Legacy cities are characterized by long-term, declining trends in both population and economic characteristics, but how these events translate to the neighborhood scale is less well understood. This research investigates the evolution of neighborhood types in four legacy cities—Baltimore, Cleveland, Philadelphia, and St. Louis—from 1970 to 2010. Working from a multidimensional framework of variables across five census decades, hierarchical cluster analysis and discriminant analysis are used to develop a neighborhood typology, identify temporal trends, and describe the pathways of transition. Results reveal four crosscutting neighborhood types: Black Distressed; Lower Middle; Multifamily, Educated, Turnover; and Upper Middle, which persist across space and time. Most neighborhoods (61%) remained classified within the same type over 40 years, and transitions were concentrated in two decades (1970–1980 and 2000–2010). The results offer a new descriptive dimension for understanding the unevenness present across legacy cities and suggest that existing policy approaches continually reproduce the same neighborhood outcomes.
AdamsCarolyn T.2014. From the Outside in: Suburban Elites, Third-Sector Organizations, and the Reshaping of Philadelphia. Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press.
2.
AkersJoshuaBéalVincentRousseauMax. 2019. “Redefining the City and Demolishing the Rest: The Techno-Green Fix in Postcrash Cleveland, Ohio.” Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space. Published electronically June2. doi:10.1177/2514848619854371.
3.
American Assembly. 2011. Reinventing America’s Legacy Cities: Strategies for Cities Losing Population. New York: American Assembly.
4.
BeauregardRobert A.2006. When America Became Suburban. Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press.
5.
BeauregardRobert A.2012. “Growth and Depopulation in the United States.” In Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland, edited by MallachAlan, 1–21. New York: American Assembly.
6.
BoehlkeDavid. 2012. “Preserving Healthy Neighborhoods: Market-Based Strategies for Housing and Neighborhood Revitalization.” In Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland, edited by MallachAlan, 143–62. New York: American Assembly.
7.
BrophyPaulBurnettKim. 2003. A Framework for Community: Development in Weak Market Cities. Denver: Community Development Partnership Network.
ChavesElisabethKnoxPaulBieriDavid. 2011. “The Restless Landscape of Metroburbia.” In International Perspectives on Suburbanization, edited by PhelpsNicholas A.WuFulong, 35–53. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
10.
ClatworthyJaneBuickDeannaHankinsMatthewWeinmanJohnHorneRobert. 2005. “The Use and Reporting of Cluster Analysis in Health Psychology: A review.” British Journal of Health Psychology10 (3): 329–58.
11.
DelmelleElizabeth C.2015. “Five Decades of Neighborhood Classifications and Their Transitions: A Comparison of Four US Cities, 1970–2010.” Applied Geography57:1–11.
12.
DelmelleElizabeth C.2017. “Differentiating Pathways of Neighborhood Change in 50 US Metropolitan Areas.” Environment and Planning A49 (10): 2402–24.
13.
DewarMargaretThomasJune Manningeds. 2013. The City after Abandonment. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press.
14.
GalsterGeorge. 2001. “On the Nature of Neighbourhood.” Urban Studies38 (12): 2111–24.
15.
GanningJoanna P.TigheJ. Rosie. 2018. “Moving Toward a Shared Understanding of the US Shrinking City.” Journal of Planning Education and Research. Published electronically June4. doi:10.1177/0739456X18772074.
16.
GoldsteinIraSchreckerWilliamRoschJacob L.2016. “Demographics and Characteristics of Middle Neighborhoods in Select Legacy Cities.” Community Development Investment Review11: 21–45.
17.
GroßmannKatrinBontjeMarcoHaaseAnnegretMykhnenkoVlad. 2013. “Shrinking Cities: Notes for the Further Research Agenda.” Cities35: 221–25.
18.
GuerrieriVeronicaHartleyDanielHurstErik. 2013. “Endogenous Gentrification and Housing Price Dynamics.” Journal of Public Economics100: 45–60.
HackworthJason. 2014. “The Limits to Market-Based Strategies for Addressing Land Abandonment in Shrinking American Cities.” Progress in Planning90: 1–37.
21.
HackworthJason. 2016. “Demolition as Urban Policy in the American Rust Belt.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space48 (11): 2201–22.
22.
HairJoseph F.BlackWilliam C.BabinBarry J.AndersonRolph E.2010. Multivariate Data Analysis: A Global Perspective. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education.
23.
HarttMaxwell. 2018. “The Diversity of North American Shrinking Cities.” Urban Studies55 (13): 2946–59.
24.
HillEdward W.WolmanHarold L.KowalczykKatherineSt. ClairTravis2012. “Forces Affecting City Population Growth or Decline: The Effects of Inter-regional and Inter-municipal Competition.” In Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland, edited by MallachAlan, 31–79. New York: American Assembly.
25.
HillEdward W.BrennanJohn F.WolmanHarold L.1998. “What is a Central City in the United States? Applying a Statistical Technique for Developing Taxonomies.” Urban Studies35 (11): 1935–69.
26.
HoborGeorge. 2013. “Surviving the Era of Deindustrialization: The New Economic Geography of the Urban Rust Belt.” Journal of Urban Affairs35 (4): 417–34.
27.
HollanderJustin B.2010. “Moving Toward a Shrinking Cities Metric: Analyzing Land Use Changes Associated with Depopulation in Flint, Michigan.” Cityscape12: 133–51.
28.
HollanderJustin B.NémethJeremy. 2011. “The Bounds of Smart Decline: A Foundational Theory for Planning Shrinking Cities.” Housing Policy Debate21 (3): 349–67.
