The importance of customer requirement management in product development has been
well-recognized in both academia and industry alike. This article provides a
comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art research in this field. Customer
requirement management entails various issues related to requirement elicitation,
analysis, and specification, as well as the requirement management process. With
respect to a holistic view of customer requirement management, key challenges and
future research directions are identified.
Tseng, M. M.
and
Piller, F. T.
(2003). The Customer Centric Enterprise: Advances in Mass
Customization and Personalization,
Springer Verlag, Berlin, New York
.
2.
McKay, A.
,
de Pennington, A.
and
Baxter, J.
(2001).
Requirements Management: A Representation Scheme for Product
, Computer-Aided Design, 33(7):
511-520
.
3.
Prasad, B.
,
Morenc, R. S.
and
Rangan, R. M.
(1993).
Information Management for Concurrent Engineering: Research Issues
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications,
1(1):
2-20
.
4.
Fiksel, J.
and
Hayes-Roth, F.
(1993).
Computer-aided Requirements Management
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications,
1(2):
83-92
.
5.
Darlington, M. J.
and
Culley, S. J.
(2002).
Current Research in the Engineering Design Requirement
, In: Proceedings of IMechE, Part B: Journal of Engineering
Manufacture, 216(3):
375-388
.
6.
Tseng, M. M.
and
Jiao, J.
(1998).
Computer-aided Requirement Management for Product Definition: A Methodology
and Implementation
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Application,
6(2):
145-160
.
7.
Tarasewich, P.
and
Nair, S. K.
(2001).
Designer-moderated Product Design
, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,
48(2):
175-188
.
8.
Yan, W.
,
Chen, C.-H.
and
Khoo, L. P.
(2002).
An Integrated Approach to the Elicitation of Customer Requirements for
Engineering Design using Picture Sorts and Fuzzy Evaluation
, AIEDAM, 16(2):
59-71
.
9.
Chen, C.-H.
,
Khoo, L. P.
and
Yan, W.
(2002a).
Web-enabled Customer-oriented Product Concept Formation via Laddering
Technique and Kohonen Association
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications,
10(4):
299-310
.
10.
Hauge, P. L.
and
Stauffer, L. A.
(1993). ELK: A Method for Eliciting Knowledge from Customers,
Design and Methodology,
ASME
, DE-Vol. 53, pp. 73-81.
11.
Yan, W.
,
Chen, C.-H.
and
Khoo, L. P.
(2001).
A Radial Basis Function Neural Network Multicultural Factors Evaluation
Engine for Product Concept Development
, Expert System, 8(5):
219-232
.
12.
Shaw, M. L. G.
and
Gaines, B. R.
(1996).
Requirements Acquisition
, Software Engineering Journal, 11(3):
149-165
.
13.
Clausing, D.
(1994). Total Quality Development: A Step-by-Step Guide to
World Class Concurrent Engineering,
ASME Press, New York
.
14.
Du, X.
,
Jiao, J.
and
Tseng, M. M.
(2003).
Identifying Customer Need Patterns for Customization and Personalization
, Integrated Manufacturing Systems,
14(5):
387-396
.
15.
Prudhomme, G.
,
Zwolinski, P.
and
Brissaud, D.
(2003).
Integrating into the Design Process the Needs of those Involved in the
Product Life-cycle
, Journal of Engineering Design, 14(3):
333-353
.
16.
Kotonya, G.
and
Sommerville, I.
(1996).
Requirements Engineering with Viewpoints
, BCS/IEE Software Engineering Journal,
11(1):
5-18
.
17.
Stauffer, L.
and
Morris, L.
(1992).
A New Program to Enhance the Development of Product Requirements
, In: NSF Design and Manufacturing Systems Conference,
Atlanta, Georgia.
18.
Kano, N.
,
Seraku, N.
,
Takahashi, F.
and
Tsuji, S.
(1984). Attractive Quality and Must-be Quality, Vol.
14(2), pp. 39-48,
The Japan Society for Quality Control, Hinshitsu
.
19.
Lancaster, G.
and
Massingham, L.
(1994). The Essentials of Marketing: Text and Cases,
McGraw-Hill, Hong Kong
.
20.
Nagamachi, M.
