Efficacy of Combining Education and Site Management in Reducing Off-Trail Travel in a Fragile Biotic Community,Acadia National Park

Abstract

Averaging 2.4 million visits annually across fewer than 50,000 acres, Acadia National Park (ANP) is a “densely visited” park whose managers seek to protect the quality of natural resources and visitor experiences. The proliferation of informal (visitor-created) trail networks increases resource degradation and management costs to curtail and repair them. This paper evaluates the efficacy and acceptability of adaptive management measures for discouraging off-trail travel in a backcountry setting at ANP. Additive combinations of management techniques—designed to address multiple motives for going off-trail—are evaluated for efficacy along a high use backcountry summit trail. Trail site management actions and educational signs addressing multiple motives for off-trail travel were shown to be effective, as are more direct, obtrusive measures relying on fewer additive components. Management situations warranting the use of direct measures (e.g., fencing) vs. combinations of less direct and obtrusive measures are discussed.

Keywords

recreation ecology visitor impact off-trail impact deterring off-trail hiking vegetation trampling visitor communication informal trails

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alessa

Bennett

S. M.

Kliskey

A. D.

(2003). Effects of knowledge, personal attribution and perception of ecosystem health on depreciative behaviors in the intertidal zone of Pacific Rim National Park and Reserve. Journal of Environmental Management, 68, 207–218.

Baldwin

LaPage

(2003). Visitor behaviors and resource impacts at Cadillac Mountain Acadia National Park, Part II: Sign comparison study summer 2002 (Technical report for Acadia National Park Natural Resources Division).

Barros

Pickering

C. M.

(2017). How networks of informal trails cause landscape level damage to vegetation. Environmental Management, 60, 57–68.

Bradford

McIntyre

(2007). Off the beaten track: Messages as a means of reducing social trail use at St. Lawrence Islands National Park. 25, 1–21.

Brown

T. J.

Ham

S. H.

Hughes

(2010). Picking up litter: An application of theory-based communication to influence tourist behaviour in protected areas. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 18(7), 879–900.

Cacioppo

J. T.

Petty

R. E.

Kao

C. F.

Rodriguez

(1986). Central and peripheral routes to persuasion: An individual difference perspective. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51(5), 1032–1043.

Cahill

K. L.

Marion

J. L.

Lawson

S. R.

(2008). Exploring visitor acceptability for hardening trails to sustain visitation and minimise impacts. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 16(2), 232–245.

Carls

E. G.

(1974). The effects of people and man-induced conditions on preferences for outdoor recreation landscapes. Journal of Leisure Research, 6(2), 113–124.

Cheung

H. K.

(1972). A day-use park visitation model. Journal of Leisure Research, 4, 139–156.

10.

Christensen

Dustin

(1989). Reaching recreationists at different levels of moral development. Journal of Park and Recreation Administration, 7(4), 72–80.

11.

Cole

D. N.

(1995a). Experimental trampling of vegetation. II. Predictors of resistance and resilience. Journal of Applied Ecology, 32, 215–224.

12.

Cole

D. N.

(1995b). Disturbance of natural vegetation by camping: Experimental applications of low-level stress. Journal of Environmental Management, 19(3), 405–416.

13.

Cole

D. N.

Hammond

T. P.

McCool

S. F.

(1997). Information quantity and communication effectiveness: Low-impact messages on wilderness trailside bulletin boards. Leisure Sciences, 19(1), 59–72.

14.

Cole

D. N.

Petersen

M. E.

Lucas

R. C.

(1987). Managing wilderness recreation use: Common problems and potential solutions. USDA Forest Service, Intermountain Research Station. Gen. Tech. Rpt. INT-230.

15.

Crandall

(1980). Motivations for leisure. Journal of Leisure Research, 12(1), 45–54.

16.

Croft

D. B.

(2019). Walking in each other’s footsteps: Do Animal Trail makers confer resilience against trampling tourists? Environments, 6(7), 83.

17.

Davis

R. B.

(1966). Spruce-Fir forests of the coast of Maine. Ecological Monographs, 36(2), 79–94.

