Abstract
Acute traumatic coagulopathy (ATC) is commonly seen among patients with severe injury and will lead to uncontrolled bleeding diathesis, which is an important contributor to trauma death. During the past 10 years, the understanding of the mechanism causing ATC has changed rapidly. The mechanisms for ATC are complicated. To date, the possible mechanisms include activation of protein C, shedding of endothelial glycocalyx, catecholamine release, platelet dysfunction, primary, and secondary fibrinolysis, with tissue injury and hypoperfusion as the triggers. Classic factors such as dilution, acidosis, and hypothermia can further aggravate the coagulopathy. Inflammation may have a potential effect on the onset and prognosis of ATC. With the aid of diagnostic device, the outcome can be improved through early and customized treatment. Antifibrinolytics such as tranexamic acid has some benefits in patients with bleeding trauma, especially in the early time. This review presents the current understanding of ATC mechanisms and management.
Introduction
Trauma is still a very common reason for mortality and morbidity. 1,2 Trauma-induced hemorrhage accounts for around 40% of all trauma casualties, 3 and control of the bleeding is the priority of the management. Systemic inflammatory response syndrome and multiple organ failure are the ensuing complications without timely or proper treatment. 4 In the past, traumatic coagulopathy was considered to be the result of acidosis, hypothermia, dilution, and other conditions. 5 In the recent years, robust researchers have emerged to study the pathophysiology and treatment of acute traumatic coagulopathy (ATC). Much attention has been thrown into the protein C (PC) activation, shedding of glycocalyx, catecholamine, and inflammation. In a large multicenter retrospective study, ATC was closely related to tissue damage and systemic hypoperfusion and that was corroborated by a rat model. 6 Also, some new devices have been introduced for the early diagnosis of ATC, 7 which facilitated the management of the coagulopathy and reduced the usage of blood product. In this article, we reviewed the possible mechanisms for the development of ATC as well as the current treatment.
Methods
A literature search (PubMed) was performed to locate relevant articles and studies pertaining to the mechanism and treatment of ATC. The reference lists of relevant articles were then hand searched for other references. Relevant articles also underwent a “cited reference search” (ISI Web of Science). Studies that were not in English language or published in abstract form only were excluded. Specific search terms included “acute traumatic coagulopathy,” “ATC,” “trauma induced coagulopathy,” “TIC,” “hemorrhagic shock coagulation,” “trauma disseminated intravascular coagulation” “mechanism trauma coagulopathy,” and “treatment trauma coagulopathy.”
The Characteristics and Definition of ATC
Acute traumatic coagulopathy was first described by Brohi et al in 2003. 8 It is characterized by dysfunction of the coagulation, anticoagulation, and fibrinolysis system, mainly featuring a hypocoagulant state, with a prolonged prothrombin time (PT), active partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), and a relative sparing of platelet and fibrinogen in the very early phase (less than 30 minutes). 9 Patients with ATC often result in increased transfusion requirements, incidence of organ dysfunction, critical care unit stay, and mortality. 10 In particular, ATC is often presented with a functional reduction in clot strength with a smaller change in clotting times. 11 Increased bleeding in the early stage after trauma switch into a hypercoagulable state with a high risk of thrombosis in the following days is the main clinical trajectory. 5,12,13 The dynamic process indicates the complex and variable features of the disease.
Whether ATC is a new disease or just a disease entity similar or equal to disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) with a fibrinolytic phenotype is under intense discussion. 14,15 Gando et al have proposed the 2 diseases to be the same one due to the similar characteristics, laboratory data, time courses, and prognosis. 14 In a prospective study, Yanagida et al have shown that almost all patients with ATC overlapped patients with DIC, and the changes in the measured variables in patients with ATC coincided with those in patients with DIC. 16 However, 2 recent studies focusing on the coagulation status after trauma failed to find convincing evidence to support the unification of the 2 concepts. 17,18 Despite the higher Injury Severity Score, transfusion requirements, and mortality, none of these patients with ATC met the criteria for overt DIC. According to the general concepts, ATC is hypocoagulable both inside and outside the vessels, whereas DIC is hypercoagulable inside the vessels and hypocoagulable outside the vessels. 14 So a clear distinction of the properties of blood between the inside and the outside of vessels may provide some evidence to solve the puzzle.