(1989). Kansei Engineering,
Kaibundo Publisher, Tokyo
.
21.
JSKE (2003). Japan Society of Kansei Engineering, http://www.jske.org/.
22.
Burchill, G.
and
Fine, C. H.
(1997).
Time versus Market Orientation in Product Concept Development:
Empirically-based Theory Generation
, Management Science, 43(4):
465-478
.
23.
Rugg, G.
and
McGeorge, P.
(1995).
Laddering
, Expert System, 12(4):
279-291
.
24.
Maiden, N. A. M.
and
Rugg, G.
(1996).
ACRE: Selection Methods for Requirements Acquisition
, Software Engineering Journal, 11(3):
183-192
.
25.
Turksen, I. B.
and
Willson, I. A.
(1992).
Customer Preferences Models: Fuzzy Theory Approach
, In: Proceedings of the SPIE - International Society for Optical
Engineering, Boston, MA, pp.
203-211
.
26.
Jenkins, S.
(1995). Modeling a Perfect Profile,
Marketing, London
, p. 6-6.
27.
Finch, B. J.
(1999).
Internet Discussions as a Source for Consumer Product Customer Involvement
and Quality Information: An Exploratory Study
, Journal of Operations Management,
17(22):
535-556
.
28.
Chen, C.-H.
,
Occeña, L. G.
and
Fok, S. C.
(2001).
Condense - A Concurrent Design Evaluation System for Product Design
, International Journal of Production Research,
9(3):
413-433
.
29.
Chen, C.-H.
and
Occeña, L. G.
(2000).
Knowledge Decomposition for a Product Design Blackboard Expert System
, Artificial Intelligence in Engineering,
14(1):
71-82
.
30.
Chen, C.-H.
and
Occeña, L. G.
(1999).
A Knowledge Sorting Process for a Product Design Expert System
, Expert Systems, 16(3):
170-182
.
31.
Chen, C.-H.
,
Khoo, L. P.
and
Yan, W.
(2002b).
A Strategy for Acquiring Customer Requirement Patterns using Laddering
Technique and ART2 Neural Network
, Advanced Engineering Informatics,
16(3):
229-240
.
32.
Shahin, T. M. M.
,
Andrews, P. T. J.
and
Sivaloganathan, S.
(1999).
A Design Reuse System
, In: Proceedings of IMechE, Part B, Journal of Engineering
Manufacture, 213(6):
621-627
.
33.
Jiao, J.
and
Zhang, Y.
(2005a).
Product Portfolio Identification based on Association Rule Mining
, Computer-Aided Design, 37(2):
149-172
.
34.
Karkkainen, H.
and
Elfvengren, K.
(2002).
Role of Careful Customer Need Assessment in Product Innovation Management -
Empirical Analysis
, International Journal of Production Economics,
80(1):
85-103
.
35.
Barness, J. G.
(1997).
Closeness, Strengths and Satisfaction: Examining the Nature of
Relationships Between Providers and Financial Services and their Retail Customers
, Psychol Market, 14(8):
765-790
.
36.
Curry, J.
(1991). Know Your Customers: How Customer Marketing Can
Increase Profits,
Kogan-Page, London
.
37.
Bennett, R.
(1996).
Relationship Formation and Governance in Consumer Markets: Transactional
versus Behaviorist Approach
, Journal of Marketing Management,
12(12):
417-436
.
38.
Khoo, L. P.
,
Chen, C.-H.
and
Yan, W.
(2002).
An Investigation on a Prototype Customer-oriented Information System for
Product Concept Development
, Computers in Industry, 49(2):
157-174
.
39.
Kotler, P.
(1991). Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning
Implementation and Control,
Prentice-Hall, Engelwood Cliffs
.
40.
Nielson, C. C.
(1998).
An Empirical Examination of the Role of ‘Closeness’ in
Individual Buyer-Seller Relationships
, European Journal of Marketing, 32(5/6):
441-463
.
41.
Green, P. E.
,
DeSarbo, W. S.
(1978).
Additive Decomposition of Perceptions Data via Conjoint Analysis
, Journal of Consumer Research, 5(1):
58-65
.
42.
Louviere, J.
,
Anderson, D.
