The Research Literature on Why Women Delay in Seeking Medical Care for Breast Symptoms

Abstract

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrams RD : The patient with cancer: His changing pattern of communication. N Eng J Med 274:317-322, February 10, 1966 .

Adams Mjt , Spicer CC : Recent mortality from breast cancer. Lancet 2:732-734, October 1965.

Aday LA , Eichorn R. : The Utilization of Health Services — Indices and Correlates: A Research Bibliography. Rockville, Maryland, National Center for Health Services Research and Development, DHEW Pub. No. (HSM) 73-3003, 1972.

Aitken-Swan J. , Paterson R. : Assessment of the results of five years of cancer education. Brit Mcd J 1:708-712, March 1959.

Aitken-Swan J. Paterson R. : The cancer patient: Delay in seeking advice . Brit Med J 1:623-627, March 1955.

Andersen R. : A Behavioral Model of Families' Use of Health Services. Chicago, University of Chicago Center for Health Administration Studies, 1968.

Antonovsky A. , Hartman H. : Delay in the detection of cancer: A review of the literature. Health Educ Monogr 2:98-128 June 1974.

Bard M. , Sutherland AM : Psychological impact of cancer and its treatment. IV. Adaptation to radical mastectomy. Cancer 8:656-672, July-August 1955.

Bates FE , Ariel IM : Delay in treatment of cancer. III Med J 94:361-365, December 1948.

10.

Battistella RM : Factors associated with delay in the initiation of physicians' care among late adulthood persons. Amer J Public Health 61:1348-1361, July 1971.

11.

Baumann B. : Diversities in conceptions of health and physicial fitness. J Health Hum Behav 2:39-46, Spring 1961 .

12.

Berg JW , Robbins GF , Farrow JH , Ritter F. : Improved short- and long-term survivals following operations for breast cancer . Surg Gynecol Obstet 123:737-745, October 1966.

13.

Blackwell BL : Anticipated pre-medical care activities of upper middle-class adults and their implications for health education practice . Health Educ Monogr 17:17-36, 1964.

14.

Blackwell BL : The literature of delay in seeking medical care for chronic illness. Health Educ Mongr 16:3-31, 1963.

15.

Blackwell BL : Upper middle class adult expectations about entering the sick role for physical and psychiatric dysfunctions. J Health Soc Behav 8:83-95, June 1967 .

16.

Bond BW : A study in health education methods. Int J Health Educ 1:41-46, January 1958.

17.

Briggs JE , Wakefield J. : Public Opinion on Cancer: A Survey of Knowledge and Attitudes Among Women in Lancaster. Manchester, Regional Committee on Cancer, Christie Hospital and Holt Radium Institute. 1967.

18.

Callahan E. et al: The "sick role" in chronic illness: Some reactions. J. Chronic Dis 19:883-897, August 1966.

19.

Cameron A. , Hinton JM : Delay in seeking treatment for mammary tumors. Cancer 21:1121-1126, June 1968.

20.

Cobb B. : Emotional problems of adult cancer patients. Cancer 7:274-285, March 1969.

21.

Cobb B. , Clark RL , MacGuire C. et al: Patient responsible delay of treatment in cancer: A social psychological-study . Cancer 7:920-926. September 1954.

22.

Collin BF , Feldman R. , Soghikian K. , et al: The educational adjunct to multiphasic health testing. Prev Med 2:247-260, June 1973

23.

Cornely PB , Bigman SK : Cultural consideration in changing health attitudes. Med Ann DC 30:191-199, April 1961.

24.

Dalarne NC : The management of primary breast cancer. Surg Gynecol Obstct 118:133-152, January 1964.

25.

DeLawter DeWE : Culpability for delay in management of cancer . Med Ann DC 17:342-346, June 19-18.

26.

Fink R. , Shapiro S. , Lewison J. : The reluctant participant in a breast cancer screening program. Public Health Rep 83:479-490, June 1968 .

27.

Fink R. , Shapiro S. , Roester R. : Impact of efforts to increase participation in repetitive screenings for early breast cancer detection. Amer J Public Health 62:328-336, March 1972.

28.

Fisher S. : Motivation for patient delay. Arch Gen Psychiat 16:676-678, June 1967.

29.

Friedman B. , Parker P. , Lipworth L. : The influence of Medicaid and private health insurance on the early diagnosis of breast cancer. Med Care 11:485-490, November-December 1973.