18.

Eagly

A. H.

Chaiken

(1993). The psychology of Attitudes. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College Publishers.

19.

Evans

C. B.

(2002). Summit steward 2002 Season Report. USDI National Park Service, Acadia National Park.

20.

Fennell

D. A.

(2001). A content analysis of ecotourism definitions. Current Issues in Tourism, 4(5), 403–421.

21.

Goh

(2020). Walking off-trail in national parks: Monkey see monkey do. Leisure Sciences, https://doi.org/10.1080/01490400.2020.1755750.

22.

Gramann

J. H.

Christensen

H. H.

Vander Stoep

G. A.

(1992). Indirect management to protect cultural and natural resources: Research, ethics, and social policy. In Christensen

H. H.

Johnson

D. R.

Brookes

M. H.

(Eds.), Vandalism: Research, prevention, and Social Policy (pp. 103–120). USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station. General Technical Report PNW-GTR-293.

23.

Gramann

J. H.

Vander Stoep

G. A.

(1986). Reducing depreciative behavior at Shiloh National Military Park. Department of Recreation and Parks, Texas Agricultural Experiment Station, Texas A & M University.

24.

Guo

Smith

J. W.

Leung

Y.-F.

Seekamp

Moore

R. L.

(2015). Determinants of responsible hiking behavior: Results from a stated choice experiment. Environmental Management, 56, 765–776.

25.

Guo

Smith

J. W.

Moore

R. L.

Schultz

C. L.

(2017). Integrating off-site visitor education into landscape conservation and management: An examination of timing of educational messaging and compliance with low-impact hiking recommendations. Landscape and Urban Planning, 164, 25–36.

26.

Ham

S. H.

Weiler

Hughes

Brown

(2008). Asking Visitors to Help: Research to Guide Strategic Communication in Protected Area Management. Technical Rpt., Rayner

(Ed.), CRC for Sustainable Tourism Pty Ltd. Australia.

27.

Hammitt

W. E.

Cole

D. N.

Monz

C. A.

2015. Wildland Recreation: Ecology and Management. John Wiley & Sons, NY.

28.

Harrison

(1976). Problems: Vandalism and depreciative behavior. In Sharpe

G. W.

(Ed.), Interpreting the Environment (pp. 473–495). John Wiley and Sons.

29.

Havlick

D. G.

Billmeyer

Huber

Vogt

Rodman

(2016). Informal trail creation: Hiking, trail running, and mountain bicycling in shortgrass prairie. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 24(7), 1041–1058.

30.

Hill

Pickering

C. M.

(2006). Vegetation associated with different walking track types in the Kosciuszko alpine area, Australia. Journal of Environmental Management, 78(1), 24–34.

31.

Hockett

K. S.

Marion

J. L.

Leung

Y.-F.

(2017). The efficacy of combined educational and site management actions in reducing off-trail hiking in an urban-proximate protected area. Journal of Environmental Management, 203, 17–28.

32.

Howard

Buttke

D. E.

Lovejoy

T. E.

Clark

K. A.

Ashby

E. J.

Alonso Aguirre

(2021). The Loop Trail “Quest”: Use of a choice-based digital simulation, an interactive video, and a booklet to communicate and analyze decision-making of Park visitors. Environmental Communication, 15(8), 1025–1044.

33.

Jacobi

(2013). Hiker use of selected summits and trails in Acadia National Park, 2012. USDI National Park Service, Acadia National Park, Natural Resources Report. 38 pp.

34.

Johnson

Bratton

Firth

(1987). The feasibility of using brushing to deter visitor use of unofficial trails at Craggy Gardens, Blue Ridge Parkway, North Carolina. CPSU Report No. 43. USDI National Park Service Cooperative Studies Unit, Institute of Ecology, University of Georgia, Athens, GA.

35.