,
White, J. B.
and
Eagle, T. C.
(1990).
Predicting Preferences for New Product Configurations: A High-tech Example
, In: Proceedings of the IFIP TC 7 Conference, Modeling the
Innovation: Communications, Automation and Information
Systems, Rome, Italy, pp.
53-61
.
43.
LaChance-Porter, S.
(1993).
Impact of User Focus Groups on the Design of New Products
, In: The 14th National Online Meeting, pp.
265-271
, New York.
44.
Griffin, H.
and
Hauser, J. R.
(1993).
The Voice of the Customer
, Marketing Science, 12(1):
1-27
.
45.
D’Ambrosio, J. G.
and
Birmingham, W. P.
(1995).
Preference-directed Design
, AIEDAM, 9:
219-230
.
46.
Tseng, M. M.
and
Du, X. H.
(1998).
Design by Customers for Mass Customization Products
, Annals of the CIRP, 47(1):
103-106
.
47.
Wan, J.
and
Krishnamurty, S.
(2001).
Learning-based Preference Modeling in Engineering Design Decision-making
, ASME Journal of Mechanical Design,
123(2):
191-198
.
48.
McAdams, D. A.
,
Stone, R. B.
and
Wood, K. L.
(1999).
Functional Interdependence and Product Similarity Based on Customer Needs
, Research in Engineering Design, 11(1):
1-19
.
49.
Yan, W.
,
Chen, C.-H.
and
Khoo, L. P.
(2006).
Identification of Different Demographical Customer Preferences for Product Conceptualization
, Journal of Engineering Design, 17(6)
(in press).
50.
Kwong, C. K.
and
Bai, H.
(2003).
Determining the Importance Weights for the Customer Requirements in QFD
using a Fuzzy AHP with an Extent Analysis Approach
, IIE Transactions, 35(7):
619-626
.
51.
Ho, E. S.
,
Lai, Y. J.
and
Chang, S. I.
(1999).
An Integrated Group Decision-making Approach to Quality Function Deployment
, IIE Transactions, 31(6):
553-567
.
52.
Chen, C.-H.
,
Khoo, L. P.
and
Yan, W.
(2003).
Evaluation of Multicultural Factors from Elicited Customer Requirements for
New Product Development
, Research in Engineering Design, 14(3):
119-130
.
53.
Gustafsson, A.
and
Gustafsson, N.
(1994).
Exceeding Customer Expectations
, In: The 6th Symposium on Quality Function Deployment,
Novi, MI, pp.
52-57
.
54.
Chan, L. K.
,
Kao, H. P.
,
Ng, A.
and
Wu, M. L.
(1999).
Rating the Importance of Customer Needs in Quality Function Deployment by
Fuzzy and Entropy Methods
, International Journal of Production Research,
37(11):
2499-2518
.
55.
Saaty, T. L.
(1990). The Analytic Hierarchy Process,
RWS Publications, Pittsburgh
.
56.
Akao, Y.
(1990). Quality Function Deployment: Integrating Customer
Requirements into Product Design,
Productivity Press, Cambridge, MA
.
57.
Armacost, R. T.
,
Componation, P. J.
,
Mullens, M. A.
and
Swart, W. W.
(1994).
An AHP Framework for Prioritizing Custom Requirements in QFD: An
Industrialized Housing Application
, IIE Transactions, 26(4):
72-79
.
58.
Fukuda, S.
and
Matsuura, Y.
(1993).
Prioritizing the Customer’s Requirements by AHP for Concurrent Design
, In: Proceedings of Design for Manufacturability,
DE-Vol. 52, ASME, pp.
13-19
.
59.
Zakarian, A.
and
Kusiak, A.
(1999).
Forming Teams: An Analytical Approach
, IIE Transactions, 31(1):
85-97
.
60.
Larichev, Q. I.
and
Moshkovich, H. M.
(1995).
ZAPROS-LM - A Method and System for Rank Ordering of Multiattribute Alternative
, European Journal of Operational Research,
82(3):
503-521
.
61.
Van Laarhoven, P. J. M.
and
Pedrycz, W.
(1983).
Fuzzy Extension of Saaty’s Priority Theory
, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 11(3):
229-242
.
62.
