay/Bisexual Male Escorts Who Advertise on the Internet.” Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity8:101–12.
51.
PoonColleen S.SaewycElizabeth M.2009. “Out Yonder: Sexual-minority Adolescents in Rural Communities in British Columbia.” American Journal of Public Health99:118–24.
52.
PoteatToniaWirtzAndrea L.RadixAnitaBorquezAnnickSilva-SantistebanAlfonsoDeutschMadeline B.KhanSharful IslamWinterSamOperarioDon. 2015. “HIV Risk and Preventive Interventions in Transgender Women Sex Workers.” The Lancet385:274–86.
53.
RekartMichael L.2005. “Sex-work Harm Reduction.” The Lancet366:2123–34.
54.
RistockJaniceZoccoleArtPassanteLisa. 2010. “Aboriginal Two-spirit and LGBTQ Migration, Mobility and Health Research Project: Winnipeg.” Final Report, November 2010,Winnipeg, MB.
55.
RomansSarah E.PotterKathleenMartinJudyHerbisonPeter. 2001. “The Mental and Physical Health of Female Sex Workers: A Comparative Study.” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry35:75–80.
56.
Rotheram-BorusMary JaneMahlerKaren A.KoopmanCherylLangabeerKris. 1996. “Sexual Abuse History and Associated Multiple Risk Behavior in Adolescent Runaways.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry66:390–400.
57.
SaewycElizabeth M.2011. “Research on Adolescent Sexual Orientation: Development, Health Disparities, Stigma, and Resilience.” Journal of Research on Adolescence21:256–72.
58.
ScamblerGrahamPaoliFrederique. 2008. “Health Work, Female Sex Workers and HIV/AIDS: Global and Local Dimensions of Stigma and Deviance as Barriers to Effective Interventions.” Social Science & Medicine66:1848–62.
59.
ScheimAyden I.JacksonRandyJamesLizSharp DoplerT.PyneJakeBauerGreta R.2013. “Barriers to Well-being for Aboriginal Gender-diverse People: Results from the Trans PULSE Project in Ontario, Canada.” Ethnicity and Inequalities in Health and Social Care6:108–20.
60.
SchleiferDavid. 2006. “Make Me Feel Mighty Feel: Gay Female-to-male Transgenderists Negotiating Sex, Gender, and Sexuality.” Sexualities9:57–75.
61.
ScottJohn. 2003. “A Prostitute’s Progress: Male Prostitution in Scientific Discourse.” Social Semiotics13:179–99.
62.
SeveliusJae M.2013. “Gender Affirmation: A Framework for Conceptualizing Risk Behavior among Transgender Women of Color.” Sex Roles68:675–89.
63.
ShannonKateStrathdeeSteffanie A.GoldenbergShira M.DuffPutuMwangiPeninahRusakovaMaiaReza-PaulSushenaLauJosephDeeringKathleenPicklesMichael R.BoilyMarie-Claude. 2015. “Global Epidemiology of HIV among Female Sex Workers: Influence of Structural Determinants.” The Lancet385:55–71.
64.
ShannonKateStrathdeeSteffanie A.ShovellerJeanRuschMelanieKeerThomasTyndallMark W.2009. “Structural and Environmental Barriers to Condom Use Negotiation with Clients among Female Sex Workers: Implications for HIV-prevention Strategies and Policy.” American Journal of Public Health99:659–65.
65.
TeengsDoris O’BrienTraversRobb. 2006 “‘River of Life, Rapids of Change’: Understanding HIV Vulnerability among Two-spirit Youth Who Migrate to Toronto.” Canadian Journal of Aboriginal Community-based HIV/AIDS Research1:17–28.
Trans PULSE. 2011. “Challenging the Binary: Gender Characteristics of Trans Ontarians.” Trans PULSE E-Bulletin2:2.
68.
Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. 2015. Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada: Calls to Action. Winnipeg, MN: Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada.
69.
VanwesenbeeckIne. 2001. “Another Decade of Social Scientific Work on Sex Work: A Review of Research 1990–2000.” Annual Review of Sex Research12:242–89.
70.
VealeJaimieSaewycElizabeth M.Frohard-DourlentHélèneDobsonSarahClarkBeth, and the Canadian Trans Youth Health Survey Research Group. 2015. Being Safe, Being Me: Results of the Canadian Trans Youth Health Survey. Vancouver, BC: Stigma and Resilience Among Vulnerable Youth Centre, School of Nursing, University of British Columbia.
71.
WalbyKevin. 2012. Touching Encounters: Sex, Work, & Male-for-Male Internet Escorting. London, UK: University of Chicago Press.
72.
WaltersKarina L.Evans-CampbellTeresaSimoniJane M.RonquilloTheresaBhuyanRupaleem. 2006. “‘My Spirit in My Heart’: Identity Experiences and Challenges among American Indian Two-spirit Women.” Journal of Lesbian Studies10:125–49.
73.
WechsbergW. M.LusenoW. K.LamW. K.2005. “Violence against Substance-abusing South African Sex Workers: Intersection with Culture and HIV risk.” AIDS Care17:55–64.
74.
WeinbergMartin S.ShaverFrances M.WilliamsColin J.1999. “Gendered Sex Work in the San Francisco Tenderloin.” Archives of Sexual Behavior28:503–21.
75.
WestbrookLaurelSapersteinAliya. 2015. “New Categories Are Not Enough: Rethinking the Measurement of Sex and Gender in Social Surveys.” Gender & Society29:534–60.
76.
WilsonAlex. 1996. “How We Find Ourselves: Identity Development and Two-spirit People.” Harvard Educational Review66:303–17.
77.
WongWilliam C. W.HolroydEleanorBinghamAmie. 2011. “Stigma and Sex Work from the Perspective of Female Sex Workers in Hong Kong.” Sociology of Health & Illness33:50–65.
78.
World Health Organization. 2012. Prevention and Treatment of HIV and Other Sexually Transmitted Infections for Sex Workers in Low- and Middle-income Countries: Recommendations for a Public Health Report. Geneva, Switzerland. Accessed November 14, 2015. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/77745/1/9789241504744_eng.pdf?ua=1.
