What Counts? A Mixed-Methods Study to Inform Evaluation of Shelters for Abused Women

Abstract

Shelters for abused women have expanded from “safe havens” to providing a range of residential and outreach services, and face increasing pressure to demonstrate “value for money” by providing evaluation metrics that may or may not reflect what they actually do. We conducted interviews and surveys with 68 shelter directors in Ontario, Canada, and found that differences in service philosophy and how abuse is defined influence decisions about who receives services and the shelter’s role in the broader community; these in turn affect how the work of shelters is positioned. Implications for shelter service evaluation are discussed.

Keywords

evaluation interviews survey women’s shelters

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

Saunders

(2003). Leaving an abusive partner: An empirical review of predictors, the process of leaving, and psychological well-being. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 4, 163-191.

Bennett

Riger

Schewe

Howard

Wasco

(2004). Effectiveness of hotline, advocacy, counseling, and shelter services for victims of domestic violence: A statewide evaluation. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 19, 815-829.

Berg

B. L.

(1995). Qualitative research methods for the social sciences (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

Brennan

(2011). Violent victimization of Aboriginal women in the Canadian provinces, 2009 (Catalogue no. 85-002-X). Statistics Canada, Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics Profile Series. Retrieved from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2011001/article/11439-eng.htm

Brownridge

D. A.

(2003). Male partner violence against Aboriginal women in Canada: An empirical analysis. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 18, 65-83.

Brownridge

D. A.

(2008). Understanding the elevated risk of partner violence against Aboriginal women: A comparison of two nationally representative surveys of Canada. Journal of Family Violence, 23, 353-367.

Chan

K. L.

Cho

E. Y.

(2010). A review of cost measures for the economic impact of domestic violence. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 11, 129-143.

Feder

Ramsay

Dunne

Rose

Arsene

Norman

. (2009). How far does screening women for domestic (partner) violence in different health-care settings meet criteria for a screening programme? Systematic reviews of nine UK National Screening Committee criteria. Health Technology Assessment, 13(16), 1-113, 137-347.

Ford-Gilboe

Wuest

Merritt-Gray

(2005). Strengthening capacity to limit intrusion: Theorizing family health promotion in the aftermath of woman abuse. Qualitative Health Research, 15, 477-501.

10.

Global Network of Women’s Shelters. (2011). Global shelter data count. Edmonton, Canada: Alberta Council of Women’s Shelters. Retrieved from http://www.gnws.org/en/work/global-data-count.html

11.

Goard

Tutty

(2003). Turning points: An analysis of YWCA violence against women shelters and family violence programs (Phase I). Toronto, Ontario: YWCA Canada.

12.

Grossman

Lundy

(2011). Characteristics of women who do and do not receive onsite shelter services from domestic violence programs. Violence Against Women, 17, 1024-1045.

13.

Haaken

Yragui

(2003). Going underground: Conflicting perspectives on domestic violence shelter practices. Feminism & Psychology, 13, 49-71.

14.

Harris

R.M.

Wathen

C.N.

Lynch

(2014). Assessing performance in shelters for abused women: Can ‘caring citizenship’ be measured in ‘value for money’ accountability regimes? International Journal of Public Administration, 37, 737–746.

15.

Jones

A. S.

Dienemann

Schollenberger

Kub

O’Campo

Gielen

A. C.

Campbell

J. C.

(2006). Long-term costs of intimate partner violence in a sample of female HMO enrollees. Women’s Health Issues, 16, 252-261.

16.

Lyon

Lane

Menard

(2008). Meeting survivors’ needs: A multi-state study of domestic violence shelter experiences. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice. Retrieved from http://www.vawnet.org/research/MeetingSurvivorsNeeds

17.

Lyon

Lane

Menard

(2011). Meeting survivors’ needs through non-residential domestic violence services & supports: Results of a multi-state study. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice. Retrieved from http://www.vawnet.org/research/MeetingSurvivorsNeeds

18.

McDonald

(2005). Neo-liberalism and the pathologising of public issues: The displacement of feminist service models in domestic violence support services. Australian Social Work, 58, 275-284.

19.

McLellan

(1997). Alternative service delivery in Ontario: The new public management. Toronto, Canada: Ontario Legislative Library.

20.

Ministry of Community and Social Services. (2009). Survey of VAW emergency shelter services: Final report. Toronto, Canada: Government of Ontario.

21.

Ministry of Community and Social Services. (2012). Violence against women data elements and definitions (Ref: 2B-ADSVAW3-MCSS-E). Toronto, Canada: Government of Ontario.

