Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Governments across the developing world are adopting digital technologies to improve the performance of public sector supply chains. However, empirical evidence regarding the impact of these technologies on performance is mixed. In this paper, we evaluate the impact of using biometric authentication (BA) devices on the performance of India’s food security program. The program aims to deliver subsidized food grains to nearly 160 million low-income households through approximately 500,000 fair price shops (FPSs). Nearly half of those grains do not reach the beneficiaries and are diverted to the open market for private benefit. We estimate the impact of installing BA devices on reducing diversion in more than 3,300 FPSs in the Indian state of Karnataka between 2013 and 2015 using a difference-in-differences approach. We find that BA devices reduce up to 4% of the current diversion at the last mile. We argue that this relatively low impact is due to the presence of a workaround mechanism which results in imperfect monitoring and validate the decrease in diversion mechanism by estimating the differential impact of BA devices. We complement the empirical analysis with a simulation exercise to estimate the additional value that can be unlocked by using the BA devices. We find that the value of better replenishment planning using sales and inventory information captured by BA devices can be significant. The value of better planning can be as high as six times the value of reduction in diversion, depending on the preintervention levels of demand from genuine beneficiaries and diversion at the FPSs.

Keywords

Digital technology food security program public sector supply chains value of information value of monitoring

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdalla

Al-Shawarby

(2017) The Tamween Food Subsidy System in Egypt: Evolution and recent implementation reforms, The 1.5 Billion People Question, Chapter 3, World Bank Publications, Available at: https://elibrary.worldbank.org/doi/pdf/10.1596/978-1-4648-1087-9_ch3 (accessed 29 March 2024)

Alderman

Gentilini

Yemtsov

(Eds.) (2017) The 1.5 Billion People Question: Food, Vouchers, or Cash Transfers? World Bank Publications.

Alderman

Gentilini

Yemtsov

(2018) The evolution of food as social assistance, The 1.5 Billion People Question, Chapter 1, World Bank Publications. Available at: https://elibrary.worldbank.org/doi/10.1596/978-1-4648-1087-9_ch1 (accessed 29 March 2024)

Allu

Deo

Devalkar

(2019) Alternatives to Aadhaar-based biometrics in the public distribution system. Economic and Political Weekly 54(12): 31.

Angrist

Pischke

J-S

(2008) Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 221–246.

APEC (2017) Cooperation, Asia-Pacific Economic, and Better Than Cash Alliance. The role of digital payments in sustainable agriculture and food security. New York, NY, USA.: Better Than Cash Alliance.

Austin

(2013) The performance of different propensity score methods for estimating marginal hazard ratios. Statistics in Medicine 32(16): 2837–2849.

Babich

Tang

(2012) Managing opportunistic supplier product adulteration: Deferred payments, inspection, and combined mechanisms. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management 14(2): 301–314.

Barnwal

(2014) Curbing leakage in public programs with direct benefit transfers. World Bank Working Paper. Available at: https://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/826341466181741330/pdf/Barnwal-DBT-India.pdf (accessed 29 March 2024).

10.

Bertrand

Duflo

Mullainathan

(2004) How much should we trust differences-in-differences estimates? The Quarterly Journal of Economics 119(1): 249–275.

11.

Brynjolfsson

Hitt

(1996) Paradox lost? Firm-level evidence on the returns to information systems spending. Management Science 42(4): 541–558.

12.

Brynjolfsson

Yang

(1996) Information technology and productivity: A review of the literature. Advances in Computers 43: 179–214.

13.

Business Today (2016) Govt to computerise all ration shops by March 2017: Ram Vilas Paswan. Available at: https://www.businesstoday.in/current/policy/govt-to-computerise-all-ration-shops-by-march-2017-ram-vilas-paswan/story/230159.html (accessed 29 March 2024).

14.

Cachon

Fisher

(2000) Supply chain inventory management and the value of shared information. Management Science 46(8): 1032–1048.