30.

Friedson E. : Client control and medical practice. Amer J Sociol 65:374-382, January 1960.

31.

Gold MA : Causes of patients' delay in diseases of the breast. Cancer 17:564-577, May 1964.

32.

Goldsen RK : Patient delay in seeking cancer diagnosis: Behavioral aspects. J Chronic Dis 16:427-436, May 1963.

33.

Goldsen RK , Gerhardt PR , Handy VH : Some factors related to patient delay in seeking diagnosis for cancer symptoms . Cancer 10:1-7, January-February 1957.

34.

Goldstein B. , Eichhorn RL : The changing Protestant ethic: Rural patterns in health, work and leisure. Amer Social Rev 26:557-565, August 1961.

35.

Gordon G. : Role Theory and Illness: A Sociological Perspective. New Haven, College and University Press, 1966.

36.

Green LW : Should health education abandon attitude change strategies? Perspectives from recent research. Health Educ Monogr 30:25-48, 1970.

37.

Green LW : Status Identity and Preventive Health Behavior. Berkeley , University of California, Pacific Health Education Reports No. 1, 1970.

38.

Hackett TP , Cassem NH , Raker JW : Patient delay in cancer. N Eng J Med 289:14-20, July 1973.

39.

Haefner DP , Kegeles SS , Kirscht J. et al: Preventive actions in dental disease, tuberculosis. and cancer . Public Health Rep 82:451-459, May 1967 .

40.

Hammerschlag CA , Fisher S. , Decasse J. et al: Breast symptoms and patient delay: Psychological variables involved. Cancer 17:1480-1485, November 1964.

41.

Hammond EC Seidman H. : Progress in control of cancer of the uterus. Archives Environ Health 13:105-116, July 1966.

42.

Harms CR , Plaut JA , Oughterson AW : Delay in the treatment of cancer. J Amer Med Assoc 121:335-338, January 1943.

43.

Henderson JG , Wittkower ED , Lougheed MN : A psychiatric investigation of the delay factor in patient to doctor presentation in cancer. J Psychosom Res 3:27-41, 1958.

44.

Henderson JG : Denial and repression as factors in the delay of patients with cancer presenting themselves to the physician. Ann NY Acad Sci 125:856.864, 1966 .

45.

Higbee KL : Fifteen years of fear arousal: Research on threat appeals, 1953-1968. Psychol Bull 72:426-444, 1969.

46.

Hinton J. : Bearing cancer. Brit J Mcd Psychol 46:105-113, June 1973.

47.

Hobbs P. : Public Opinion on Cancer: A Survey of Knowledge and Attitudes Among Women in Merscyside. Liverpool, Merseyside Cancer Education Committee. 1968.

48.

Hochhaum GM : Public Participation in Medical Screening Programs. Washington DC, Government Printing Office, Public Health Service Publication No. 572, 1958.

49.

Horn D. Waingrow S: What changes arc occuring in public opinions towards cancer: National public opinion survey. Amer J Public Health 54:431-440, March 1964.

50.

Institute for Public Opinion Research, The Czechoslovak Academy of Science : A survey of public opinion on cancer in Czechoslovakia. Health Educ J 31:50-56, 1972.

51.

Jenkins CD , Zyanski SJ : Dimensions of beliefs and feelings concerning three diseases, poliomyelitis. cancer, and mental illness: A factor analytic study. Behav Sci 13:372-381. 1968.

52.

Kasselbaum G. Baumann B : Dimensions of the sick role in chronic illness. J Health Hum Behav 6:16-27, Spring 1965.

53.

Kegeles SS : Behavioral sciences data and approaches relevant to the development of education programs in cancer. Health Educ Mongr 36:18-33, 1973.

54.

Kelly JL , Thieme ET : Impact of public education about cancer on detection and treatment of cancer of the breast hy surgery. Cancer 20:260-262. February 1967.

55.

King RA Leach JE : Factors contributing to delay by patients in seeking medical care. Cancer 3:571-579, July 1950.

56.

King RA , Leach JE : Habits of medical care. Cancer 4:221-225, March 1951.

57.

Kirscht JP , Haefner DP , Kegeles SS et al: A national study of health beliefs. J Health Hum Behav 7:248-254, Winter 1966.

58.

