Collaborative Planning in the Context of Deindustrialization: A Qualitative Evaluation of Comparative Cases in Northeast Ohio

Abstract

This article investigates whether and how the contexts of the Rust Belt decline extend collaborative planning theory. We evaluate two collaborative planning projects in Northeast Ohio: (1) the Cuyahoga Greenways (CG), a regional trails project and (2) the Mahoning River Corridor Initiative (MRCI), a postindustrial river restoration project. Based on participant interviews and document analysis, we find that the projects are distinct in their contextual conditions and collaborative processes, with CG better aligning with common expectations found in the literature. MRCI deviates from normative theory pertaining to collaborative planning; we discuss how this might relate to processes of institutional change. Our results suggest that the collaborative planning literature is insufficiently tailored to assess collaborative projects in the context of decline—particularly where there is controversy around the project and where collaborative institutions and networks are weak.

Keywords

shrinking cities legacy cities deindustrialization collaborative planning regionalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agranoff

McGuire

. 2003. Collaborative Public Management. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.

Alperovitz

2017, September 25. Black Monday, ‘77, The Birth of the Rust Belt in Youngstown. Moyers On Democracy. https://billmoyers.com/story/black-monday-77-mill-shutdown-youngstown-gave-birth-rust-belt/.

Andrew

Simon A

. 2009. “Regional Integration Through Contracting Networks: An Empirical Analysis of Institutional Collection Action Framework.” Urban Affairs Review 44 (3): 378–402. https://doi.org/10.1177/1078087408323941.

Ansell

Gash

. 2008. “Collaborative Governance in Theory and Practice.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 18 (4): 543–71. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mum032.

Armeni

2016. “Participation in Environmental Decision-Making: Reflecting on Planning and Community Benefits for Major Wind Farms.” Journal of Environmental Law 28 (3): 415–41. https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/eqw021.

Barzotto

Corradini

Fai

F. M.

Labory

Tomlinson

P. R.

. 2019. “Enhancing Innovative Capabilities in Lagging Regions: An Extra-Regional Collaborative Approach to RIS3.” Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 12 (2): 213–32. https://doi.org/10.1093/cjres/rsz003.

Berardo

2010. “Sustaining Joint Ventures: The Role of Resources Exchange and the Strength of Interorganizational Relationships.” In Self-Organizing Federalism, edited by Feiock

R. C.

Scholz

J. T.

, 204–28. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Berube

2019. Small and midsized legacy communities: Trends, assets, and principles for action. Brookings Institution. https://policycommons.net/artifacts/4141091/small-and-midsized-legacy-communities/4949645/ on 05 Jul 2023. CID: 20.500.12592/6vp2j1.

Blyth

2013. Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

10.

Bryson

J. M.

Crosby

B. C.

Stone

M. M.

. 2006. “The Design and Implementation of Cross-Sector Collaborations: Propositions from the Literature.” Public Administration Review 66: 44–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2006.00665.x.

11.

Calderon

Westin

. 2021. “Understanding Context and its Influence on Collaborative Planning Processes: A Contribution to Communicative Planning Theory.” International Planning Studies 26 (1): 14–27. https://doi.org/10.1080/13563475.2019.1674639.

12.

Cleveland Metroparks. n.d. History. Cleveland Metroparks. Retrieved March 30, 2021, from https://www.clevelandmetroparks.com/about/cleveland-metroparks-organization/history.

13.

Cochrane

Koropeckyj

Smith

Ellis

. 2013. “Central Cities and Metropolitan Areas: Manufacturing and Nonmanufacturing Employment as Drivers of Growth.” In Revitalizing American Cities, edited by Wachter

Zeuli

, 65–80. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

14.

Čolić

2014. “Evaluation of the Capacity Development of Actors Within Participatory Planning Process.” SPATIUM International Review 31: 45–50. https://doi.org/10.2298/SPAT1431045C.

15.

Connick

2006. The Sacramento Area Water Forum: A Case Study. Berkeley, CA: University of California, Institute for Urban & Regional Development. https://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/39270.

16.

Connick

Innes

J. E.

. 2003. “Outcomes of Collaborative Water Policy Making: Applying Complexity Thinking to Evaluation.” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 46 (2): 177–97. https://doi.org/10.1080/0964056032000070987.

17.

Cuyahoga County Planning Commission. 2015. Eastside Greenway Plan . https://www.countyplanning.us/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/esgreenway_final_reduced.pdf.

