In this study we extend previous research on the impact of constituency preferences on the roll-call behavior of senators during Supreme Court con firmations by examining the 1967 vote on Thurgood Marshall. In contrast to the later case of Clarence Thomas, we find that constituent racial characteristics (as measured by African-American percentage of state popula tion) had a significant negative impact in the Marshall case. We conclude with a discussion of the theoretical implications of these findings, and what they illuminate about the changing nature of the Southern Democratic coalition.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abraham, Henry J.1985. Justices and Presidents: A Political History of Appointments to the Supreme Court, 2d ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
2.
Ackerman, Bruce A.1988. "Transformative Appointments." Harvard Law Review101: 1164-84.
3.
Aitchison, J., and S.D. Silvey.1957. "The Generalization of Probit Analysis to the Case of Multiple Responses." Biometrika44: 131-40.
4.
Arnold, R. Douglas.1990. The Logic of Congressional Action. New Haven: Yale University Press.
5.
Baker, B.O., C.F. Hardyck, and L.F. Petrinovich .1966. "Weak Measurements vs. Strong Statistics." Educational and Psychological Measurement26: 291-306.
6.
Bass, Jack, and Walter De Vries .1976. The Transformation of Southern Politics: Social Change and Political Consequence Since 1945. New York: Basic Books.
7.
Bernstein, Robert A., and William A. Anthony .1974. "The ABM Issue in the Senate, 1968-1970: The Importance of Ideology." American Political Science Review68: 1198-1206.
8.
Black, Earl, and Merle Black.1987. Politics and Society in the South. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
9.
Black, Merle.1978. "Racial Composition of Congressional Districts and Support for Federal Voting Rights in the American South." Social Science Quarterly59: 435-50.
10.
Bland, Randall W.1973. Private Pressure on Public Law: The Legal Career of Justice ThurgoodMarshall. Port Washington, NY: Kennikat Press.
11.
Bullock, CharlesS. Iii.1985. "Congressional Roll-Call Voting in a Two-Party South." Social Science Quarterly66: 789-804.
12.
Caldeira, Gregory A.1988-89. "Commentary on Senate Confirmation of Supreme Court Justices: The Roles of Organized and Unorganized Interests." KentuckyLaw Journal77: 531-38.
13.
Cameron, Charles M., Albert D. Cover, and Jeffrey A. Segal .1990. "Senate Voting on Supreme Court Nominees: A Neoinstitutional Model." American Political Science Review84: 525-34.
14.
Daniels, William J.1978. "The Geographic Factor in Appointments to the United States Supreme Court: 1789-1976." Western Political Quarterly31: 226-37.
15.
Felice, John D., and Herbert F Weisberg .1988-89. "The Changing Importance of Ideology, Party, and Region in Confirmation of Supreme Court Nominees, 1953-1988." Kentucky Law Journal77: 509-30.
16.
Fenno, Richard F., Jr.1978. Home Style: House Members in Their Districts . Boston: Little, Brown .
17.
_ . 1982. The United States Senate: A Bicameral Perspective. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute .
18.
Fiorina, Morris P1974. Representatives, Roll Calls, and Constituencies . Lexington, MA: Heath.
19.
_ . 1977. Congress: Keystone of the Washington Establishment. New Haven: Yale University Press.
20.
Fish, Peter G.1988-1989. "Perspectives on the Selection of Federal Judges: Spite Nominations to the United States Supreme Court: Herbert C. Hoover, Owen J. Roberts, and the Politics of Presidential Vengeance in Retrospect." KentuckyLaw Journal77: 545-76.
21.
Grossman, Joel B., and Stephen L. Wasby .1972. "The Senate and Supreme Court Nominations: Some Reflections." Duke Law Journal1972: 557-91.
Hulbary, William E., and Thomas G. Walker .1980. "The Supreme Court Selection Process: Presidential Motivations and Judicial Performance." Western Political Quarterly33: 185-96.
24.
Key. V.O.1949. Southern Politics in State and Nation. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press .
25.
Labovitz, Sanford.1970. "The Assignment of Numbers to Rank Order Categories ." American Sociological Review35: 515-24.
26.
Lamis, Alexander P1990. The Two-Party South, 2d ed. New York : Oxford University Press.
27.
Lawson, Steven F1976. Black Ballots: Voting Rights in the South, 1944-1969 . New York: Columbia University Press.
28.
Lindsay, James M.1991. "Testing the Parochial Hypothesis: Congress and the Strategic Defense Initiative." Journal of Politics53: 860-76.
29.
Lively, Donald E.1986. "The Supreme Court Appointment Process: In Search of Constitutional Roles and Responsibilities." Southern California Law Review59: 551-79.
30.
McCormick, James, and Michael Black.1983. "Ideology and Senate Voting on the Panama Canal Treaty ." Legislative Studies Quarterly8: 45-63.
31.
MacDonald, Stuart Elaine, and George Rabinowitz.1987. "The Dynamics of Structural Realignment." American Political Science Review81: 775-96.
32.
Massaro, John.1990. Supremely Political: The Role of Ideology and Presidential Management in Unsuccessful Supreme Court Nominations. Albany: State University of New York Press.
