Functional versus Fractional Oxygen Saturation Readings: Bias and Agreement Using Simulated Solutions and Adult Blood

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the bias and agreement between functional oxygen saturation (SO2) and fractional oxyhemoglobin (HbO2) using simulated quality control (QC) solutions and adult blood. Using a hemoximeter, 5 analysts performed at least 5 tests each on QC solutions with 3 different hemoglobin (Hb) levels and on adult blood samples of various oxygen saturation levels representing venous or arterial samples. Bias and the limits of agreement were determined using the technique of Bland and Altman. Using QC solutions with low, normal, and high Hb levels, the bias for SO2 against HbO2 was 20.82 0.50 (n = 66), 19.14 0.56 (n = 81), and 19.59 0.43 (n = 79), respectively, with SO2 reading consistently higher. The correlation between SO2 and HbO2 was –0.49, –0.69, and –0.68, respectively. Using adult blood, the bias for SO2 against HbO2 was 1.29 0.48 for venous samples (n = 62) and 1.9 0.19 for fully oxygenated samples (n = 36), and the correlation between SO2 and HbO2 was 1.0 and 0.68, respectively. These findings suggest that the consistency between the measurements of SO2 and HbO2 may be dependent on hemoglobin levels and oxygenation status. Thus, caution is warranted when assuming that the measurements of SO2 and HbO2 are interchangeable.

Keywords

functional oxygen saturation fractional oxygen saturation quality control blood

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andersen C . 2001. Critical haemoglobin thresholds in premature infants. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Educ 84:F146-F148.

Aoyagi T , Kishi M , Yamaguchi K , Watanabe S . 1974. Improvement of the earpiece oximeter. In: Abstracts of the Japanese Society of Medical Electronics and Biological Engineering. Tokyo. p 90-91.

Bard H , Widness JA .1997. The life span of erythrocytes transfused to preterm infants. Pediatr Res 42:9-11.

Barker SJ , Tremper KK , Hyatt J . 1989. Effects of methemoglobinemia on pulse oximetry and mixed venous oximetry. Anesthesiology 70:112-117.

Blaisdell CJ , Goodman S , Clark K , Casella JF , Loughlin GM . 2000. Pulse oximetry is a poor predictor of hypoxemia in stable children with sickle cell disease. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 154:900-903.

Bland JM , Altman, DG . 1986. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1:307-310.

Burke-Martindale CH . 1998. Inhaled nitric oxide therapy for adult respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Nurse 18:21-27.

Carter BG , Carlin JB , Tibballs J , Mead H , Hochmann M , Osborne A . 1998. Accuracy of two pulse oximeters at lowarterial hemoglobinoxygen saturation. Crit Care Med 26:1128-1133.

Choe H , Tashiro C , Fukumitsu K , Yagi M , Yoshiya I . 1989. Comparison of recorded values from six pulse oximeters. Crit Care Med 17:678-681.

10.

Chulay M , Palmer J , Neblett J , Nancherla AR , Tripodi D , Caden D . 1992. Clinical comparison of two-and three-wavelength systems for continuous measurement of venous oxygen saturation. Am J Crit Care 1:69-75.

11.

Comber JT , Lopez BL . 1996. Evaluation of pulse oximetry in sickle cell anemia patients presenting to the emergency department in acute vasoocclusive crisis. Am J Emerg Med 14:16-18.

12.

Corwin HL . 2001a. Anemia in the critically ill: the role of erythropoietin. Sem Hematol 38(3, suppl 7):24-32.

13.

Corwin HL . 2001b. Blood transfusion in the critically ill patient. Paper presented at the Society of Critical Care Medicine 30th International Educational and Scientific Symposium, San Diego, CA.

14.

Decker MJ , Dickensheets D , Arnold JL , Cheung PW , Strohl KP . 1990. A comparison of a new reflectance oximeter with the Hewlett-Packard ear oximeter. Biomed Instrum Technol 24:122-126.

15.

Ehrmeyer S , Burnett RW , Chatburn RL , Clausen JL , Durst RA , Fallon KD , Moran RF , Van Kessel AL , Wandrup J . 1997. Fractional oxyhemoglobin, oxygen content and saturation, and related quantities in blood: terminology, measurement, and reporting: approved guidelines. C25-A 17(3). NCCLS.

16.

Hampson NB . 1998. Pulse oximetry in severe carbon monoxide poisoning. Chest 114:1036-1041.

17.

Haney M , Tait AR , Tremper KK . 1994. Effect of carboxyhemoglobin on the accuracy of mixed venous oximetry monitors in dogs. Crit Care Med 22:1181-1185.

