The growth of the carceral state over the last few decades has been remarkable, with millions of Americans in prison, jail, on parole or probation. Political science explanations of this phenomenon identify partisanship as a key explanatory variable in the adoption of punitive policies; by this theory, Republicans are the driving force behind growing incarceration. This article argues this explanation is incomplete and instead emphasizes the bipartisan coalition that constructed the carceral state. I argue Democratic governors are incentivized to pursue more punitive policies to compete with Republicans when those Democrats are electorally vulnerable. I test this proposition using a series of regression discontinuity designs and find causal evidence for Democrats’ complicity in the expansion of the carceral state. Democratic governors who barely win their elections outspend and outincarcerate their Republican counterparts. This article highlights Democrats’ role as key architects in the creation of vast criminal justice institutions in the states when those Democrats are electorally vulnerable.
AlexanderMichelle. 2010. The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. New York: The New Press.
2.
AmbarSaladin M.2018. American Cicero: Mario Cuomo and the Defense of American Liberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
BarrilleauxCharlesBerkmanMichael. 2003. “Do Governors Matter? Budgeting Rules and the Politics of State Policymaking.” Political Research Quarterly56 (4): 409–17.
4.
BarrilleauxCharlesHolbrookThomasLangerLaura. 2002. “Electoral Competition, Legislative Balance, and American State Welfare Policy.” American Journal of Political Science46:415–27.
5.
BeckettKatherine. 1997. Making Crime Pay. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6.
BehrensAngelaUggenChristopherManzaJeff. 2003. “Ballot Manipulation and the ‘Menace of Negro Domination’: Racial Threat and Felon Disenfranchisement in the United States, 1850-2002.” American Journal of Sociology109 (3): 559–605.
7.
BelandLouis-PhilippeOloomiSara. 2017. “Party Affiliation and Public Spending: Evidence from US Governors.” Economic Inquiry55 (2): 982–95.
8.
BernickE. Lee. 2016. “Studying Governors over Five Decades: What We Know and Where We Need to Go?” State and Local Government Review48 (2): 132–46.
9.
BesleyTimothyPerssonTorstenSturmDaniel M.2010. “Political Competition, Policy and Growth: Theory and Evidence from the US.” The Review of Economic Studies77 (4): 1329–52.
CaldeiraGreg A.CowartAndrew T.1980. “Budgets, Institutions, and Change: Criminal Justice Policy in America.” American Journal of Political Science24:413–38.
12.
CalonicoSebastianCattaneoMatias D.FarrellMax H.TitiunikRocío. 2019. “Regression Discontinuity Designs Using Covariates.” Review of Economics and Statistics101 (3): 442–51.
13.
CalonicoSebastianCattaneoMatias D.TitiunikRocío. 2014. “Robust Data-Driven Inference in the Regression-Discontinuity Design.” The Stata Journal14 (4): 909–46.
14.
CalonicoSebastianCattaneoMatias D.TitiunikRocío. 2015. “rdrobust: An R Package for Robust Nonparametric Inference in Regression-Discontinuity Designs.” R Journal7 (1): 38–51.
15.
CampbellMichael C.2018. “Varieties of Mass Incarceration: What We Learn from State Histories.” Annual Review of Criminology1:219–34.
16.
CampbellMichael C.SchoenfeldHeather. 2013. “The Transformation of Americas Penal Order: A Historicized Political Sociology of Punishment.” American Journal of Sociology118 (5): 1375–423.
17.
Canes-WroneBrandiceMinozziWilliamReveleyJessica Bonney. 2011. “Issue Accountability and the Mass Public.” Legislative Studies Quarterly36 (1): 5–35.
18.
Canes-WroneBrandiceShottsKenneth W.2004. “The Conditional Nature of Presidential Responsiveness to Public Opinion.” American Journal of Political Science48 (4): 690–706.
19.
CattaneoMatias D.IdroboNicolasTitiunikRocío. 2019. A Practical Introduction to Regression Discontinuity Designs: Foundations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20.
CattaneoMatias D.JanssonMichaelMaXinwei. 2018. “Manipulation Testing Based on Density Discontinuity.” The Stata Journal18 (1): 234–61.
21.
CattaneoMatias D.JanssonMichaelMaXinwei. 2020. “Simple Local Polynomial Density Estimators.” Journal of the American Statistical Association115:1449–55.
22.
CaugheyDevinSekhonJasjeet S.2011. “Elections and the Regression Discontinuity Design: Lessons from Close U.S. House Races, 1942-2008.” Political Analysis19 (4): 385–408.