18.

Cuyahoga County Planning Commission. n.d. Cuyahoga Greenways. Cuyahoga County Planning Commission. Retrieved February 4, 2021, from https://www.countyplanning.us/projects/cuyahoga-greenways/.

19.

Cuyahoga County Planning Commission, Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency, & Cleveland Metroparks. 2019. Cuyahoga Greenways Vision Plan . https://www.countyplanning.us/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/CGW_Report_2020–0107_sm.pdf.

20.

Dixit

Clouse

Turken

. 2019. “Strategic Business Location Decisions: Importance of Economic Factors and Place Image.” Rutgers Business Review 4 (1): 73–91. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3378663.

21.

Eastgate Regional Council of Governments. n.d. Mahoning River Restoration. Retrieved March 16, 2021, from https://www.eastgatecog.org/environmental-planning/mahoningriver.

22.

Emerson

Nabatchi

. 2015. “Evaluating the Productivity of Collaborative Governance Regimes: A Performance Matrix.” Public Performance & Management Review 38 (4): 717–47. https://doi.org/10.1080/15309576.2015.1031016.

23.

Emerson

Nabatchi

Balogh

. 2012. “An Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 22 (1): 1–29. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mur011.

24.

Fee

Hartley

. 2013. “The Relationship Between City Center Density and Urban Growth or Decline.” In Revitalizing American Cities, edited by Wachter

Zeuli

, 45–64. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

25.

Fox

Axel-Lute

. 2008. To Be Strong Again: Renewing the Promise in Smaller Industrial Cities. PolicyLink. https://www.policylink.org/resources-tools/to-be-strong-again-renewing-the-promise-in-smaller-industrial-cities.

26.

Friedmann

Weaver

. 1979. Territory and Function: The Evolution of Regional Planning. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

27.

Friends of the Mahoning River. n.d. About the River. Retrieved July 9, 2020, from https://friendsofthemahoningriver.org/about-the-river/.

28.

Galster

2012. Driving Detroit: The Quest for Respect in the Motor City. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

29.

Ganning

J. P.

Tighe

J. R.

. 2021. “Moving Toward a Shared Understanding of the U.S.” Shrinking City. Journal of Planning Education and Research 41 (2): 188–201. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X18772074.

30.

George

A. L.

Bennett

. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

31.

GPD Group and Enviroscience. 2020. Mahoning River Corridor Evaluation Study. Prepared for Eastgate Regional Council of Governments.

32.

Gray

1989. Collaborating: Finding Common Ground for Multiparty Problems. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

33.

Greater Cleveland Trails Leadership Network. n.d. Greater Cleveland Trails & Greenways Conference 2020. Greater Cleveland Trails & Greenways Conference. Retrieved August 6, 2020, from http://gctrails.org/index.html.

34.

Guerrieri

2017. On the 40^th Anniversary of Youngstown’s “Black Monday,” An Oral History. Belt Magazine. Retrieved July 11, 2020, from https://beltmag.com/40th-anniversary-youngstowns-black-monday-oral-history/.

35.

Habermas

1981. The Theory of Communicative Action: Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Boston: Beacon Press.

36.

Hackworth

2019. Manufacturing Decline: How Racism and the Conservative Movement Crush the American Rust Belt. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

37.

Hall

2002. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design Since 1880. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

38.

Hartig

J. H.

Zarull

M. A.

, eds. 1992. Under RAPs: Toward Grassroots Ecological Democracy in the Great Lakes Basin. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

39.

Head

B. W.

2008. “Assessing Network-Based Collaborations: Effectiveness for Whom?” Public Management Review 10 (6): 733–49. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719030802423087.

40.

Healey

1997. Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies. 1st ed. Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK: Palgrave MacMillan.

41.

Healey

Cars

Madanipour

De Magalhaes

. 2017. “Transforming Governance, Institutionalist Analysis and Institutional Capacity.” In Urban Governance, Institutional Capacity and Social Milieux, 6–28. Abingdon, Oxfordshire, UK: Routledge.

42.

Hollingsworth

Goebel

. 2017. Revitalizing America’s Smaller Legacy Cities. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. https://www.lincolninst.edu/publications/policy-focus-reports/revitalizing-americas-smaller-legacy-cities.

43.

Innes

J. E.

Booher

D. E.

. 1999. “Consensus Building and Complex Adaptive Systems: A Framework for Evaluating Collaborative Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association 65 (4): 412–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944369908976071.

