The objective of this research was to examine whether users of mental health or substance abuse (MH/SA) services incurred greater costs for non-MH/SA services than nonusers of MH/SA services. Two years of health care utilization data were collected on 443 at-risk drinkers from six southern U.S. states. We then examined predictors of using MH/SA services and costs associated with non-MH/SA services. The results showed that use of MH/SA services was associated with female gender, military service, health insurance, and not being employed full-time. Unadjusted analyses indicated that non-MH/SA service costs were significantly higher among MH/SA service users than nonusers. However, this association did not endure in multivariable models. In fact, emergency department costs were significantly lower among MH/SA users. It is commonly assumed that users of MH/SA services are also heavy users of other medical services. Through multivariable models, this study found that overall costs of non-MH/SA services were similar between users and nonusers of MH/SA services.
Aday, L.A., and R. Andersen.1974. A framework for the study of access to medical care. Health Services Research9 (3): 208—20.
2.
American Psychiatric Association.1994. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
3.
Andersen, R.M.1995. Revisiting the behavioral model and access to medical care: Does it matter?Journal of Health and Social Behavior36 (1): 1—10.
4.
Armstrong, M.A., L.T. Midanik, and A.L. Klatsky.1998. Alcohol consumption and utilization of health services in a health maintenance organization. Medical Care36 (11): 1599—1605.
5.
Boffetta, P., and M. Hashibe.2006. Alcohol and cancer. Lancet Oncology7 (2): 149—56.
6.
Booth, B.M., R.L. Ross, and K. Rost.1999. Rural and urban problem drinkers in six Southern states. Substance Use and Misuse34 (4—5): 471—93.
7.
Booth, B.M., F.C. Blow, C.A. Cook, J.Y. Bunn, and J.C. Fortney.1997. Relationship between inpatient alcoholism treatment and longitudinal changes in health care utilization. Journal of Studies on Alcohol58 (6): 625—37.
8.
Booth, B.M., J. Kirchner, J. Fortney, R. Ross, and K. Rost.2000. Rural at-risk drinkers: Correlates and one-year use of alcoholism treatment services. Journal of Studies on Alcohol61 (2): 267—77.
9.
Brazier, J.E., R. Harper, N.M. Jones, A. O'Cathain, K.J. Thomas, T. Usherwood, and L. Westlake.1992. Validating the SF-36 health survey questionnaire: New outcome measure for primary care. British Medical Journal305 (6846): 160—64.
10.
Cherpitel, C.J., K. Soghikian, and L.B. Hurley.1996. Alcohol-related health services use and identification of patients in the emergency department. Annals ofEmergency Medicine28 (4): 418—23.
11.
Duan, N., W.G. Manning, C.N. Morris, and J.P. Newhouse.1983. A comparison of alternative models for the demand for medical care. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics1: 115—26.
12.
Duan, N., W.G. Manning, C.N. Morris, and J.P. Newhouse.1984. Choosing between the sample-selection model and the multi-part model. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics2: 283—89.
13.
Fleming, M.F., K.L. Barry, L.B. Manwell, K. Johnson, and R. London.1997. Brief physician advice for problem alcohol drinkers. A randomized controlled trial in community-based primary care practices . JAMA277 (13): 1039—45.
14.
Fortney, J.C., B.M. Booth, and G.M. Curran.1999. Do patients with alcohol dependence use more services? A comparative analysis with other chronic disorders. Alcoholism, Clinical & Experimental Research23 (1): 127—33.
15.
Fortney, J., B. Booth, M. Zhang, M.J. Humphrey, and E. Wiseman.1998. Controlling for selection bias in the evaluation of Alcoholics Anonymous as aftercare treatment. Journal of Studies on Alcohol59 (6): 690—97.
16.
Fortney, J.C., B.M. Booth, J.E. Kirchner, D.K. Williams, and X. Han.2003. Differences between physical and behavioral health benefits in the health plans of at-risk drinkers. Psychiatric Services54 (1): 97—102.
17.
Fortney, J., S. Mukherjee, G. Curran, S. Fortney, X. Han, and B.M. Booth.2004. Factors associated with perceived stigma for alcohol use and treatment among at-risk drinkers. Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research31 (4): 418—29.
18.
Frenzen, P.D.1993. Health insurance coverage in U.S. urban and rural areas. Journal of RuralHealth9 (3):204—14.
19.
Garnick, D.W., A.M. Hendricks, C. Comstock, and C. Horgan.1997. Do individuals with substance abuse diagnoses incur higher charges than individuals with other chronic conditions?Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment14 (5): 457—65.
20.
Grant, B.F.1996. Toward an alcohol treatment model: A comparison of treated and untreated respondents with DSM-IV alcohol use disorders in the general population. Alcoholism, Clinical and Experimental Research20 (2): 372—78.
21.
Hadida, A., N. Kapur, K. Mackway-Jones, E. Guthrie, and F. Creed.2001. Comparing two different methods of identifying alcohol related problems in the emergency department: A real chance to intervene ? Emergency Medicine Journal18 (2): 112—15.
22.
Harwood, H.2000. Updating estimates of the economic costs of alcohol abuse in the United States: Estimates, update data, and methods. NIH Publication No. 98-4327. Rockville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.
23.