23.
CaugheyDevinWarshawChristopher. 2016. “The Dynamics of State Policy Liberalism, 1936-2014.” American Journal of Political Science60 (4): 899–913.
24.
CaugheyDevinXuYiqingWarshawChristopher. 2017. “Incremental Democracy: The Policy Effects of Partisan Control of State Government.” The Journal of Politics79 (4): 1342–58.
25.
De la CuestaBrandonImaiKosuke. 2016. “Misunderstandings about the Regression Discontinuity Design in the Study of Close Elections.” Annual Review of Political Science19:375–96.
26.
DilgerRobert Jay. 1998. “Does Politics Matter? Partisanship’s Impact on State Spending and Taxes, 1985-95.” State and Local Government Review30 (2): 139–44.
27.
DonnellyEllen A.2017. “The Politics of Racial Disparity Reform: Racial Inequality and Criminal Justice Policymaking in the States.” American Journal of Criminal Justice42 (1): 1–27.
28.
DynesAdam M.HolbeinJohn B.2020. “Noisy Retrospection: The Effect of Party Control on Policy Outcomes.” American Political Science Review114 (1): 237–57.
29.
EggersAndrew C.FowlerAnthonyHainmuellerJensHallAndrew B.SnyderJames M.Jr.2015. “On the Validity of the Regression Discontinuity Design for Estimating Electoral Effects: New Evidence from over 40,000 Close Races.” American Journal of Political Science59 (1): 259–74.
30.
EnnsPeter. 2016. Incarceration Nation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
31.
EriksonRobert S.FolkeOlleSnyderJames M.2015. “A Gubernatorial Helping Hand? How Governors Affect Presidential Elections.” Journal of Politics77 (2): 491–504.
GarlandDavid. 2002. The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
GelmanAndrewImbensGuido. 2019. “Why High-Order Polynomials Should not Be Used in Regression Discontinuity Designs.” Journal of Business & Economic Statistics37:447–56.
35.
GilmoreRuth. 2007. Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California. Berkeley: American Crossroads University of California Press.
36.
GottschalkMarie. 2006. The Prison and the Gallows: The Politics of Mass Incarceration in America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37.
GottschalkMarie. 2008. “Hiding in Plain Sight: American Politics and the Carceral State.” Annual Review of Political Science11 (1): 235–60.
38.
GreenbergDavid F.WestValerie. 2001. “State Prison Populations and Their Growth, 1971-1991.” Criminology39 (3): 615–53.
39.
GriffinJohn D.2006. “Electoral Competition and Democratic Responsiveness: A Defense of the Marginality Hypothesis.” The Journal of Politics68 (4): 911–21.
40.
GrosecloseTim. 2001. “A Model of Candidate Location When One Candidate Has a Valence Advantage.” American Journal of Political Science45:862–86.
41.
GrumbachJacob M.2018. “From Backwaters to Major Policymakers: Policy Polarization in the States, 1970-2014.” Perspectives on Politics16 (2): 416–35.
42.
HainmuellerJensHallAndrew B.SnyderJames M.2015. “Assessing the External Validity of Election RD Estimates: An Investigation of the Incumbency Advantage.” Journal of Politics77 (3): 707–20.
43.
HallAndrew B.2015. “What Happens When Extremists Win Primaries?” American Political Science Review109 (1): 18–42.
44.
HintonElizabeth. 2016. From the War on Poverty to the War on Crime. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
45.
HolbrookThomas M.Van DunkEmily. 1993. “Electoral Competition in the American States.” The American Political Science Review87 (4): 955–62.
46.
HolianDavid. 2004. “He’s Stealing My Issues! Clinton’s Crime Rhetoric and the Dynamics of Issue Ownership.” Political Behavior26 (2): 95–124.
47.
HurwitzJonPeffleyMark. 1997. “Public Perceptions of Race and Crime: The Role of Racial Stereotypes.” American Journal of Political Science41:375–401.
48.
HurwitzJonPeffleyMark. 2005. “Playing the Race Card in the Post-Willie Horton Era: The Impact of Racialized Code Words on Support for Punitive Crime Policy.” Public Opinion Quarterly69 (1): 99–112.
49.
ImbensGuido W.LemieuxThomas. 2008. “Regression Discontinuity Designs: A Guide to Practice.” Journal of Econometrics142 (2): 615–35.
50.