22.

Morrow

Hankivsky

Varcoe

(2004). Women and violence: The effects of dismantling the welfare state. Critical Social Policy, 24, 358-384.

23.

Nelson

H. D.

Nygren

McInerney

Klein

, & The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. (2004). Screening women and elderly adults for family and intimate partner violence: A review of the evidence for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Annals of Internal Medicine, 140, 387-396.

24.

Ontario Association of Interval and Transition Houses. (1996). Locked in, left out: Impacts of the Progressive Conservative budget cuts and policy initiatives on abused women and their children in Ontario. Retrieved from http://www.oaith.ca/assets/files/Publications/Locked.pdf

25.

Ontario Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration. (2004). Domestic violence action plan for Ontario. Retrieved from http://www.women.gov.on.ca/owd/docs/dvap.pdf

26.

Ontario Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration. (2007, January). Domestic violence action plan for Ontario: Update. Retrieved from http://www.women.gov.on.ca/owd/docs/dvap_update.pdf

27.

Panzer

Philip

Hayward

(2000). Trends in domestic violence service and leadership: Implications for an integrated shelter model. Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 27, 339-352.

28.

Perreault

(2011). Violent victimization of Aboriginal people in the Canadian provinces, 2009 (Catalogue no. 85-002-X). Juristat, Statistics Canada, Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2011001/article/11415-eng.htm

29.

Ramsay

Carter

Davidson

Dunne

Eldridge

Feder

. (2009). Advocacy interventions to reduce or eliminate violence and promote the physical and psychosocial well-being of women who experience intimate partner abuse. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3, Article CD005043.

30.

Ricciutelli

Larkin

O’Neill

(Eds.). (1998). Confronting the cuts: A sourcebook for women in Ontario. North York, Ontario, Canada: Inanna Publications.

31.

Sauve

Burns

(2009). Residents of Canada’s shelters for abused women, 2008 (Juristat Article, 29[2], Catalogue no. 85-002-x). Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada.

32.

Sullivan

C. M.

(2011). Evaluating domestic violence support service programs: Waste of time, necessary evil, or opportunity for growth? Aggression and Violent Behavior, 16, 354-360.

33.

Sullivan

C. M.

Baptista

O’Halloran

Okroj

Morton

Sutherland Stewart

(2008). Evaluating the effectiveness of women’s refuges: A multi-country approach to model development. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 32, 291-308.

34.

Sullivan

C. M.

Basta

Tan

Davidson

W. S.

(1992). After the crisis: A needs assessment of women leaving a domestic violence shelter. Violence and Victims, 7, 267-275.

35.

Sullivan

C. M.

Bybee

D. I.

(1999). Reducing violence using community-based advocacy for women with abusive partners. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 67, 43-53.

36.

Sullivan

C. M.

Campbell

Angelique

Eby

K. K.

Davidson

W. S.

II (1994). An advocacy intervention program for women with abusive partners: Six-month follow-up. American Journal of Community Psychology, 22(1), 101-122.

37.

Tutty

L. M.

(2006). Effective practices in sheltering women leaving violence in intimate relationships (Phase II). Toronto, Ontario: YWCA Canada.

38.

Tutty

L. M.

Rothery

M. A.

(2002). How well do emergency shelters assist abused women and their children? In Tutty

L. M.

Goard

(Eds.), Reclaiming self: Issues and resources for women abused by intimate partners (pp. 25-42). Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Fernwood Publishing and RESOLVE.

39.

Varcoe

Hankivsky

Ford-Gilboe

Wuest

Wilk

Hammerton

. (2011). Attributing selected costs to intimate partner violence in a sample of women who have left abusive partners: A social determinants of health approach. Canadian Public Policy, 37, 359-380.

40.

Wathen

C. N.

MacMillan

H. L.

(2003). Interventions for violence against women: Scientific review. Journal of the American Medical Association, 289, 589-600.

41.

Women’s Aid in Scotland. (2011). National service standards: Summary. Scottish Women’s Aid. Retrieved from http://www.scottishwomensaid.org.uk/sites/default/files/NationalServiceStandards-SummaryApril2011.pdf

42.

Wuest

Merritt-Gray

(1999). Not going back: Sustaining the separation in the process of leaving abusive relationships. Violence Against Women, 5, 110-133.

43.

YWCA Canada. (2009). Life beyond shelter: Toward coordinated public policies for women’s safety and violence prevention (Phase III). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.