15.

Chatfield

Kim

Harrison

, et al. (2004) The bullwhip effect–impact of stochastic lead time, information quality, and information sharing: A simulation study. Production and Operations Management 13(4): 340–353.

16.

Chatterjee

Sheoran

(2007) Vulnerable Groups in India. Mumbai, India: Centre for Enquiry into Health and Allied Themes. Available at: http://www.cehat.org/go/uploads/Hhr/vulnerable.pdf (accessed 26 July 2022).

17.

Cho

S-H

Fang

Tayur

, et al. (2019) Combating child labor: Incentives and information disclosure in global supply chains. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management 21(3): 692–711.

18.

Correspondent (2018) Ration dealers will be paid increased commission: Eatala. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Hyderabad/ration-dealers-will-be-paid-increased-commission-eatala/article23315122.ece (accessed 29 March 2024).

19.

Cui

Allon

Bassamboo

, et al. (2015) Information sharing in supply chains: An empirical and theoretical valuation. Management Science 61(11): 2803–2824.

20.

Cuttler

(2019) Mastercard and Edenred announce first biometric card trial in Mexico. Mastercard Newsroom. Available at: https://www.mastercard.com/news/press/2019/may/mastercard-and-edenred-announce-first-biometric-card-trial-in-mexico/ (accessed 29 March 2024).

21.

De Kok

Van Donselaar

van Woensel

(2008) A break-even analysis of RFID technology for inventory sensitive to shrinkage. International Journal of Production Economics 112(2): 521–531.

22.

Department of Food and Public Distribution, India (2013) Coverage and entitlement under NFSA. Available at: https://nfsa.gov.in/portal/Coverage_Entitlements_NFSA_AA (accessed 29 March 2024).

23.

Dewan

Kraemer

(2000) Information technology and productivity: Evidence from country-level data. Management Science 46(4): 548–562.

24.

Doerr

Gates

Mutty

(2006) A hybrid approach to the valuation of RFID/MEMS technology applied to ordnance inventory. International Journal of Production Economics 103(2): 726–741.

25.

Dreze

Khera

(2015) Understanding leakages in the public distribution system. Economic and Political Weekly 50(7): 39–42.

26.

Fan

Tao

Deng

, et al. (2015) Impact of RFID technology on supply chain decisions with inventory inaccuracies. International Journal of Production Economics 159: 117–125.

27.

Gaur

Giloni

Seshadri

(2005) Information sharing in a supply chain under ARMA demand. Management Science 51(6): 961–969.

28.

Gertler

Martinez

Premand

, et al. (2016) Impact Evaluation in Practice. World Bank Publications.

29.

GOK (2015) FPS/WSD statistics. Food Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs Department, Government of Karnataka. Available at: https://ahara.kar.nic.in/fcsstat/Stat˙Active˙FPS.aspx?catagory (accessed 29 March 2024).

30.

Goldfarb

Tucker

(2014) Conducting research with quasi-experiments: A guide for marketers. Rotman School of Management Working Paper (2420920).

31.

Government of India (2015) Recommendations of High Level Committee on restructuring of FCI. Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution. Available at: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=114860 (accessed 29 March 2024).

32.

Gulati

Saini

(2015) Leakages from public distribution system (PDS) and the way forward. ICRIER, Working paper. Available at: http://icrier.org/pdf/Working˙Paper˙294.pdf (accessed 29 March 2024).

33.

Huang

Song

J-S

Swinney

(2022) Managing social responsibility in multitier supply chains. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management 24(6): 2843–2862.

34.

Iacobucci

Posavac

Kardes

, et al. (2015a) The median split: Robust, refined, and revived. Journal of Consumer Psychology 25(4): 690–704.

35.

Iacobucci

Posavac

Kardes

, et al. (2015b) Toward a more nuanced understanding of the statistical properties of a median split. Journal of Consumer Psychology 25(4): 652–665.