Klein RT , Dean A. , Bagdonoff MD : The impact of illness upon the spouse. J Chronic Dis 20:241-248, April 1967.

59.

Kriesburg L. : The relationship between socioeconomic rank and behavior. Soc Problems 10:334-352, Spring 1963.

60.

Kutner B. , Makover HB , Oppenheim A. : Delay in the diagnosis and treatment of cancer: A critical analysis of the literature. J Chronic Dis 7:95-120, February 1958.

61.

Kutner B. , Gordan G. : Seeking care for cancer. J Health Hum Behav 2: 171-178, Fall 1961.

62.

Lambert C. , Freeman HE : The Clinic Habit. New Haven, College and University Press, 1967.

63.

LaPointe JL , Wittkower ED , Lougheed MN : Psychiatric evaluation of the effect of cancer education on the lay public . Cancer 12:1200-1206, November-December 1959.

64.

Leach JE , Robbins G. : Delay in the diagnosis of cancer. JAMA 135:5-8, September 1947.

65.

Leventhal H. : Fear communications in the acceptance of preventive health practices. Bull NY Acad Med 41:1144-1168, November 1965.

66.

Levine GN : Anxiety about illness. J Health Hum Behav 3:30-34, Spring 1962.

67.

Lewison EF , Montague Acw , Kuller I. : Breast cancer treated at the Johns Hopkins Hospital, 1951-1956. Cancer 19: 1359-1368, October 1966.

68.

Lieberman Associates : Study of Motivational, Attitudinal, and Environmental Deterrents to the Taking of Physical Examinations that Include Cancer Tests. Vols I and II. New York, Lieberman Research Inc., for the American Cancer Society, 1966.

69.

Lilienfeld AM : Epidemiology of breast cancer. Cancer Res 23:1503-1513, 1963.

70.

Lipowski ZJ : Phvsical illness, the individual and the coping process. Psychiat Med 1:91-102, 1970.

71.

Ludwig EG , Gibson G. : Self perception of sickness and the seeking of medical care. J Health Soc Behav 10:125-133, June 1969 .

72.

Lynch HT : Delay: A deterrent to cancer detection. Arch Environ Health 17:207-209, August 1968.

73.

Mabry JH : Medicine and the family. J Marriage Fam 26:160-165, May 1974.

74.

Macdonald EJ : Changing reasons for cancer patient delay. Conn Health Bull 61:91-101, April 1947 .

75.

MacDonald I. : The natural history of mammary carcinoma. Amer J Surg 11:435-442. 1966.

76.

Madsen W. : Cultural variations in the concepts of sickness and health. J Natl Med Assoc 55:123-125, March 1963.

77.

Makover HB : Patient and physician delay in cancer diagnosis: Medical aspects. J Chronic Dis 16:419-426, May 1963.

78.

Mechanic D. , Volkart EH : Illness behavior and medical diagnosis. J Health and Hum Behav 1:86-94, 1960.

79.

Mechanic D. : Medical Sociology: A Selective View. Glencoe, Illinois , The Free Press, 1968.

80.

Miller MH : Seeking advice for cancer symptoms. Amer J Public Health 63:955-961, November 1973.

81.

Miller MH : Who receives optimal medical care? J Health Soc Behav 14:176-182, June 1973.

82.

Pack GT , Gallo JS : The culpability for delay in the treatment of cancer. Amer J Cancer 33:443-462, July 1938.

83.

Parsons T. : Social change and medical organization in the United States: A sociological perspective. Ann Amer Acad Polit Soc Sci 346:21-33, March 1963.

84.

Reeder LG , Berkanovic E. : Sociological concomitants of health orientations: A partial replication of Suchman. J Health Soc Behav 14:134-143, June 1973.

85.

Renneker R. , Cutler M. : Psychological problems of adjustment to cancer of the breast. JAMA 148:833-838. March 1952.

86.

Robbins GF , Conte AJ : Leach JE et al: Delay in diagnosis and treatment of cancer. JAMA 143:346-348, May 1950.

87.

Robbins GF , Berg JW , Bross I. et al: The significance of early treatment of breast . cancer: Changes correlated with the cancer education programs of 1940-55. Cancer 12:688-692. July-August 1959 .

88.

Roberts BJ : A framework for consideration of forces in achieving earliness of treatment . Health Educ Monogr 19:16-32, 1965.

89.