Johnson

D. R.

Swearingen

T. C.

(1992). The effectiveness of selected trailside sign texts in deterring off-trail hiking, Paradise Meadows, Mount Rainier National Park. In Christensen

H. H.

Johnson

D. R.

Brookes

M. H.

(Eds.), Vandalism: Research, prevention, and Social Policy (pp. 103–120). USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station. General Technical Report PNW-GTR-293.

36.

Johnson

D. R.

Vande Kamp

M. E.

(1996). Extent and control of resource damage due to non-compliant visitor behavior: A case study from the U.S. National parks. 16, 134–141.

37.

Kidd

A. M.

Monz

D’Antonio

Manning

R. E.

Reigner

Goonan

K. A.

Jacobi

(2015). The effect of minimum impact education on visitor spatial behavior in parks and protected areas: An experimental investigation using GPS-based tracking. Journal of Environmental Management, 162, 53–62.

38.

Kim

M.-K.

Daigle

J. J.

(2022). Long-term monitoring of vegetation cover changes by remote sensing, cadillac Mountain summit, Acadia National Park. Parks Stewardship Forum, 38(1), 132–144. https://doi.org/10.5070/P538156127

39.

Knopf

R. C.

Dustin

(1992). A multidisciplinary model for managing vandalism and depreciative behavior in recreation settings. In Manfredo

(Ed.), Influencing Human Behavior (pp. 209–261). Sagamore Publishing.

40.

Liddle

M. J.

(1997). Recreation ecology. Chapman & Hall.

41.

Liu

Segovia

Tse

E. C. Y.

Nayga

R. M.

(2022). Become an environmentally responsible customer by choosing low-carbon footprint products at restaurants: Integrating the elaboration likelihood model (ELM) and the theory of planned behavior (TPB). Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 52, 346–355.

42.

Manning

R. E.

(2003). Emerging principles for using information/education in wilderness management. 9(1), 20–28.

43.

Manning

R. E.

(2010). Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and research for Satisfaction (3rd ed., p. 448). Oregon State University Press.

44.

Marion

J. L.

(2014). Leave No Trace in the outdoors. Stackpole Books.

45.

Marion

J. L.

(2016). A review and synthesis of recreation ecology research supporting carrying capacity and visitor use management decisionmaking. Forestry Journal, 114, 339–351.

46.

Marion

J. L.

Leung

Y.-F.

Eagleston

Burroughs

(2016). A review and synthesis of recreation ecology research findings on visitor impacts to wilderness and protected natural areas. Forestry Journal, 114, 352–362.

47.

Marion

J. L.

Reid

S. E.

(2007). Minimising visitor impacts to protected areas: The efficacy of low impact education programmes. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 15(1), 5–27.

48.

Marion

J. L.

Wimpey

Park

(2011). Informal and formal trail monitoring protocols and baseline conditions: Acadia National Park. Final research report. USDI U.S. Geological Survey. Blacksburg, VA: Virginia Tech College of Natural Resources & Environment. 120p.

49.

Marion

J. L.

Wimpey

Park

L. O.

(2009). Monitoring and assessing trail conditions at Acadia National Park. In Manning

R. E.

(Ed.), Parks and People: Managing Outdoor Recreation at Acadia National Park (pp. 185–195). University of Vermont Press.

50.

Meadema

Marion

J. L.

Arredondo

Wimpey

(2020). The influence of layout on Appalachian Trail soil loss, widening, and muddiness: Implications for sustainable trail design and management. Journal of Environmental Management, 257. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109986

51.

Monteiro

L. C. N.

Cabral

(2022, June). Assessing informal trails impacts and fragmentation effects on protected areas using volunteered geographic information. In Proceedings of the 8th International conference on geographical information systems theory, applications and management (Vol. 1, pp. 48-55). SciTePress-Science and Technology Publications.

52.

Monz

C. A.

Marion

J. L.

Goonan

K. A.

Manning

R. E.

Wimpey

Carr

(2010). Assessment and monitoring of recreation impacts and resource conditions on mountain summits: Examples from the northern forest, USA. Mountain Research and Development, 30(4), 332–343.

53.

