The supply of personal care aides (PCAs), who assist people receiving home care, is a growing concern. PCA shortages result, in part, from the low wages earned by these workers. State policies have had some effect on wages. Self-direction (SD) may be associated with wages because SD allows home care recipients to hire and manage workers, including setting wages in most states. We used wage data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics to examine the association between SD and the wages of PCAs. We found implementation of SD did not have a consistent association with PCA wages, with wages improving in some states and worsening in others. We also found little difference in PCA wages between states that allow participants to set worker wages and those that do not. SD does not seem to improve PCA wages in states, so other policy strategies will be needed.
BaughmanR. A.SmithK. (2010). The effect of Medicaid wage pass-through programs on the wages of direct care workers. Medical Care, 48(5), 426–432.
2.
BenjaminA. E. (2018). Consumer-directed services at home for older people in the United States. In CarmelS.MorseC. A.Torres-GilF. M.HendricksJ.(Eds.), Lessons on aging from three nations: The art of caring for older adults (pp. 21–36). Routledge.
3.
CampbellS.DrakeA. D.EspinozaR.ScalesK. (2021). Caring for the future: The power and potential of America’s direct care workforce. PHI.
4.
CarlsonB. L.FosterL.DaleS. B.BrownR. (2007). Effects of cash and counseling on personal care and well-being. Health Services Research, 42(1 Pt. 2), 467–487.
ChapmanS. A.GreimanL.BatesT.WagnerL. M.LissauA.Toivanen-AtillaK.SageR. (2022). Personal care aides: Assessing self-care needs and worker shortages in rural areas: Study examines self care needs for people with disabilities and worker shortages in rural areas. Health Affairs, 41(10), 1403–1412.
DaleS.BrownR.PhillipsB.CarlsonB. (2005). Experiences of workers hired under cash and counseling: Findings from Arkansas, Florida, and New Jersey. Mathematica Policy Research.
DuffyM.BaughmanR.SmithK. (2021). The flip side of turnover: Employment transitions and occupational attachment among low-wage care workers in the United States. Feminist Economics, 27(4), 62–89.
FosterL.DaleS. B.BrownR. (2007). How caregivers and workers fared in Cash and Counseling. Health Services Research, 42(1 Pt. 2), 510–532.
17.
HartmannH.HayesJ. (2017). The growing need for home care workers: Improving a low-paid, female-dominated occupation and the conditions of its immigrant workers. Public Policy & Aging Report, 27(3), 88–95.
18.
IezzoniL. I.GallopynN.ScalesK. (2019). Historical mismatch between home-based care policies and laws governing home care workers. Health Affairs, 38(6), 973–980.
19.
KraiemD. (2011). Consumer direction in Medicaid long term care: Autonomy, commodification of family labor, and community resilience. Journal of Gender, Social Policy & Law, 19, 671–719.
20.
KreiderA. R.WernerR. M. (2023). The home care workforce has not kept pace with growth in home and community-based services: Study examines the US home care workforce alongside the growth in home-and community-based services. Health Affairs, 42(5), 650–657.
21.
McGarryB. E.GrabowskiD. C. (2023). Medicaid home and community-based services spending for older adults: Is there a “woodwork” effect?Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 71, 3143–3151. https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.18478
22.
Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission. (2020). MACStats: Medicaid and CHIP data book.
ScalesK. (2022). Transforming direct care jobs, reimagining long-term services and supports. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 23(2), 207–213.
33.
SchmittJ.WallerM.FremstadS.ZippererB. (2008). Unions and upward mobility for low-wage workers. WorkingUSA, 11(3), 337–348.
34.
SciegajM.MahoneyK. J.SchwartzA. J.Simon-RusinowitzL.SelkowI.LoughlinD. M. (2016). An inventory of publicly funded participant-directed long-term services and supports programs in the United States. Journal of Disability Policy Studies, 26(4), 245–251.
SwaineJ. G.ParishS. L.IgdalskyL.PowellR. M. (2016). Consumers’ and workers’ perspectives about consumer-directed services in the United States. Disability and Health Journal, 9, 3464–3471.
37.
ThompsonF.NadashP.GusmanoM.MillerE. A. (2016). Federalism and the growth of self-directed long-term services and supports. Public Policy & Aging Report, 26(4), 123–128.
38.
TillyJ.WienerJ. M. (2001). Consumer-directed home and community services programs in eight states: Policy issues for older people and government. Journal of Aging & Social Policy, 12(4), 1–26.
39.
TylerD. A.SquillaceM. R.PorterK. A.HunterM.HaltermannW. (2022). COVID-19 exacerbated long-standing challenges for the home care workforce. Journal of Aging & Social Policy, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/08959420.2022.2136919
40.
TylerD. A.StoneR. (2022). Policy attention needed to improve direct care worker wages and other challenges. Innovation in Aging, 6(Suppl. 1), 248–249.
