This article argues that the “fiscal trilemma”—the tension between sufficient revenue and long-run fiscal sustainability on one side; medium- to long-run growth opportunities on the other; and progressivity and avoidance of inequality on the third side—is very much present in Denmark. We provide an overview of main features of the Danish tax system; the state of fiscal balances in the short and longer run; growth and productivity developments; and the extent of inequality in the Danish society. Thereafter, we go into details with reforms and changes in the tax system over the last twenty-five years and diagnose main problem areas. We argue that the tax reform carried in Parliament on September 13, 2012, does not pass a “trilemma test”; that is, it is in conflict with at least one of the three key considerations. Finally, we put forth reform elements that should improve the system.
AndersenAsger LauSpangeMorten. 2012. Produktivitetsudviklingen i Danmark (Productivity developments in Denmark, in Danish). Danmarks Nationalbank (The Central Bank of Denmark). Quarterly Report, First Quarter 2012, part 2.
2.
AndersenTorben M.SvarerMichael. 2007. “Flexicurity—Labour Market Performance in Denmark.”University of Aarhus Economics Working Paper 2007-9, Aarhus, Denmark.
3.
ArnbergSørenBarslundMikkel. 2012. “The Crowding-Out Effect of Mandatory Labour Market Pension Schemes on Private Savings: Evidence from Renters in Denmark.”Working Paper 2012:1, Economic Council, Copenhagen.
4.
ArnoldJens MatthiasBrysBertHeadyChristopherJohanssonÅsaSchwellnusCyrilleVartiaLaura. 2011. “Tax Policy for Economic Recovery and Growth.”The Economic Journal121:F59–80.
5.
BloomNicholasSadunRaffaellaReenenJohn Van. 2011. “Americans do I.T. better: US Multinationals and the Productivity Miracle.”The American Economic Review102:167–201.
6.
CaroliEveReenenJohn Van. 2001. “Skill-biased Organizational Change? Evidence from a Panel of British and French Establishments.”The Quarterly Journal of Economics116:1449–92.
7.
Economic Council. 2001. Dansk Økonomi Forår 2001[The Danish Economy Spring 2001].Copenhagen, Denmark: Economic Council.
Economic Council. 2012. Dansk Økonomi Forår 2012[The Danish Economy Spring 2012]. Copenhagen: Economic Council.
12.
FrederiksenNiels KleisLassenDavid DreyerNielsenSøren Bo. 1997. “Would the Flat Tax Fall Flat in Denmark?” In Macroeconomic Perspectives on the Danish Economy, edited by AndersenTorben M.JensenSvend E. HougaardRisagerOle. 16–130. Denmark: MacMillan Press Ltd.
13.
GaardSørenKielerMads. 2005. “Two Decades of Structural Reform in Denmark: A Review.”Working paper no. 16/2005, Danish Ministry of Finance, Copenhagen.
14.
GemmellNormanKnellerRichardSanzIsmael. 2011. “The Timing and Persistence of Fiscal Policy Impacts on Growth: Evidence from OECD Countries.”The Economic Journal121:F33–79.
15.
GordonRoger H.SlemrodJoel. 1988. “Do We Collect any Revenue from Taxing Capital Income?” In Tax Policy and the Economy 2, edited by SummersLawrence H.. National Bureau of Economic Research. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
JensenArne Hauge. 2001. “Summary of Danish Tax Policy 1986-2002.”Working Paper No. 2/2001,Danish Ministry of Finance, Copenhagen.
18.
JungeMartinSevergniniBattistaSørensenAnders. 2012. “Product-Marketing Innovation, Skills, and Firm Productivity Growth.”Working paper, Department of Economics, Copenhagen Business School.
19.
KeuschniggChristianNielsenSøren Bo. 2004a. “Start-ups, Venture Capitalists, and the Capital Gains Tax.”Journal of Public Economics88:1011–42.
20.
KeuschniggChristianNielsenSøren Bo. 2004b. “Taxation and Venture Capital Backed Entrepreneurship.”International Tax and Public Finance11:369–90.
21.
KlevenHenrik JacobsenSchultzEsben Anton. 2011. “Estimating Taxable Income Responses using Danish Tax Reforms.”Working Paper, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark.
22.
KlevenHenrik JacobsenKnudsenMartin B.KreinerClaus ThustrupPedersenSørenSaezEmmanuel. 2011. “Unwilling or Unable to Cheat? Evidence from a Tax Audit Experiment in Denmark.”Econometrica79:651–92.
23.
LazearEdward P.ShawKathryn L.. 2011. “A Personnel Economics Approach to Productivity Enhancement.” In Productivity and Competitiveness, edited by MadsenJakob B.SørensenAnders. Nordic Economic Policy Review2:209–51.
24.
MadsenJakob B.AndersSørensen. 2011. “The Widening Productivity Gap between the EU and US: An Introduction into the Conference on Productivity and Competitiveness.” In Productivity and Competitiveness, edited by Jakob B. Madsen and Anders Sørensen. Nordic Economic Policy Review 2: 7–25
25.
Ministry of Finance (and other ministries). 2009. Forårspakke 2.0[Spring Package 2.0]. Copenhagen: Ministry of Finance.
26.
Ministry of Taxation. 2009. “Danish Tax Reform 2010.” Paper to the OECD WP 2 meeting November 2009, Denmark.
27.
Ministry of Taxation. 2010. Skatteudgifter—en samlet oversight[Tax Expenditures—a Complete Overview], Copenhagen, August 2010.
28.
MirrleesJ.AdamS.BesleyT.BlundellR.BondS.ChoteR.GammieM.JohnsonP.MylesG.PoterbaJ., eds. 2010. Dimensions of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
29.
NielsenSøren BoSørensenPeter Birch. 1997. “On the Optimality of the Nordic Dual Income Tax.”Journal of Public Economics63:311–29.
30.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 2008. “Tax and Economic Growth.”Economics Department Working Paper No. 620, Paris, France.
31.
PrammerDoris. 2011. “Quality of Taxation and the Crisis: Tax Shifts from a Growth Perspective.”Working Paper No. 29, European Commission’s Directorate-General for Taxation and Customs Union.
32.
Report from the Danish Tax Commission. 2009. Report from the Danish Tax Commission(in Danish), Copenhagen: Danish Tax Commission.
33.
SørensenPeter Birch. 1994. “From the Global Income Tax to the Dual Income Tax: Recent Tax Reforms in the Nordic Countries.”International Tax and Public Finance1:57–79.
34.
TerkilsenLars KjærgårdJessenPernille WegenerPoulsenSimon KjærLarsenAnders Fuglsig. 2012. National Legal and Economic Report Denmark. InYearbook for Nordic Tax Research 2012 - Tax Expenditures, edited by BolanderJane, 73–90. Copenhagen, Denmark: DJØF Publishing.
35.
van ArkBart. 2011. “Up the Hill and Down Again: A History of Europe’s Productivity Gap Relative to the United States, 1950-2009.” In Productivity and Competitiveness, edited by MadsenJ.SørensenA.. Nordic Economic Policy Review2:27–56.
