Critical thinking is widely regarded as a crucial capability for competent management and also for any leadership role in society. In this article, we ask, “How do textbooks play a role in the weakness of many management graduates’ critical thinking skills?” Management teachers can find plentiful advice about best teaching practices, yet the critical skills gap remains. We argue that the nature and use of management textbooks intersect and interact with students’ epistemology to support a culture of surface learning, resulting in a failure to develop critical thinking skills. Textbooks reinforce underdeveloped student epistemology through limitations of content and position students as passive recipients of an authoritative version of oversimplified knowledge. In our survey of 30 successful management textbooks, we found the majority of popular management textbooks potentially inhibit, or only weakly support, the development of students’ capacity for critical thinking. The article concludes with suggestions for improving textbooks and textbook choice or considering alternatives.
AndersonT. H.ArmbrusterB. B. (1985). Studying strategies and their implications for textbook design. In DuffyT. M.WallerR. (Eds.), Designing usable texts (pp. 159-177). Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
4.
AnthonyP. D. (1986). The foundation of management. London, England: Tavistock.
5.
AntonacopoulouE. P. (2010). Making the business school more “critical”: Reflexive critique based on phronesis as a foundation for impact. British Journal of Management, 21, 6-25.
6.
AppleM. W. (1992). The text and cultural politics. Educational Researcher, 21(4), 4-11.
7.
ArbaughJ. B. (2010). Introduction: And now for something completely different—Business school envy?Academy of Management Learning & Education, 9, 280-281.
8.
ArnaudG. (2012). The contribution of psychoanalysis to organization studies and management: An overview. Organization Studies, 33, 1121-1135.
9.
BarkerR. (2010). No, management is not a profession. Harvard Business Review, 88(7/8), 52-60.
10.
BartolK.TeinM.MatthewsG.SharmaB.Scott-LaddB. (2011). Management: A Pacific rim focus (6th ed.). North Ryde, New South Wales, Australia: McGraw-Hill.
11.
Baxter MagoldaM. B. (1992). Knowing and reasoning in college: Gender-related patterns in students’ intellectual development. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
12.
BloomB. S.EngelhartM. D.FurstE. J.HillW. H.KrathwohlD. R. (1956). Taxonomy of educational objectives: The classification of educational goals. Handbook 1. Cognitive domain. London, England: Longman.
13.
BogrenA. (2010). Studying social power in textual data: Combining tools for analyzing meaning and positioning. Critical Discourse Studies, 7, 73-84.
14.
BrookfieldS. D. (2012). Teaching for critical thinking. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
15.
BrownK. G.RynesS. L.CharlierS. D.HosmanekA. (2013). What do we teach in Organizational Behavior? An analysis of MBA syllabi. Journal of Management Education, 37, 447-471.
16.
Bubna-LiticD.North-SamardzicA. (2008, December). The strategic implications of sustainability in strategy textbooks. Paper presented at the 22nd Australia and New Zealand Academy of Management conference 2008: Managing in the Pacific Century, Auckland, New Zealand. Retrieved from http://www.anzam.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf-manager/1229_BUBNA-LITIC_DAVID-297.PDF
17.
CarrellS. E.WestJ. E. (2010). Does professor quality matter? Evidence from random assignment of students to professors. Journal of Political Economy, 118, 409-432.
18.
CleggS. R. (2003). Strange fruit hanging from the knowledge tree: Carry on carping. Management Learning, 34, 375-378.
19.
ColbyA.EhrlichT.SullivanW. S.DolleJ. R. (2011). Rethinking undergraduate business education. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
20.
CzarniawskaB. (2003). Forbidden knowledge organization theory in times of transition. Management Learning, 34, 353-365.
21.
DaviesB.HarréR. (1990). Positioning: The discursive production of selves. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 20, 43-63.
22.
De CastellS. (1990). Teaching the textbook: Teacher/text authority and the problem of interpretation. Linguistics and Education, 2, 75-90.
23.
DelbridgeR.KeenoyT. (2010). Beyond managerialism?International Journal of Human Resource Management, 21, 799-817.
24.
DiMaggioP. J.PowellW. W. (1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48, 147-160.
25.
DinhJ.LordR.GardnerW.MeuserJ.LidenR. C.HuJ. (2014). Leadership theory and research in the new millennium: Current theoretical trends and changing perspectives. Leadership Quarterly, 25, 36-62.
26.
EhrensalK. N. (2001). Training capitalism’s foot soldiers: The hidden curriculum of undergraduate business education. In MargolisE. (Ed.), The hidden curriculum in higher education (pp. 97-115). New York, NY: Routledge.
