Core political values, which reflect abstract, prescriptive beliefs about humanity, society, and public affairs, have long been recognized as central elements in belief systems. Despite their demonstrated importance, for example, in structuring issue attitudes, evidence regarding their ability to shape partisanship is surprisingly under-examined, with limited evidence to date finding, in the United States, that partisanship structures core values, with little reciprocal influence. I reexamine this here, using panel data from the 2016-2020-2024 ANES. Overall, I find that ordinary Americans do indeed update their partisan attachments, to a substantively significant degree, in order to better align their party support with their core value orientations. I also find that this relationship is not confined to a politically sophisticated minority of the public. Importantly, I find that partisanship and values dynamically influence each other, rather than the former dominating the latter. These findings have important implications for collective understanding regarding mass belief systems, as well as for the nature and dynamics of American mass partisanship.
AbramowitzAlan I.WebsterSteven. 2016. “The Rise of Negative Partisanship and the Nationalization of US Elections in the 21st Century.” Electoral Studies41: 12–22.
2.
AchenChristopher H.BartelsLarry M.. 2016. Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government. Princeton University Press.
3.
AldrichJohn H.BaeSuhyenSaundersBailey K.. 2024. The Fundamental Voter: American Electoral Democracy, 1952-2020. Oxford University Press.
4.
AlvarezR. MichaelBrehmJohn. 2002. Hard Choices, Easy Answers: Values, Information, and American Public Opinion. Princeton University Press.
5.
BankertAlexaHuddyLeonieRosemaMartin. 2017. “Measuring Partisanship as a Social Identity in multi-party Systems.” Political Behavior39 (1): 103–32.
6.
BarberMichaelPopeJeremy C.. 2019. “Does Party Trump Ideology? Disentangling Party and Ideology in America.” American Political Science Review113 (1): 38–54.
7.
BartelsLarry M.2002. “Beyond the Running Tally: Partisan Bias in Political Perceptions.” Political Behavior24 (2): 117–150.
8.
BurdenBarry C.KlofstadCasey A.. 2005. “Affect and Cognition in Party Identification.” Political Psychology26 (6): 869–86.
9.
CampbellAngusConversePhilip E.MillerWarren E.StokesDonald E.. 1960. The American Voter. Wiley.
10.
CarseyThomas M.LaymanGeoffrey C.. 2006. “Changing Sides or Changing Minds? Party Identification and Policy Preferences in the American Electorate.” American Journal of Political Science50 (2): 464–77.
11.
ChenPhilip G.GorenPaul N.. 2016. “Operational Ideology and Party Identification: A Dynamic Model of Individual-level Change in Partisan and Ideological Predispositions.” Political Research Quarterly69 (4): 703–15.
12.
CiukDavid J.2023. “Value Disagreement and Partisan Sorting in the American Mass Public.” Political Research Quarterly76 (1): 60–74.
13.
CiukDavid J.LuptonRobert N.ThorntonJudd R.. 2018. “Values Voters: The Conditional Effect of Income on the Relationship Between Core Values and Political Attitudes and Behavior.” Political Psychology39 (4): 869–88.
14.
ClaassenChristopherTuckerPatrickSmithSteven S.. 2015. “Ideological Labels in America.” Political Behavior37 (2): 253–78.
15.
ConnorsElizabeth C.2020. “The Social Dimension of Political Values.” Political Behavior42 (3): 961–82.
16.
ConversePhilip E.1964. “The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Publics.” In Ideology and Discontent, edited by ApterDavid E., 206–61. Free Press.
17.
ConversePhilip E.2000. “Assessing the Capacity of Mass Electorates.” Annual Review of Political Science3 (1): 331–53.
18.
DanceyLoganGorenPaul. 2010. “Party Identification, Issue Attitudes, and the Dynamics of Political Debate.” American Journal of Political Science54 (3): 686–99.
19.
DyckJoshua J.SantucciJack. 2026. “Measuring Party Identification in Public Opinion Surveys of Americans.” Public Opinion Quarterly90 (1): 65–95.
20.
EllisChristopherStimsonJames A.. 2009. “Symbolic Ideology in the American Electorate.” Electoral Studies28 (3): 388–402.
21.
EndersAdam M.LuptonRobert N.. 2021. “Value Extremity Contributes to Affective Polarization in the US.” Political Science Research and Methods9 (4): 857–66.
22.
EngelhardtAndrew M.2021. “Racial Attitudes Through a Partisan Lens.” British Journal of Political Science51 (3): 1062–79.
23.