Roberts BJ : A Study of Selected Factors and Their Association with Action for Medical Care. Unpublished Dr.P.H. dissertation, Harvard University School of Public Health, 1956.

90.

Roberts BJ : Factors and forces influencing decision-making related to health behavior . In Proceedings of the Seminar on Health Education in Uterine Cancer Control. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan School of Public Health, 1967.

91.

Rosenstock IM : Why people use health services, Part 2. Milbank Mem Fund Quart 64:94-127, July 1966 .

92.

Ross JA : Social class and medical care. J Health Hum Behav 3:35-40, Spring 1962.

93.

Sandifcr WG , Pritchett BS : Psychologic reactions causing a delay in treatment of cancer of the cervix. J Obstet Gynecol 11:82-88, January 1958.

94.

Shands HC , Finesinger JE , Cobb S. et al: Psychological mechanisms in patients with cancer. Cancer 4:1159-1170, November 1951.

95.

Shapiro S. : Evaluation of two contrasting types of screening programs. Prev Med 2:266-277, June 1973 .

96.

Shapiro S. , Goldberg JD , Hutchison GB : Lead Time in Breast Cancer Detection and Implications for Periodicity of Screening . Paper presented at the American Public Health Association, San Francisco, November 1973.

97.

Shapiro S. , Brindle J. : Serving Medicaid eligibles. III. Amer J Public Health 59:635-641, April 1969.

98.

Simmons CC , Daland EM : Cancer: Delay in its surgical treatment. Boston Med Surg J 190:15-18, January 1924.

99.

Simmons CC , Daland EM : Cancer: Factors entering into the delay in its surgical treatment. Boston Med Surg J 183:298-303, September 1920.

100.

Simonds SK : Public opinion surveys about cancer: An overview . Health Educ Monogr 30:3-24, 1970.

101.

Skipper JK , Leonard R. : Social Interaction and Patient Care. Philadelphia, Lippincott Co., 1965.

102.

Smith FM : Factors causing delay in operative therapy of carcinoma. Surg Gynecol Obstet 60:45-53, January 1935.

103.

Steele J. , McBroom WH : Conceptual and empirical dimensions of health behavior. J Health Soc Behav 13:382-392, December 1972.

104.

Suchman EA : Social patterns of illness and medical care . J Health Soc Behav 6:2-16, Spring 1965 .

105.

Suchman EA : Sociomedical variations among ethnic groups . Amer J Sociol 70:319-331, November 1964.

106.

Suchman EA : Stages of illness and medical care. J Health Soc Behav 6:114-128, Fall 1965 .

107.

Sweet RH , Twaddle AC : An exploration of delay in hospitalization. Inquiry 6:35-41, June 1969.

108.

Taylor HS : Factors Associated with Culpability or Nonculpability in Delaying Medical Care for Cancer. Master's thcsis, G.W. Brown School of Social Work, Washington Unviersity, 1946.

109.

Titchener JL , Zwerling I. Gottschalk L et al: Problem of delay in seeking surgical care. JAMA 160:1187-1193. April 1956.

110.

Twaddle AC : Health decisions and sick role variations: An exploration. J Health Soc Behav 10:105-115, June 1969 .

111.

Urban JA : Evaluation of newer techniques of treatment for breast cancer. Clin Obstet Gynecol 235:235-251, March 1966.

112.

Wakefield J. : The social implications of cancer. Radiography 37:93-95, April 1970.

113.

Waxenberg SE : The importance of the communication of feelings about cancer. Ann NY Acad Sci 125:1000-1005. 1966.

114.

Wiggins WS , Hilfinger MF , Berman LG : Delay in cancer diagnosis. NY State J Med 51:626-638, March 1951.

115.

Williams AF , Wechsler H. : Interrelationship of preventive actions in health and other areas. Health Serv Rep 87:969-976, December 1972.

116.

Williams EM , Cruickshank A. , Walker WM : Public Opinion on Cancer in South East Wales: A Report on the Findings of a Survey of Knowledge and Opinions. Cardiff, Tenovus Cancer Information Center, 1972.

117.

Youngman NV : Psychological aspects of the early diagnosis of cancer. Med J Aust 34:581-587, May 1947 .

118.

Zola I. : Culture and symptoms — an analysis of patients presenting complaints. Amer Sociol Rev 31:615-630, October 1966.