Policy makers generally see resource extraction as a boon for local economies and citizens. Numerous studies, however, have shown negative socioeconomic outcomes in extractive communities, supporting the notion that resources can be more of a curse than a blessing. One aspect of this debate that requires further clarification is the role played by method of extraction. In this article, we use the case of West Virginia coal mining and a fixed effects model to test whether extraction methods affect socioeconomic outcomes. We observe little difference in these outcomes between surface and underground mining; rather, it is the presence or absence of mining that matters most. We find that nonmining counties have lower poverty and unemployment rates than mining counties. These results lead us to conclude that leaving remaining coal stores in the ground will likely prove most beneficial to the state’s people and economy in the long run.
AhernM. M.HendryxM.ConleyJ.FedorkoE.DucatmanA.ZulligK. J. (2011). The association between mountaintop mining and birth defects among live births in Central Appalachia, 1996-2003. Environmental Research, 111, 838-846.
BebbingtonA.HinojosaL.BebbingtonD. H.BurneoM. L.WarnaarsX. (2008). Contention and ambiguity: Mining and the possibilities of development. Development and Change, 39, 887-914.
4.
BellS. E. (2009). “There ain’t no bond in town like there used to be”: The destruction of social capital in the West Virginia Coalfields. Sociological Forum, 24, 631-657.
5.
BellS. E.YorkR. (2010). Community economic identity: The coal industry and ideology construction in West Virginia. Rural Sociology, 75, 113-143.
6.
BenderL. D.GreenB. L.HadyT. F.KuehnJ. A.NelsonM. K.PerkinsonL. B.RossP. J. (1985). The diverse social and economic structure of Non-Metropolitan America. Washington, DC: Agriculture and Rural Economic Division, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture.
7.
BerryC. (2000). Southern migrants, Northern exiles. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
BunkerS. G. (1985). Underdeveloping the Amazon: Extraction, unequal exchange, and the failure of the modern state. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
10.
CardosoF. E.FalettoE. (1979). Dependency and development in Latin America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
11.
CaudillH. (1963). Night comes to the Cumberlands: A biography of a depressed area. Ashland, KY: Jess Stuart Foundation.
12.
CoutoR. A. (1993). The memory of miners and the conscience of capital: Coal miners’ strikes as free spaces. In FisherS. L. (Ed.), Fighting back in Appalachia: Traditions of resistance and change (pp. 165-194). Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
13.
EloI. T.BealeC. L. (1985). Natural resources and rural poverty: An overview. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future.
EvansP. (1979). Dependent development: The alliance of multinational, state and local capital in Brazil. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
18.
FaberD. (1998). The political ecology of American capitalism: New challenges for the environmental justice movement. In FaberD. (Ed.), The struggle for ecological democracy: Environmental justice movements in the United States (pp. 27-59). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
19.
FisherD. R. (2001). Resource dependency and rural poverty: Rural areas in the United States and Japan. Rural Sociology, 66, 181-202.
20.
FrankA. G. (1967). Capitalism and underdevelopment in Latin America. New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.
21.
FreudenburgW. R. (1992). Addictive economies: Extractive industries and vulnerable localities in a changing world economy. Rural Sociology, 57, 305-332.
22.
FreudenburgW. R.GramlingR. (1998). Linked to what? Economic linkages in an extractive economy. Society & Natural Resources, 11, 569-586.
23.
FreudenburgW. R.WilsonL. (2002). Mining the data: Analyzing the economic implications of mining for nonmetropolitan regions. Sociological Inquiry, 72, 549-575.
24.
FrickelS.FreudenburgW. R. (1996). Mining the past: Historical context and the changing implications of natural resource extraction. Social Problems, 43, 444-466.
25.
GedicksA. (2001). Resource rebels: Native challenges to mining and oil companies. Cambridge, MA: South End Press.
26.
HendryxM. (2011). Poverty and mortality disparities in Central Appalachia: Mountaintop mining and environmental justice. Community Health, 4(3), 44-53.
27.
HendryxM.ZulligK. J. (2009). Higher coronary heart disease and heart attack morbidity in Appalachian coal mining regions. Preventive Medicine, 49, 355-359.
