Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2023-4
Talking Turtles With Tourists: Evaluating the Relative Conservation Impacts of Different Types of Sea Turtle Education Programs at Jekyll Island,GA,USA
We used a pre-post survey approach to compare learning and conservation-focused behavioral outcomes for tourists participating in two different types of field-based wildlife education programs at the Jekyll Island Authority Georgia Sea Turtle Center (GSTC) on Jekyll Island, GA, USA: a low-interaction program (n = 59) led by education guides that featured minimal direct contact between visitors and sea turtles, and a high-interaction program (n = 42) led by turtle biologists that featured more intimate interactions between visitors and turtles. Both programs revealed comparable positive effects on participants’ knowledge of sea turtles and intent to engage in turtle advocacy behaviors, but neither type of program had a major influence on pro-turtle attitudes or participation in turtle-friendly beach behaviors (partly because scores for these variables were high entering the program). Results suggest managers and educators at wildlife tourism destinations could employ different program delivery methods while still achieving similar education and conservation goals.
ArdoinN. M.BowersA. W.GaillardE. (2020). Environmental education outcomes for conservation: A systematic review. Biological Conservation, 241, 108224.
2.
ArdoinN. M.WheatonM.BowersA. W.HuntC. A.DurhamW. H. (2015). Nature-based tourism’s impact on environmental knowledge, attitudes, and behavior: A review and analysis of the literature and potential future research. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 23(6), 838–858.
3.
BallantyneR.HughesK.LeeJ.PackerJ.SneddonJ. (2018). Visitors’ values and environmental learning outcomes at wildlife attractions: Implications for interpretive practice. Tourism Management, 64, 190–201.
4.
BallantyneR.PackerJ. (2005). Promoting environmentally sustainable attitudes and behaviour through free-choice learning experiences: what is the state of the game?Environmental Education Research, 11, 281–295.
5.
BallantyneR.PackerJ. (2009). Introducing a fifth pedagogy: Experience-based strategies for facilitating learning in natural environments. Environmental Education Research, 15, 243–262.
6.
BallantyneR.PackerJ. (2011). Using tourism free-choice learning experiences to promote environmentally sustainable behaviour: The role of post-visit ‘action resources’. Environmental Education Research, 17, 201–215.
7.
BallantyneR.PackerJ.FalkJ. (2011). Visitors’ learning for environmental sustainability: Testing short- and long-term impacts of wildlife tourism experiences using structural equation modelling. Tourism Management, 32, 1243–1252.
8.
BallantyneR.PackerJ.HughesK. (2009). Tourists’ support for conservation messages and sustainable management practices in wildlife tourism experiences. Tourism Management, 30, 658–664.
9.
BallantyneR.PackerJ.HughesK.DierkingL. (2007). Conservation learning in wildlife tourism settings: Lessons from research in zoos and aquariums. Environmental Education Research, 13, 367–383.
10.
BallantyneR.PackerJ.SutherlandL. A. (2011). Visitors’ memories of wildlife tourism: Implications for the design of powerful interpretive experiences. Tourism Management, 32, 770–779.
11.
BallouardJ. M.ProvostG.BarréD.BonnetX. (2012). Influence of a field trip on the attitude of schoolchildren toward unpopular organisms: An experience with snakes. Journal of Herpetology, 46, 423–428.
12.
BeaumontN. (2001). Ecotourism and the conservation ethic: Recruiting the uninitiated or preaching to the converted?Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 9(4), 317–341.
13.
BognerF. X. (1998). The influence of short-term outdoor ecology education on long-term variables of environmental perspective. The Journal of Environmental Education, 29, 17–29.
14.
BuckleyR. C. (2022). Sensory and emotional components in tourist memories of wildlife encounters: Intense, detailed, and long-lasting recollections of individual incidents. Sustainability, 14(8), 4460.
15.
ClarkE.MulgrewK.Kannis-DymandL.SchafferV.HobergR. (2019). Theory of planned behaviour: Predicting tourists’ pro-environmental intentions after a humpback whale encounter. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 27(5), 649–667.
16.
CurtinS. (2010). What makes for memorable wildlife encounters? Revelations from ‘serious’ wildlife tourists. Journal of Ecotourism, 9, 149–168.
17.
DimopoulosD.ParaskevopoulosS.PantisJ. D. (2008). The cognitive and attitudinal effects of a Conservation Educational Module on elementary school students. The Journal of Environmental Education, 39, 47–61.
18.
DudaM. D.NobileJ. L. (2010). The fallacy of online surveys: No data are better than bad data. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 15, 55–64.
19.
DunnO. J. (1964). Multiple comparisons using rank sums. Technometrics, 6(3), 241–252.
20.
EaglesP. F. J.DemareR. (1999). Factors influencing children’s environmental attitudes. The Journal of Environmental Education, 30, 33–37.