33.
Mayhew, David R.1974. Congress: The Electoral Connection. New Haven: Yale University Press.
34.
Moyer, Wayne.1973. "House Voting on Defense: An Ideological Explanation ." In B. Russett and A. Stephens, eds., Military Force and American Society. New York: Harper & Row.
35.
Nagel, Robert F1990. "Advice, Consent, and Influence." Northwestern University Law Review84: 858-75.
36.
" Negroes Gain Seat on Court, Other High Offices." 1967. CQ Almanac. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.
37.
Nye, Mary Alice.1991. "The U.S. Senate and Civil Rights Roll-Call Votes ." Western Political Quarterly44: 971-86.
38.
Overby, L. Marvin.1991. "Assessing Constituency Influence: Congressional Voting on the Nuclear Freeze, 1982-1983." Legislative Studies Quarterly16: 297-312.
39.
Overby, L. Marvin, Beth M. Henschen, Michael H. Walsh, and Julie Strauss.1992. "Courting Constituents?: An Analysis of the Senate Confirmation Vote on Justice Clarence Thomas." American Political Science Review86: 997-1003.
40.
Overby, L. Marvin, and Beth M. Henschen .1994. "Race Trumps Gender?: Women, African Americans, and the Senate Confirmation of Justice Clarence Thomas ." American Politics Quarterly22: 62-73.
41.
Palmer, Jan.1983. "Senate Confirmation of Appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court." Review of Social Economy41: 152-62.
42.
Peltzman, Sam.1984. "Constituent Interest and Congressional Voting ." Journal of Law and Economics27: 181-210.
43.
Perry, Barbara A.1991. A "Representative" Supreme Court? The Impact of Race, Religion and Gender on Appointments. Westport, CT : Greenwood Press.
44.
Petrocik, John R.1987. "Realignment: New Party Coalitions and the Nationalization of the South." Journal of Politics49: 347-75.
45.
Rader, Randall R.1988-89. "The Independence of the Judiciary: A Critical Aspect of the Confirmation Process." KentuckyLaw Journal77: 767-820.
46.
Reed, Roy.1967. "Johnson Calls Nominee 'Best Qualified; and Rights Leaders Are Jubilant-Southerners Silent on Confirmation." New York Times, June 14, A1, 32.
47.
Rohde, David W, and Harold J. Spaeth .1976. Supreme Court Decision Making . San Francisco, CA: Freeman.
48.
Ross, William G.1987. "The Questions of Supreme Court Nominees at Senate Confirmation Hearings: Proposals for Accommodating the Needs of the Senate and Ameliorating the Fears of the Nominees." Tulane Law Review62: 109-74.
49.
Schmidhauser, John R.1979. Judges and Justices: The Federal Appellate Judiciary . Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
50.
Schmidhauser, John R., and Larry L. Berg.1972. The Supreme Court and Congress: Conflict and Interaction, 1945-1968. New York: Free Press.
51.
Scigliano, Robert.1971. The Supreme Court and the Presidency. New York: Free Press.
52.
Segal, Jeffrey.1987. "Senate Confirmation of Supreme Court Justices: Partisan and Institutional Politics." Journal of Politics49: 998-1015.
53.
Segal, Jeffrey A., Charles M. Cameron, and Albert D. Cover1992. "A Spatial Model of Roll Call Voting: Senators, Constituents, Presidents, and Interest Groups in Supreme Court Confirmations." American Journal of Political Science36: 96-121.
54.
Segal, Jeffrey A., Albert D. Cover, and Charles M. Cameron .1988-89. "Senate Confirmation of Supreme Court Justices: The Role of Ideology in Senate Confirmation of Supreme Court Justices." KentuckyLaw Journal77: 485-507.
55.
Segal, Jeffrey A., and Harold J. Spaeth .1986. "If a Supreme Court Vacancy Occurs, Will the Senate Confirm a Reagan Nominee?" Judicature69: 186-90.
56.
Shapiro, Catherine R., David W. Brady, Richard A. Brody, and John Ferejohn.1990. "Linking Constituency Opinion and Senate Voting Scores: A Hybrid Explanation." Legislative Studies Quarterly15: 599-622.
57.
Songer, Donald R.1979. "The Relevance of Policy Values for the Confirmation of Supreme Court Nominees." Law & Society Review13: 927-48.
58.
Sulfridge, Wayne.1980. "Ideology as a Factor in Senate Consideration of Supreme Court Nominations." Journal of Politics42: 560-67.
59.
Thomas, Martin. 1985. "Election Proximity and Senatorial Roll Call Voting." American Journal of Political Science29: 96-111.
60.
Weisberg, Herbert F, John D. Felice, Leo V Hennessy, and Steven R. Van Winkle .1992. "Senate Voting on Supreme Court Nominations Revisited: A Response to the 'Neoinstitutionalist' Perspective ." Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association.
61.
Whitby, Kenneth J., and Franklin D. Gilliam , Jr.1991. "A Longitudinal Analysis of Competing Explanations for the Transformation of Southern Congressional Politics." Journal of Politics53: 504-18.
