Evidence shows that downward social comparisons (DSCs), messages delivered by frontline employees describing how service experiences turned out even worse for others, can reduce customers’ anger following a service failure. This study contributes to the literature on DSCs and service recovery by highlighting pitfalls associated with the use of these messages in service recovery and showing the conditions necessary for their effectiveness. Building on persuasion knowledge theory, we show that customers draw manipulative inferences about DSCs because of the perceived bias associated with the source of the message and the implicit derogation of a competitor that DSCs entail. To reduce inferences of manipulative intentions, frontline employees should both accompany DSC messages with intense apologies and use self-derogation to reduce the perception that they are criticizing another firm. Past claims on the generalized effectiveness of DSCs need to be revised. Managers should craft social comparison messages carefully to avoid negative reactions from customers. Our research indicates that once adapted to address these concerns, DSCs can be an effective recovery strategy among individuals with a strong need for social comparison information.
AhluwaliaRohiniBurnkrantRobert E. (2004), “Answering Questions about Questions: A Persuasion Knowledge Perspective for Understanding the Effects of Rhetorical Questions,” Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (1), 26–42.
2.
AlexandrovAliooshaLillyBryanBabakusEmin (2013), “The Effects of Social- and Self-Motives on the Intentions to Share Positive and Negative Word of Mouth,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41 (5), 531–546.
3.
AspinallLisa G.TaylorShelley E. (1993), “Effects of Social Comparison Direction, Threat, and Self-Esteem on Affect, Self-Evaluation, and Expected Success,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 64 (5), 708–722.
4.
BagozziRichard P.YiYoujae (1988), “On the Evaluation of Structural Equation Models,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 16 (1), 74–94.
5.
BollenKennethLennoxRichard (1991), “Conventional Wisdom on Measurement: A Structural Equation Perspective,” Psychological Bulletin, 110 (2), 305–314.
6.
BonifieldCarolynColeCatherine A. (2008), “Better Him Than Me: Social Comparison Theory and Service Recovery,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36 (4), 565–577.
7.
BramelDanaTaubBarryBlumBarbara (1968), “An Observer’s Reaction to the Suffering of His Enemy,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 8 (4 pt 1), 384–392.
8.
ButzerBethanyKuiperNicholas A. (2006), “Relationship between the Frequency of Social Comparisons and Self-Concept Clarity, Intolerance of Uncertainty, Anxiety, and Depression,” Personality and Individual Differences, 41 (1), 167–176.
9.
BuunkBram P.GibbonsFrederick X. (2007), “Social Comparison: The End of a Theory and the Emergence of a Field,” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 102 (1), 3–21.
10.
BuunkBram P.MussweilerThomas (2001), “New Directions in Social Comparison Research,” European Journal of Social Psychology, 31 (5), 467–475.
11.
BuunkBram P.OldersmaFrans L.de DreuCarsten K. W. (2001), “Enhancing Satisfaction through Downward Comparison: The Role of Relational Dis-Content and Individual Differences in Social Comparison Orientation,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 37 (6), 452–467.
12.
BuunkBram P.van der ZeeKarenYperenNico W. van (2001), “Neuroticism and Social Comparison Orientation as Moderators of Affective Responses to Social Comparison at Work,” Journal of Personality, 69 (5), 745–763.
13.
CampbellMargaret C. (1995), “When Attention-Getting Advertising Tactics Elicit Consumer Inferences of Manipulative Intent: The Importance of Balancing Benefits and Investments,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 4 (3), 225–254.
14.
CampbellMargaret C.KirmaniAmna (2000), “Consumers’ Use of Persuasion Knowledge: The Effects of Accessibility and Cognitive Capacity on Perceptions of an Influence Agent,” Journal of Consumer Research, 27 (1), 69–83.
15.
ColquittJason A. (2001), “On the Dimensionality of Organizational Justice: A Construct Validation of a Measure,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 86 (3), 386–400.
16.
CoulterKeith S. (2009), “Enough Is Enough! Or Is It? Factors That Impact Switching Intentions in Extended Travel Service Transactions,” Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, 26 (2), 144–155.
17.
CoulterRobin HigiePintoMary Beth (1995), “Guilt Appeals in Advertising: What Are Their Effects?” Journal of Applied Psychology, 80 (6), 697–705.
18.
DavidowMoshe (2000), “The Bottom Line Impact of Organizational Responses to Customer Complaints,” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research, 24 (4), 473–490.
19.