21.
ErnstJ.BloodN.BeeryT. (2017). Environmental action and student environmental leaders: Exploring the influence of environmental attitudes, locus of control, and sense of personal responsibility. Environmental Education Research, 23(2), 149–175.
22.
ErnstJ.TheimerS. (2011). Evaluating the effects of environmental education programming on connectedness to nature. Environmental Education Research, 17, 577–598.
23.
García-CegarraA. M.PachecoA. S. (2017). Whale-watching trips in Peru lead to increases in tourist knowledge, pro-conservation intentions and tourist concern for the impacts of whale-watching on humpback whales. Aquatic Conservation Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 27, 1011–1020.
24.
HailmanJ. P.ElowsonA. M. (1992). Ethogram of the nesting female loggerhead (Caretta caretta). Herpetologica, 48, 1–30.
25.
HammertonZ. (2017). Low-impact diver training in management of SCUBA diver impacts. Journal of Ecotourism, 16, 69–94.
26.
HamS. H.WeilerB. (2012). Interpretation as the centerpiece of sustainable wildlife tourism. In HarrisR.GriffinT.WilliamsP (eds.). Sustainable Tourism (2nd ed., pp. 35–44). Butterworth-Heinemann.
27.
HassanR.YahyaN. K.OngL. M.KengL. K.AbidinZ. Z.AyobA.JainalA. M. (2017). Public awareness program and development of education toolkit for green sea turtle conservation in Sarawak, Malaysia. The International Journal of Environmental and Science Education, 12, 463–474.
28.
HeberleinT. A. (2012). Navigating environmental attitudes. Oxford University Press.
29.
Herrera-SilveiraJ. A.CebrianJ.HauxwellJ.Ramirez-RamirezJ.RalphP. (2010). Evidence of negative impacts of ecological tourism on turtlegrass (Thalassia testudinum) beds in a marine protected area of the Mexican Caribbean. Aquatic Ecology, 44, 23–31.
30.
HicksJ. R.StewartW. P. (2018). Exploring potential components of wildlife-inspired awe. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 23(3), 293–295.
31.
HoneyM. (2008). Ecotourism and sustainable development: Who owns paradise? (2nd ed.). Island Press.
HughesK. (2013). Measuring the impact of viewing wildlife: Do positive intentions equate to long-term changes in conservation behaviour?Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 21(1), 42–59.
34.
HughesM.SaundersA. M. (2005). Interpretation, activity participation, and environmental attitudes of visitors to Penguin Island, Western Australia. Society & Natural Resources, 18, 611–624.
35.
HungerfordH. R.VolkT. L. (1990). Changing learner behavior through environmental education. The Journal of Environmental Education, 21, 8–21.
36.
KimA. K.AireyD.SzivasE. (2011). The multiple assessment of interpretation effectiveness: Promoting visitors’ environmental attitudes and behavior. Journal of Travel Research, 50, 321–334.
37.
LarsonL. R.StedmanR. C.CooperC. B.DeckerD. J. (2015). Understanding the multi-dimensional structure of pro-environmental behavior. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 43, 112–124.
38.
LarsonL. R.UsherL. E.ChapmonT. (2018). Surfers as environmental stewards: understanding place-protecting behavior at Cape Hatteras National Seashore. Leisure Sciences, 40, 442–465.
39.
LeemingF. C.DwyerW. O.PorterB. E.CobernM. K. (1993). Outcome research in environmental education: A critical review. The Journal of Environmental Education, 24, 8–21.
40.
LeeW. H.MoscardoG. (2005). Understanding the impact of ecotourism resort experiences on tourists’ environmental attitudes and behavioural intentions. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 13, 546–565.
41.
MascovichK. A.LarsonL. R.AndrewsK. M. (2018). Lights on, or lights off? Hotel guests’ response to nonpersonal educational outreach designed to protect nesting sea turtles. Chelonian Conservation and Biology, 17, 206–215.
42.
MeletisZ.HarrisonE. (2010). Tourists and turtles: searching for a balance in Tortuguero, Costa Rica. Conservation and Society, 8, 26–43.
43.
MillerL. B.HalloJ. C.DvorakR. G.FeferJ. P.PetersonB. A.BrownleeM. T. J. (2020). On the edge of the world: Examining pro-environmental outcomes of last chance tourism in Kaktovik, Alaska. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 28(11), 1703–1722.
44.
MillerZ. D. (2017). The enduring use of the theory of planned behavior. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 22(6), 583–590.
45.
MorganJ. M.GramannJ. H. (1989). Predicting effectiveness of wildlife education programs: A study of students’ attitudes and knowledge toward snakes. Wildlife Society Bulletin, 17, 501–509.
46.