EvansGeoffreyNeundorfAnja. 2020. “Core Political Values and the long-term Shaping of Partisanship.” British Journal of Political Science50 (4): 1263–81.
24.
EvansGeoffreyPickupMark. 2010. “Reversing the Causal Arrow: The Political Conditioning of Economic Perceptions in the 2000-2004 US Presidential Election Cycle.” The Journal of Politics72 (4): 1236–1251.
25.
FeldmanStanley. 1988. “Structure and Consistency in Public Opinion: the Role of Core Beliefs and Values.” American Journal of Political Science32 (2): 416–40.
26.
FeldmanStanley. 2003. “Values, Ideology, and the Structure of Political Attitudes.” In Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology, edited by SearsDavid O.HuddyLeonie.JervisRobert, 477–508. Oxford University Press.
27.
FiorinaMorris P.1981. Retrospective Voting in American National Elections. Yale University Press.
28.
GorenPaul. 2005. “Party Identification and Core Political Values.” American Journal of Political Science49 (4): 881–96.
29.
GorenPaul. 2012. “Political Values and Political Awareness.” Critical Review24 (4): 505–25.
30.
GorenPaul. 2013. On Voter Competence. Oxford University Press.
31.
GorenPaulChappChristopher. 2017. “Moral Power: How Public Opinion on Culture War Issues Shapes Partisan Predispositions and Religious Orientations.” American Political Science Review111 (1): 110–28.
32.
GorenPaulFedericoChristopher M.KittilsonMiki Caul. 2009. “Source Cues, Partisan Identities, and Political Value Expression.” American Journal of Political Science53 (4): 805–20.
33.
GorenPaulSchoenHaraldReiflerJasonScottoThomasChittickWilliam. 2016. “A Unified Theory of Value-based Reasoning and US Public Opinion.” Political Behavior38 (4): 977–97.
34.
GorenPaulSmithBriannaMottaMatthew. 2022. “Human Values and Sophistication Interaction Theory.” Political Behavior44 (1): 49–73.
35.
GreenDonald P.PalmquistBradleySchicklerEric. 2002. Partisan Hearts and Minds: Political Parties and the Social Identities of Voters. Yale University Press.
36.
HeathAnthonyEvansGeoffreyMartinJean. 1994. “The Measurement of Core Beliefs and Values: the Development of Balanced socialist/laissez Faire and libertarian/authoritarian Scales.” British Journal of Political Science24 (1): 115–32.
37.
HetheringtonMarc J.2001. “Resurgent Mass Partisanship: the Role of Elite Polarization.” American Political Science Review95 (3): 619–31.
38.
HightonBenjaminKamCindy D.. 2011. “The long-term Dynamics of Partisanship and Issue Orientations.” The Journal of Politics73 (1): 202–15.
39.
HopkinsDaniel J.NoelHans. 2022. “Trump and the Shifting Meaning of “Conservative”: Using Activists’ Pairwise Comparisons to Measure Politicians’ Perceived Ideologies.” American Political Science Review116 (3): 1133–40.
40.
JacobyWilliam G.2006. “Value Choices and American Public Opinion.” American Journal of Political Science50 (3): 706–23.
41.
JacobyWilliam G.2014. “Is There a Culture War? Conflicting Value Structures in American Public Opinion.” American Political Science Review108 (4): 754–71.
42.
JohnstonRichard. 2006. “Party Identification: Unmoved Mover or Sum of Preferences?” Annual Review of Political Science9 (1): 329–51.
43.
JungJae-HeeCliffordScott. 2025. “Varieties of Values: Moral Values are Uniquely Divisive.” American Political Science Review119 (1): 462–78.
44.
KalmoeNathan P.2020. “Uses and Abuses of Ideology in Political Psychology.” Political Psychology41 (4): 771–93.
45.
KeeleLukeWolakJennifer. 2006. “Value Conflict and Volatility in Party Identification.” British Journal of Political Science36 (4): 671–90.
46.
KinderDonald R.KalmoeNathan P.. 2017. Neither Liberal nor Conservative: Ideological Innocence in the American Public. University of Chicago Press.
47.
KollmanKenJacksonJohn E.. 2021. Dynamic Partisanship: How and Why Voter Loyalties Change. University of Chicago Press.
48.
KollmanKenJacksonJohn E.. 2026. “Revisiting Ideology Measures in Political Surveys.” The Journal of Politics88 (1): 1–17.
49.
LauRichard R.PatelParinaFahmyDalia F.KaufmanRobert R.. 2014. “Correct Voting Across thirty-three Democracies: a Preliminary Analysis.” British Journal of Political Science44 (2): 239–59.
