For decades, scholars and politicians have debated the likely impacts of school choice. Yet few have studied the nation's largest state-level charter school market, Arizona, whose 20-year-old charter sector accounts for about 17% of Arizona public school enrollment. This article summarizes the extant literature on this market, some 23 studies, supplemented with original fieldwork to derive tentative lessons for social scientists and policymakers. While the charter sector seems to have promoted innovation, teacher and parent empowerment, and modest improvement in traditional public schools, findings regarding student learning and segregation are less clear.
BatdorffM., MaloneyL., MayJ., SpeakmanS., WolfP., ChengA. (2014). Charter school funding: Inequity expands.Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Department of Education Reform at http://www.uaedreform.org/research-reports/
2.
BerendsM., SpringerM., BallouD., WalbergH. (2009). Handbook of research on school choice.Philadelphia: Routledge.
3.
BerendsM., CannataM., & GoldringE. (2011). School choice and school improvement.Cambridge: Harvard Education Press.
4.
BettsJ. R., & HillP. (Eds.) (2010). Taking measure of charter schools.Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Education.
5.
BuckS., & MarantoR. (2011). School choice. In QuirkP., & CunionW. (Eds.) Governing America: Major policies and decisions of federal, state, and local government (pp. 509–513). New York: Facts on File.
6.
BuckleyJ., & SchneiderM. (2007). Charter schools: Hope or hype?Princeton: Princeton University Press.
7.
CampbellD. (2001). Making democratic education work. In PetersonP., & CampbellD. (Eds.) Charters, vouchers, and public education (pp. 241–267). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
FinnC. E., MannoB. V., & WrightB. L. (2016). Charter schools at the crossroads.Cambridge: Harvard Education Press.
17.
FoxR. A., & BuchananN. K. (Eds.). (2014). Proud to be different: Ethnocentric Niche charter schools in America.Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Education.
18.
FriedmanM. (1962). Capitalism and freedom.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
19.
GarciaD. R. (2008). The impact of school choice on racial segregation in charter schools. Educational Policy, 22(6), 805–829.
20.
GarciaD. R. (2010). Charter schools challenge traditional notions of segregation. In LubienskiC., & WeitzelP. (Eds.), The charter school idea: Two decades of evidence and implications.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
21.
GarciaD.R., McIlroyL., & BarberR. (2008). Starting behind: A comparative analysis of the academic standing of students entering charter schools. Social Science Quarterly, 89(1), 199–216.
22.
GarciaD. R., DongH., McIlroyL., & AckmanE. (In Press). The importance of student reenrollment: Toward a reconceptualization of school quality in a maturing education marketplace.
GlassG. V. (2008). Fertilizers, pills, and magnetic strips.Charlotte: Information Age Publishing.
25.
GreeneJ. P. (2005). Education myths.Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.
26.
GreeneJ. P., & KingsburyI. (2017). The relationship between public and private schooling and anti-semitism. Journal of School Choice, 11(1), 111–130.
27.
GreshamA., HessF., MarantoR., & MillimanS. (2000). The wild west of education reform: Arizona charter schools. Phi Delta Kappan, 81(10), 751–757.
28.
HessF. M. (2017). Letters to a young education reformer.Cambridge: Harvard Education Press.
29.
HessF. M., MarantoR., & MillimanS. (2001a). Coping with competition: The impact of charter schooling on public school outreach in Arizona. Policy Studies Journal, 29(3), 388–404.
30.
HessF., MarantoR., & MillimanS. (2001b). Small districts in big trouble: How four Arizona school districts coped with charter competition. Teachers College Record, 103(6), 1102–1124.
HornJ. (2011). Corporatism, KIPP, and Cultural eugenics. In KovacsP.E. (ed). The gates foundation and the future of U.S. “Public” schools (pp. 80–103). New York: Routledge.
33.
HoxbyC. (2003). School choice and school productivity (or could school choice be a tide that lifts all boats?). NBER Working Paper No. 8873.
34.
HoxbyC. M. (2004). Achievement in charter schools and regular public schools in the United States: Understanding the differences.Harvard University and the National Bureau of Economic Research.
35.