44.

Innes

J. E.

Booher

D. E.

. 2018. Planning with Complexity: An Introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. London: Routledge.

45.

Innes

J. E.

Booher

D. E.

Di Vittorio

. 2010. “Strategies for Megaregion Governance: Collaborative Dialogue, Networks, and Self-Organization.” Journal of the American Planning Association 77 (1): 55–67. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944363.2011.533640.

46.

Innes

J. E.

Gruber

. 2005. “Planning Styles in Conflict: The Metropolitan Transportation Commission.” Journal of the American Planning Association 71 (2): 177–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944360508976691.

47.

Innes

Gruber

Neuman

Thompson

. 1994. Coordinating Growth Management Through Consensus-Building: Incentives and the Generation of Social, Intellectual and Political Capital. Berkeley, CA: California Policy Seminar.

48.

Innes

J. E.

Rongerude

. 2006. Collaborative regional initiatives: Civic entrepreneurs work to fill the governance gap (No. 2006, 04). Working Paper.

49.

Innes

J. E.

Rongerude

. 2013. “Civic Networks for Sustainable Regions–Innovative Practices and Emergent Theory.” Planning Theory & Practice 14 (1): 75–100. https://doi.org/10.1080/14649357.2012.754487.

50.

J. Max Bond Center. 2015. Mapping America’s Legacy Cities. The City College of New York. https://ssa.ccny.cuny.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/MappingAmericanLegacyCities_15Dec2015.pdf.

51.

Kwak

C.-G.

Song

. 2020. “Strength of Strong Ties in Intercity Government: Information Sharing and County Jurisdictional Boundaries.” Public Administration Review 80 (1): 23–35. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13135.

52.

Kim

Malizia

Nelson

Wolf-Powers

Ganning

Schrock

. 2020. “Real Estate Development and Economic Development Planning Education: Pragmatic Turn or Trojan Horse?” Journal of Planning Education and Research 44: 9–15. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X20963568.

53.

Kodrzycki

Y. K.

Munoz

A. P.

. 2013. “Lessons from Resurgent Mid-Size Manufacturing Cities.” In Revitalizing American Cities, edited by Wachter

Zeuli

, 83–104. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

54.

Kwon

Feiock

R. C.

. 2010. “Overcoming the Barriers to Cooperation: Intergovernmental Service Agreements.” Public Administration Review 70 (6): 876–84. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2010.02219.x.

55.

Leach

W. D.

Pelkey

N. W.

. 2001. “Making Watershed Partnerships Work: A Review of the Empirical Literature.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 127 (6): 378–85. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9496(2001)127:6(378).

56.

Leach

W. D.

Pelkey

N. W.

Sabatier

P. A.

. 2002. “Stakeholder Partnerships as Collaborative Policymaking: Evaluation Criteria Applied to Watershed Management in California and Washington.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management: The Journal of the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management 21 (4): 645–70. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.10079.

57.

LeRoux

Brandenburger

P. W.

Pandey

S. K.

. 2010. “Interlocal Service Cooperation in U.S. Cities: A Social Network Explanation.” Public Administration Review 70 (2): 268–78. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2010.02133.x.

58.

Mallach

Brachman

. 2013. Regenerating America’s Legacy Cities. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. https://www.lincolninst.edu/publications/policy-focus-reports/regenerating-americas-legacy-cities.

59.

Mamula

Daniel C

. 2009. Mahoning River Corridor Initiative Feasibility Study. Youngstown: Youngstown State University.

60.

Mandarano

L. A.

2008. “Evaluating Collaborative Environmental Planning Outputs and Outcomes: Restoring and Protecting Habitat and the New York—New Jersey Harbor Estuary Program.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 27 (4): 456–68. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X08315888.

61.

Margerum

R. D.

1999. “Getting Past Yes: From Capital Creation to Action.” Journal of the American Planning Association 65 (2): 181–92. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944369908976046.

62.

Margerum

R. D.

2002. “Evaluating Collaborative Planning: Implications from an Empirical Analysis of Growth Management.” Journal of the American Planning Association 68 (2): 179–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944360208976264.

63.

Margerum

R. D.

Lewis

Dobrinich

. 2019. “Collaborative Metropolitan Governance: An Evaluation of Local Adoption in Denver.” Cities 93: 136–44. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2019.04.010.

64.

