Validity of Physician Self-Report in Tracking Patient Education Objectives

Abstract

Patient education objectives are included as a strategy in every health promotion area addressed in Healthy People 2000. The likelihood of accomplishing these objectives is linked to the accuracy of the baseline estimates of practice. These estimates have most usually relied upon patient and physician reports. However, the accuracy of these reports has been infrequently studied. We analyzed audiotapes of interactions among 377 adult chronic disease patients and 38 physicians in a variety of practice settings to estimate the accuracy of their reports. Our findings indicate that neither doctors nor patients provide a consistently accurate reflection of health promotion discussions, nor do they appear to agree with one another very much as to what was discussed. Smoking and diet were reported quite accurately by both doctors and patients, whereas discussions regarding physical activity, alcohol, and stress were less so. Further, our findings suggest that underreport may pose an even greater threat to accurate estimates of physician practice than overreports.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Department of Health and Human Services. ( 1991). Healthy People 2000: National Health Promotion and Disease Prevention Objectives (DHHS Publication No. PHS 91-50212 Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Lewis CE : Disease prevention and health promotion practices of primary care physicians in the United States Am J Prev Med Suppl. 4:9-16, 1988.

Ley P. : Memory for medical information Br J Soc Clin Psychol 18:245-255, 1979.

Joyce CB , Caple G. , Mason M. , Reynolds E. , Mathews J. : Quantitative study of doctor-patient communication Q J Med 38:183-194, 1969.

Svarstad B. : The Patient-Physician Encounter: An Observational Study of Communication and Outcome. Doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Department of Sociology, 1974.

Norman GR , Neufeld VR , Walsh A. , Woodward CA , McConvey GA : Measuring physicians' performances by using simulated patients J Med Educ 60:925-934, 1985.

Hoppe RB , Farquhar LJ , Henry R. , Stoffelmayr B. : Resident's attitudes towards and skills in counseling: Using undetected standardized patients J Gen Intern Med 5:415-420, 1990.

Zuckerman AE , Starfield B. , Hochreiter C. , Kovasznay B. : Validating the content of pediatric outpatient medical records by means of tape recording Pediatrics 56:407-411, 1975.

Bentsen BG : The accuracy of recording patient problems in family practice J Med Educ 51:311-316, 1976.

10.

Jencks SF : Recognition of mental distress and diagnosis of mental disorder in primary care JAMA 253:1903-1907, 1985 .

11.

Radecki SE , Mendenhall RC : Patient counseling by primary care physicians: Results of a nationwide survey Patient Educ Counseling 8:165-177, 1986.

12.

Radecki SE : Patient counseling by specialists in internal medicine: Results of a nationwide survey Patient Educ Counseling 8:179-188, 1986.

13.

Russell NK : Health Promotion Practice of Primary Care Physicians: Direct Observation of Lifestyle Discussion in Routine Visits. Doctoral dissertation, Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, 1990.

14.

Landis JR , Koch GG : The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data Biometrics 33:159-174, 1977.

15.

Russell NK , Roter DL : Lifestyle discussion in routine primary care visits Am J Public Health (in press).

16.

Cypress BK : Patterns of Ambulatory Care in General and Family Practice: The National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (Vital and Health Statistics: Series 13, No. 73 Hyattsville, Maryland: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1983.