Vanegas, L. V.
and
Labib, A. W.
(2001).
A Fuzzy Quality Function Deployment (FQFD) Model for Driving Optimum Targets
, International Journal of Production Research,
39(1):
99-120
.
63.
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Popplewell, K.
and
Xie, J.
(1998).
An Intelligent Hybrid System for Customer Requirements Analysis and Product
Attribute Targets Determination
, International Journal of Production Research,
36(1):
13-34
.
64.
Rounds, K. S.
and
Cooper, J. S.
(2002).
Development of Product Design Requirements using Taxonomies of
Environmental Issues
, Research in Engineering Design, 13(2):
94-108
.
65.
Lin, J.
,
Fox, M. S.
and
Bilgic, T.
(1996).
A Requirement Ontology for Engineering Design
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications,
4(4):
279-291
.
66.
Morris, L. J.
and
Stauffer, L. A.
(1994).
A Design Taxonomy for Eliciting Customer Requirements
, In: The 16th Annual Conference on Computers and Industrial
Engineering, Pergamon, New York.
67.
Stauffer, L. A.
and
Slaughterbeck-Hyde, R. A.
(1989). The Nature of Constraints and their Effect on
Quality and Satisficing, In:
Elmaraghy, W. H.
,
Seering, W. P.
and
Ullman, D. G.
(eds), Design Theory and Methodology,
ASME, New York
.
68.
Gershenson, J. K.
and
Stauffer, L. A.
(1999a).
A Taxonomy for Design Requirements from Corporate Customers
, Research in Engineering Design, 11(2):
103-115
.
69.
Gershenson, J. A.
and
Stauffer, L. A.
(1999b).
Assessing the Usefulness of a Taxonomy of Design Requirements for Manufacturing
, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications,
7(2):
147-158
.
70.
Brahim, S. B.
,
Smith, A. E.
and
Bidanda, B.
(1993).
Relating Product Specifications and Performance Data with a Neural Network
Model for Design Improvement
, Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing,
4(6):
367-374
.
71.
Karsak, E. E.
,
Sozer, S.
and
Alptekin, S. E.
(2002).
Product Planning in Quality Function Deployment using a Combined Analytic
Network Process and Goal Programming Approach
, Computers and Industrial Engineering,
44(1):
171-190
.
72.
Yan, W.
,
Khoo, L. P.
and
Chen, C.-H.
(2005).
A QFD-enabled Product Conceptualization Approach via Design Knowledge
Hierarchy and RCE Neural Network
, Knowledge-Based Systems, 18(6):
279-293
.
73.
Mousavi, A.
,
Adl, P.
,
Rakowski, R. T.
,
Gunasekaran, A.
and
Mirnezami, N.
(2001).
Customer Optimization Route and Evaluation (CORE) for Product Design
, International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing,
14(2):
236-243
.
74.
Shoji, S.
,
Graham, A.
and
Walden, D.
(1993). A New American TQM,
Productivity Press, Portland
.
75.
Tseng, M. M.
,
Jiao, J.
,
Su, C.-J.
(1997).
A Framework of Virtual Design for Product Customization
, In: The 6th IEEE International Conference on Emerging
Technologies and Factory Automation, Los Angeles,
pp.
7-14
.
76.
Huang, G. Q.
and
Mak, K. L.
(1999).
Web-based Collaborative Conceptual Design
, Journal of Engineering Design, 10(2):
183-194
.
77.
Otto, K. N.
and
Wood, K. L.
(1998).
Product Evolution: A Reverse Engineering and Redesign Methodology
, Research in Engineering Design, 10(4):
226-243
.
78.
Chen, C.-H.
,
Khoo, L. P.
and
Yan, W.
(2005).
PDCS - A Product Definition and Customization System for Product Concept Development
, Expert Systems with Applications,
28(3):
591-602
.
79.
Prasad, B.
(1998).
Review of QFD and Related Deployment Techniques
, Journal of Manufacturing Systems,
17(3):
221-234
.
80.
Byrne, J. G.
and
Barlow, T.
(1993).
Structured Brainstorming: A Method for Collecting User Requirements
, In: Proceedings of the 37th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors
and Ergonomics Society, Seattle, WA, pp.
