Recent reformulations of health promotion focus on empowerment as both a means and an end in health promotion practice. Both concepts, however, are rarely examined for their assumptions about social change processes or the potential of community groups, professionals, and institutions to create healthier living situations. This article attends to some of these assumptions, expressing ideas generated during 6 years of professional training workshops with over 2,500 community health practitioners in Canada, New Zealand, and Australia. The article first argues that health promotion is not a social movement but a professional and bureaucratic response to the new knowledge challenges of social movements. As such, it has both empowering and disempowering aspects. The article analyzes empowerment as a dialectical relation in which power is simultaneously given and taken, and illustrates this in the context of health promotion programs. A model of an empowering professional (institutional) health promotion practice is pre sented, in which linkages among personal services, small group supports, community organizing, coalition advocacy, and political action are made explicit. Practice examples are provided to illustrate each level of the empowering relation, and the article concludes with a brief discussion of the model's educational and organizational utility.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
World Health Organization: Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion, 1986.
2.
Epp J.: Achieving Health for All: A Framework for Health Promotion. Ottawa, Health and Welfare Canada, 1986.
3.
Rappaport J. : In praise of paradox: A social policy of empowerment over prevention. Am J Community Psychol9:1-25, 1981.
4.
Stevenson HM , Burke M.: Bureaucratic logic in new social movement clothing. Health Promotion Int6:281-290, 1991.
5.
Miliband R.: The State in Capitalist Society. London, Quartet Books, 1973.
6.
Offe C.: Contradictions of the Welfare State. Boston, MA,MIT Press, 1984.
7.
Eyerman R., Jamison A: Social Movements: A Cognitive Analysis. Philadelphia, PA, University of Pennsylvania Press , 1991.
8.
Robertson A. , Minkler M.: The new health promotion movement: A critical examination. Health Educ Q (accepted for publication, Fall 1994).
9.
Rappaport J. : Terms of empowerment/examplars of prevention: Towards a theory for community psychology. Am J Community Psychol15:121-48, 1987.
10.
Minkler M.: Health education, health promotion and the open society. Health Educ Q16:17-30, 1989.
11.
Seidman S, Wagner D (eds.): Postmodernism and Social Theory. Oxford , Blackwell, 1992.
12.
Compact Edition of the Oxford English Dictionary, 1971, p. 855.
13.
Schon D.: The Reflectice Practitioner. New York, NY, Basic Books, 1983.
14.
Finne M.: When non-victims derogate powerlessness in the helping professions. Pers SocialPsychol Bull8:637-643, 1982.
15.
McKinlay J.: Comments at Health Promotion Research Conference. Toronto , Canada, University of Toronto, 1990.
16.
Fay B.: Critical Social Science. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press, 1987.
17.
Nyswander D. : Education for health: Some principles and their application. California's Health14:69-70, 1956.
18.
Labonte R.: Community health promotion strategies, in Martin C, McQueen D (eds.): Readings for a New Public Health. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press, 1989.
19.
Labonte R.: Heart health inequalities in Canada: Models, theory and planning. Health Promotion Int7:119-28, 1992.
20.
Labonte R.: Health and Empowerment: Practice Frameworks. Toronto , Centre for Health Promotion/Participation, 1993.
21.
Bogan III, G.: Organizing an urban African American community for health promotion: Lessons from Chicago. J Health Educ23:157-159, 1992.
22.
Valvarde C.: Critical Theory in Health Education. Montreal, Montreal DSC, 1991. (mimeo)
23.
Israel B., Checkoway B., Schulz A., Zimmerman M.: Health education and community empowerment: Conceptualizing and measuring perceptions of individual, organizational and community control. Health Educ Q:21:00-00, 1994.
24.
Labonte R., Little S.: Determinants of Health: Empowering Strategies for Nurses. Vancouver, BC, Registered Nurses Association of British Columbia, 1992.
25.
McKnight J.: Comments at Prevention Congress III. Waterloo, Ontario , 1987.
26.
Zald M.: The trajectory of social movements in America. Res Social Movements19:19-41, 1988.
27.
Freeman J.: On the origins of social movements, and a model for analyzing the strategic options of social movement organizations, in Freeman J (ed.): Social Movements of the 60s and 70s. New York, Longman, 1983 .
28.
Eder K.: The "new social movements": Moral crusades, political pressure groups or social movements? Social Res52:869-890, 1985.
29.
Jackson T., Mitchell S., Wright M.: The Community Development Continuum. Second National Conference of the Australian Community Health Association, April 1988.
30.
Wallerstein N.: Powerlessness, empowerment and health : Implications for health promotion programs . Am J Health Promotion6:197-205, 1992.
31.
Minkler M.: Building supportive ties among inner city elderly: The Tenderloin Senior Outreach Project. Health Educ Q12:303-314, 1985.
32.
Labonte R.: Community Health Responses to Health Inequalities. North York, North York Community Health Promotion Research Unit, 1993.
33.
Labonte R: Empowerment: Notes on community and professional dimensions. Can ResSocial Policy26:64-75, 1990.
34.
Watt A., Rodmell S.: Community involvement in health promotion: Progress or panacea?Health Promotion2:359-368, 1988.
35.
City of Toronto: Advocacy for Basic Prerequisites for Health (Policy Paper). Toronto, Department of Public Health, 1991.
36.
Ward J.: Community development with marginal people: The role of conflict. Community Dev J22:18-21, 1987.
37.
Wilkinson R. : Income distribution and mortality: A 'natural' experiment. Sociol Health Illness12:391-412, 1990.
38.
Green L., Raeburn J.: Health promotion. What is it? What will it become? Health Promotion3:151-59, 1988.
39.
Durning A.: Mobilizing at the grassroots, in Brown L, Durning A, Flavin C, Heise L, Jacobson J, Postel S, Renner M, Shea CP, Starke L, (eds.): State of the World 1989 . New York, NY, Norton, 1989.
40.
Daly H., Cobb J.: For the Common Good. Boston, MA, Beacon Press, 1989.
41.
Gardner J: Building Communities .Independent Sector Leadership Studies Program , Stanford University, 1991.
42.
Gray B: Collaborating: Finding Common Ground for Multiparty Problems. San Francisco, CA, Jossey-Bass, 1989.
43.
Sherif M.: Group Conflict and Cooperation. Routledge. Kegan and Paul , 1966.
44.
Panet-Raymond J.Partnership: Myth or reality? Community Dev J27:156-165, 1992. 45. Seligman M.: Helplessness: On Depression, Development and Death. San Francisco, CA, W.H. Freeman, 1975 .
45.
O'Higgins M. : Social policy in the global economy, in Hunsley T (ed.): Social Policy in the Global Economy. Ontario. School of Policy Studies, Queens University. Ontario, 1992 .
46.
Frye N.: The Dauble Vision. Toronto, University of Toronto Press, 1991.