Margerum

R. D.

Robinson

C. J.

. 2015. “Collaborative Partnerships and the Challenges for Sustainable Water Management.” Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 12: 53–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cosust.2014.09.003.

65.

NEOSCC. 2018. Vibrant NEO Champion Awards. Retrieved July 18, 2020, from http://vibrantneo.org/vibrant-neo-champion-awards/.

66.

NOACA. n.d. Transportation for Livable Communities Initiative (TLCI). Cleveland, OH: Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency. Retrieved February 5, 2021, from https://www.noaca.org/community-assistance-center/funding-programs/transportation-for-livable-communities-initiative-tlci.

67.

Northeast Ohio Sustainable Communities Consortium (NEOSCC), & Sasaki Associates. 2014. Vibrant NEO 2040 A Vision, Framework, and Action Products for Our Future. Cleveland, OH: NEOSCC.

68.

Ohio Department of Taxation. n.d. Distributions—LGF and PLF. Ohio Department of Taxation. https://tax.ohio.gov/wps/portal/gov/tax/government/resources/distributions-lgf-and-plf.

69.

Patton

2013. Three blows to local government: Loss in state aid, estate tax, and property tax rollback (Local Government and the State Budget). Policy Matters Ohio. https://www.policymattersohio.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/72313-Three-blows-to-local-government.pdf.

70.

Putnam

R. D.

1993. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

71.

Riano

2021. Field Notes: The Mahoning River as Urban Reinvention. The Architectural League. Accessed October 4, 2023. URL: https://archleague.org/article/mahoning-valley-dam-removal/.

72.

Rubado

M. E.

2019. “The Role of Interlocal Collaboration in Legacy Cities.” In Legacy Cities: Continuity and Change Amid Decline and Revival, edited by Tighe

J. R.

Ryberg-Webster

, 21–36. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

73.

Rubado

M. E.

2021. “From Neighbors to Partners: The Adoption of Interlocal Government Collaboration in the United States, 1977–2007.” Administration & Society 53 (5): 708–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095399720960483.

74.

Sabatier

P. A.

Focht

Lubell

Trachtenberg

Vedlitz

. 2005. Swimming Upstream: Collaborative Approaches to Watershed Management. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

75.

Safford

2004. Why the Garden Club Couldn’t Save Youngstown: Civic Infrastructure and Mobilization in Economic Crises (MIT-IPC-04-002; IPC Working Paper Series). Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

76.

Samanta

Kellogg

. 2019. “Back to the Beginning: The Resurgence of the Cuyahoga River and Cleveland.” In Legacy Cities: Continuity and Change Amid Decline and Revival, edited by Tighe

J. R.

Ryberg-Webster

, 205–20. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

77.

Scott

J. W.

2007. “Smart Growth as Urban Reform: A Pragmatic ‘Recoding’ of the New Regionalism.” Urban Studies 44 (1): 15–35. https://doi.org/10.1080/00420980601074284.

78.

Stradling

. 2008. “Perceptions of the Burning River: Deindustrialization and Cleveland’s Cuyahoga River.” Environmental History 13 (3): 515–35. https://doi.org/10.1093/envhis/13.3.515.

79.

Strauss

Corbin

. 1990. Basics of Qualitative Research. Los Angeles: Sage Publications.

80.

Susskind

L. E.

McKearnen

Thomas-Lamar

. 1999. The Consensus Building Handbook: A Comprehensive Guide to Reaching Agreement. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

81.

Tighe

J. R.

Ryberg-Webster

. 2019. Legacy Cities: Continuity and Change Amid Decline and Revival. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

82.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. 2001. Final Report: Lower Mahoning River, Pennsylvania Environmental Dredging Reconnaissance Study. Pittsburgh District.

83.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. 2006. Mahoning River, Ohio Environmental Dredging Draft Feasibility Report and Environmental Impact Statement. Pittsburgh District.

84.

U.S. Census Bureau. 2023. 2022 Census of Governments – Organization. Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2022/econ/gus/2022-governments.html.

85.

Waldrop

M. M.

1992. Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos. New York: Simon and Schuster.

86.

Wheeler

S. M.

2002. “The New Regionalism: Key Characteristics of an Emerging Movement.” Journal of the American Planning Association 68 (3): 267–78. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944360208976272.

87.

Yost

2017. Ohio Village Officer’s Handbook. Columbus: Ohio Auditor of State. https://ohioauditor.gov/trainings/lgoc/2017/VillageOfficerHandbook.pdf .