18.

Harris AP , Sendak MJ , Donham RT , Thomas M , Duncan D . 1988. Absorption characteristics of human fetal hemoglobin atwavelengths used in pulse oximetry. J Clin Monitoring 4:175-177.

19.

Hirano K , Morinobu T , Kim H , Hiroi M , Ban R , Ogawa S , Ogihara H , Tamai H , Ogihara T . 2001. Blood transfusion increases radical promoting non-transferrin bound iron in preterm infants. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Educ 84:F188-F193.

20.

Jackson SH , Barker SJ . 1995. Methemoglobinemia in a patient receiving flutamide. Anesthesiology 82:1065-1067.

21.

Krarup T . 1998. The ABL 700™ oximeter: a technical overview. Bulletin no. 2, Radiometer Copenhagen.

22.

Krzeminski A . 1992. Howis fetal hemoglobin determined and corrected for in the OSM3, the ABL510, and the ABL 520? Info, No. 1992-4, 1-4. Radiometer Copenhagen.

23.

Moyle JT . 1996. Uses and abuses of pulse oximetry. Arch Dis Child 74:77-80.

24.

Nakanishi N , Yoshioka T , Okano Y , Nishimura R . 1993. Continuous Fick cardiac output measurement during exercise by monitoring of mixed venous oxygen saturation and oxygen uptake. Chest 104:419-424.

25.

Pianosi P , Charge TD , Esseltine DW , Coates AL . 1993. Pulse oximetry in sickle cell disease. Arch Dis Child 68:735-738.

26.

Poets CF , Southall DP . 1994. Noninvasive monitoring of oxygenation in infants and children: practical considerations and areas of concern. Pediatrics 93:737-746.

27.

Rajadurai VS , Walker AM , Yu VY , Oates A . 1992. Effect of fetal haemoglobin on the accuracy of pulse oximetry in preterm infants. JP aediatr Child Health 28:43-46.

28.

Ralston AC , Webb RK , Runciman WB . 1991. Potential errors in pulse oximetry: I: pulse oximeter evaluation. Anaesthesia 46:202-206.

29.

Rausch-Madison S , Mohsenifar Z . 1997. Methodologic problems encountered with cooximetry in methemoglobinemia. Am J Med Sci 314:203-206.

30.

Reynolds KJ , Palayiwa E , Moyle JT , Sykes MK , Hahn CE . 1993. The effect of dyshemoglobins on pulse oximetry: part I, theoretical approach; part II, experimental results using an in vitro test system. J Clin Monitoring 9:81-90.

31.

Sendak MJ , Harris AP , Donham RT . 1988. Accuracy of pulse oximetry during arterial oxyhemoglobin desaturation in dogs. Anesthesiology 68:111-114.

32.

Severinghaus JW , Naifeh KH , Koh SO . 1989. Errors in 14 pulse oximeters during profound hypoxia. J Clin Monitoring 5:72-81.

33.

Surgenor SD , Hampers MJ , Corwin HL . 2001. Is blood transfusion good for the heart? Crit Care Med 29:442-444.

34.

Thilo EH , Andersen D , Wasserstein ML , Schmidt J , Luckey D . 1993. Saturation by pulse oximetry: comparison of the results obtained by instruments of different brands. J Pediatr 122:620-626.

35.

Trivedi NS , Ghouri AF , Lai E , Shah NK , Barker SJ . 1997. Pulse oximeter performance during desaturation and resaturation: a comparison of seven models. J Clin Anesth 9:184-188.

36.

Trivedi NS , Ghouri AF , Shah NK , Lai E , Barker SJ . 1997. Effects of motion, ambient light, and hypoperfusion on pulse oximeter function. J Clin Anesth 9:179-183.

37.

White KM . 1985. Completing the hemodynamic picture: SvO2. Heart & Lung 14:272-280.

38.

Whyte RK , Jangaard KA , Dooley KC . 1995. From oxygen content to pulse oximetry: completing the picture in the newborn. Acta Anaesth Scand 39(suppl 107):95-100.

39.

Wimberly PD . 1993. Oxygen monitoring in the newborn. Scandd J Clin Lab Invest 54(suppl 214):127-130.

40.

Wimberly PD , Siggaard-Anderson O , Fogh-Anderson N . 1990. Accurate measurement of hemoglobin oxygen saturation, and fraction of carboxyhemoglobin and methemoglobin in fetal blood using Radiometer OSM3: corrections for fetal hemoglobin fraction and pH. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 50(suppl 203):235-239.