At present, there are no prospectively validated diagnostic criteria for ATC. Previously, PT test (Quick value) <70% and/or platelets <100 000 μL−1 were used to categorize patients. 1 Also, Floccard et al clarified ATC (score ≥ 5) or non-ATC patients using the scoring system proposed by the International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis (ISTH), 9 which was the criterion for DIC diagnosis. However, in an epidemiology study of over 5000 patients, a prothrombin ratio (PTr) of 1.2 was found to be a clinically significant cutoff for the diagnosis, and the study disproved the often cited threshold, PTr/international normalized ratio >1.5, to be a reliable reference in 16% of the patients with ATC. 6 Davenport et al have conducted a prospective cohort study to compare the correlation between several diagnostic methods and the transfusion requirements in the 12 hours following admission, which found rotational thromboelastometry (ROTEM) can identify ATC with a threshold of clot amplitude (CA) ≤35 mm in 5 minutes and has a high detective rate of massive transfusion (MT) than that of conventional test. 7 Compared with traditional coagulation screen test, viscoelastic hemostatic assays (VHAs), such as thromboelastography (TEG) or ROTEM, assess the whole blood rather than the plasma, giving a global view of the hemostatic state. In addition, VHA can reflect the 3 different phases of cell-based hemostasis and have feature figures to different coagulopathy, including hyperfibrinolysis. 19 Therefore, VHAs have a more sensitive and comprehensive reflection of the coagulation state than that of traditional test. But a more accurate diagnostic criterion is urgently needed for the early recognition of ATC.
Mechanisms for ATC Development
The Activation of PC
Protein C is an important substance in the anticoagulation system. Normally, PC is in a nonactive state and can be converted into activated PC (aPC) by the thrombin–thrombomodulin (T–TM) complex. The aPC inhibits the extrinsic pathway by inactivating factor V and VIII. Brohi et al have proposed that the systemic anticoagulation of ATC was caused by the activation of PC. 20 They found that low PC and high TM levels were associated with poor outcomes among patients with major trauma having hypoperfusion featured by enhanced base deficit. Also, low PC level was associated with prolongation of PT, aPTT, and hyperfibrinolysis with low levels of plasminogen activator inhibitor 1 (PAI-1), suggesting the activation of PC in the ATC, although the aPC levels were not measured. In a prospective cohort study, aPC–PC ratio was used to reflect the activation of PC, and the elevated value was found to be significantly associated with the derepression of the fibrinolysis, as well as the outcomes among patients with hypoperfusion, further supporting the activation of PC. 21 In the study, a dynamic PC level was tested, showing that patients with the greatest reduction in the early 12 hours followed by no recovery or more depletion in the coming 12 hours had higher risks of ventilator-associated pneumonia or other complications. Consistent with these findings, monoclonal antibody, which inhibits the anticoagulant function of PC, pretreated mice showed an attenuated coagulopathy and relatively normal histological tissues. However, those pretreated by antibody blocking both the anticoagulant and the cytoprotective functions of aPC had much higher mortality and severe pulmonary thrombosis. 22 Besides, some venous thromboembolism occurred several hours or days after severe injury was inferred due to the exhaustion and impairment of further generation of PC. 20 Thus, PC may have a complicated role in the process of coagulation and response to trauma or shock. However, the exact mechanism of PC pathway activation, such as the trigger of PC activation and related regulatory factor need further study to be verified. Most present studies focus on the fluid phase of the hemostatic system, such as the concentration of several plasma elements, neglecting the local site changes. The activation of PC needs its interaction with 2 receptors, thrombomodulin and the endothelial PC receptor, 23 so the histological or genetic changes may need to be further validated.
