This article addresses the impact of financial incentives on physician behavior, focusing on quality of care. Changing market conditions, evolving social forces, and continuing organizational evolution in health services have raised societal awareness and expectations concerning quality. This article proceeds in four parts. First, the authors place financial incentives in the context of broader forces shaping the quality of physician services. Second, the article reviews the literature on financial incentive effects on physician behavior. Third, a simple net income maximization model of physician choices is presented, from which are derived formal hypotheses regarding the effect of financial incentives on physician choices of quality per unit of physician service and the quantity of services per patient. The model is extended qualitatively to offer further hypotheses and research directions. Finally, gaps and limitations of the model and of the extant empirical research are articulated, and additional researchable questions are posed.
Adams, J. S.1963. Towards an understanding of inequity. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology67: 422-436.
2.
Armour, B. S., M. M. Pitts, R. Maclean, C. Cangialose, M. Kishel, H. Imai, and J. Etchason. 2001. The effect of explicit financial incentives on physician behavior. Archives of Internal Medicine161 (May 28): 1261-1266.
3.
Bailit Health Purchasing, LLC. 2002. Provider incentive models for improving quality of care. Prepared for the National Health Care Purchasing Institute: An Initiative of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
4.
Bailit Health Purchasing, LLC, and Sixth Man Consulting, Inc. 2001. The growing case for using physician incentives to improve health care quality. Prepared for the National Health Care Purchasing Institute: An Initiative of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
5.
Berwick, D. M.1996. A primer on leading the improvement of systems. British Medical Journal312: 619-622.
6.
Christianson, J. B., and R. Feldman. 2002. Evolution in the Buyers Health Care Action Group Purchasing Initiative. Health Affairs21 (1): 76-88.
7.
Christianson, J. B., S. Parente, and R. Taylor. 2002. Defined-contribution health insurance products: Development and prospects. Health Affairs21 (1): 49-64.
8.
Condry, J., and J. Chambers. 1978. Intrinsic motivation and the process of learning. In The hidden cost of rewards: New perspectives on the psychology of human motivation, edited by M. R. Lepper and D. Greene, 61-83. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
9.
Congleton, R. D.1991. The economic role of a work ethic. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization15: 365-385.
10.
Conrad, D. A., C. Maynard, A. Cheadle, S. Ramsey, M. Marcus-Smith, H. Kirz, C. A. Madden, et al. 1998. Primary care compensation methods in medical groups: Does it influence the use and cost of health services for enrollees in managed care organizations?Journal of the American Medical Association279 (11): 853-858.
11.
Conrad, D. A., A. Sales, S. Y. Liang, A. Chaudhuri, C. Maynard, L. Pieper, L. Weinstein, D. Gans, and N. Piland. 2002. Impact of financial incentives on physician productivity in medical groups. Health Services Research37 (4): 885-906.
12.
Dranove, D., and M. A. Satterthwaite. 1992. Monopolistic competition when price and quality are imperfectly observable. Rand Journal of Economics23 (4): 518-534.
13.
Dudley, R. A., R. H. Miller, T. Y. Korenbrot, and H. S. Luft. 1998. The impact of financial incentives on quality of health care. Milbank Quarterly76 (4): 649-686.
14.
Fairbrother, G., M. J. Siegel, S. Friedman, P. D. Kory, and G. C. Butts. 2001. The impact of financial incentives on documented immunization rates in the inner city: Results of a randomized controlled trial. Ambulatory Pediatrics1 (4): 206-212.
15.
Fernandopulle, R., T. Ferris, A. Epstein, B. McNeil, J. Newhouse, G. Pisano, and D. Blumenthal. 2003. A research agenda for bridging the “quality chasm.”Health Affairs22 (2): 178-190.
16.
Flood, A. B., A. M. Fremont, K. Jin, D. M. Bott, J. Ding, and R. C. Parker Jr.1998. How do HMOs achieve savings? The effectiveness of one organization’s strategies. Health Services Research33 (1): 79-99.
17.
Frey, B. S.1997. On the relationship between intrinsic and extrinsic work motivation. International Journal of Industrial Organization15: 427-439.
18.
Gaynor, M., and M. V. Pauly. 1990. Compensation and productive efficiency in part-nerships: Evidence from medical group practice. Journal of Political Economy98 (3): 544-573.
19.
Goodson, J. D., A. S. Bierman, O. Fein, K. Rask, E. C. Rich, and H. P. Selker. 2001. The future of capitation: The physician role in managing change in practice. Journal of General Internal Medicine16 (April): 250-256.
20.
Gosden, T., F. Forland, I. S. Kristiansen, M. Sutton, B. Leese, A. Giuffrida, M. Sergison, and L. Pedersen. 2001. Impact of payment method on behavior of primary care physicians: Asystematic review. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy6 (1): 44-55.
21.
Hellinger, F. J.1998. The effect of managed care on quality: Areview of recent evidence. Archives of Internal Medicine158 (April 27): 833-841.
22.
Hillman, A. L., M. V. Pauly, and J. Kerstein. 1989. How do financial incentives affect physicians’ clinical decisions and financial performance of HMOs?New England Journal of Medicine321 (July 13): 86-92.
23.
Hillman, A. L., K. Ripley, N. Goldfarb, I. Nuamah, J. Weiner, and E. Lusk. 1998. Physician financial incentives and feedback: Failure to increase cancer screening in Medicaid managed care. American Journal of Public Health88 (11): 1699-1701.
24.
Institute of Medicine. 2001. Crossing the quality chasm: Anew health system for the 21st century. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
25.
