How Do Persuasive Health Messages Work? A Health Education Field Study

Abstract

The authors tested an empirical definition of comprehension and investigated the relationship between comprehension, retention, attitudes, beliefs, and behavioral change in response to a persuasive health message. The study used a randomized post-tests only design with one ex perimental and one control group. A booklet about exercise was given to experimental group participants in their homes. They were interviewed immediately after reading the booklet and one month later. Control group participants were interviewed at both times without exposure to the booklet. The authors found that participants who were able to operationalize key concepts related to the exercise message were the most likely group to have performed the recommended behavior according to self-reports. Measures of recognition and recall were not significantly related to behavior, but measures of psychological-operational meaning (defined as the learner's ability to use the information and relate it to his/her own life) were related significantly to self- reported behavior. The authors also examined the relationship of comprehension to other vari ables, such as attitudes, beliefs, and behavior. The study's results support the hypothesis that comprehension is a necessary but not sufficient precursor of behavior. Implications for both program design and measurement are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Fishbein M. , Ajzen I. : Beliefs, Attitudes, Intentions and Behaviors. Philippines, Addison-Wesley, 1975.

Eagly A. : Comprehension as a determinant of opinion. J Pers Soc Psychol 29(6):758-773, 1974.

Evans R. , Rozelle R. , Lasater T. , et al: Fear arousal, persuasion and actual versus implied behavior change. J Pers Soc Psychol 16(2):220-227, 1974.

Maccoby N. , Farquhar J. , Wood P. , et al: Reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease. J Community Health 3(2):100-135, 1977.

Howe H. : Social factors associated with BSE among high risk women. Amer J Public Health 71(3):251-253, March, 1981.

McGuire W. : Communication modules for drug education in Goodstadt, M (ed): Research on Methods and Programs of Drug Education, Toronto, Addiction Research Fdn., 1974.

McGuire W. : Some internal psychological factors influencing consumer choice. J Cons Res 2(4):302-319, 1976.

Green L. , Kreuter M. , Deeds S. , et al: Health Education Planning. Palo Alto, Mayfield, 1980.

Rosenstock I. : The health belief model and preventive health behavior. Health Education Monographs 2(4):354, 1974.

10.

Ausubel D. : Educational Psychology. New York, Holt, 1968.

11.

Jacoby J. , Chestnut R. , Silberman W. : Consumer use and comprehension of nutrition information. J Cons Res 4:119-128, 1977.

12.

Schallert D. : Improving memory for prose. J Verb Learning and Verb Behav 15:621-632, 1976.

13.

Nunnally J. : Psychometric Theory. New York, McGraw Hill, 1978.

14.

Reid E. , Morgan R. : Exercise prescription: A clinical trial. Am J Public Health 69:591-595, 1979.

15.

Campbell D. , Stanley J. : Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research. Chicago, Rand, 1963.

16.

Zar J. : Biostatistical Analysis. New York, Prentice Hall, 1974.

17.

Hardy W. : Language, Thought and Experience. Baltimore, University Park Press, 1978.

18.

Kreuter M. , Christenson G. : School health education: Does it cause an effect? Health Education Quarterly 8(1):43-56, Spring 1981 .

19.

Windsor R. , Cutter G. : Methodological issues in using time series designs and analysis, in Progress in Cancer Control 1981. Buffalo, Alan Liss, 1981.

20.

Glanz K. , Kirscht J. , Rosenstock I. : Initial knowledge and attitudes as predictors of intervention effects. Patient Counselling and Health Education 3:30-40, 1981.

21.

Jaccard J. : Toward theories of persuasion and belief change. J Pers and Soc Psych 40:260-269, 1981.