Effects of enzyme associations on bread dough performance. A response surface analysis/ Efectos de las asociaciones enzimáticas sobre la calidad funcional de masas panarias. Análisis de superficies de respuesta

Abstract

Effects of starch (bacterial α-amylase and NMYL) and non-starch (xylanase PTP, lipase NVZ and glucose-oxidase GLZ) degrading enzymes on dough quality parameters (rheological, fermentative, textural and thermal characteristics) were determined by means of the response surface methodology to a central composite design of white wheat dough samples. PTP showed linear, interactive and/or quadratic significant effects on most functional properties. Higher dosages of PTP yielded softer and less adhesive doughs with higher gas retention capability but with weakened gluten and poorer machinability (stickier). Negative linear and positive quadratic effects of PTP were observed on dough hardness and derived mechanical properties gumminess and chewiness. Optimized dosage of 30 mg/100g flour led to improved handling and fermentative dough characteristics and avoided excessive dough hardness and stickiness. The simultaneous presence of PTP and NVZ decreased fermentation time and increased dough extensibility. The combination of both PTP and NMYL and / or incorporation of NVZ decreased dough resilience, which corresponded to a greater extensibility and a lower dough consistency. Although GLZ addition induced some desirable effects on the final dough volume and the amylose-lipid complexation, the incorporation of the pair PTP/GLZ into dough formulas is not recommended because of the reduction of the induced softening effect of PTP. A significant negative and quadratic effect of NMYL addition was observed for the enthalpy of dissociation of the amylose-lipid complex. Incorporation of this enzyme up to 30 mg/100 g flour did not significantly decrease values for this thermal property. No criteria for optimum dosage of NVZ were established, and it is recommended that doses higher than those recommended by the manufacturer (5 mg/100 g of flour) be used.

Keywords

bread dough enzymes dough functionality response surface analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andreu P. , Collar C. and Martínez-Anaya M.A. (1999). Thermal properties of doughs formulated with enzymes and starters. Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 209 (3-4): 286-293.

Armero E. and Collar C. (1997). Texture properties of formulated wheat doughs . Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 204: 136-145.

Armero E. and Collar C. (1998). Crumb firming kinetics of wheat breads with anti-staling additives. Journal of Cereal Science 28: 165-174.

Barrett F.F. (1975). Enzyme uses in the milling and baking industries . In: Reed G. (ed.), Enzymes in Food Processing. New York: Academic Press. pp. 301-348.

Bowles L.K. (1996). Amylolytic enzymes. In: Hebeda R.E. and Zobel H.F. (eds.), Baked Goods Freshness. Technology, Evaluation and Inhibition of Staling . New York: Marcel Dekker Inc. pp. 105-130.

Castelló P. , Jollet S. , Potus J. , Baret J.L. and Nicolas J. (1998). Effect of exogenous lipase on dough lipids during mixing of wheat flours. Cereal Chemistry 75: 595-601.

Chamberlain N.T. , Collins T.H. and McDermott E. E. (1981). Alpha-amylase and bread properties. Journal of Food Technology 16: 127.

Cleemput G. , Booij C. , Hessing M. , Gruppen H. and Delcour J.A. (1997). Solubilisation and changes in molecular weight distribution of arabinoxylans and protein in wheat flours during bread-making, and the effects of endogenous arabinoxylans hydrolyzing enzymes. Journal of Cereal Science 26: 55-66.

Collar C. and Armero E. (1996). Physico-chemical mechanisms of bread staling during storage: formulated doughs as a technological issue for improvement of bread functionality and keeping quality. Recent Research Development in Nutrition 1: 115-143.

10.

Collar C. , Andreu P. and Martínez-Anaya M.A. (1998). Interactive effects of flour, starter and enzyme on bread dough machinability. Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 207: 133-139.

11.

D'Appolonia B.L. (1973). Comparison of pentosans extracted from conventional and continuous bread. Cereal Chemistry 50: 27-36.

12.

Davidou S. , Le Meste M. , Debever E. and Bekaert D. (1996). A contribution to the study of the staling of white bread: effect of water and hydrocolloid. Food Hydrocolloids 10: 375-386.

13.

Faisy F. and Neyreneuf O. (1996). Performance d'une association enzymatique glucose-oxidase-hémicellulases pour remplacer l'acide ascorbique en panification. Industrie des Céréales 97: 3-12.

14.

Friedman H.H. , Whitney J.E. and Szczesniak A.S. (1963). The texturometer. A new instrument for objective texture measurement. Journal of Food Scence 28: 390-396.

15.

Haarasilta S. , Pullinen T. , Vaiasanen S. and Tammersalo-Karsten I. (1989). Enzyme product and method of improving the properties of dough and the quality of bread. United States Patent Nr 4 990 343.