36.

Imbens

Wooldridge

(2009) Recent developments in the econometrics of program evaluation. Journal of Economic Literature 47(1): 5–86.

37.

Kelley

(1994) Productivity and information technology: The elusive connection. Management Science 40(11): 1406–1425.

38.

Khera

(2011) Trends in diversion of grain from the public distribution system. Economic and Political Weekly, Volume 46, No.21, pages 106–114.

39.

Lakhani

(2018) Devices at ration shops in Delhi fail to recognise fingerprints, govt says no one will be turned away. Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/devices-at-ration-shops-in-delhi-fail-to-recognise-fingerprints-govt-says-no-one-will-be-turnedaway-5012156/#:˜:text=If%20the%20biometric%20machine%20does,distributed%20will%20be%20taken%20seriously. (accessed 29 March 2024).

40.

Lechner

et al. (2011) The estimation of causal effects by difference-in-difference methods. Foundations and Trends in Econometrics 4(3): 165–224.

41.

Lee

Padmanabhan

Whang

(1997) Information distortion in a supply chain: The bullwhip effect. Management Science 43(4): 546–558.

42.

Lee

Tang

(2000) The value of information sharing in a two-level supply chain. Management Science 46(5): 626–643.

43.

Lee

Cheng

Leung

(2004) Exploring the impact of RFID on supply chain dynamics. In: Proceedings of the 2004 winter simulation conference, 2004., vol. 2. IEEE, pp. 1145–1152, IBM Research division, NewYork. Available at: https://dominoweb.draco.res.ibm.com/reports/rc23284.pdf (accessed 29 March 2024)

44.

Levi

Singhvi

Zheng

(2020) Economically motivated adulteration in farming supply chains. Management Science 66(1): 209–226.

45.

Masiero

(2017) Digital governance and the reconstruction of the Indian anti-poverty system. Oxford Development Studies 45(4): 393–408.

46.

Mayer

Nickerson

Owan

(2004) Are supply and plant inspections complements or substitutes? a strategic and operational assessment of inspection practices in biotechnology. Management Science 50(8): 1064–1081.

47.

Dawande

Geng

, et al. (2016) Milking the quality test: Improving the milk supply chain under competing collection intermediaries. Management Science 62(5): 1259–1277.

48.

Dawande

Mookerjee

(2014) Improving the milk supply chain in developing countries: Analysis, insights, and recommendations. Production and Operations Management 23(7): 1098–1112.

49.

Mukherjee

(2015) 6 technological interventions to rid India of corruption. Available at: https://blog.socialcops.com/intelligence/best-practices/6-technological-interventions-rid-india-corruption (accessed 29 March 2024)

50.

Muralidharan

Niehaus

Sukhtankar

(2016) Building state capacity: Evidence from biometric smartcards in India. The American Economic Review 106(10): 2895–2929.

51.

Nagavarapu

Sekhri

(2016) Informal monitoring and enforcement mechanisms in public service delivery: Evidence from the public distribution system in India. Journal of Development Economics 121: 63–78.

52.

NCAER (2015) Evaluation study of targeted public distribution system in selected states. Available at: https://www.ncaer.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/1460106533TPDS-140316.pdf (accessed 29 March 2024).

53.

Plambeck

Taylor

(2015) Supplier evasion of a buyer’s audit: Implications for motivating supplier social and environmental responsibility. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management 18(2): 184–197.

54.

Pradhan

Rao

(2018) Gender justice and food security: The case of public distribution system in India. Progress in Development Studies 18(4): 252–266.

55.

Raghunathan

(2001) Information sharing in a supply chain: A note on its value when demand is nonstationary. Management Science 47(4): 605–610.

56.

Raju

Rampal

Bhavani

, et al., et al (2018) Introduction of millets into the public distribution system: Lessons from Karnataka. The Journal 8(2): 120–136.