DeCarloThomas E. (2005), “The Effects of Sales Message and Suspicion of Ulterior Motives on Salesperson Evaluation,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 15 (3), 238–249.
20.
de RuyterKoWetzelsMartin (2000), “Customer Equity Considerations in Service Recovery: A Cross-Industry Perspective,” International Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (1), 91–108.
21.
DuJiangangFanXiuchengFengTianjun (2014), “Group Emotional Contagion and Complaint Intentions in Group Service Failure: The Role of Group Size and Group Familiarity,” Journal of Service Research, 17 (3), 326–338.
22.
FehrRyanGelfandMichele J. (2010), “When Apologies Work: How Matching Apology Components to Victims’ Self-Construals Facilitates Forgiveness,” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 113 (1), 37–50.
23.
FestingerLeon (1954), “A Theory of Social Comparison Processes,” Human Relations, 7 (2), 117–140.
24.
FornellClaesLarckerDavid F. (1981), “Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error: Algebra and Statistics,” Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (3), 382–388.
25.
FriestadMarianWrightPeter (1994), “The Persuasion Knowledge Model: How People Cope with Persuasion Attempts,” Journal of Consumer Research, 21 (1), 1–31.
26.
GelbrichKatja (2010), “Anger, Frustration, and Helplessness after Service Failure: Coping Strategies and Effective Informational Support,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 38 (5), 567–585.
27.
GelbrichKatjaRoschkHolger (2011), “A Meta-Analysis of Organizational Complaint Handling and Customer Responses,” Journal of Service Research, 14 (1), 24–43.
28.
GibbonsFrederick X.BuunkBram P. (1999), “Individual Differences in Social Comparison: Development and Validation of a Measure of Social Comparison Orientation,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76 (1), 129–142.
29.
GibbonsFrederick X.McCoySue B. (1991), “Self-Esteem, Similarity, and Reactions to Active Versus Passive Downward Comparison,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60 (3), 414–424.
30.
GrégoireYanyLauferDanielTrippThomas M. (2010), “A Comprehensive Model of Customer Direct and Indirect Revenge: Understanding the Effects of Perceived Greed and Customer Power,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 38 (6), 738–758.
31.
GrégoireYanyTrippThomas M.LegouxRenaud (2009), “When Customer Love Turns into Lasting Hate: The Effects of Relationship Strength and Time on Customer Revenge and Avoidance,” Journal of Marketing, 73 (6), 18–32.
32.
GuimondSergeBrunotSophieChatardArmandGarciaDonna M.MartinotDelphineBranscombeNyla R.BuunkAbraham P.DesertMichelHaqueShamsulYzerbytVincent (2007), “Culture, Gender and the Self: Variations and Impact of Social Comparison Processes,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92 (6), 1118–1134.
33.
GuoWenxiaMainKelley J. (2012), “The Vulnerability of Defensiveness: The Impact of Persuasion Attempts and Processing Motivations on Trust,” Marketing Letters, 23 (4), 959–971.
34.
HayesAndrew F. (2018), Introduction to Mediation, Moderation and Conditional Process Analysis, 2nd ed. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
35.
HenselerJörgRingleChristianSarstedtMarko (2015), “A New Criterion for Assessing Discriminant Validity in Variance-Based Structural Equation Modeling,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 43 (1), 115–135.
36.
HillRonald P.MartinKelly D.ChaplinLan Nguyen (2012), “A Tale of Two Marketplaces: Consumption Restriction, Social Comparison, and Life Satisfaction,” Marketing Letters, 23 (2), 731–744.
37.
HykenS. (2017, 218), Every Employee Needs Customer Service Training—Here’s Why. New York, NY: Forbes.
38.
IsaacMathew S.GraysonKent (2017), “Beyond Skepticism: Can Accessing Persuasion Knowledge Bolster Credibility?” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (6), 895–912.
39.
JainShailendra P.BuchananBruceMaheswaranDurairaj (2000), “Comparative Versus Noncomparative Advertising: The Moderating Impact of Prepurchase Attribute Verifiability,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 9 (4), 201–211.
40.
JainShailendra P.PosavacSteven S. (2004), “Valenced Comparisons,” Journal of Marketing Research, 41 (1), 46–58.
41.
JergerChristinaWirtzJochen (2017), “Service Employee Responses to Angry Customer Complaints: The Roles of Customer Status and Service Climate,” Journal of Service Research, 20 (4), 362–378.
42.