LindblomC. E., & CohenD. K. (1979). Usable knowledge: Social science and problem solving.New Haven: Yale University Press.
36.
LovelessT. (1999). The tracking wars.Washington: The Brookings Institution.
37.
MarantoR. (2015, January). Did the teachers destroy the school? Public entrepreneurship as creation and adaptation. Journal of School Leadership, 25(1), 69–101.
38.
MarantoR., & MarantoA. (2006). Markets, bureaucracies, and clans: The role of organization culture. In HessF. (Ed.) Educational entrepreneurship: Realities, challenges, possibilities (pp. 145–164). Cambridge: Harvard Education Press.
39.
MarantoR., MillimanS., HessF., & GreshamA. (Eds.) (2001). School choice in the real world: Lessons from Arizona charter schools.Boulder: Westview.
40.
MarantoR., MillimanS. R., & HessF. M. (2010, April–June). How traditional public schools respond to competition: The mitigating role of organization culture. Journal of School Choice, 4(2), 113–136.
41.
MarantoR., VasileA., & ShakeelD. (2015). Does school mission matter? An Arizona test. Presented at the annual American Education Finance and Policy meeting in Washington, February 27.
42.
MarantoR., McShaneM. Q., & RhinesmithE. (2016). Education reform in the Obama Era: The second term and the 2016 election.New York: Palgrave/Macmillan Pivot.
43.
McDermottK. (1999). Controlling public education: Localism versus equity.Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.
44.
MillimanS. R. (2016). Charter schools, enrollment size, and educational accountability: A preliminary Arizona analysis. Journal of School Choice, 10(1), 73–95.
45.
MillimanS.R., MarantoR., & GreshamA. (2004). Does school choice segregate or integrate public schools? Arizona charter schools as a test case. Journal of Public Management and Social Policy, 8(2), 1–22.
MironG., WelnerK., HincheyP., & MathisW. (Eds.) (2012). Exploring the school choice universe: Evidence and recommendations.Charlotte: Information Age Publishing.
48.
MohmeG. M. (2017). Somali-Swedes' reasons for choosing a Muslim-profiled school—Recognition and educational ambitions as important influencing factors. Journal of School Choice, 11(2), 239–257
49.
MulhollandL. (1999). Arizona charter school progress evaluation.Phoenix: Morrison Institute for Public Policy, Arizona University Press.
50.
RavitchD. (2010). The death and life of the Great American school system.New York: Basic Books.
51.
RofesE., & StulbergL. (Eds.) (2004). The emancipatory promise of charter schools.Albany: State University of New York Press.
52.
SolmonL. C. (1999). Findings from the 1999 survey of parents with children in Arizona charter schools.Santa Monica: Human Resources Police Corporation.
53.
SolmonL. C. (2003). Findings from the 2002 survey of parents with children in Arizona charter schools.Santa Monica: Human Resources Police Corporation.
54.
StewartT., & WolfP. (2014). The school choice journey.New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
ThernstromA., & ThernstromS. (2003). No excuses: Closing the racial gap in learning.New York: Simon & Schuster.
57.
UludagA., GochiyevP., BaharK., & KorkmazA. (In press). The estimated effect of charter schooling on educational outcomes: Overcoming apples to oranges comparisons. Also presented at the 2013 AERA annual conference in Philadelphia.
58.
ValleJ. W. (2009). What mothers say about special education.New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
59.
WellsA. S. (1993). Time to choose.New York: Hill and Wang.
60.
WilderT., & JacobsenR. (2010). The short supply of saints: Limits on replication of models that “Beat the Odds.”Reading & Writing Quarterly, 26, 23–63.
61.
WintersM. A. (2015, May). Understanding the gap in special education enrollments between charter and traditional public schools. Educational Researcher, 44(4), 228–236.
62.
WohlstetterP., SmithJ., & FarrellC. C. (2013). Choices and challenges: Charter school performance in perspective.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
63.
WolfP. (2005). School choice and civic values. In BettsJ., & LovelessT. (Eds.) Getting choice right: Ensuring equity and efficiency in education policy (pp. 210–244). Washington: Brookings.
