Specialty providers claim to offer a new competitive benchmark for efficient delivery of health care. This article explores this view by examining evidence for price competition between ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) and hospital outpatient departments (HOPDs). I studied the impact of ASC market presence on actual prices paid to HOPDs during 2007-2010 for four common surgical procedures that were performed in both provider types. For the procedures examined, HOPDs received payments from commercial insurers in the range of 3.25% to 5.15% lower for each additional ASC per 100,000 persons in a market. HOPDs may have less negotiating leverage with commercial insurers on price in markets with high ASC market penetration, resulting in relatively lower prices.
Ambulatory Surgery Center Association. (2007). Ambulatory surgery centers: A positive trend in health care. Alexandria, VA: Ambulatory Surgery Center Association.
2.
AndersonG. F.ReinhardtU. E.HusseyP. S.PetrosyanV. (2003). It’s the prices, stupid: Why the United States is so different from other countries. Health Affairs, 22, 89-105.
3.
BarroJ. R.HuckmanR. S.KesslerD. P. (2006). The effects of cardiac specialty hospitals on the cost and quality of medical care. Journal of Health Economics, 25, 702-721.
4.
BerensonR. A.GinsburgP. B.KemperN. (2012). The growing power of some providers to win steep payment increases from insurers suggests policy remedies may be needed. Health Affairs, 31, 973-981.
5.
BianJ.MorriseyM. A. (2007). Free-standing ambulatory surgery centers and hospital surgery volume, Inquiry, 44, 200-210.
6.
CareyK. (2015). Price increases were much lower in ambulatory surgery centers than hospital outpatient departments in 2007-12. Health Affairs, 34, 1738-1744.
7.
CareyK.BurgessJ. F.YoungG. Y. (2011). Hospital competition and financial performance: The effects of ambulatory surgery centers. Health Economics, 20, 571-581.
8.
CourtemancheC.PlotzkeM. (2010). Does competition from ambulatory surgical centers affect hospital surgical output?Journal of Health Economics, 29, 765-773.
9.
CramP.RosenthalG. E.Vaughan-SarrazinM. S. (2005). Cardiac revascularization in specialty and general hospitals. New England Journal of Medicine, 352, 1454-1462.
10.
DorA.GrossmanM.KoroukianS. M. (2004). Hospital transaction prices and managed-care discounting for selected medical technologies. American Economic Review, 94, 352-356.
11.
DorA.KoroukianS. M.GrossmanM. (2004). Managed care discounting: Evidence from the MarketScan database. Inquiry, 41, 159-169.
12.
ElixhauserA.SteinerC.HarrisD. R.CoffeyR. M. (1998). Comorbidity measures for use with administrative data. Medical Care, 36, 8-27.
13.
GaynorM. (2014). Competition policy in health care markets: Navigating the enforcement and policy maze. Health Affairs, 33, 1088-1093.
14.
GinsburgP. B.PawlsonL. G. (2014). Seeking lower prices where providers are consolidated: An examination of market and policy strategies. Health Affairs, 33, 1067-1075.
15.
HollingsworthJ. M.KreinS. L.YeZ.KimH. M.HollenbeckB. K. (2011). Opening of ambulatory surgery centers and procedure use in elderly patients: Data from Florida. Archives of Surgery, 146, 187-193.
16.
HollingsworthJ. M.YeZ.StropeS. A.KreinS. L.HollenbeckA. T.HollenbeckB. K. (2009). Urologist ownership of ambulatory surgery centers and urinary stone surgery use. Health Services Research, 44, 1370-1384.
MeyerhoferC. D.ColbyM. S.McFetridgeJ. T. (2012). Patient mix in outpatient surgery settings and implications for Medicare payment policy. Medical Care Research and Review, 69, 62-82.
20.
MitchellJ. M. (2007). Utilization changes following market entry by physician-owned specialty hospitals. Medical Care Research and Review, 64, 395-415.
21.
MoriyaA. S.GaynorM.VogtW. B. (2010). Hospital prices and market structure in the hospital and insurance industries. Health Economics, Policy and Law, 5, 459-479.
22.
MunnichE. L.ParenteS. T. (2014). Procedures take less time at ambulatory surgery centers, keeping costs down. Health Affairs, 33, 764-769.
23.
OberlanderJ.WhiteJ. (2009). Public attitudes toward health care spending aren’t the problem; prices are. Health Affairs, 28, 1285-1293.
24.
PlotzkeM. R.CourtemancheC. (2011). Does procedure profitability impact whether an outpatient surgery is performed at an ambulatory surgery center or hospital?Health Economics, 20, 817-830.
25.
SchactmanD. (2005). Specialty hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers, and general hospitals: Charting a wise public policy course. Health Affairs, 24, 868-873.
26.
TrentmanT. L.MuellerJ. T.GrayR. J.PockajB. A.SimulaD. V. (2010). Outpatient surgery performed in an ambulatory surgery center versus a hospital: Comparison of perioperative time intervals. American Journal of Surgery, 200, 64-67.
27.
TrybouJ.De ReggeM.GemmelP.DuyckP.AnnemansL. (2014). Effects of physician-owned specialized facilities in health care: A systematic review. Health Policy, 118, 316-340.
YeeC. A. (2011). Physicians on board: An examination of physician financial interests in ASCs using longitudinal data. Journal of Health Economics, 30, 904-918.