JacobsDavidCarmichaelJason T.2001. “The Politics of Punishment across Time and Space: A Pooled Time-Series Analysis of Imprisonment Rates.” Social Forces80 (1): 61–91.
51.
JacobsDavidHelmsRobert. 1999. “Collective Outbursts, Politics, and Punitive Resources: Toward a Political Sociology of Spending on Social Control.” Social Forces77 (4): 1497–523.
52.
JensenJennifer M.BeyleThad. 2003. “Of Footnotes, Missing Data, and Lessons for 50-State Data Collection: The Gubernatorial Campaign Finance Data Project, 1977-2001.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly3 (2): 203–14.
53.
JordanMarty P.GrossmannMatt. 2020. The Correlates of State Policy Project v. 2.2. East Lansing: Institute for Public Policy and Social Research.
Kohler-HausmannJulilly. 2015. “Guns and Butter: The Welfare State, the Carceral State, and the Politics of Exclusion in the Postwar United States.” Journal of American History102 (1): 87–99.
58.
KousserThadPhillipsJustin H.2012. The Power of American Governors: Winning on Budgets and Losing on Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
LeeDavid S.LemieuxThomas. 2010. “Regression Discontinuity Designs in Economics.” Journal of Economic Literature48 (2): 281–355.
61.
LeighAndrew. 2008. “Estimating the Impact of Gubernatorial Partisanship on Policy Settings and Economic Outcomes: A Regression Discontinuity Approach.” European Journal of Political Economy24 (1): 256–68.
62.
ListJohn A.SturmDaniel M.2006. “How Elections Matter: Theory and Evidence from Environmental Policy.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics121 (4): 1249–81.
63.
LynchMona. 2009. Sunbelt Justice: Arizona and the Transformation of American Punishment. Palo Alto: Critical Perspectives on Crime and Law, Stanford University Press.
McDonaldMichael.2012. “Turnout 1980-2012.” United States Election Project15:2012.
66.
MurakawaNaomi. 2014. The First Civil Right. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
67.
PercivalGarrick. 2016. Smart on Crime. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
68.
PerkinsonRobert. 2010. Texas Tough: The Rise of America’s Prison Empire. New York: Metropolitan Books.
69.
PfaffJohn. 2017. Locked in: The True Causes of Mass Incarceration—and How to Achieve Real Reform. New York: Basic Books.
70.
PhelpsMichelle S.PagerDevah. 2016. “Inequality and Punishment: A Turning Point for Mass Incarceration?” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science663 (1): 185–203.
71.
PotrafkeNiklas. 2018. “Government Ideology and Economic Policy-Making in the United States: A Survey.” Public Choice174 (1–2): 145–207.
72.
RikerWilliam H.1986. The Art of Political Manipulation. New Haven: Political Science, Yale University Press.
73.
ScheingoldStuart A.1995. “Politics, Public Policy, and Street Crime.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science539 (1): 155–68.
74.
SchlosserEric. 1998. “The Prison-Industrial Complex.” The Atlantic Monthly282 (6): 51–77.
75.
SidesJohn. 2006. “The Origins of Campaign Agendas.” British Journal of Political Science36 (3): 407–36.
76.
SimonJohnathan. 2007. Governing through Crime. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
77.
SmithKevin B.2004. “The Politics of Punishment: Evaluating Political Explanations of Incarceration Rates.” The Journal of Politics66 (3): 925–38.
78.
SpelmanWilliam. 2009. “Crime, Cash, and Limited Options: Explaining the Prison Boom.” Criminology & Public Policy8 (1): 29–77.
79.
StuckyThomas D.HeimerKarenLangJoseph B.2007. “A Bigger Piece of the Pie? State Corrections Spending and the Politics of Social Order.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency44 (1): 91–123.
80.
SulkinTracy. 2005. Issue Politics in Congress. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ThorpeRebecca U.2015. “Perverse Politics: The Persistence of Mass Imprisonment in the Twenty-First Century.” Perspectives on Politics13 (3): 618–37.
84.
TonryMichael. 2010. “The Social, Psychological, and Political Causes of Racial Disparities in the American Criminal Justice System.” Crime and Justice39 (1): 273–312.
85.
UnahIsaacCogginsElizabeth. 2013. “When Governors Speak up for Justice: Punishment Politics and Mass Incarceration in the American States.” Journal of Political Science and Public Affairs1:1–12.
86.
WacquantLoic. 2009. Punishing the Poor. Durham: Duke University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
