The promise of public journalism is that it makes politics “go well.” However, empirical evaluation of it has been fragmentary. The introduction of a new electoral system in New Zealand saw the print media experiment with the new model. In our study, we examined the journalistic interpretation of election campaign issues under the new circumstances and compared conventional coverage with the use of public journalism. The findings reveal that public journalism provided readers with a different, more constructive framing of political news.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Atkinson, Joe . 1994. “Structures of Television News.” In Power and Responsibility: Broadcasters Striking a Balance, ed. Phillipa Ballard . Wellington, New Zealand: Broadcasting Standards Authority .
2.
Carey, James W.1987. “The Press and the Public Discourse.”Center Magazine (Mar.-Apr.): 4-16 .
3.
Charity, Arthur . 1995. Doing Public Journalism. New York: Guildford Press .
4.
Edelstein, Alex S. , Youichi Ito , and Hans M. Kepplinger . 1989. Communication and Culture: A Comparative Approach. New York: Longman .
5.
Eksterowicz, Anthony J. , Robert Roberts , and Adrian Clark . 1998. “Public Journalism and Public Knowledge.”Press/Politics3(2): 74-95 .
6.
Grimes, Charlotte . 1997. “Whither the Civic Journalism Bandwagon?”Press/Politics2(3): 125-130 .
7.
Gunaratne, Shelton . 1996. “Old Wine in a New Bottle: Public Journalism Movement in the United States and the Erstwhile NWICO Debate.” Presented at the twentieth general assembly and scientific conference of the International Association for Mass Communication Research, Sydney, Aug. 18-22.
8.
Hoyt, Michael . 1992. “The Wichita Experiment.”Columbia Journalism Review (July-Aug.): 43-47 .
9.
Lemert, James B. 1981. Does Mass Communication Change Public Opinion After All? An Approach to Effects Analysis. Chicago: Nelson-Hall .
10.
Major, Ann M.1992. “ `Problematic' Situations in Press Coverage of the 1988 U.S. and French Elections.”Journalism Quarterly69(3): 600-611 .
11.
McGregor, Judy. 1995. “The Manufacture of News in the 1993 New Zealand General Election.” Ph.D. diss., Massey University.
12.
McGregor , Judy , Margie Comrie , and Judi Campbell . 1998. “Public Journalism and Proportional Representation: The New Zealand Experiment.”Australian Journalism Review. 20 (1): 1-22 .
13.
McQuail, Denis . 1987. Mass Communication Theory: An Introduction. 2nd Edition. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage .
14.
Merritt, Davis, Jr. 1994. “A Few Words about Broadcast and Public Journalism: Presentation to Radio and Television News Director's Foundation.”Community Journalism Workshop, Northwestern University, June 10.
15.
Merritt, Davis . 1995. Public Journalism and Public Life: Why Telling the News Is Not Enough. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum .
16.
Morrison, Alistair . 1996. “The Challenge of MMP (Or Will Journalism Be Caught with Its Pants Down?).” In Dangerous Democracy: News Media Politics in New Zealand, ed. Judy McGregor . Palmerston North, New Zealand: Dunmore Press .
17.
Palmer, G. 1996. “Towards a Constitutional Theory for the Media in the MMP Era.” In Dangerous Democracy: News Media Politics in New Zealand, ed. Judy McGregor . Palmerston North, New Zealand: Dunmore Press .
18.
Parisi, Peter . 1998. “Toward a `Philosophy of Framing': News Narratives for Public Journalism.”Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly74(4): 673-686 .
19.
Riffe , Daniel , Charles F. Aust , and Stephen R. Lacy . 1993. “The Effectiveness of Random, Consecutive Day and Constructed Week Sampling in Newspaper Content Analysis.”Journalism Quarterly70(1): 133-139 .
20.
Rosen, Jay . 1992. “Politics, Vision and the Press: Toward a Public Agenda for Journalism.” In The New News v. the Old News. New York: Twentieth Century Fund .
21.
Shephard , Alicia . 1994. “The Gospel of Public Journalism.”American Journalism Review (Sept.): 29-31 .
22.
Stein, M.L.1994. “In Praise of Public Journalism.”Editor and Publisher (Nov. 12): 15,45 .
