The More Divided Academy: Did the Fall of the Faculty and the Rise of the All-Administrative University Increase Racial Conflict in Higher Education?

Abstract

Despite efforts to redress racial grievances, American’s most progressive institutional sector, higher education, suffers racial incidents with disturbing frequency. We hypothesize that one explanation lies in the bureaucratization of higher education. Various trends have led to what Benjamin Ginsberg calls “the fall of the faculty” and “the all-administrative university.” We hypothesize that insulated from students and responsive to national employment markets, administrators adopt policies promoting the short-term appearance of successful integration, and driven by ideology. Faculty, in contrast, may focus on long-term student well-being, acknowledging policy tradeoffs. Using the North American Academic Survey Study (n = 1,643 faculty and 808 administrators), we construct statistical models of attitudes toward race-based undergraduate admissions and faculty hiring. Contrary to predictions, both faculty and administrators offer nuanced support for affirmative action acknowledging potential tradeoffs. Further, ideology better explains faculty than administrator support. Implications are discussed.

Keywords

higher education race affirmative action race relations higher education administration

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aberbach

J. D.

Putnam

R. D.

Rockman

B. A

. (1981). Bureaucrats and politicians in Western democracies. Harvard University Press.

Alhejji

Garavan

Carbery

O’Brien

McGuire

. (2016). Diversity training programme outcomes: A systematic review. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 27(1), 95–149.doi:10.1002/hrdq.21221

Armstrong

E. A.

Hamilton

L. T

. (2013). Paying for the party. Harvard University Press.

Arum

Roksa

. (2011). Academically adrift. University of Chicago Press.

Arum

Roksa

. (2014). Aspiring adults adrift. University of Chicago Press.

Balch

S. H

. (2009). The route to academic pluralism. In Maranto

Redding

R. E.

Hess

F. M.

(Eds.), The politically correct university (pp. 227–240). AEI.

Bregman

(2012). Diversity Training Doesn’t Work. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2012/03/diversity-training-doesnt-work.

Brennan

Magness

. (2019). Cracks in the ivory tower. Oxford University Press.

Campbell

D. T

. (1979). Assessing the impact of planned social change. Evaluation and Program Planning, 2(1), 67–90.doi:10.1016/0149-7189(79)90048-X

10.

Carter

S. L

. (1991). Reflections of an affirmative action baby. Basic Books.

11.

Chatelain

. (2017). How Universities embolden white nationalists. The Chronicle of Higher Education. http://www.chronicle.com/article/How-Universities-Embolden/240956.

12.

Chenoweth

(2007). African American college presidents in decline. Diverse Education, 2017. http://diverseeducation.com/article/8499/.

13.

Chua

. (2018). Political tribes. Penguin Press.

14.

Cross

J. G.

Goldenberg

E. N

. (2009). Off-track profs: Nontenured teachers in higher education. MIT Press.

15.

Dawson

M. C

. (1994). Behind the mule: Race and class in african-american politics. Princeton University Press.

16.

DiAngelo

. (2016). What does it mean to be white? Peter Lang.

17.

Downs

. (1967). Inside bureaucracy. Little Brown.

18.

Eligon

(2015). At University of Missouri, black students see a campus riven by race. New York Times, 2015. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/12/us/university-of-missouri-protests.html.

19.

Follett

M. P

. (1926). The giving of orders. In Shafritz

J. M.

Steve Ott

(Eds.), Classics of organization theory (3rd ed., pp. 150–158). Brooks/Cole.

20.

Frisby

C. L.

O’Donohue

W. T

. (2018). Cultural competence in applied psychology. Springer.

21.

Gaventa

. (1980). Power and powerlessness. University of Illinois Press.

22.

Ginsburg

. (2011). The fall of the faculty: The rise of the all-administrative university and why it matters. Oxford University Press.

23.

Golembiewski

R. T

. (1995). Managing diversity in organizations. University of Alabama Press.

24.

Greene

J. P

. (2010). Administrative Bloat at American Universities. Goldwater Institute Policy Report. http://goldwaterinstitute.org/en/work/topics/education/education-spending/administrative-bloat-at-american-universities-the-/.

25.

Haidt

. (2012). The righteous mind. Simon and Schuster.

26.

Hess

F. M

. (1999). Spinning wheels. Brookings Institution.

27.

Kinder

D. R.

Kam

C. D

. (2009). Us against them: Ethnocentric foundations of American opinion. University of Chicago Press.

28.