JoiremanJeffGrégoireYanyDevezerBernaTrippThomas M. (2013), “When Do Customers Offer Firms a “Second Chance” Following a Double Deviation? The Impact of Inferred Firm Motives on Customer Revenge and Reconciliation,” Journal of Retailing, 89 (3), 315–337.
43.
KalamasMariaLarocheMichelMakdessianLucy (2008), “Reaching the Boiling Point: Consumers’ Negative Affective Reactions to Firm-Attributed Service Failures,” Journal of Business Research, 61 (8), 813–824.
44.
KarandeKiranMagniniVincent P.TamLeona (2007), “Recovery Voice and Satisfaction after Service Failure. An Experimental Investigation of Mediating and Moderating Factors,” Journal of Service Research, 10 (2), 187–203.
45.
KimEunjin A.RatneshwarS.RoeslerErinChowdhuryTilottama G. (2016), “Attention to Social Comparison Information and Brand Avoidance Behaviors,” Marketing Letters, 27 (2), 259–271.
46.
KirmaniAmnaZhuRui (2007), “Vigilant Against Manipulation: The Effect of Regulatory Focus on the Use of Persuasion Knowledge,” Journal of Marketing Research, 44 (4), 688–701.
47.
KuppensPeterMechelenIven VanSmitsDirk J. M.BoeckPaul De (2003), “The Appraisal Basis of Anger: Specificity, Necessity and Sufficiency of Components,” Emotion, 3 (3), 254–269.
48.
LarosFleur J. M.SteenkampJan-Benedict E. M. (2005), “Emotions in Consumer Behavior: A Hierarchical Approach,” Journal of Business Research, 58 (10), 1437–1445.
49.
MajorBrendaSciacchitanoAnne M.CrockerJennifer (1993), “Ingroup vs. Outgroup Comparisons and Self-Esteem,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 19 (6), 711–721.
50.
MattilaAnna S. (2006), “The Power of Explanations in Mitigating the Ill-Effects of Service Failures,” Journal of Services Marketing, 20 (7), 422–428.
51.
McColl-KennedyJanet R.PattersonPaul G.SmithAmy K.BradyMichael K. (2009), “Customer Rage Episodes: Emotions, Expressions and Behaviors,” Journal of Retailing, 85 (2), 222–237.
52.
McCulloughMichael E.SandageSteven J.BrownSusan W.RachalChrisWorthingtonE. L.JrHightTerry L. (1998), “Interpersonal Forgiving in Close Relationships: II. Theoretical Elaboration and Measurement,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75 (6), 1586–1603.
53.
MikolonSvenQuaiserBenjaminWiesekeJan (2015), “Don’t Try Harder: Using Customer Inoculation to Build Resistance against Service Failures,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 43 (4), 512–527.
54.
MussweilerThomasRüterKatjaEpstudeKai (2004), “The Man Who Wasn’t There: Subliminal Social Comparison Standards Influence Self-Evaluation,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 40 (5), 689–696.
55.
ObeidatZaid M. I.XiaoSarah H.IyerGopalkrishnanNicholsonMichael (2017), “Consumer Revenge Using the Internet and Social Media: An Examination of the Role of Service Failure Types and Cognitive Appraisal Processes,” Psychology & Marketing, 34 (4), 496–515.
56.
OuelletteJudith A.HesslingR.GibbonsFrederick X.Reis-BerganMonicaGerrardMeg (2005), “Using Images to Increase Exercise Behavior: Prototypes versus Possible Selves,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 31 (5), 610–620.
57.
PeerEyalBrandimarteLauraSamatSonamAcquistiAlessandro (2017), “Beyond the Turk: Alternative Platforms for Crowdsourcing Behavioral Research,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 70, 153–163.
58.
RainsStephen A. (2013), “The Nature of Psychological Reactance Revisited: A Meta-Analytic Review,” Human Communication Research, 39 (1), 47–73.
59.
RichinsMarsha L. (1991), “Social Comparison and the Idealized Images of Advertising,” Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (1), 71–83.
60.
RoggeveenAnne L.TsirosMichaelGrewalDhruv (2012), “Understanding the Co-Creation Effect: When Does Collaborating with Customers Provide a Lift to Service Recovery?” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 40 (6), 771–790.
61.
RoschkHolgerKaiserSusanne (2013), “The Nature of an Apology: An Experimental Study on How to Apologize after a Service Failure,” Marketing Letters, 24 (3), 293–309.
62.
SpillerStephen A.FitzsimonsGavan J.LynchJohn G.JrMcClellandGary H. (2013), “Spotlights, Floodlights, and the Magic Number Zero: Simple Effects Tests in Moderated Regression,” Journal of Marketing Research, 50 (2), 277–288.