57.

Rawley

Simcoe

(2013) Information technology, productivity, and asset ownership: Evidence from taxicab fleets. Organization Science 24(3): 831–845.

58.

Rekik

(2010) Inventory inaccuracies in supply chains: How can RFID improve the performance? In: Wiley Encyclopedia of Operations Research and Management Science, Wiley Online Library. Available at: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9780470400531.eorms0432 (accessed 29 March 2024).

59.

Rosamma

(2016) Machine fails to read fingerprints, 1.4cr rajasthanis go without ration. Times of India. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/Machine-fails-to-read-fingerprints-1-4cr-Rajasthanis-go-without-ration/articleshow/52948427.cms (accessed 29 March 2024).

60.

Rosenbaum

Rubin

(1983) The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika 70(1): 41–55.

61.

Rui

Lai

(2015) Sourcing with deferred payment and inspection under supplier product adulteration risk. Production and Operations Management 24(6): 934–946.

62.

Sabharwal

(2011) Caste, religion and malnutrition linkages. Economic and Political Weekly 16–18.

63.

Sachdev

(2018) Aadhaar authentication for govt services fails 12% of time: Uidai. The Quint. Available at: https://www.thequint.com/news/india/uidai-ceo-admits-aadhaar-authentication-failure-rate-12 (accessed 29 March 2024).

64.

Saha

(2015) What 13 million fake cooking-gas consumers reveal. Business Standard. Available at: https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/what-13-million-fake-cooking-gas-consumers-reveal-115032800202_1.html (accessed 29 March 2024).

65.

Santiso

(2019) Integrity tech: Three ways governments can use technology to disrupt corruption. apolitical. Available at: https://apolitical.co/solution-articles/en/integrity-tech-disrupt-corruption (accessed 29 March 2024)

66.

Saygin

(2007) Adaptive inventory management using RFID data. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 32(9–10): 1045–1051.

67.

Silveira

(2016) 4 technologies helping us to fight corruption. World Economic Forum 18: 1–7.

68.

Słoczyński

Wooldridge

(2018) A general double robustness result for estimating average treatment effects. Econometric Theory 34(1): 112–133.

69.

Smith

(2014) Case studies of RFID practices for competitive inventory management systems. In: Management Science, Logistics, and Operations Research, IGI Global Publishers, pp. 1–25. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-4506-6.ch001.

70.

Stephen

(2019) Mastercard piloting first biometric card trial in Mexico with Edenred. Biometric News. Available at: https://www.biometricupdate.com/201905/mastercard-piloting-first-biometric-card-trial-in-mexico-with-edenred (accessed 29 March 2024).

71.

Stiroh

(2001) Investing in information technology: Productivity payoffs for U.S. industries. SSRN. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=702573 (accessed 29 March 2024).

72.

The Hindu (2015) Funds for malnourished Anganwadi children diverted. The Hindu. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/bangalore/funds-for-malnourished-anganwadi-children-diverted/article6782667.ece (accessed 29 March 2024).

73.

Tilakaratna

Sooriyamudali

(2017) Food-Based Social Assistance Programs in Sri Lanka: Evolution and Transition to Cash Transfers, The 1.5 Billion People Question, Chapter 4, World Bank Publications, Available at: https://elibrary.worldbank.org/doi/pdf/10.1596/978-1-4648-1087-9_ch4 (accessed 29 March 2024)

74.

Timmer

Hastuti

Sumarto

(2017) Evolution and implementation of the Rastra program in Indonesia. Technical Report, University Library of Munich, Germany.

75.

Wickberg

(2013) Technological innovations to identify and reduce corruption, Transparency International, (s 8), CHR. Michelsen Institute. Available at: https://knowledgehub.transparency.org/assets/uploads/helpdesk/376_technological_innovations_to_identify_and_reduce_corruption.pdf (accessed 29 March 2024) .

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

1.03 MB