Why does Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) conduct worksite raids when employers are rarely ever charged with hiring undocumented immigrant workers? This article shows how exploitative labor conditions and ICE worksite enforcement raids exist in a mutually reinforcing feedback loop that (re)produces precarity for undocumented workers. Analysis of interviews from the Immigrant Workers Project (IWP) Survey of 2018, a community-based participatory action research project in Northeast Ohio, reveals that individuals directly and indirectly impacted by ICE worksite raids understand and experience these operations within the broader context of anti-immigrant labor discrimination and worker exploitation. Although previous scholarship has theorized the role of “spectacle” in various aspects of immigration enforcement a critical analysis of media coverage, public records, and government documents shows how government agencies and the media choreograph worksite raids for maximum public spectacle. The underlying logics of this immigration enforcement tactic highlight how undocumented immigrant workers exist simultaneously as individuals whose labor is deregulated but whose presence is hyper-regulated.
164 Cong. Rec. H5198 (daily ed. June 14, 2018) (statement of Rep. Kaptur).
2.
AleazizHamed. 2018. “The number of people ICE arrested at their jobs skyrocketed.” Buzzfeed News. December 11.
3.
AlexanderMichelle. 2010. The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. New York, The New Press.
4.
AndreasPeter. 2009. Border Games: Policing the U.S.-Mexico Divide.Cornell University Press.
5.
ApostolidisPaul. 2010. Breaks in the chain: What immigrant workers can teach America about democracy.University of Minnesota Press.
6.
ArmentaAmada. 2017. Protect, serve, and deport: The rise of policing as immigration enforcement. Oakland: University of California Press.
7.
BaconDavid.2007. “The Real Political Purpose of the ICE Raids.” New America Media. March 30.
8.
BeltránCristina. 2020. Cruelty as Citizenship: How Migrant Suffering Sustains White Democracy. University of Minnesota Press.
9.
BernsteinJoanna. 2020. “After ICE: Life in a Guatemalan immigrant community in rural Ohio.” Belt Magazine. January 22.
10.
BrendesePhilip J.2014. “Borderline epidemics: Latino immigration and racial biopolitics.” Politics, Groups, and Identitiesv2(2): 168-187.
11.
BrownWendy. 2010. Walled States, Waning Sovereignty. MIT Press.
12.
ChamplinDellHakeEric. 2006. “Immigration as industrial strategy in American meatpacking.” Review of Political Economyv18(1): 49-70.
13.
ChavezLeo. 2008. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens, and the Nation.Stanford University Press.
14.
ChengYilun. 2021. “Advocates resuming in-person outreach to provide legal help for immigrant Ohio farmworkers.” The Columbus Dispatch. July 20.
15.
CorchadoAlfredo. 2020. “A Former Farmworker on American Hypocrisy.” The New York Times.May 6.
16.
CorneliusWayne. 1982. “Interviewing undocumented immigrants: Methodological reflections based on fieldwork in Mexico and the US.” International Migration Reviewv16(2): 378-411.
17.
De GenovaNicholas P.2002. “Migrant “illegality” and deportability in everyday life." Annual Review of Anthropologyv31(1): 419-447.
18.
De GenovaNicholas. 2013. “Spectacles of migrant ‘illegality’: the scene of exclusion, the obscene of inclusion.” Ethnic and Racial Studiesv36(7): 1180-1198.
19.
De LeónJason. 2015. The Land of Open Graves: Living and Dying on the Migrant Trail.University of California Press.
20.
DickersonCaitlin. 2020. “Farmworkers, Mostly Undocumented, Become ‘Essential’ During Pandemic.” The New York Times. April 10.
21.
FerriseAdam. 2018. “Canton business at center of ICE raid was fined $211,000 by OSHA for workplace safety problems.” Cleveland.com. June 25.
22.
FloresRené D.SchachterAriela. 2018. “Who are the “illegals”? The social construction of illegality in the United States.” American Sociological Reviewv83(5): 839-868.
23.
GallagherDianneShoichetCatherineHolcombeMadeline. 2019. “680 undocumented workers arrested in record-setting immigration sweep on the first day of school.” CNN. August 9.
24.
Golash-BozaTanya Maria. 2015. Immigration nation: Raids, detentions, and deportations in post-9/11 America. Routledge.
25.
Gomberg-MuñozRuth. 2012. “Inequality in a “Postracial” era: Race, immigration, and criminalization of low-wage labor.” Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Racev9(2): 339-353.
26.
Gómez CervantesAndrea. 2021. ““Looking Mexican”: indigenous and non-indigenous Latina/o immigrants and the racialization of illegality in the Midwest.” Social Problemsv68(1): 100-117.
27.
GoodmanAdam. 2020. The Deportation Machine: America’s Long History of Expelling Immigrants.Princeton University Press.
28.
GrazierSteven. 2018. “‘I didn’t realize we had so many illegals’: Massillon reacts to immigration raid at meat supplier.” The Massillon Independent. June 27.
29.
HarrisonJill LindseyLloydSarah E.. 2012. “Illegality at work: Deportability and the productive new era of immigration enforcement.” Antipodev44(2): 365-385.
30.
HerreraJuan. 2016. “Racialized illegality: The regulation of informal labor and space.” Latino Studies14(3): 320-343.