Knott

J. H.

Miller

G. J

. (1987). Reforming bureaucracy. Prentice Hall.

29.

Ledbetter

. (2011). Unwarranted influence: Dwight d. Eisenhower and the military-industrial complex. Yale University Press.

30.

Levine

. (2005). Worlds apart: Disconnects between students and their colleges. In R. H. Hersh, Merrow (Eds.), Declining by degree: Higher education at risk (pp. 155–168). Palgrave/Macmillan.

31.

Levine

. (2011). Private-college presidents getting higher salaries. New York Times, A17.

32.

Levine

. (2014). Colleges increasing spending on sports faster than on academics, report finds. New York Times, A12.

33.

Lewis

D. E

. (2008). The politics of presidential appointments: Political control and bureaucratic performance. Princeton University Press.

34.

Lipsky

. (1980). Street level bureaucracy. Russell Sage Foundation.

35.

Lukianoff

. (2014). Unlearning liberty. Encounter Books.

36.

Lukianoff

Haidt

. (2018). The coddling of the american mind. Penguin Press.

37.

Maranto

. (1993). Politics and bureaucracy in the modern presidency. Greenwood.

38.

Maranto

(2016). Separate and unequal: Why do our most progressive institutions have lousy race relations? Inside Higher Education. https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2016/12/19/why-even-our-most-progressive-institutions-have-lousy-race-relations-essay.

39.

Maranto

. (2005). Beyond a government of strangers. Lexington Books.

40.

Maranto

Wolf

P. J

. (2013). Cops, teachers, and the art of the impossible: Explaining the lack of diffusion of innovations that make impossible jobs possible. Public Administration Review, 73(2), 230–240.doi:10.1111/j.1540-6210.2012.02626.x

41.

Maranto

Redding

R. E.

Hess edited

F. M

. (2009). The politically correct university: Problems, scope, and reforms. American Enterprise Institute.

42.

Moskos

C. C.

Butler

J. S

. (1996). All we can be: Black leadership and racial integration the army way. Basic Books.

43.

Myrdal

. (2008). An american dilemma. Transaction Publishers.

44.

Ostrom

. (1974). The intellectual crisis in american public administration. University of Alabama Press.

45.

Perrow

. (1979). Complex organizations (2nd ed.). Scott, Foresman and Company.

46.

Professor

. (2012). In the basement of the ivory tower: The truth about college. Penguin.

47.

Reeves

Halikias

. (2017). Illiberal arts colleges: Pay more, get less (free speech). Brookings Institution, March 14. https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/illiberal-arts-colleges-pay-more-get-less-free-speech/

48.

Rothman

Kelly-Woessner

Woessner

. (2011). The still divided academy. Rowman and Littlefield.

49.

Rothman

Nagai

withA.

Maranto

Woessner

M. C.

Rothman

. (2016). The end of the experiment. Transaction Press.

50.

Sander

Taylor

. (2012). Mismatch. Basic Books.

51.

Saul

(2016). Campuses cautiously train freshman against subtle insults. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/07/us/campuses-cautiously-train-freshmen-against-subtle-insults.html.

52.

Scott

J. C

. (1998). Seeing like a state. Yale University Press.

53.

Smith

R. M

. (2015). Political science and the public sphere today. Perspectives on Politics, 13(2), 366–376.doi:10.1017/S1537592715000225

54.

Sowell

. (1972). Black education: Myths and tragedies. McKay.

55.

Sumter

(2017). Protests erupt over racism at Evergreen State College. USA Today. http://college.usatoday.com/2017/05/30/protests-erupt-over-racism-at-evergreen-state-college/.

56.

Teodoro

M. P

. (2011). Bureaucratic ambition. Johns Hopkins University Press.

57.

Trachtenberg

S. J

. (2012). Squeezing the ivory tower. Cato Letter, 10(2), 1–5.

58.

Warikoo

N. K

. (2016). The diversity bargain. University of Chicago Press.

59.

Washington Monthly editors . (2013). Introduction: A different kind of college ranking. Washington Monthly, 45(9/10), 17–20.

60.

Whittington

. (2018). Speak freely. Princeton University Press.

61.

Wilson

J. Q

. (1989). Bureaucracy. Basic Books.

62.

Wood

. (2009). College conformity 101: Where the diversity of ideas meets the idea of diversity. In Maranto

Redding

R. E.

Hess

F. M.

(Eds.), The politically correct university (pp. 121–137). AEI.

63.

Zimmerman

. (2016). Campus politics: What everyone needs to know. Oxford University Press.