History matters. Inspired by evolutionary approaches in economics and, more recently, economic geography, the authors present, through the lens of a slaughterhouse development on the city's fringe, a historical model of urban development in the metropolitan region of Calgary, Canada. Their analysis shows how an unanticipated system shock conditioned by strong historical differences in the political and economic aspirations of adjacent urban and rural jurisdictions manifested at multiple temporal and spatial scales. Their narrative explores the intertwined evolutionary trajectories of five key system elements whose pathways converged in 2004, resulting in unintended, and from a regional environmental perspective, undesirable, consequences.
Alberta Environment.2005. (Draft) water management plan for the South Saskatchewan River Basin in Alberta. Edmonton, AB: Alberta Queen's Printer.
2.
Alberta Environment: Regional Services Southern Region.2003. South Saskatchewan River Basin allocation. Edmonton, AB: Alberta Queen's Printer.
3.
Alberta Royal Commissions and Commissions of Inquiry and G. F. McNally.1956. Report of the Royal Commission on the Metropolitan Development of Calgary and Edmonton. Edmonton, AB: Province of Alberta.
4.
Allen, C.R., and C.S. Holling.2002. Cross-scale structure and scale breaks in ecosystems and other complex systems. Ecosystems5:315-18.
5.
Bettison, D.G., J.K. Kenward, L. Taylor, and Alberta Human Resources Research Council.1975. Urban affairs in Alberta. Vol. 2 of Urbanization in Canada . Edmonton: Univ. of Alberta Press .
6.
Boschma, R., and K. Frenken.2006. Why is economic geography not an evolutionary science? Journal of Economic Geography6 (3): 273-302.
7.
Burton, T.L.1981. The roles and relevance of Alberta's regional planning commissions. Edmonton: Univ. of Alberta, Department of Recreation Administration.
8.
Climenhaga, D.1997. The death and life of regional planning in the Calgary area. Master's thesis, Carleton University, Ottawa, ON.
9.
Collin, J.P., J. Leveillee, and C. Poitras.2002. New challenges and old solutions: Metropolitan reorganization inCanadian and U.S. city-regions. Journal of Urban Affairs24 (3): 317-32.
10.
David, P.1985. Clio and the economics of QWERTY. American Economic Review (Papers and Proceedings)75:332-37.
11.
---. 2007. Path dependence: A foundational concept for historical social science. Cliometrica: The Journal of Historical Economics and Econometric History1 (2): 91-114.
12.
Elder, P.S.1996. Alberta's 1995 planning legislation. Journal of Environmental Law and Practice6:23-58.
13.
Fairbairn, J., and L.J. Gustafson.2005. Cattle slaughter capacity in Canada: Interim report of the Standing Senate Committee on Agriculture and Forestry . Ottawa, ON: Senate of Canada .
14.
Foran, M.2002. Crucial and contentious: The American market and the development of the western Canadian beef cattle industry to 1948. American Review of Canadian Studies32 (Autumn): 451-76.
15.
---. 2004. Blurred vision: The Calgary Union Stockyard issue, 1913-1914 . Urban History Review32 (2): 33-44.
16.
---. 2008. Expansive discourses: Residential urban sprawl in Calgary, 1945-1978. Edmonton, AB: AU Press .
17.
Foran, M., H.M. Foran, and J.D. Balcers.1982. Calgary, Canada's frontier metropolis: An illustrated history. Windsor, ON: Windsor.
18.
Garud, R., and P. Karnøe.2001. Path creation as a process of mindful deviation. In Path dependence and creation, edited by R. Garud and P. Karnoe, 1-38. London: Lawrence Erlbaum.
19.
Gordon, M., and J.D. Hulchanski .1985. The evolution of the land use planning process in Alberta, 1945-1984. Land policy paper no. 5. Toronto, ON: University of Toronto, Centre for Urban and Community Studies.
20.
Greener, I.2002. Theorising path-dependency: How does history come to matter in organisations? Management Decision40 (5/6): 614-19.
21.
Hope, M.2004. Land in limbo: Annexation stalled as Calgary grows . Calgary Herald, November 20, J1.
22.
Klassen, H.1999. A business history of Alberta. Calgary , AB: Univ. of Calgary Press.
23.
Lake, R.W.1993. Rethinking NIMBY. Journal of the American Planning Association59 (1): 87-93.
24.
Laux, F.1990. Planning law and practice in Alberta. Calgary, AB: Carswell.
25.
Leo, C., and K. Anderson.2006. Being realistic about urban growth . Journal of Urban Affairs28 (2): 169-89.
26.
Leo, C., and M. Piel.2006. Unicity superannuated at 35. In Metropolitan governing: Canadian cases, comparative lessons, edited by E. Razin and P. Smith, 121-46. Jerusalem: Hebrew Univ. Magnes Press.
27.
MacArthur, M.2007. Red ink forces Rancher's Beef packing plant to close doors . Western Producer, 11.
28.
MacLachlan, I., and I. Townshend.2003/2004. Stockyard districts as industrial clusters in two western Canadian cities. Western Geography13/14:44-68.
29.
Martin, R., and P. Sunley.2006. Path dependence and regional economic evolution. Journal of Economic Geography6 (4): 395-437.
30.
McCormick, K., and M. Hope.2006. "Open for business": Projects welcomed by Municipal District of Rocky View. Calgary Herald, February 18, J1.
31.
Municipal District of Rocky View No. 44.2004 . Municipal development plan. Calgary, AB : Author.
32.
Myers, S.2005. Regional feuds a "powder keg": Mayor urges return of planning commission. Calgary Herald, September 9, B1.
33.
Parker, R.2005. Calgary: A uni-city at 50 years. Plan Canada45 (Autumn): 29-31.
34.
Percy, D.1996. Seventy-five years of Alberta water law: Maturity, demise and rebirth. Alberta Law Review35 (1): 221-41.
35.
Pierson, P.2000a. Increasing returns, path dependence, and the study of politics. American Political Science Review94 (2): 251-67.
36.
---. 2000b. Not just what, but when: Timing and sequence in political processes. Studies in American Political Development14 (Spring): 72-92.
37.
---. 2004. Politics in time: history, institutions, and social analysis . Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.
38.
Plummer, P., and E. Sheppard.2006. Geography matters: Agency, structures and dynamics at the intersection of economics and geography. Journal of Economic Geography6 (5): 619-37.
39.
Sancton, A.2001. Canadian cities and the new regionalism. Journal of Urban Affairs23 (5): 543-55.
40.
---. 2002. Metropolitan and regional governance. In Urban policy issues: Canadian perspectives, edited by Edmund P. Fowler and David Siegel, 54-68. Toronto, ON: Oxford Univ. Press.
41.
Smart, J., A. Smart A, V. Terstappen, and L. Arkell.2006. Consumer confidence and BSE in Canada . Paper presented at the Prion 2006, Turin, Italy.
Statistics Canada.2007. Population and dwelling counts, for census metropolitan areas and census agglomerations, 2006 and 2001 censuses. http://www.12.statcan.ca/english/census06/data/popdwell/SubTables.cfm?T=200.
44.
Torfing, J.1999. Towards a Schumpeterian workfare postnational regime: Path-shaping and path-dependency in Danish welfare state reform. Economy and Society28 (3): 369-402.