The Role of Hypoperfusion, Glycocalyx, and Catecholamine
It is well known that vascular endothelium has a critical role in the normal hemostasis. Upon vessel damage or trauma, endothelium can contract and provide a binding site for platelet assembling to localize the coagulation as well as release some factors (such as von Willebrand factor [vWF] and adenosine diphosphate) to stimulate platelet. Several studies have shown a well-established association between endothelium dysfunction and the outcome in patients with sepsis, similar to ATC, which is characterized by extensive neurohumoral, inflammatory, and coagulation activation. 24,25 In the vessel lumen, the endothelium bears the endothelial glycocalyx, a 0.2- to 1-μm thick negatively charged antiadhesive and anticoagulant carbohydrate-rich surface layer that protects the endothelium and maintains the vascular barrier function. 26 –28 And a dynamic equilibrium exists between the soluble components of glycocalyx and the plasma component of blood. 29 Previously, Rehm et al have demonstrated that the ischemia/reperfusion injury during the aortic surgery can cause an immediate increase in circulating syndecan 1, a marker of endothelial glycocalyx degradation. 30 In accordance with this, Johansson et al have found that high circulating syndecan 1 is associated with inflammation, coagulopathy, and increased mortality among patients with trauma and speculated that these changes were induced by neurohumoral system activation in the early phase of trauma and would cause downstream derangements. 31 It should be noted that heparin sulfate, a major component of glycocalyx, increases simultaneously with sydecan 1 during degradation of glycocalyx. 30,31 Furthermore, a study has shown endogenous heparinization, detected by TEG, in patients with ATC appeared to be caused by the degradation of endothelial glycocalyx. 32 Taken together, the degradation of glycocalyx seemly has some relationship with the hypocoagulation state, but more convincing evidences are demanded to support this theory.
From an evolutionary prospective, Johansson et al hypothesized that the pro- and anticoagulant state of solid and fluid phase was regulated by trauma and sympathoadrenal response. 33 Tissue injury and high levels of catecholamine cause endothelium damage, glycocalyx degradation, and exposure of tissue factor and vessel collagen, resulting in a local procoagulant state. In proportional to the endothelium injury, circulating anticoagulant molecules (glycocalyx, tissue type plasminogen activator [tPA], urokinase, soluble thrombomodulin [sTM], and aPC), mainly released from the solid phase (vessel walls and tissues), increase to prevent microvascular thrombi and maintain the oxygen transport. In addition, previous study reported a dose-dependent stimulation of factor VIII, vWF, tPA, and platelets within a 15- to 40-minute infusion of epinephrine, mainly released into circulation through β2 receptor pathway, 34 suggesting a critical role of catecholamine in the coagulation process. However, the hypothesis that catecholamine modulated traumatic coagulopathy needs more experiments to validate.
Reduction in Fibrinogen and Augmented Fibrinolysis
The role of factors consumption in ATC is debated. Several studies have inconsistently identified the elevation of prothrombin fragment 1 + 2, reflecting thrombin generation in patients with ATC; however, the fibrinogen levels detected varies greatly leading to different opinions. 12,17,20,35 Martini et al have conducted a series of experiments to show deficit of fibrinogen availability in traumatic models. 36 –38 Either accelerated fibrinogen breakdown or inhibited fibrinogen synthesis, due to hemorrhage, hypothermia, or acidosis, may have contributed to the change. 39
Fibrinolysis is a key component of this coagulopathy. The magnitude of fibrinolysis, often reflected by
Sawamura et al have proposed that, in addition to tPA, neutrophil elastase was also involved in the fibrinolysis. 44 Overt high levels of neutrophil elastase as well as decreased α2-antiplasmin were detected among patients with trauma on admission. 45 Apart from reducing the 2 plasmin inhibitors, neutrophil elastase may directly degrade several clot factors including fibrinogen, causing a hyperfibrinolytic state. In addition to the primary systemic fibrinolysis (fibrinolytic activation without formation of a fibrin clot) described previously, secondary fibrinolysis also occurred in response to the deposition of fibrin. 46
Dysfunction of Platelet
The newly developed cell-based model of coagulation emphasizes the importance of platelet activation through the hemostasis process, especially in the amplification and propagation phases. 47,48 Platelet can be activated by thrombin previously generated in the TF-bearing cells via protease-activated receptor 1 (PAR1) and PAR4, 49,50 thus providing a phospholipid membrane for the formation of tenase (FVIIIa/FIXa) and prothrombinase (FVa/FXa). 47 Platelet hypofunction, defined as below-normal platelet response to agonist, can be observed in patients with trauma although the platelet count showed little differences. 51 Hyperfibrinolysis may affect the platelet function, as plasmin could cleave receptors on platelet such as glycoprotein Ib and IIb/IIIa. 52 Other combined effects of acidosis and hypothermia may also make contributions. However, the exact underlying mechanism is not clear. Besides, whether the circulating platelet studied truly reflect the “trauma-induced” platelet remains to be seen, as amounts of platelets would replenish into circulation from spleen and liver when blood loss occurs.