Havassy, B.E., J. Alvidrez, and K.K. Owen.2004. Comparisons of patients with comorbid psychiatric and substance use disorders: Implications for treatment and service delivery. American Journal of Psychiatry161 (1): 139—45.
24.
Hilton, M.E. and W.B. Clark.1987. Changes in American drinking patterns and problems, 1967—1984. Journal of Studies on Alcohol48 (6): 515—22.
25.
Holder, H.D.1987. Alcoholism treatment and potential health care cost saving . Medical Care25 (1): 52—71.
26.
—— 1998. Cost benefits of substance abuse treatment: An overview of results from alcohol and drug abuse. Journal of Mental Health Policy and Economics1 (1): 23—29.
27.
Holder, H.D., and J.O. Blose.1986. Alcoholism treatment and total health care utilization and costs. A four-year longitudinal analysis of federal employees . JAMA256 (11): 1456—60.
28.
—— 1992. The reduction of health care costs associated with alcoholism treatment: A 14-year longitudinal study. Journal ofStudies on Alcohol53 (4): 293—302.
29.
Holder, H.D., and J.B. Hallan.1986. Impact of alcoholism treatment on total health care costs: A six-year study. Advances in Alcohol and Substance Abuse6 (1): 1—15.
30.
Institute of Medicine.1990. Broadening the base of treatment for alcohol problems. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
31.
Kaskutas, L.A., C. Weisner, and R. Caetano.1997. Predictors of help seeking among a longitudinal sample of the general population, 1984—1992. Journal of Studies on Alcohol58 (2): 155—61.
32.
Lowenstein, S.R., M.P. Weissberg, and D. Terry.1990. Alcohol intoxication, injuries, and dangerous behaviors—and the revolving emergency department door. Journal of Trauma30 (10): 1252—58.
33.
Manning, W.G., N. Duan, and W.H. Rogers.1987. Monte Carlo evidence on the choice between sample selection and two-part models. Journal of Econometrics35: 59—82.
34.
McAuliffe, W.E., R. LaBrie, R. Woodworth, C. Zhang, and R.P. Dunn.2003. State substance abuse treatment gaps . American Journal of Addiction12 (2): 101—21.
35.
Merzel, C.2000. Gender differences in health care access indicators in an urban, low-income community. American Journal of Public Health90 (6): 909—16.
36.
Moyer, A., J.W. Finney, C.E. Swearingen, and P. Vergun, P. 2002. Brief interventions for alcohol problems: A meta-analytic review of controlled investigations in treatment-seeking and non-treatment-seeking populations. Addiction97 (3): 279—92.
37.
Nietert, P.J., M.T. French, J. Kirchner, X. Han, X., and B.M. Booth.2004. Health services utilization and cost for at-risk drinkers: Rural and urban comparisons. Journal of Studies on Alcohol65 (3): 353—62.
38.
Padgett, D.K., C. Patrick, B.J. Burns, and H.J. Schlesinger .1994. Ethnicity and the use of outpatient mental health services in a national insured population. American Journal of Public Health84 (2): 222—26.
39.
Parthasarathy, S., and C.M. Weisner.2005. Five-year trajectories of health care utilization and cost in a drug and alcohol treatment sample. Drug and Alcohol Dependence80 (2): 231—40.
40.
Parthasarathy, S., C. Weisner, T.W. Hu, and C. Moore.2001. Association of outpatient alcohol and drug treatment with health care utilization and cost: Revisiting the offset hypothesis. Journal of Studies on Alcohol62 (1): 89—97.
41.
Penchansky, R., and J.W. Thomas.1981. The concept of access: Definition and relationship to consumer satisfaction. Medical Care19 (2): 127—40.
42.
Putnam, S.L.1982. Alcoholism, morbidity and care-seeking. The inpatient and ambulatory service utilization and associated illness experience of alcoholics and matched controls in a health maintenance organization. Medical Care20 (1): 97—121.
43.
Rhine, S.L., and Y.C. Ng.1998. The effect of employment status on private health insurance coverage: 1977 and 1987. Health Economics7 (1): 63—79.
44.
Room, R., T. Babor, and J. Rehm.2005. Alcohol and public health. Lancet365 (9458): 519—30.
45.
Sobell, L.C., M.B. Sobell, and S. Agrawal.2002. Self-change and dual recoveries among individuals with alcohol and tobacco problems: Current knowledge and future directions. Alcoholism, Clinical and Experimental Research26 (12): 1936—38.
46.
Sobell, L.C., M.B. Sobell, G.I. Leo, S. Agrawal, L. Johnson-Young, and J.A. Cunningham .2002. Promoting self-change with alcohol abusers: A community-level mail intervention based on natural recovery studies. Alcoholism, Clinical and Experimental Research26 (6): 936—48.
47.
Wang, P.S., M. Lane, M. Olfson, H.A. Pincus, K.B. Wells, and R.C. Kessler.2005. Twelve-month use of mental health services in the United States: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives ofGeneral Psychiatry62 (6): 629—40.
48.
Weisner, C.1993. Toward an alcohol treatment entry model: A comparison of problem drinkers in the general population and in treatment. Alcoholism, Clinical and Experimental Research17 (4): 746—52.
49.
Weisner, C., and L. Schmidt.1992. Gender disparities in treatment for alcohol problems. JAMA268 (14): 1872—76.