16.

Hebeda R.E. , Bowles L.K. and Martin Teague W. (1990). Developments in enzymes for retarding staling of baked goods. Cereal Foods World 35: 453-457.

17.

Hebeda R.E. , Bowles L.K. and Martin Teague W. (1991). Use of intermediate temperature stability enzymes for retarding staling in baked goods. Cereal Foods World 36: 619-624.

18.

Hoseney R.C. and Chen W.Z. (1994). Adhesion testing apparatus and method for flowable materials such as wheat doughs. US Patent 5 280 616.

19.

Icc (1972). ICC standard No. 115. Method for using the Brabender Farinograph. Detrnold , Germany: ICC.

20.

Icc (1994). ICC standard No. 155. Determination of wheat gluten quantity and quality (Gluten Index ac. To Perten) of whole wheat meal and wheat flour (Triticum aestivum). Detmold, Germany: ICC.

21.

Krueger J.E. and Lineback D.R. (1987). Carbohydrate degrading enzymes in cereals. In: Krueger J.E. , Lineback D.R. and Stauffer C.E. (eds), Enzymes and their Role in Cereal Technology. St Paul, MN: AACC. pp. 117-139.

22.

Kulp K. ( 1993). Enzymes as dough improvers. In: Kamel B.S. and Stauffer C.E. (eds), Advances in Baking Technology. Glasgow, UK: Blackie Academic and Professional. pp. 152-178.

23.

Laurikainen T. , Härkönen H. , Autio K. and Poutanen K. (1998). Effects of enzymes in fiber-enriched baking. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 76: 239-249.

24.

León A. , Durán E. and Benedito de Barber C. (1997). A new approach to study starch changes occurring in the dough-baking process and during bread storage . Zeitschrift für-Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 204: 316-320.

25.

Magnus E. M. , Brathen E. , Sahlström S. , Mosleth Faergestad E. and Ellekjaer M. R. (1997). Effects of wheat variety and processing conditions in experimental bread baking studied by univariated and multivariate analysis . Journal of Cereal Science 25: 289-301.

26.

Martinez-Anaya M.A. and Jiménez T. (1997). Functionality of enzymes that hydrolyze starch and non-starch polysaccharide in breadmaking. Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 205: 209-214.

27.

Martínez-Anaya M.A. and Jiménez T. (1998). Physical properties of enzyme-supplemented doughs and relationship with bread quality parameters. Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung 206: 134-142.

28.

Mettler E. and Seibel W. (1993). Effects of emulsifiers and hydrocolloids on whole bread quality: a response surface methodology study. Cereal Chemistry 70: 373-377.

29.

Olesen T. (1990). Anti-staling process and agent. European Patent EP 0494 233.

30.

Poulsen C. and Bak Hostrup P. (1998). Purification and characterization of a hexose-oxidase with excellent strengthening effects in bread. Cereal Chemistry 75: 51-57.

31.

Qi Si J. (1997). Synergistic effect of enzymes for breadmaking . Cereal Foods World 42: 802-807.

32.

Qi Si J. and Hansen T.T. (1994). Effect of lipase on breadmaking in correlation with their effects on dough rheology and wheat lipids. In: Proceedings of the International Symposium of AA CC/ICC/CCOA, Beijing, China.

33.

Rouau X. , El-Hayek M.L. and Moreau D. (1994). Effect of an enzyme preparation containing pentosanases on the breadmaking quality of flours in relation to changes in pentosan properties. Journal of Cereal Science 19: 259-272.

34.

Sato N. , Sato M. and Nagashima A. (1991). Bread improver and method of producing bread. European Patent Application No 913066692.

35.

Smewing J. (1995). The measurement of dough and gluten extensibility using the SMS/ Kieffer rig and the TA.XT2 texture analyser. Instruction manual . Godalming, Surrey, UK: Stable Micro Systems.

36.

Tait S.P.C. and Galliard T. (1998). Oxidation of linoleic acid in doughs and aqueous suspensions of wholemeal flours: effects of storage. Journal of Cereal Science 8: 55-67.

37.

Van Dam H.W. and Hille J.D.R. (1992). Yeast and enzymes in breadmaking. Cereal Foods World 37: 245-251.

38.

Weegels P.L. and Hamer R.J. (1992). Improving the breadmaking quality of gluten. Cereal Foods World 37: 379-385.

39.

Westerlund E. , Theander O. and Aman P. (1989a). Effects of baking on protein and aqueous ethanol extractable carbohydrate in white bread fractions. Journal of Cereal Science 10:139-147.

40.

Westerlund E. , Theander O. , Andersson R. and Aman P. (1989b). Effect of baking on polysaccharides in white bread fractions. Journal of Cereal Science 10: 149-156.