Reliability of an Expanded Non-alcoholic Steatohepatitis Grading and Staging System for Assessment of Disease Activity and Fibrosis

Abstract

The nonalcoholic steatohepatitis clinical research network (NASH-CRN) system is commonly used for histologic assessment of disease activity and fibrosis in NASH. Despite this, the system does not fully capture the range of disease activity and fibrosis. As such, an expanded NAS (E-NAS) grading and staging system with a calculated E-NAS index was developed by our group. In this follow up study, we aim to revalidate the E-NAS system and compare its reliability to existing systems. Hematoxylin and eosin and trichrome stained sections from 40 liver biopsies were reviewed digitally by four hepatopathologists and assessed using the NASH-CRN and E-NAS systems as well as a modified Ishak fibrosis stage. The pathologist's gestalt impression of disease activity and fibrosis was scored on a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), which ranged from 0 (no activity/fibrosis) to 100 (the worst activity/fibrosis ever seen). Inter-rater reliability was assessed, and Spearman correlation coefficients were calculated. The E-NAS index had higher inter-rater agreement versus the NAS score (ICC 0.70 vs 0.61). The inter-rater agreement for ballooning in the E-NAS system was also higher at 0.67 compared to the NAS (ICC 0.60). ICCs for fibrosis were comparable between all the systems assessed (0.78 to 0.88). Finally, the calculated E-NAS index was higher with increasing stage of fibrosis compared to the NAS suggesting that it associates better with fibrosis. In summary, the E-NAS system demonstrates substantial inter-rater reliability as well as improved correlation with disease activity VAS and fibrosis compared to the NAS score.