FloresK. L.MatkinG. S.BurbachM. E.QuinnC. E.HardingH. (2012). Deficient critical thinking skills among college graduates: Implications for leadership. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 44, 212-230.
29.
FotakiM.LongS.SchwartzH. S. (2012). What can psychoanalysis offer organization studies today? Taking stock of current developments and thinking about future directions. Organization Studies, 33, 1105-1120.
30.
FoucaultM. (1978). The history of sexuality: Vol. 1. An introduction (HurleyR.Trans.). New York, NY: Vintage.
31.
GergenK. J. (2009). Relational being: Beyond self and community. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
32.
GhoshalS. (2005). Bad management theories are destroying good management practices. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 4, 75-91.
33.
GirouxH. A. (2002). Neoliberalism, corporate culture, and the promise of higher education: The university as a democratic public sphere. Harvard Educational Review, 72, 425-463.
34.
GrantJ. D.MillsA. J. (2006). The quiet Americans: Formative context, the Academy of Management leadership, and the management textbook, 1936-1960. Management & Organizational History, 1, 201-224.
35.
GreaneyV. (2006). Textbooks, respect for diversity, and social cohesion. In Roberts-SchweitzerE.GreaneyV.DuerK. (Eds.), Promoting social cohesion through education: Case studies and tools for using textbooks and curricula (pp. 47-71). Washington, DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development.
36.
HardinM.DoddJ. E.LaufferK. (2006). Passing it on: The reinforcement of male hegemony in sports journalism textbooks. Mass Communication and Society, 9, 429-446.
37.
HeikkilaA.LonkaK. (2006). Studying in higher education: Students’ approaches to learning, self-regulation and cognitive strategies. Studies in Higher Education, 31, 99-117.
38.
HoferB. K.PintrichP. R. (1997). The development of epistemological theories: Beliefs about knowledge and knowing and their relation to learning. Review of Educational Research, 67, 88-140.
39.
HooksB. (2010). Teaching critical thinking: Practical wisdom. New York, NY: Routledge.
40.
KalmiP. (2007). The disappearance of cooperatives from economics textbooks. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 31, 625-647.
41.
KeenS. (2001). Debunking economics: The naked emperor of the social sciences. Annandale, New South Wales, Australia: Pluto Press.
42.
KemberD.JenkinsW.NgK. (2003). Adult students’ perception of good teaching as a function of their conceptions of learning—Part 1. Influencing the development of self-determination. Studies in Continuing Education, 25, 239-251.
43.
KrammerH. P. M. (1985). The textbook as classroom context variable. Teaching and Teacher Education, 1, 273-278.
44.
LeaM.StreetB. (1998). Student writing in higher education: An academic literacies approach. Studies in Higher Education, 23, 157-172.
45.
LeungD. Y. P.KemberD. (2010). The relationship between approaches to learning and reflection upon practice. Educational Psychology, 23, 61-71.
46.
LissackM. R.RichardsonK. A. (2003). Models without morals: Towards the ethical use of business models. Emergence, 52, 72-102.
47.
LucasU.TanP. L. (2013). Developing a capacity to engage in critical reflection: Students’ “ways of knowing” within an undergraduate business and accounting programme. Studies in Higher Education, 38, 104-123.
48.
LukeC.de CastellS.LukeA. (1983). Beyond criticism: The authority of the school text. Curriculum Inquiry, 13, 111-127.
49.
MartonF.SaljoR. (1976). On qualitative differences in learning. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 46, 4-11.
50.
McShaneS.OlekalnsM.TravaglioneT. (2013). Organisational behaviour: Emerging knowledge, global insights (4th ed.). Sydney, New South Wales, Australia: McGraw-Hill.
51.
MillsA. J.Helms HatfieldJ. (1999). From imperialism to globalization: Internationalization and the management text. In CleggS. R.IbarraE.BuenoL. (Eds.), Theories of the management process: Making sense through difference (pp. 37-67). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
52.
MingersJ. (2000). What is it to be critical? Teaching a critical approach to management undergraduates. Management Learning, 31, 219-237.
53.
MirA. (2003). The hegemonic discourse of management texts. Journal of Management Education, 27, 734-738.
54.
MizruchiM. S.FeinL. C. (1999). The social construction of organizational knowledge: A study of the uses of coercive, mimetic, and normative isomorphism. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44, 653-683.
55.
MyersG. A. (1992). Textbooks and the sociology of scientific knowledge. English for Specific Purposes, 11, 3-17.
56.
NichollsN. H. (2009). Rising textbook expenses and a search for solutions: Survey and interview results from Michigan faculty. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.
57.
