Efforts to eradicate human trafficking continue, with the 2017 Trafficking in Persons Report calling on governments to improve the detection and prosecution of all involved in this crime, with specific reference to recruitment agencies. Yet despite calls to examine the wider scope of potential trafficking perpetrators, an important element remains problematic; namely, establishing that all involved in the recruitment and movement of individuals possess the requisite mental element for this crime. This article examines this mental element and applies it to the different actors commonly involved in the migration and alleged trafficking of migrant domestic workers. The article concludes that establishing such experiences as human trafficking and attributing the mental element of the offense to all people in the supply chain becomes less attainable. The flexibility permitted under the United Nations Trafficking Protocol, as to the national threshold for the crime’s mens rea, has resulted in disparities as to what and who the crime of human trafficking encompasses. The specific intent element of the Protocol is at odds with the constructive knowledge element incorporated in some states, a reality that runs counter to the intentions of the Protocol’s drafters for a unified definition and jeopardizes the prosecution of trafficking cases. In rectifying this, it is pivotal for states to ensure that alternative legal provisions are available to capture those who often pave the way to migrant domestic workers’ exploitation.
Amnesty International. (2013). Exploited for profit, failed by governments: Indonesian migrant domestic workers trafficked to Hong Kong. London, England: Author.
2.
Amnesty International. (2014). My sleep is my break: Exploitation of migrant domestic workers in Qatar. London, England: Author.
AronowitzA. (2001). Smuggling and trafficking in human beings. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 9, 163–195.
5.
Australian Criminal Code Act. (1995). (No. 12).
6.
BadarM. E. (2013). The concept of mens rea in international criminal law: The case for a unified approach. Oxford, England: Hart.
7.
Belgium-Code Penal, Livre II, Titre VIII, Chapitre IIIter: de la traite des etres humains. Introduit par la loi du 10 août 2005, M.B., 2 septembre 2005.
8.
BennS. I. (1988). A theory of freedom. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
9.
BuchananA. (1985). Ethics, efficiency and the market. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefields.
10.
CasseseA. (2003). International criminal law. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
CN and V v. France ECtHR (Application No. 67724/09)1011, 2012.
13.
CN v. The United Kingdom ECtHR (Application No. 4239/08)113, 2012.
14.
Council Directive 2011/36/EU. (O.J. 2011, L101/01). On preventing and combating trafficking in human beings and protecting its victims and replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/629/JHA.
15.
Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings Explanatory Report. (2005). Council of Europe Treaty Series—No. 197. Warsaw 16V.2005.
16.
Criminal Code of Canada, RSC1985, c. C-46.
17.
Criminal Code of Slovenia. (2005). Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, Nos. 63/94, 70/94—Correction, 23/99, 40/2004 and 95/2004—Officially consolidated text.
18.
EnglundC.ViuhkoM.JokinenA.AromaaK.ResetnikovaA.MarkinaA.SoderstromU.NilsenM. (2008). The organisation of human trafficking—A study of criminal involvement in sexual exploitation in Sweden, Finland and Estonia. Stockholm, Sweden: Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention.
19.
FeinbergJ. (1988). Harmless wrongdoing: The moral limits of the criminal law. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
20.
GallagherA. T. (2010). The international law of human trafficking. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Harroff-TavelH.NasriA. (2013). Tricked and trapped: Human trafficking in the Middle East. Beirut, Lebanon: ILO.
23.
HillJ. L. (1994). Exploitation. Cornell Law Review, 79, 631–699.
24.
HonderichT. (Ed.) (1995). The Oxford companion to philosophy (2nd ed.). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
25.
Human Rights Watch. (2006). Swept under the rug: Abuses against domestic workers around the world. New York, NY: Author.
26.
Human Rights Watch. (2014a). “I already bought you”: Abuse and exploitation of female migrant domestic workers in the United Arab Emirates. New York, NY: Author.
27.
Human Rights Watch. (2014b). Hidden away: Abuses against migrant domestic workers in the UK. New York, NY: Author.
28.
Human Rights Watch. (2016). I was sold—Abuse and exploitation of migrant domestic workers in Oman. New York, NY: Author.
International Labor Organization Convention Concerning Forced or Compulsory Labour, No. 29. (1930). Adopted June 28, 1930, 14th ILC Session, entered into force May 1, 1932.
31.
International Labor Organization Convention Concerning Migration for Employment (Revised) No. 97. Adopted July 1, 1949, 32nd ILC Session, entered into force January 22, 1952.
32.
International Labor Organization Convention Concerning Private Employment Agencies, No. 181. Adopted June 19, 1997, 85th ILC Session, entered into force May 10, 2000.
33.
International Labor Organization Protocol of 2014 to the Forced Labor Convention. (1930). Adopted June, 11 2014, 103rd ILC Session, entered into force November 9, 2016.
34.