Participation of Inflammation
Trauma is a strong trigger of inflammation. Recent studies tend to consider coagulation as an integral part of inflammation, 53 and an increasingly close relationship may exist between the inflammation, coagulation, and fibrinolytic system. 54 In patients with severe injury or sepsis, coagulation activation may lead to a spillover release of inflammatory cytokines, which could in turn further activate systemic coagulation. 46,53 Finally, many studies have described the participation of toll-like receptors 4 (TLR4) in the acute trauma response, such as hemorrhagic shock and ischemia/reperfusion. 55 Those cells, which express TLR including monocyte/macrophages, dendritic cells, epithelium, and endothelium, are all involved in injury response, inflammation, and coagulation, 56 suggesting a complex interplay between these reactions. Therefore, inflammation may be highly involved in the onset and development of ATC process, but further research is needed to ravel the cause–effect relationship between the 2 responses.
Classic Triad Theory
Hypothermia, acidosis, and dilution are classically considered to be the 3 initiators for traumatic coagulopathy. However, recently these factors are recognized more responsible for the subsequent coagulant derangement rather than the early alteration. Mild hypothermia (35°C-33°C) can be seen in some patients with trauma as a result of environmental exposure, hypoperfusion, and cold fluid administration. 57 Previous studies have demonstrated that severe hypothermia (<33°C) could reduce coagulant factor activity (TF, FVIIa complex) and fibrinogen synthesis 58 as well as decrease platelet activation, aggregation, and adhesion, which is due to a reduced effect of vWF traction on glycoprotein Ib/IX. 5 However, the prevalence of such low temperature is low in patients with trauma. 10,57 Therefore, hypothermia alone may have a limited impact on hemostasis in patients with ATC. Acidosis can be caused by hypoperfusion. Severe acidosis (pH < 7.1) could prolong PT and aPTT 59 and inhibit thrombin generation as well as increase degradation of fibrinogen. 5,58 However, the coagulant state cannot be reversed even after correcting acidosis by buffer solution, 60 suggesting the importance of acidosis causing ATC needs to be reevaluated. Obviously, dilution contributes to coagulopathy in trauma and several studies have shown the close relationship in patients with trauma. 1,61 In the early stage, fluid administration is often small or limited in some countries, 12 thus the critical role of hemodilution in the early stage is questioned.
Treatment of ATC
As described earlier, ATC is mainly caused by trauma and trauma-induced hypoperfusion (shock). The control of the underlying disorder should come first. However, some overlaps may exist between the treatment of underlying disorders and the coagulation itself, such as bleeding control and plasma transfusion. Although many hemorrhage control products are available today, a targeted and individualized intervention can hardly be gained. Recently, damage control resuscitation has been put forward to correct ATC, which emphasizes the perfusion of vital organs without a “normal” blood pressure to reduce fluid requirement, avoiding iatrogenic hemodilution and acidosis. 62,63 However, prolonged hypotensive resuscitation may not benefit the coagulation. Doran et al have demonstrated that initial saline-based resuscitation to systolic pressures of 80 mm Hg for 60 minutes followed by resuscitation to 110 mm Hg led to attenuation of markers of ATC and systemic inflammation, improved tissue perfusion, reduced metabolic acidosis, and prolonged survival time when compared with sustained hypotensive resuscitation. 64 Thus, the resuscitation strategy for correction of ATC is not simply hypotensive resuscitation and warranted further study, especially in combination with various resuscitation fluids and blood products. Plasma, platelet, fibrinogen, and hemostatics are commonly used for the treatment of ATC, but there are few consensuses for the application.