427-431
.
81.
Tang, J.
,
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Xu, B.
and
Wang, D.
(2002).
A New Approach to Quality Function Deployment Planning with Financial Consideration
, Computers and Operations Research,
29(1):
1447-1463
.
82.
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Tang, J.
,
Tu, P. Y.
and
Chen, Y.
(2003).
Modeling of Quality Function Deployment Planning with Resource Allocation
, Research in Engineering Design, 14(1):
247-255
.
83.
Wang, J.
(1999).
Fuzzy Outranking Approach to Prioritize Design Requirements in Quality
Function Deployment
, International Journal of Production Research,
37(4):
899-916
.
84.
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Tang, J.
,
Tu, Y.
and
Wang, D.
(2002).
Product Design Resources Optimization using a Non-linear Fuzzy Quality
Function Deployment Model
, International Journal of Production Research,
40(3):
585-599
.
85.
Karsak, E. E.
(2004).
Fuzzy Multiple Objective Programming Framework to Prioritize Design
Requirements in Quality Function Deployment
, Computers & Industrial Engineering,
47(2-3):
149-163
.
86.
Temponi, C.
,
Yen, J.
and
Tiao, W. A.
(1999).
House of Quality: A Fuzzy Logic-based Requirements Analysis
, European Journal of Operational Research,
117(2):
340-354
.
87.
Chen, Y.
,
Tang, J.
,
Fung, R. Y. K.
and
Ren, Z.
(2004).
Fuzzy Regression-based Mathematical Programming Model for Quality Function Deployment
, International Journal of Production Research,
42(5):
1009-1027
.
88.
Chan, L. K.
and
Wu, M. L.
(2002).
Quality Function Deployment: A Literature Review
, European Journal of Operational Research,
143(3):
463-497
.
89.
Wasserman, G. S.
(1993).
On How to Prioritize Design Requirements during the QFD Planning Process
, IIE Transactions, 25(3):
59-65
.
90.
Bode, J.
and
Fung, R. Y. K.
(1998).
Cost Engineering with Quality Function Deployment
, Computers and Industrial Engineering,
35(3-4):
587-590
.
91.
Ramasamy, N. R.
and
Selladurai, V.
(2004).
Fuzzy Logic Approach to Prioritize Engineering Characteristics in Quality
Function Deployment (FL-QFD)
, International Journal of Quality & Reliability
Management, 21(9):
1012-1023
.
92.
Büyüközkan, G.
,
Ertay, T.
,
Kahraman, C.
and
Ruan, D.
(2004).
Determining the Importance Weights for the Design Requirements in the House
of Quality using the Fuzzy Analytic Network Approach
, International Journal of Intelligent Systems,
19(5):
443-461
.
93.
Khoo, L. P.
and
Ho, N. C.
(1996).
Framework of a Fuzzy Quality Function Deployment System
, International Journal of Production Research,
34(2):
299-311
.
94.
Trappey, C. V.
,
Trappey, A. J. C.
and
Hwang, S.-J.
(1996).
A Computerized Quality Function Deployment Approach for Retail Services
, Computers and Industrial Engineering,
30(4):
611-622
.
95.
Masud, A. S. M.
and
Dean, E. B.
(1993).
Using Fuzzy Sets in Quality Function Deployment
, In: The 2nd Industrial Engineering Research Conference,
pp.
270-274
, LA.
96.
Kalargeros, N.
and
Gao, J. X.
(1998).
QFD: Focusing on its Simplification and Easy Computerization using Fuzzy
Logic Principles
, International Journal of Vehicle Design,
19(4):
315-325
.
97.
Park, T.
and
Kim, K.-J.
(1998).
Determination of an Optimal Set of Design Requirements using House of Quality
, Journal of Operations Management,
16(5):
569-581
.
98.
Zhou, M.
(1998).
Fuzzy Logic and Optimization Models for Implementing QFD
, Computers and Industrial Engineering,
35(1-2):
237-240
.
99.
Moskowitz, H.
and
Kim, K. J.
(1997).
QFD Optimizer: A Novice Friendly Quality Function Deployment Decision
Support System for Optimizing Product Designs
, Computers and Industrial Engineering,
32(3):
641-655
.