International Labor Conference (96th Session) Report III (Part 1B) General Survey concerning the Forced Labour Convention, 1930(No. 29), and the Abolition of Forced Labour Convention, 1957 (No. 105) (ILO, Geneva 2007).
35.
International Labor Office. (2005). A global alliance against forced labour: Global report under the follow-up to the ILO declaration on fundamental principles and rights at work. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
International Organization for Migration. (2005). Fertile fields: Trafficking in persons in central Asia. Vienna, Austria: Author.
43.
J. and others v Austria ECtHR(App No. 58216/12). January 17, 2017.
44.
JureidiniR. (2010). Trafficking and contract migrant workers in the Middle East. International Migration, 48, 142–163.
45.
JureidiniR. (2016). Ways forward in recruitment of “low-skilled” migrant workers in the Asia-Arab States Corridor. Beirut, Lebanon: ILO.
46.
Labor Code of the Philippines, Presidential Decree No 442, as amended.
47.
MartinP. (2017). Merchants of labour. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
48.
MarxK. (1990). Capital: A critique of political economy. London, England: Penguin Books.
49.
National Police Commission, Republic of the Philippines. (1999). Trafficking in human beings from the Philippines: A survey of government experts and law enforcement case files. UN global programme against trafficking in human beings: Coalitions against trafficking in human beings in the Philippines—Phase 1. Vienna, Austria: United Nations Global Programme Against Trafficking in Human Beings.
50.
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe Office of the Special Representative and Co-ordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings. (2010). Unprotected work, invisible exploitation: Trafficking for the purpose of domestic servitude. Vienna, Austria: Author.
PiperN. (2005). A problem by a different name? A review of research on trafficking in South-East Asia and Oceania. International Migration, 43, 203–233.
53.
Philippine Overseas Employment Administration. (2002). Rules and regulations governing the recruitment and employment of land-based overseas workers.
54.
Prosecutor v. Jean-Paul Akayesu, Trial Judgment. Case No. ICTR-96-4-T. September 2, 1998.
55.
Protocol Against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea and Air, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. (2000). Adopted November 15, 2000, entered into force January 28, 2004. 241 UNTS 507.
56.
Regina v. G and Another [2003] UKHL 50, [2004] 1 A.C. 1034.
57.
Report of the International Law Commission on the Work of its Forty-Eighth Session. May 6 to July 26, 1996, Official Records of the General Assembly. UN Doc. A/51/10.
Roper v. Taylor’s Central Garages (Exeter) Ltd. [1951] 2T.L.R. 2T.L.R.”
60.
Sansregret v. The Queen. (1985). 1 SCR 570.
61.
Siliadin v. France ECtHR(App No. 77316/01)July 26, 2005.
62.
StoyanovaV. (2017). Human trafficking and slavery reconsidered: Conceptual limits and states’ positive obligations in European law. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
63.
The Law Commission. (1989). A criminal code for England and Wales (Vol. 1). Report and Draft Criminal Code Bill (House of Commons, 1989) Law Com. No. 177.
UN Committee on the Protection of the Rights of all Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families. (2011). General Comment No. 1 on Migrant Domestic Workers. UN Doc CMW/C/GC/1.
67.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2004). Legislative guides for the implementation of the United Nations convention against transnational organized crime and the protocols thereto. UN Sales No. 05.v.2. Part 2.
68.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2006). Travaux Préparatoires of the negotiations for the elaboration of the United Nations convention against transnational organized crime and the protocols thereto. New York, NY: United Nations. Sales No. E.06.V.5.
69.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2009a). Anti-human trafficking manual for criminal justice practitioners—Module 1: Definitions of trafficking in persons and smuggling of migrants. New York, NY: United Nations.
70.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2009b). Model law against trafficking in persons. Vienna, Austria: United Nations. UN Sales No. E.09.V.11, 11.
71.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2013). Abuse of a position of vulnerability and other “means” within the definition of trafficking in persons. New York, NY: Author.
72.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2015a). The role of recruitment fees and abusive and fraudulent recruitment practices of recruitment agencies in trafficking in persons. Vienna, Austria: United Nations.
73.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2015b). The concept of ‘exploitation’ in the trafficking in persons protocol. Vienna, Austria: Author.
74.
UN Office on Drugs and Crime. (2016). Global report on trafficking in persons. New York, NY: United Nations.
75.
UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, Supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. (2000). UN Doc. A/55/383.
76.
UN Human Rights Council. (2010). Report of the Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Slavery, Including its Causes and Consequences, Gulnara Shahiniaa. UN Doc. A/HRC/15/20.
77.
UN Human Rights Council. (2014). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants, François Crépeau, Addendum: Mission to Qatar. UN Doc. A/HRC/26/35/Add.1.
78.
United States v. Askarkhodjaev, No. 4:09-CR-00143(W.D. Mo. May 27, 2009).
