Operational modal analysis of a multi-span skew bridge using real-time wireless sensor networks

Abstract

A large-scale field deployment of high-density, real-time wireless sensors networks for the acquisition of local acceleration measurements across a medium length, multi-span highway bridge is presented. The advantages, performance characteristics, and limitations of employing this emerging technology in favor of the traditional cable-based acquisition systems are discussed in the context of the in-service instrumentation and ambient vibration testing of a multi-span bridge. Of particular highlight in this study is the deployment of a large number of stationary rather than reference-based accelerometers to uniquely permit simultaneous acquisition of vibration measurements across the structure and thereby ensure consistent temperature, ambient vibration, and traffic loading. The deployment consisted of 30 dual-axis accelerometers installed across the girders of the bridge and interfaced with 30 wireless acquisition and transceiver nodes operating in two star topology networks. Real-time wireless acquisition at a per channel sampling rate of 128 samples per second was maintained across both networks for the specified test durations of 3 min with insignificant data loss. Output-only system identification of the structure from the experimental data is presented to provide estimates of natural frequencies, damping ratios, and operational mode shapes for 19 modes. The analysis of the structure under test provides a unique case study documenting the measured response of a multiple-span skewed bridge supported by elastomeric bearings. The feasibility of embedded wireless instrumentation for structural health monitoring of large civil constructions is concluded while highlighting relevant technological shortcomings and areas of further development required. In particular, previously undocumented obstacles relating to radio transmission of the sensor data using low-power 2.4 GHz wireless instrumentation, such as the effect of solid piers within the line-of-sight and the reflection of the radio waves on the surface of the water, are discussed.

Keywords

Bridge dynamics operational modal analysis wireless sensor network structural health monitoring skew bridge elastomeric bearings

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aktan

Catbas

Türer

Zhang

(1998) Structural identification: analytical aspects. Journal of Structural Engineering 124(7): 817–829.

Alampalli

Dillon

(1997) Signal versus noise in damage detection by experimental modal analysis. Journal of Structural Engineering 123(2): 237–245.

Catbas

Ciloglu

Hasancebi

Grimmelsman

Aktan

(2007) Limitations in Structural identification of large constructed structures. Journal of Structural Engineering 133(8): 1051–1066.

De Roeck G, Peeters B and Ren W-X (2000) Benchmark study on system identification through ambient vibration measurements. In: Proceedings of the International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC 18), San Antonio, TX, 7–10 February, 2000, pp.1106–1112.

Farrar CR, Baker WE, Bell TM, Cone KM, Darling TW, Duffey TA, Eklund A and Migliori A (1994) Dynamic characterization and damage detection in the I-40 Bridge over the Rio Grande. Technical Report LA-12767-MS, Los Alamos National Laboratory.

Farrar

Jauregui

(1998) Comparative study of damage identification algorithms applied to a bridge: I. Experiment. Smart Materials and Structures 7704–719.

Huth

Feltrin

Maeck

Kilic

Motavalli

(2005) Damage identification using modal data: experiences on a prestressed concrete bridge. Journal of Structural Engineering 131(12): 1898–1910.

Kang

Park

S-K

Shin

Lee

(2005) Structural system identification in time domain using measured acceleration. Journal of Sound and Vibration 288(1–2): 215–234.

Lynch

Loh

(2006) A summary review of wireless sensors and sensor networks for structural health monitoring. Shock and Vibration Digest 38(2): 91–128.

10.

Lynch

Wang

Loh

J-H

Yun

C-B

(2006) Performance monitoring of the Geumdang Bridge using a dense network of high-resolution wireless sensors. Smart Materials and Structures 15(6): 1561–1575.

11.

Maleki S (2001) Free vibration of skew bridges. Journal of Vibration and Control 7(7): 935–952.

12.

Meng

Lui

(2000) Seismic analysis and assessment of a skew highway bridge. Engineering Structures 221433–1452.

13.

Morassi

Tonon

(2008) Dynamic testing for structural identification of a bridge. Journal of Bridge Engineering 13(6): 573–585.

14.

Paek

Jang

OGK-Y

Nishimura

Govindan

Caffrey

Wahbeh

Masri

(2006) A programmable wireless sensing system for structural monitoring. Proceedings 4th World Conference on Structural Control and Monitoring San Diego, CA, July 2006.

15.

Pakzad

Fenves

Kim

Culler

(2008) Design and implementation of scalable wireless sensor network for structural monitoring. Journal of Infrastructure Systems 14(1): 89–101.

16.

Peeters B (2000) System identification and damage detection in civil engineering, PhD Dissertation, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven.

17.

Peeters

Maeck

De Roeck

(2001) Vibration-based damage detection in civil engineering: excitation sources and temperature effects. Smart Materials and Structures 10518–527.

18.

Ratcliffe

(1997) Damage detection using a modified laplacian operator on mode shape data. Journal of Sound and Vibration 204(3): 505–517.

19.

Ren

W-Z

Zhao

Harik

(2004) Experimental and analytical modal analysis of steel arch bridge. Journal of Structural Engineering 130(7): 1022–1031.

20.

Teughels

De Roeck

(2004) Structural damage identification of the highway bridge Z24 by FE model updating. Journal of Sound and Vibration 278589–610.

21.

Van den Branden

Peeters

De Roeck

(1999) Introduction to MACEC v2.0: modal analysis on civil engineering constructions. User Guide and Case Studies Katholieke Universiteit Leuven: p.47.

22.

Whelan

Fuchs

Janoyan

(2008) Large scale remote sensing for environmental monitoring of infrastructure. Journal of Environmental Monitoring 10812–816.

23.

Whelan

Gangone

Janoyan

Jha

(2009) In-service modal analysis of a highway bridge using a real-time wireless sensor network. Engineering Structures 30(10): 2224–2235.

24.

Whelan

Janoyan

(2009) Design of a robust, high-rate wireless sensor network for static and dynamic structural health monitoring. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 20(7): 849–863.

25.

Whelan

Janoyan

(2010) In-service diagnostics of a highway bridge from a progressive damage case study. Journal of Bridge Engineering 15(5): 597–607.

26.

Law

(2004) Damage localization in plate structures from uniform load surface curvature. Journal of Sound and Vibration 276(1–2): 227–244.

27.

Zhiqiang

Lee

(2009) A comparative study of bridge damage due to the Wenchuan, Northridge, Loma Prieta, and San Fernando earthquakes. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration 8(2): 251–261.