29.
HwangJackelynSampsonRobert J.2014. “Divergent Pathways of Gentrification: Racial Inequality and the Social Order of Renewal in Chicago Neighborhoods.” American Sociological Review79 (4): 726–51.
30.
KatzBruce. 2006. Revitalising Weak Market Cities in the US (Presentation to Council on Foundations 8). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
31.
KleckaWilliam R.1980. Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences: Discriminant analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. doi: 10.4135/9781412983938
32.
Legacy City Partnership. 2018. “What Are Legacy Cities?”The facts. Accessed August 29, 2018. http://www.legacycities.org/.
33.
MaddenJanice FanningRutherMatt. 2018. “The Paradox of Expanding Ghettos and Declining Racial Segregation in Large US Metropolitan Areas, 1970–2010.” Journal of Housing Economics40:117–28.
34.
Mallach, Alan, ed.2012. Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland. New York: American Assembly.
35.
MallachAlan. 2013. “Parallel Histories, Diverging Trajectories: Resilience in Small Industrial Cities.” In Revitalizing American Cities, edited by WachterSusanZeuliKimberly A., 125–46. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press.
36.
MallachAlan. 2015. “The Uncoupling of the Economic City: Increasing Spatial and Economic Polarization in American Older Industrial Cities.” Urban Affairs Review51 (4): 443–73.
37.
MallachAlan. 2016. “Is the Urban Middle Neighborhood an Endangered Species? Multiple Challenges and Difficult Answers.” Community Development Investment Review11: 46–62.
38.
MallachAlanPooleyKaren Beck. 2018. What Drives Neighborhood Revival? Qualitative Research Findings from Baltimore and St. Louis. Cambridge: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
39.
MallachAlanBrachmanLavea. 2013. Regenerating America’s Legacy Cities. Cambridge: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
40.
MasseyDouglas S.2015. “The Legacy of the 1968 Fair Housing Act.” Sociological Forum30: 571–88.
41.
MikelbankBrian A.2004. “A Typology of US Suburban Places.” Housing Policy Debate15 (4): 935–64.
42.
MikelbankBrian A.2011. “Neighborhood déjà vu: Classification in Metropolitan Cleveland, 1970-2000.” Urban Geography32 (3): 317–33.
OwensAnn. 2012. “Neighborhoods on the Rise: A Typology of Neighborhoods Experiencing Socioeconomic Ascent.” City & Community11 (4): 345–69.
45.
PaganoMichal A.BowmanAnn O. M.2000. Vacant Land in Cities: An Urban Resource. Washington, DC: Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy, Brookings Institution.
46.
ReardonSean F.BischoffKendra. 2011. “Income Inequality and Income Segregation.” American Journal of Sociology116 (4): 1092–153.
47.
ReibelMichael. 2011. “Classification Approaches in Neighborhood Research: Introduction and Review.” Urban Geography32 (3): 305–16.
48.
ReibelMichaelRegelsonMoira. 2011. “Neighborhood Racial and Ethnic Change: The Time Dimension in Segregation.” Urban Geography32 (3): 360–82.
49.
RichtellBobbie. 2012. “Case Study: Re-imagining Cleveland: Pilot Land Reuse Projects.” In Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland, edited by MallachAlan, 185–88. New York: American Assembly.
50.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2013. “Preserving Downtown America: Federal Rehabilitation Tax Credits and the Transformation of US Cities.” Journal of the American Planning Association79 (4): 266–79.
51.
SilvermanRobert MarkYinLiPattersonKelly L.2013. “Dawn of the Dead City: An Exploratory Analysis of Vacant Addresses in Buffalo, NY 2008–2010.” Journal of Urban Affairs35 (2): 131–52.
52.
ThomasJune M. 2012. “Addressing the Racial, Ethnic, and Class implications of Legacy Cities.” In Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: Defining a Future for American Cities Experiencing Severe Population Loss, edited by MallachAlan, 223–42. New York: American Assembly.
53.
ThomsonDale E.2013. “Targeting Neighborhoods, Stimulating Markets: The Role of Political, Institutional, and Technical Factors in Three Cities.” In The City after Abandonment, edited by DewarMargaretThomasJune Manning, 104–32. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press.
54.
TigheJ. RosieGanningJoanna P.2015. “The Divergent City: Unequal and Uneven Development in St. Louis.” Urban Geography36 (5): 654–73.
55.
TigheJ. RosieGanningJoanna P.2016. “Do Shrinking Cities Allow Redevelopment without Displacement? An Analysis of Affordability Based on Housing and Transportation Costs for Redeveloping, Declining, and Stable Neighborhoods.” Housing Policy Debate26 (4–5): 785–800.
56.
TimberlakeJeffrey M.Johns-WolfeElaina. 2017. “Neighborhood Ethnoracial Composition and Gentrification in Chicago and New York, 1980 to 2010.” Urban Affairs Review53 (2): 236–72.
57.
van HamMaartenManleyDavidBaileyNickSimpsonLudiMaclennanDuncan. 2012. “Neighbourhood Effects Research: New perspectives.” In Neighbourhood Effects Research: New Perspectives, edited by Van HamMaartenManleyDavidBaileyNickSimpsonLudiMaclennanDuncan, 1–21. Dordrecht: Springer.
58.
WeiFangKnoxPaul L.2014. “Neighborhood Change in Metropolitan America, 1990 to 2010.” Urban Affairs Review50 (4): 459–89.
59.
WilsonWilliam J.1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