NewsomeD.DowlingR. K.MooreS. A. (2005). Wildlife Tourism. Channel View Publications.
47.
Oliver de la EsperanzaA.Arenas MartínezA.Tzeek TuzM.Pérez-CollazosE. (2017). Are anthropogenic factors affecting nesting habitat of sea turtles? The case of Kanzul beach, Riviera Maya-Tulum (Mexico). Journal of Coastal Conservation, 21, 85–93.
48.
OndichB. L.AndrewsK. M. (2013). A history of sea turtle tagging and monitoring on Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA. Marine Turtle Newsletter, 138, 11–15.
49.
PearceJ.Strickland-MunroJ.MooreS. A. (2017). What fosters awe-inspiring experiences in nature-based tourism destinations?Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25, 362–378.
50.
PowellR. B.HamS. H. (2008). Can ecotourism interpretation really lead to pro-conservation knowledge, attitudes and behaviour? Evidence from the Galapagos Islands. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 16, 467–489.
51.
PowellR. B.SternM. J. (2013). Speculating on the role of context in the outcomes of interpretive programs. Journal of Interpretation Research, 18, 61–78.
52.
PowellR. B.VezeauS. L.SternM. J.MooreD. D.WrightB. A. (2018). Does interpretation influence elaboration and environmental behaviors?Environmental Education Research, 24(6), 875–888.
53.
RenQ.FoltaE. (2016). Evaluating environmental interpretation with mixed method: A Case Study at the International Crane Foundation, Wisconsin. Journal of Interpretation Research, 21, 5–19.
54.
SchulerG. M.SkibinsJ. C. (2022). #oldnews: Diffusion of pro-conservation behaviors and social media in wildlife tourism. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/10871209.2022.2078522
55.
SharpR. L.LarsonL. R.GreenG. T.TomekS. (2012). Comparing interpretive methods targeting invasive species management at Cumberland Island National Seashore. Journal of Interpretation Research, 17, 23–40.
56.
SkibinsJ. C.PowellR. B.SternM. J. (2012). Exploring empirical support for interpretation’s best practices. Journal of Interpretation Research, 17, 25–44.
57.
SkupienG. M.AndrewsK. M.LarsonL. R. (2016). Teaching tolerance? Effects of conservation education programs on wildlife acceptance capacity for the American alligator. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 21, 264–279.
58.
SmithJ. R.LindborgR. J.HernandezV.AbneyE. A.WitheringtonB. E. (2021). Using behavior indices and vital rates to determine the conservation impact of wildlife tourism: Guided sea turtle watch programs in Florida. Global Ecology and Conservation, 27, e01537.
59.
SpringJ. (2022). Nature-based tourism and guided wildlife tours: Designing wildlife tour experiences that optimise sustainable learning opportunities. Journal of Ecotourism, 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/14724049.2022.2098963
60.
SternM. J.PowellR. B. (2013). What leads to better visitor outcomes in live interpretation?Journal of Interpretation Research, 18, 9–43.
61.
SternM. J.PowellR. B.ArdoinN. M. (2010). Evaluating a constructivist and culturally responsive approach to environmental education for diverse audiences. The Journal of Environmental Education, 42, 109–122.
62.
SternM. J.PowellR. B.HillD. (2014). Environmental education program evaluation in the new millennium: what do we measure and what have we learned?Environmental Education Research, 20, 581–611.
63.
TisdellC.WilsonC. (2005). Perceived impacts of ecotourism on environmental learning and conservation: Turtle watching as a case study. Environment Development and Sustainability, 7, 291–302.
64.
TraveC.BrunnschweilerJ.SheavesM.DiedrichA.BarnettA. (2017). Are we killing them with kindness? Evaluation of sustainable marine wildlife tourism. Biological Conservation, 209, 211–222.
65.
VolkT. L.CheakM. J. (2003). The effects of an environmental education program on students, parents, and community. The Journal of Environmental Education, 34, 12–25.
66.
WaayersD.NewsomeD.LeeD. (2006). Research Note Observations of non-compliance behaviour by tourists to a voluntary code of conduct: A pilot study of turtle tourism in the Exmouth Region, Western Australia. Journal of Ecotourism, 5, 211–222.
67.
WarrenS. (2022). ‘When you have this intimacy with it, you do want to protect its environment’: The role of emotions on a zoo visit in engaging visitors in wildlife conservation. In CuttingR.PassyR. (eds) Contemporary approaches to outdoor learning (pp. 83–98). Palgrave Macmillan.
68.
WeilerB.HamS. H. (2010). Development of a research instrument for evaluating the visitor outcomes of face-to-face interpretation. Visitor Studies, 13, 187–205.
69.
ZeppelH. (2008). Education and conservation benefits of marine wildlife tours: developing free-choice learning experiences. The Journal of Environmental Education, 39(3), 3–18.