Fresh Frozen Plasma Transfusion
Severe bleeding due to traumatic coagulopathy always requires MT, although the definition of MT is inconsistent (10+ units packed red blood cell [PRBC]/24 hours, 100% blood loss in 24 hours, etc). 65 Recently, FFP and PRBCs are widely used in practice to address ATC. High doses of FFP (10-20 mL/kg) are recommended to control the severe traumatic bleeding as soon as possible, yet there are few published evidence-based guidelines. 66 And the optimal ratios of FFP and PRBC varies (from 1:3 to 1:1) according to different researchers. 65 However, due to lack of prospective randomized controlled trials (RCTs), the true efficiency of these strategies remains to be further elucidated. Despite its frequent usage, the risks of transfusion should be noted, such as immunomodulation, nosocomial infection, even acute respiratory distress syndrome, and multiorgan failure. 13
The administration of FFP is under the consideration that the coagulation factors are impaired during ATC, regardless of consumption or loss, aiming at augmenting the concentration and capacity of clotting factors. Based on the theory of aPC pathway, when TM is presented or expressed in excess, the replenished thrombin will activate more PCs, therefore stable clot can hardly be formed. On the other hand, FFP may have a potential effect of restoring the glycocalyx and reducing endothelial inflammation and hyperpermeability, all of which may contribute to the benefits gained after FFP transfusion. 29 In fact, blood loss due to trauma or subsequent complications is inevitable, and the hemostatic condition is out of normal range, regardless of pathologically elevated fibrinolytic molecules or damaged anticoagulant substances. The replenishment of FFP could buffer the “abnormal plasma” toward a physiological and controlled state, thus correcting the ATC.
Platelet Supplement
Another commonly used hemorrhage control therapy is platelet transfusion to redress the potential platelet dysfunction or dilutional thrombocytopenia from MT, although some studies have shown that platelet count is maintained above critical levels. 67 The targeted goal of platelet level was set to be >50 × 109/L in polytrauma or >100 × 109/L in the central nervous system injury. 13,65 Several retrospective studies have shown improved results with high platelet–RBC ratio (eg, >1:5 or >1:2), 65 but others have found that platelet transfusion may not be essential. 11 The lack of convincing evidence prompts further studies on the platelet administration in patients with ATC.
Fibrinogen Administration
Although fibrinogen has shown reduction to some extent in several animal models of ATC or retrospective studies, 68,69 it is still controversial whether fibrinogen has declined to the critical level for adequate hemostasis. 11,65 One retrospective study of 252 combat-related patients who received MT has shown a better result in high concentrations fibrinogen group (≥0.2 g per unit of PRBC). 70 Restoration of fibrinogen could mitigate coagulation disorder and reduce blood loss in the animal model, but the difference was not significant between the high- and the low-dose groups on blood loss. 69 Two observational studies have demonstrated improved outcome or reduced transfusion requirements in the fibrinogen-treated group, 71,72 but the evidence is low, considering the criteria of logistic or screening test difference. Most researchers have suggested supplementation of fibrinogen concentrate (3-4 g) or cryoprecipitate (50 mg/kg) to ensure that fibrinogen level was more than 1 g/L 65 or increase fibrin-based clot strength clot firmness at 10 minutes (FIBTEM CA10) to 10 to 12 mm. 13
Recombinant Activated Factor VII and Tranexamic Acid
Recombinant activated factor VII (rFVIIa) is another resort to treat trauma-induced coagulopathy, which was first reported in 1999. 60 Incipiently, rFVIIa was approved for the treatment of bleeding in patients with hemophilia A or B. Numerous anecdotal reports have described the efficiency of rFVIIa in the treatment of ATC, 60 and an off-label usage can be commonly seen (4% or even higher). 73 In a review of 13 trials comprising 1938 patients, Stanworth demonstrated reduced blood requirement in patients receiving rFVIIa (relative risk [RR] = 0.85) with a elevated thromboembolic event (RR =1 .25). 74 D’Angelo also reported 2 doses of rFVIIa administration for patients with active ongoing hemorrhage with a high dose (100μg/kg, with shock) and low dose (50μg/kg, without shock), both resulting in favorable endings. 60 However, recently 2 large RCTs have shown few benefits and modest reduction in blood usage after rFVIIa application, 75,76 thus leading us to reconsider the efficiency and risks of the miracle drug. After analyzing data from 35 RCTs containing 4468 patients on the off-label basis, Levi et al found increased arterial thromboembolic events in patients receiving rFVIIa (5.5% vs 3.2%) than placebos, especially high among the elderly patients (>65 or 75 years), although the rates of venous thromboembolic events are comparable. 77 Reaching its peak in 2006, the usage of rFVIIa in the US military is dropping in recent years. 78