31.
HeymanJosiah. 1998. “State Effects on Labor Exploitation: The INS and Undocumented Immigrants at the Mexico–United States Border.” Critique of Anthropologyv18(2):157–180.
32.
HsuSpencer. 2008. “Immigration Raid Jars a Small Town, Critics Say Employers Should Be Targeted.” The Washington Post. May 18.
33.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2018a. “ICE worksite enforcement investigations in FY18 surge.” ICE Press Release. December 11.
34.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2018b. “Worksite enforcement targets employment law violators.” ICE Press Release. January 10.
35.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2018c. “ICE worksite enforcement investigations already double over last year.” ICE Press Release. January 10.
36.
JordanMiriam. 2019. “Trump’s Crackdown on Illegal Immigration: 11 Employers Prosecuted in the Past Year.” The New York Times. May 31.
37.
KopanTal. 2017. “ICE chief pledges quadrupling or more of workplace crackdowns.” CNN. October 17.
38.
KulishNicholasDickersonCaitlinNixonRon. 2017. “Immigration Agents Discover New Freedom to Deport Under Trump.” The New York Times. February 25.
39.
LewisHannahDwyerPeterStuartHodkinsonWaiteLouise. 2015. “Hyper-precarious lives: Migrants, work and forced labour in the Global North.” Progress in Human Geographyv39(5): 580-600.
40.
LopezWilliam D. 2022. “Immigration Worksite Raids Are Violent, Militarized, and Rooted In Racial Discrimination—and Politicians Love Them For It.” Practicing Anthropology44(1): 31-35.
41.
LopezWilliam D.CollinsKatherine M.CervantesGuadalupe R.ReynosaDalilaSalazarJulio C.NovakNicole L.. 2022. “Large-Scale Immigration Worksite Raids and Mixed-Status Families: Separation, Financial Crisis, and Family Role Rearrangement.” Family & Community Healthv45(2): 59-66.
42.
Lytle-HernándezKelly. 2010. Migra!: A History of the U.S. Border Patrol.University of California Press.
43.
MasseyDouglas S.2009. “Racial formation in theory and practice: The case of Mexicans in the United States.” Race and Social Problemsv1(1): 12-26.
MenjívarCecilia. 2021. “The racialization of “Illegality”.” Daedalusv150(2): 91-105.
46.
MenjívarCeciliaAbregoLeisy. 2012. “Legal violence: Immigration law and the lives of Central American immigrants.” American Journal of Sociologyv117(5):1380-1421.
47.
MerleRenae. 2019. “As workplace raids multiply, Trump administration charges few companies.” The Washington Post. August 9.
48.
MonfortonCeleste. 2018. “Ohio meat packing company preying on workers? Three ICE raids and hefty OSHA penalty.” The Pump Handle. June 28.
49.
MoralesDaniel Ibsen. 2009. “In Democracy's Shadow: Fences, Raids, and the Production of Migrant Illegality.” Immigration and Nationality Law Reviewv30(1): 547-614.
ParetMarcel. 2014. “Legality and Exploitation: Immigration Enforcement and the US Migrant Labor System.” Latino Studiesv12 (4): 503–526.
55.
ParetMarcelGleesonShannon. 2016. “Precarity and agency through a migration lens.” Citizenship Studiesv20(3–4): 277-294.
56.
ProvineDoris MarieDotyRoxanne Lynn. 2011. “The criminalization of immigrants as a racial project.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justicev27(3): 261-277.
57.
SampaioAnna. 2014. “Racing and gendering immigration politics: Analyzing contemporary immigration enforcement using intersectional analysis.” Politics, Groups, and Identitiesv2(2): 202-221.
58.
SampaioAnna. 2015. Terrorizing Latina/o immigrants: Race, gender, and immigration politics in the age of security. Temple University Press.
59.
ThompsonAlexander. 2020. “Working in Fear: COVID hits hard in Holmes, Stark meatpacking plants.” Wooster Daily Record. August 11.
60.
TRAC. 2019. “Few Prosecuted for Illegal Employment of Immigrants.” Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse: Syracuse University. May 30. https://trac.syr.edu/immigration/reports/559/.
61.
U.S. Congress. 2019. “Immigration Raids: Impacts and Aftermath on Mississippi Communities.” Field Hearing U. S. House of Representatives Committee on Homeland Security, November 7, Tougaloo, Mississippi (statement of Jere T. Miles, Special Agent In Charge, Homeland Security Investigations – New Orleans, U.S. Immigration And Customs Enforcement Department Of Homeland Security).
62.
ValdezInés. 2016. “Punishment, race, and the organization of US immigration exclusion.” Political Research Quarterlyv69(4): 640-654.
63.
VázquezYolanda. 2015. “Constructing crimmigration: Latino subordination in a post-racial world.” Ohio State Law Journalv76(3): 599-657.
64.
WeaverVesla M.2007. “Frontlash: Race and the development of punitive crime policy.” Studies in American Political Developmentv21(2): 230-265.
65.
WhittakerWilliam G. 2006. “Labor Practices in the Meat Packing and Poultry Processing Industry: An Overview.” Congressional Research Service Report. October 27.
66.
Zepeda-MillánChris. 2017. Latino mass mobilization: Immigration, racialization, and activism.Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