50.
LeeAmber Hye-YonLelkesYphtachHawkinsCarlee B.TheodoridisAlexander G.. 2022. “Negative Partisanship is Not More Prevalent than Positive Partisanship.” Nature Human Behaviour6 (7): 951–63.
51.
LenzGabriel S.2012. Follow the Leader? How Voters Respond to Politicians’ Policies and Performance. University of Chicago Press.
52.
LucasJackShefferLiorLoewenPeter JohnWalgraveStefaanSoontjensKarolinAmsalemEranBailerStefanieBrackNathalieBreunigChristianBundiPirminCoufalLindaDumontPatrickLachanceSarahPereiraMiguel M.PerssonMikaelPiletJean-BenoitRasmussenAnneSterbaMaj-BrittFr´ed´ericVarone. “Politicians’ Theories of Voting Behavior.” American Political Science Review119, no. 3 (2025): 1304–21.
53.
LuptonRobert N.McKeeSeth C.. 2020. “Dixie’s Drivers: Core Values and the Southern Republican Realignment.” The Journal of Politics82 (3): 921–36.
54.
LuptonRobert N.SinghShane P.ThorntonJudd R.. 2015. “The Moderating Impact of Social Networks on the Relationships Among Core Values, Partisanship, and Candidate Evaluations.” Political Psychology36 (4): 399–414.
55.
LuptonRobert N.SmallpageSteven M.EndersAdam M.. 2020. “Values and Political Predispositions in the Age of Polarization: Examining the Relationship Between Partisanship and Ideology in the United States, 1988-2012.” British Journal of Political Science50 (1): 241–60.
56.
MacdonaldDavid. 2023. “Core Values and Priming Effects in Electoral Campaigns.” Political Psychology44 (3): 515–30.
57.
MalkaArielLelkesYphtachSotoChristopher J.. 2019. “Are Cultural and Economic Conservatism Positively Correlated? A large-scale cross-national Test.” British Journal of Political Science49 (3): 1045–69.
58.
MasonLilliana. 2018. Uncivil Agreement: How Politics Became Our Identity. University of Chicago Press.
59.
McCannJames A.1997. “Electoral Choices and Core Value Change: The 1992 Presidential Campaign.” American Journal of Political Science41 (2): 564–83.
60.
PalmerHarvey D.1995. “Effects of Authoritarian and Libertarian Values on Conservative and Labour Party Support in Great Britain.” European Journal of Political Research27 (3): 273–92.
61.
PiurkoYuvalSchwartzShalom H.DavidovEldad. 2011. “Basic Personal Values and the Meaning of left-right Political Orientations in 20 Countries.” Political Psychology32 (4): 537–61.
62.
RokeachMilton. 1973. The Nature of Human Values. Free Press.
63.
SchicklerEricGreenDonald Philip. 1997. “The Stability of Party Identification in Western Democracies: Results from Eight Panel Surveys.” Comparative Political Studies30 (4): 450–83.
64.
SchwartzShalom H.1992. “Universals in the Content and Structure of Values: Theoretical Advances and Empirical Tests in 20 Countries.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology25: 1–65.
65.
SchwartzShalom H.CapraraGian VittorioVecchioneMichele. 2010. “Basic Personal Values, Core Political Values, and Voting: a Longitudinal Analysis.” Political Psychology31 (3): 421–52.
66.
SearingDonald D.JacobyWilliam G.TynerAndrew H.. 2019. “The Endurance of Politicians’ Values over Four Decades: a Panel Study.” American Political Science Review113 (1): 226–41.
67.
StapletonCarey E., Langehennig Stefani R. 2024. “Partisanship and Voting Behavior Reconsidered in the Age of Polarization.” Electoral Studies102752.
68.
VishwanathArjun. 2025. “The Impact of Values on Issue Stances: Evidence from Panel Studies.” British Journal of Political Science55: e50.
69.
ZingherJoshua N.2022. Political Choice in a Polarized America: How Elite Polarization Shapes Mass Behavior. Oxford University Press.
70.
ZingherJoshua N.2023. “How Educational Attainment Moderates the Recursive Relationship Between Policy Orientations and Partisanship.” American Politics Research51 (4): 480–91.
71.
ZingherJoshua N.FlynnMichael E.. 2019. “Does Polarization Affect Even the Inattentive? Assessing the Relationship Between Political Sophistication, Policy Orientations, and Elite Cues.” Electoral Studies57: 131–42.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