OlsonD. R. (1980). On the language and authority of textbooks. Journal of Communication, 30, 186-196.
58.
OttewillR. (2003). What’s wrong with instrumental learning? The case of business and management. Education + Training, 45, 189-196.
59.
PalmerB.MarraR. M. (2004). College student epistemological perspectives across knowledge domains. Higher Education, 47, 311-335.
60.
PaulD. B. (1988). The market as censor. Political Science & Politics, 21, 31-35.
61.
PaulsenM. B.FeldmanK. A. (1999). Student motivation and epistemological belief. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 78, 17-25.
62.
PaulsenM. B.FeldmanK. A. (2005). The conditional and interaction effects of epistemological beliefs on the self-regulated learning of college students. Research in Higher Education, 46, 731-768.
63.
PaulsenM. B.WellsC. T. (1998). Domain differences in the epistemological beliefs of college students. Research in Higher Education, 39, 365-384.
64.
PearceJ. L.HuangL. (2012). The decreasing value of our research to management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 11, 247-262.
65.
PerryW. G. (1970). Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years. New York, NY: Holt, Reinhart & Winston.
66.
PetressK. (2004). Critical thinking: An extended definition. Education, 124, 461-466.
67.
PhanH. P. (2008). Predicting change in epistemological beliefs, reflective thinking and learning styles: A longitudinal study. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 78, 75-93.
68.
PhanH. P. (2011). Deep processing strategies and critical thinking. Journal of Educational Research, 104, 283-294.
69.
PhillipsV.BondC. (2004). Undergraduates’ experiences of critical thinking. Higher Education Research & Development, 23, 277-294.
70.
PowleyE. H.TaylorS. N. (2014). Pedagogical approaches to develop critical thinking and crisis leadership. Journal of Management Education, 38, 560-585.
71.
RichardsonJ. T. E. (2013). Epistemological development in higher education. Educational Research Review, 9, 191-206.
72.
RichardsonP. W. (2004). Reading and writing from textbooks in higher education: A case study from economics. Studies in Higher Education, 29, 505-521.
73.
RobinsonR. J.KeltnerD.WardA.RossL. (1995). Actual versus assumed differences in construal: “Naive realism” in intergroup perception and conflict. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 68, 404-417.
74.
RodriguezL.CanoF. (2007). The learning approaches and epistemological beliefs of university students: A cross-sectional and longitudinal study. Studies in Higher Education, 32, 647-667.
75.
RousseauD. M. (2012). Designing a better business school. Journal of Management Studies, 49, 600-618.
76.
RubinR. S.DierdorffE. C. (2013). Building a better MBA: From a decade of critique toward a decennium of creation. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 12, 125-141.
77.
SandbergJ.TsoukasH. (2011). Grasping the logic of practice: Theorizing through practical rationality. Academy of Management Review, 36, 338-360.
78.
ShrivastavaP. (1994). Greening business education: Toward an ecocentric pedagogy. Journal of Management Inquiry, 3, 235-243.
79.
SmithG. F. (2003). Beyond critical thinking and decision making: Teaching business students how to think. Journal of Management Education, 27, 24-51.
80.
SmithG. F. (2014). Assessing business student thinking skills. Journal of Management Education, 38, 384-411.
81.
SnyderR. A. (2014). Let’s burn them all: Reflections on the learning-inhibitory nature of Introduction to Management and Introduction to Organizational Behavior textbooks. Journal of Management Education, 38, 733-758.
82.
StambaughJ. E.TrankC. Q. (2010). Not so simple: Integrating new research into textbooks. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 9, 663-681.
83.
StarkeyK.HatchuelA.TempestS. (2004). Rethinking the business school. Journal of Management Studies, 41, 1521-1531.
84.
Thayer-BaconB. J. (1997). The nurturing of a relational epistemology. Educational Theory, 47, 239-260.
85.
Thayer-BaconB. J. (2003). Relational (e)pistemologies. New York, NY: Peter Lang.
86.
TysonH.WoodwardA. (1989). Why students aren’t learning very much from textbooks. Educational Leadership, 47(3), 14-17.
87.
Van de VenA. H.JohnsonP. E. (2006). Knowledge for theory and practice. Academy of Management Review, 31, 802-821.
88.
WahbaM. A.BridwellL. G. (1976). Maslow reconsidered: A review of research on the need heirarchy theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 15, 212-240.
WatsonT. J. (2001). Beyond managism: Negotiated narratives and critical management education in practice. British Journal of Management, 12, 385-396.
91.
WittrockM. C. (1974). Learning as a generative process 1. Educational Psychologist, 11, 87-95.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