KobakS. E. (2012). OxyContin flood in the coalfields: “Searching for Higher Ground”. In FisherS. L.SmithB. E. (Eds.), Transforming places: Lessons from Appalachia (pp. 198-209). Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
30.
KrannichR. S.LuloffA. E. (1991). Problems of resource dependency in U.S. rural communities. Progress in Rural Policy and Planning, 1, 5-18.
31.
LatimerM.MenckenF. C. (2003). Socioeconomic trends in mining-dependent counties in Appalachia. In FalkW. W.SchulmanM. D.TickamyerA. R. (Eds.), Communities of work: Rural restructuring in local and global contexts (pp. 79-103). Athens: Ohio University Press.
32.
LichterD. T.McLaughlinD. K. (1995). Changing economic opportunities, family structure, and poverty in rural areas. Rural Sociology, 60, 688-706.
33.
McGinleyP. C. (2004). From pick and shovel to mountaintop removal: Environmental injustice in the Appalachian Coalfields. Environmental Law, 34, 21-106.
34.
McIlmoilR.HansenE.BoettnerT.MillerP. (2010, June22). The impact of coal on the West Virginia State Budget. Morgantown: Downstream Strategies and West Virginia Center on Budget & Policy.
35.
Mine Safety and Health Administration. (n.d.). Mining industry accident, injuries, employment, and production statistics and reports. Retrieved from http://www.msha.gov/ACCINJ/accinj.htm
NelsonR. H. (1983). The making of Federal Coal Policy. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
39.
NordM.LuloffA. E. (1993). Socioeconomic heterogeneity of mining-dependent counties. Rural Sociology, 58, 492-500.
40.
OverdevestC.GreenG. P. (1995). Forest dependence and community well-being: A segmented market approach. Society & Natural Resources, 8, 111-131.
41.
PellowD. (2011). Politics by other greens: The importance of transnational environmental justice movement networks. In CarminJ.AgeymanJ. (Eds.), Environmental inequalities beyond borders: Local perspectives on global injustices (pp. 247-265). Cambridge: MIT Press.
42.
RajanS. C. (2011). Poor little rich countries: Another look at the “resource curse”. Environmental Politics, 20, 617-632.
43.
RiceO. K.BrownS. W. (1993). West Virginia: A history (2nd ed.). Lexington: University Press of Kentucky.
44.
RossM. (2003). The natural resource curse: How wealth can make you poor. In BannonI.CollierP. (Eds.), Natural resources and violent conflict: Options and actions (pp. 17-42). Washington, DC: World Bank.
45.
Rural Sociological Society Task Force. (1993). Theories in the study of natural resource—Dependent communities and persistent rural poverty in the United States. In DeseranF. A. (Series Ed.), Persistent poverty in rural America (Rural studies series of the Rural Sociological Society, pp. 136-172). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
46.
SachsJ.WarnerA. (1995). Natural resources and economic growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Institute for International Development.
47.
SchnaibergA. (1980). The environment: From surplus to scarcity. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
StedmanR. C.ParkinsJ. R.BeckleyT. M. (2004). Resource dependence and community well-being in rural Canada. Rural Sociology, 69, 213-234.
50.
ThomasJ. B. (2010). An Appalachian reawakening: West Virginia and the perils of the New Machine Age, 1945-1972. Morgantown: West Virginia University Press.
51.
TickamyerA. R.LatimerM. (1993). A multi-level analysis of income sources of the poor and near poor. In SingelmannJ.DeseranF. (Eds.), Inequalities in labor market areas (pp. 49-68). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
52.
TickamyerA. R.TickamyerC. (1988). Gender and poverty in Central Appalachia. Social Science Quarterly, 69, 874-891.
53.
TontsM.PlummerP.LawrieM. (2012). Socio-economic well-being in Australian Mining Towns: A comparative analysis. Journal of Rural Studies, 28, 288-301.
54.
U.S. Census Bureau. (n.d.). Model-based small area income & poverty estimates (SAIPE) for school districts, counties, and states. Retrieved from http://www.census.gov/did/www/saipe/
West Virginia Office of Miners’ Health Safety and Training (n.d.-b). A brief history of coal and safety enforcement in West Virginia. Retrieved from http://www.wvminesafety.org/History.htm