Namba

Dustin

(1992). Towards new definitions of depreciative behavior and vandalism. As cited in Christensen. In Johnson

H. J.

Brooks

D. R. M. H

(Eds.), Vandalism: Research, prevention and Social Policy (pp. 62–69). USDA Forest Service GTR. PNW-GTR-293.

54.

Olive

N. D.

Marion

J. L.

(2009). The influence of use-related, environmental, and managerial factors on soil loss from recreational trails. Journal of Environmental Management, 90, 1483–1493.

55.

Park

L. O.

Manning

R. E.

Marion

J. L.

Lawson

S. R.

Jacobi

(2008). Managing visitor impacts in parks: A multi-method study of the effectiveness of alternative management practices. Journal of Park and Recreation Administration, 26(1), 97–121.

56.

Potito

A. P.

Beatty

S. W.

(2005). Impacts of recreation trails on exotic and ruderal species distribution in grassland areas along the Colorado Front Range. Journal of Environmental Management, 36(2), 230–236.

57.

Public Use Statistics Office. (2014). USDI National Park Service Public Use Statistics. Retrieved May 2014, from http://www2.nature.nps.gov/stats/

58.

Public Use Statistics Office. (2022). USDI National Park Service Public Use Statistics. Retrieved April 26, 2022, from https://irma.nps.gov/STATS/SSRSReports/Park%20Specific%20Reports/Annual%20Park%20Recreation%20Visitation%20(1904%20-%20Last%20Calendar%20Year)?Park=ACAD

59.

Riske

(2018). The effectiveness of trail mitigation and theory-grounded signage in an economical approach to reducing social trail behaviors. Master’s Thesis, Arizona State University, School of Community Resources & Development.

60.

Roggenbuck

J. W.

Berrier

D. L.

(1982). A comparison of the effectiveness of two communication strategies in dispersing wilderness campers. Journal of Leisure Research, 14(1), 77–89.

61.

Schafer

D. M.

(2022). Understanding Hikers’ behavioral intent towards leave no trace in Great Smoky Mountains National Park [Doctoral dissertation]. Western Carolina University.

62.

Schoenleber

D’Antonio

Hall

T. E.

(2022). Are signs enough? Using normative and narrative messaging to protect the western snowy plover (Charadrius nivosus) in coastal Oregon. Journal for Nature Conservation, 69, 126251.

63.

Schwartz

Taff

B. D.

Lawhon

VanderWoude

(2018). Mitigating undesignated trail use: The efficacy of messaging and direct site management actions in an urban-proximate open space context. Environmental Management, 62, 458–473.

64.

Settina

Marion

J. L.

Schwartz

(2020). Leave no trace communication: Effectiveness based on assessments of resource conditions. Journal of Interpretation Research, 25(1), 5–25.

65.

Stevenson

P. A.

Macgregor

Law

(2022). The influence of trail design on the impacts of walkers, mountain bikers and multi-use trail users: An environmentally Responsible Approach. Journal of Responsible Tourism Management, 2, 31–54.

66.

Swearingen

T. C.

Johnson

D. R.

(1988). An analysis of Off-Trail hiking in response to selected social control techniques at Paradise Meadows, Mount Rainier National Park. USDI National Park Service Cooperative Studies Unit, College of Forest Resources, University of Washington.

67.

Turner

LaPage

(2001). Visitor behaviors and resource impacts at cadillac Mountain, Acadia National Park (p. 113). Research Report for the USDI National Park Service, Acadia National Park.

68.

Walters

(1986). Adaptive management of renewable resources (p. 374). Macmillan Publishing Company.

69.

Wimpey

Marion

J. L.

(2011). A spatial exploration of informal trail networks within Great Falls Park, VA. Journal of Environmental Management, 92(3), 1012–1022.

70.

Wimpey

J. F.

Marion

J. L.

(2010). The influence of use, environmental and managerial factors on the width of rsecreational trails. Journal of Environmental Management, 91, 2028–2037.

71.

Wohlwill

J. F.

Harris

(1980). Response to congruity or contrast for man-made features in natural-recreation settings. Leisure Sciences, 3(4), 349–365.