100.
Dawson, D.
and
Askin, R. G.
(1999).
Optimal New Product Design using Quality Function Deployment with Empirical
Value Functions
, Quality and Reliability Engineering International,
15(2):
17-32
.
101.
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Chen, Y.
,
Chen, L.
and
Tang, J.
(2005).
A Fuzzy Expected Value-based Goal Programming Model for Product Planning
using Quality Function Deployment
, Engineering Optimization, 37(6):
633-647
.
102.
Chen, S. L.
and
Tseng, M. M.
(2005).
Defining Specifications for Custom Products: A Multi-attribute Negotiation Approach
, CIRP Annals, 54(1):
159-162
.
103.
Kim, K. J.
,
Moskowitz, H.
,
Dhingra, A.
and
Evans, G.
(2000).
Fuzzy Multicriteria Models for Quality Function Deployment
, European Journal of Operational Research,
121(3):
504-518
.
104.
Harding, J. A.
,
Popplewell, K.
,
Fung, R. Y. K.
and
Omar, A. R.
(2001).
An Intelligent Information Framework Relating Customer Requirements and
Product Characteristics
, Computers in Industry, 44(1):
51-65
.
105.
Schneider, G.
and
Winters, J. P.
(2001). Applying Use Cases: A Practical Guide,
Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA
.
106.
Chen, Y.
,
Fung, R. Y. K.
and
Tang, J.
(2005).
Fuzzy Expected Value Modeling Approach for Determining Target Values of
Engineering Characteristics in QFD
, International Journal of Production Research,
43(17):
3583-3604
.
107.
Bailetti, A. J.
and
Litva, P. F.
(1995).
Integrating Customer Requirements into Product Design
, Journal of Product Innovation Management,
12(1):
3-15
.
108.
Fung, R. Y. K.
,
Chen, Y.
and
Tang, J.
(2006).
Estimating the Functional Relationships for Quality Function Deployment
under Uncertainties
, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 157(1):
98-120
.
109.
Huffman, C.
and
Kahn, B.
(1998).
Variety for Sale: Mass Customization or Mass Confusion?Journal of Retailing, 74(4):
491-513
.
110.
Michalek, J. J.
,
Feinberg, F. M.
and
Papalambros, P. Y.
(2005).
Linking Marketing and Engineering Product Design Decisions via Analytical
Target Cascading
, Journal of Product Innovation Management,
22(1):
42-62
.
111.
Jiao, J.
and
Zhang, Y.
(2005b).
Product Portfolio Planning with Customer-engineering Interaction
, IIE Transactions, 37(9):
801-814
.
112.
Jiao, J.
,
Zhang, Y.
and
Helander, M.
(2006).
A Kansei Mining System for Affective Design
, Expert Systems with Applications,
30(4):
658-673
.
113.
Von Hippel, E.
(2001).
Perspective: User Toolkits for Innovation
, Journal of Product Innovation Management,
18(4):
247-257
.
114.
Franke, N.
and
Shah, S.
(2003).
How Communities Support Innovative Activities: An Exploration of Assistance
and Sharing Among End-users
, Research Policy, 32(1):
157-178
.
115.
Tietz, R.
,
Morrison, P. D.
,
Lüthje, C.
and
Herstatt, C.
(2005).
The Process of User-innovation: A Case Study in a Consumer Goods Setting
, International Journal of Product Development,
2(4):
321-338
.
116.
Bergmann, R.
and
Cunningham, P.
(2002).
Acquiring Customers’ Requirements in Electronic Commerce
, Artificial Intelligence Review,
18(3-4):
163-193
.
117.
Blecker, T.
,
Abdelkafi, N.
,
Kreutler, G.
and
Friedrich, G.
(2004).
An Advisory System for Customers’ Objective Needs Elicitation in
Mass Customization
, In: The 4th International ICSC Symposium on Engineering of
Intelligent Systems, University of Madeira, Funchal, Portugal.
118.
Wang, H.
,
Xie, M.
and
Goh, T. N.
(1998).
A Comparative Study of the Prioritization Matrix Method and the Analytic
Hierarchy Process Technique in Quality Function Deployment
, Total Quality Management, 9(6):
421-430
.