63.
StrizhakovaYuliyaTsarenkoYelenaRuthJulie A. (2012), “I’m Mad and I Can’t Get That Service Failure Off My Mind: Coping and Rumination as Mediators of Anger Effects on Customer Intentions,” Journal of Service Research, 15 (4), 414–429.
64.
SurachartkumtonkunJirapornMcColl-KennedyJanet R.PattersonPaul G. (2015), “Unpacking Customer Rage Elicitation: A Dynamic Model,” Journal of Service Research, 18 (2), 177–192.
65.
SzykmanLisa R.BloomPaul N.BlazingJennifer (2004), “Does Corporate Sponsorship of a Socially-Oriented Message Make a Difference? An Investigation of the Effects of Sponsorship Identity on Responses to an Anti-Drinking and Driving Message,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 14 (1-2), 13–20.
66.
TaxStephen S.BrownStephen W.ChandrashekaranMurali (1998), “Customer Evaluations of Service Complaint Experiences: Implications for Relationship Marketing,” Journal of Marketing, 62 (2), 60–76.
67.
TaylorShelley E.WoodJoanne V.LichtmanRosemary R. (1983), “It Could Be Worse: Selective Evaluation as a Response to Victimization,” Journal of Social Issues, 39 (2), 19–40.
68.
ThauStefanAquinoKarlWittekRafael (2007), “An Extension of Uncertainty Management Theory to the Self: The Relationship between Justice, Social Comparison Orientation, and Antisocial Work Behaviors,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 92 (1), 250–258.
69.
Van der HeijdenGielis A. H.SchepersJeroen J. L.NijssenEdwin J.OrdaniniAndrea (2013), “Don’t Just Fix It, Make It Better! Using Frontline Service Employees to Improve Recovery Performance,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41 (5), 515–530.
70.
Van der ZeeKaren, OldersmaFransBuunkBram P.BosDianne (1998), “Social Comparison Preferences among Cancer Patients as Related to Neuroticism and Social Comparison Orientation,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75 (3), 801–810.
71.
Van VaerenbergYvesOrsingherChiara (2016), “Service Recovery: An Integrative Framework and Research Agenda,” Academy of Management Perspectives, 30 (3), 328–346.
72.
Vázquez-CasiellesRodolfoIglesiasVíctorVarela-NeiraConcepción (2012), “Service Recovery, Satisfaction and Behaviour Intentions: Analysis of Compensation and Social Comparison Communication Strategies,” The Service Industries Journal, 32 (1), 83–103.
73.
VoorheesClay M.BradyMichael K.CalantoneRogerRamirezEdward (2016), “Discriminant Validity Testing in Marketing: An Analysis, Causes for Concern, and Proposed Remedies,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 44 (1), 119–134.
74.
WalsterElaineBerscheidEllenWalsterG. William (1973), “New Directions in Equity Research,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 25 (2), 151–176.
75.
WheelerLaddMiyakeKunitate (1992), “Social Comparison in Everyday Life,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 62 (5), 760–773.
76.
WhiteJudith B.LangerEllen J.YarivLeeatWelchJohn C. (2006), “Frequent Social Comparisons and Destructive Emotions and Behaviors: The Dark Side of Social Comparisons,” Journal of Adult Development, 13 (1), 36–44.
77.
WillsThomas A. (1981), “Downward Comparison Principles in Social Psychology,” Psychological Bulletin, 90 (2), 245–271.
78.
WilsonAnne E.RossMichael (2000), “The Frequency of Temporal-Self and Social Comparisons in People’s Personal Appraisals,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78 (5), 928–942.
79.
WirtzJochenMattilaAnna S. (2004), “Consumer Responses to Compensation, Speed of Recovery and Apology after a Service Failure,” International Journal of Service Industry Management, 15 (2), 150–166.
80.
WoodJoanne V.MichelaJohn L.CaterinaGiordano (2000), “Downward Comparison in Everyday Life: Reconciling Self-Enhancement Models with the Mood-Cognition Priming Model,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79 (4), 563–579.
81.
YbarraOscar (2002), “Naive Causal Understanding of Valenced Behaviors and Its Implications for Social Information Processing,” Psychological Bulletin, 128 (3), 421–441.
82.
ZhuZhenNakataCherylSivakumarK.GrewalDhruv (2007), “Self-Service Technology Effectiveness: The Role of Design Features and Individual Traits,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 35 (4), 492–506.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