An “old” antifibrinolytic drug, tranexamic acid (TXA), is now highly recommended for the early hemorrhage control after sever trauma. By blocking the lysine-binding sites on plasminogen, TXA can reduce blood transfusion as well as blood loss without obvious complications in patients undergoing elective surgery. 79 Similarly, in patients with trauma or at risk of substantial bleeding, a multicenter trial evaluating 20 211 patients, CRASH-2, has shown reduced bleeding-caused mortality (4.9% vs 5.7%, RR = 0.85) in the TXA group treated with 2 g TXA within 8 hours. 80 In the following subgroup analysis, 81 the importance of early administration of TXA was emphasized. Treatment within 3 hours, particularly less than 1 hour, can significantly reduced the risk of death due to bleeding (RR = 0.68 within 1 hour, 0.79 for 1-3 hours). Of note, for the late administration (>3 hours) the harm of TXA would outweigh the benefits. In concert with the results of CRASH-2, a big retrospective observational study including 896 soldiers with combat injury, namely, Military application of tranexamic acid in trauma emergency resuscitation (MATTERs) study, 82 showed lower mortality in the TXA group than in the non-TXA group (17.4% vs 23.9%). The benefit was even greater among patients who need MT.
In the CRASH-2 study, however, the correlative laboratory data have not been collected, limiting the insight of the pathophysiology of TXA effect. The exact mechanism underlying the phenomenon is unclear, probably repressing fibrinolysis in the early stage and reducing uncontrolled clot factor consumption, thus lowering transfusion requirements. In fact, the TXA group showed no increase in vascular occlusive events, including pulmonary embolism and deep vein thrombosis, even after attaining a reduction in myocardial infarction (P = .035). The safety maybe was related to the dose and regime, which present the topic for future investigation. Anne Godier has innovatively hypothesized that TXA has an antithrombotic effect, via inhibition of the inflammatory effects of plasmin, on platelet and factor V and VIII. 83 Downregulation of inflammatory response may be achieved, 84 for a broad spectrum of proinflammatory responses can be induced by plasmin by binding and activating monocytes, neutrophils, platelets, and endothelial cells via a cytokines-releasing or gene transcription way. 52 In the traditional view, inflammation induced by trauma or other chronic disease could activate coagulation, reducing blood loss or even increasing the risk of thrombosis. If inflammation of ATC has been compressed, the stimulator for coagulation could be weakened in some degree. So the importance of inflammation in the ATC, especially on TXA administration, is of a new field worthy of deep exploration.
However, the potential side effect of TXA, such as thrombosis, should be noted, since the coagulant state could change into hypercoagulation in the late phase, and several cases of postoperative convulsive seizures have been reported after cardiac surgery using TXA, referring to the structural similarity between TXA and γ-aminobutyric acid. 52 Other antifibrinolytic agents, such as 6-aminocaproic acid, aprotinin and neutrophil elastase inhibitor, may have a positive role in this early situation but need further studies. 46
Summary
Acute traumatic coagulopathy is an early and complicated hemostatic derangement after trauma and has its unique dynamic course. Trauma injury and systemic hypoperfusion are the 2 possible initial drivers. The underlying mechanisms include activation of protein C, shedding of endothelial glycocalyx, catecholamine release, inflammation, platelet dysfunction, primary, and secondary fibrinolysis. Treatments should be based on the condition of patients with trauma. Early identification and treatment are essential for a positive outcome. Further studies are needed for both the mechanism and the treatment of ATC.
Footnotes
Authors’ Note
KD contributed to the conception and design of the study, literature research, and article drafting. WY and NL contributed to literature research and language assistance. All authors approved the final version that was submitted.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article: This article was supported by Grant for 12th five-year plan major project (AWS11J03), Grant for 12th five-year plan major project (WS12J001), Jiangsu Province's Key Medical Talent Program (RC2011128).