Jensen, M., and W. Meckling. 1976. Theory of the firm: Management behavior, agency costs, and capital structure. Journal of Financial Economics3: 305-360.
26.
Kouides, R. W., N. M. Bennett, B. Lewis, J. D. Cappuccio, W. H. Barker, and F. M. LaForce. 1998. Performance-based physician reimbursement and influenza immunization rates in the elderly: The primary-care physicians of Monroe County. American Journal of Preventive Medicine14 (2): 89-95.
27.
Kralewski, J. E., E. C. Rich, R. Feldman, B. E. Dowd, T. Bernhardt, C. Johnson, and W. Gold. 2000. The effects of medical group practice and physician payment methods on costs of care. Health Services Research35 (3): 591-613.
28.
Kuhn, Michael. 2003. Quality in primary care: Economic approaches to analysing quality-related physician behavior. London: Office of Health Economics.
29.
Landon, B. E., J. Reschovsky, M. Reed, and D. Blumenthal. 2001. Personal, organizational, and market level influences on physicians’ practice patterns. Medical Care39 (8): 889-905.
30.
McGuire, T. G.2000. Chapter 9: Physician agency. In Handbook of health economics, vol. 1A, edited by A. J. Culyer and J. P. Newhouse, 461-536. New York: Elsevier.
31.
Miller, R. H. and H. S. Luft. 1994. Managed care plan performance since 1980. Journal of the American Medical Association271 (May 18): 1512-1519.
32.
Miller, R. H. and H. S. Luft. 1997. Does managed care lead to better or worse quality of care?Health Affairs16 (5): 7-25.
33.
Miller, R. H. and H. S. Luft. 2002. HMO plan performance update: An analysis of the literature, 1997-2001. Health Affairs21 (4): 63-86.
34.
Pauly, M. V., and M. Satterthwaite. 1981. The pricing of primary care physicians services: Atest of the role of consumer information. Bell Journal of Economics12 (2): 488-506.
35.
Pedersen, C. A., E. C. Rich, J. Kralewski, R. Feldman, B. Dowd, and T. Bernhardt. 2000. Primary care physician incentives in medical group practices. Archives of Family Medicine9 (5): 458-462.
36.
Pope, G. C., and R. T. Burge. 1992. Inefficiencies in physician practices. Advances in Health Economics and Health Services Research13: 129-164.
37.
Prendergast, C. R.1999. The provision of incentives in firms. Journal of Economic Literature37: 7-63.
38.
Reschovsky, J., M. Reed, D. Blumenthal, and B. Landon. 2001. Physicians’ assessments of their ability to provide high-quality care in changing health care system. Medical Care39 (3): 254-269.
39.
Rice, T.1997. Physician payment policies: Impact and implications. Annual Review of Public Health18: 549-565.
40.
Robinson, J. C.2001. Theory and practice in the design of physician payment incentives. Milbank Quarterly79 (2): 149-177.
41.
Rosenthal, M. B., R. G. Frank, J. L. Buchanan, and A. M. Epstein. 2002. Transmission of financial incentives to physicians by intermediary organizations in California. Health Affairs21 (4): 197-205.
42.
Safran, D. G.,W. H. Rogers, A. R. Tarlov, T. Inui, D. A. Taira, J. E. Montgomery, J. E. Ware, and C. P. Slavin. 2000. Organizational and financial characteristics of health plans: Are they related to primary care performance?Archives of Internal Medicine160 (January 10): 69-76.
43.
Safran, D. G., A. R. Tarlov, and W. H. Rogers. 1994. Primary care performance in fee-for-service and prepaid health care systems: Results from the Medical Outcomes Study. Journal of the American Medical Association271 (20): 1579-1586.
44.
St Peter, R. F., M. C. Reed, P. Kemper, and D. Blumenthal. 1999. Changes in the scope of care provided by primary care physicians. New England Journal of Medicine341 (26): 1980-1985.
45.
Silberberg, E.1990. The structure of economics: A mathematical analysis. 2nd ed.San Francisco: McGraw-Hill.
46.
Sturm, R.2002. Effect of managed care and financing on practice constraints and career satisfaction in primary care. Journal of the American Board of Family Practice5 (5): 367-377.
47.
Tufano, J., D. A. Conrad, A. Sales, C. Maynard, J. Noren, E. Kezirian, K. G. Schellhase, and S. Y. Liang. 2001. Effects of compensation method on physician behaviors. American Journal of Managed Care7 (4): 363-373.
48.
Ware, J. E., Jr.,M. S. Bayliss, W. H. Roger, M. Kosinski, and A. R.Tarlov. 1996. Differences in 4-year health outcomes for elderly and poor chronically ill patients treated in HMO and fee-for-service: Results from the Medical Outcomes Study. Journal of the American Medical Association276: 1039-1047.
49.
Ware, J. E, Jr., R. H. Brook, W. H. Rogers, E. B. Keeler, A. R. Davies, C.D. Sherbourne, G. A. Goldberg, P. Camp, and J. P. Newhouse. 1986. Comparison of health outcomes at a health maintenance organization with those of fee-for-service care. Lancet1: 1017-1022.
50.
Zierler, B. K., M. S. Marcus-Smith, A. Cheadle, D. A. Conrad, H. L. Kirz, C.Madden, J. Noren, E. B. Perrin, S. D. Ramsey, and A. Ross. 1998. Effect of compensation method on the behavior of primary care physicians in managed care organizations: Evidence from interviews with physicians and medical leaders in Washington State. American Journal of Managed Care4 (2): 209-220.
