Rationales for Practice Decisions: Variations in Knowledge Use by Decision Task and Social Work Service

Abstract

This article addresses social workers' use of knowledge by studying the rationale they provided for their actual practice decisions. Extent of knowledge use was compared across four practice decision tasks and between medical and psychiatric social work services. Data were obtained from the records of 297 clients treated by 34 experienced M.S.W. social workers in medical and psychiatric services units of two midwestern hospitals. Workers were previously trained in the approach and procedures of Systematic Planned Practice (SPP). Data were obtainedfrom SPP forms on which workers recorded their treatment decisions and rationale for each decision. Data analyzed by repeated measures (MANOVA and ANOVA's) revealed that giving of rationales, and the types of knowledge it reflected, varied significantly by the decision task and social work service. Intervention decisions were least likely to be supported by rationales, and medical services workers provided fewer rationales than psychiatric services workers. Conceptual rationales were the most frequently used, whereas rationales based on practice experience, values, research, or client wish were very little used. The implications for practice, professional education, quality assurance, and for further research are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Benbenishty, R. (1992) An overview of methods to elicit and model expert clinical judgment and decision making Social Service Review , 66, 598-616.

Berlin, S.B. , & Marsh, J.C. (1993). Informing practice decisions New York: Macmillan.

Chavkin, N.F. (1993). The use of research in social work practice Westport, CT: Praeger.

Cohen, L.H. (1979). The research readership and information source reliance of clinical psychologists Professional Psychology , 10, 780-785.

Cohen, L.H. , Sargent, M.M. , & Sechrest, L.B. (1986). Use of psychotherapy research by professional psychologists American Psychologist , 41, 198-206.

Council on Social Work Education. (1992). Curriculum policy statement for master's degree programs in social work education Washington, DC: Author.

Dowie, J., & Elstein, A. (Eds.). (1988). Professional judgment: A reader in clinical decision making. Cambridge, England : Cambridge University Press.

Dumont, F. , & Lecomte, C. (1987). Inferential processes in clinical work: Inquiry into logical errors that affect diagnostic judgments Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 18, 433-438.

Eaton, J.W. (1959). A scientific basis for helping In A. J. Kahn (Ed.), Issues in American social work (pp. 270-292). New York: Columbia University Press.

10.

Faust, D. (1986). Research on human judgment and its application to clinical practice Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 18, 420-430.

11.

Goodman, M. , Brown, J. , & Deitz, P. (1992). Managing managed care: A mental health practitioner's survival guide Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

12.

Greenwood, E. (1955). Social science and social work-A theory of their relationship Social Service Review, 29, 28.

13.

Harrison, W.D. (1987). Reflective practice in social care Social Service Review, 61, 393-404.

14.

Kadushin, A. (1959). The knowledge base of social work In A. J. Kahn (Ed.), Issues in American social work (pp. 39-79). New York: Columbia University Press.

15.

Kirk, S.A. , Osmalov, J.M. , & Fischer, J. (1976). Social workers' involvement in research Social Work, 21, 121-124

16.

. Kirk, S.A. , & Rosenblatt, A. (1981). Research knowledge and orientation among social work students In S. Briar, H. Weissman, & A. Rubin (Eds.), Research utilization in social work education (pp. 29-39). New York: Council On Social Work Education.

17.

Klein, W.C. , & Bloom, M. (1994). Social work as applied social science Social Work, 39, 421-431.

18.

Morrow-Bradley, C. , & Elliot, R. (1986). Utilization of psychotherapy research by practicing psychotherapists American Psychologist, 41, 188-197.

19.

Murdach, A.D. (1994). Avoiding error in clinical prediction Social Work, 39, 381-386.

20.

Nezu, A. M., & Nezu, C. M., (Eds.), (1989). Clinical decision making in behavior therapy. Champaign, IL: Research Press.

21.

O'Donohue, W.T. , Curtis, S.D. , & Fisher, J.E. (1985). Use of research in the practice of community mental health: A case study Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 16, 710-718.

22.

Powers, G. , Meenaghan, T. , & Toomey, B. (1985). Practice focused research: Integrating human service practice and research Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

23.

Proctor, E.K. , & Morrow-Howell, N. (1990). Complications in discharge planning with Medicare patients Health and Social Work , 15, 45-54.

24.

Reid, W.J. , & Fortune, A.E. (1992). Research utilization in direct social work practice In A. J. Grasso & I. Epstein (Eds.), Research utilization in the social services (pp. 97-115). New York: Haworth.

25.

Rosen, A. (1978). Issues in educating for the knowledge-building research doctorate Social Service Review, 52, 437-448.

26.

Rosen, A. (1992). Facilitating clinical decision making and evaluation Families in Society, 73, 522-530.

27.

Rosen, A. (1993). Systematic planned practice Social Service Review, 67, 84-100.

28.

Rosen, A. (1994). Knowledge use in direct practice Social Service Review, 68, 561-577.

29.

Rosen, A. , Proctor, E.K. , & Livne, S. (1985). Planning and direct practice Social Service Review, 59, 161-177.

30.

Rosen, A. , Proctor, E.K. , Morrow-Howell, N. , Auslander, W.A. , & Staudt, M. (1993). Systematic planned practice: A tool for planning, implementation, and evaluation St. Louis, MO: Washington University School of Social Work.

31.

Rosenblatt. A. (1968). The practitioner's use and evaluation of research Social Work, 18 , 53-59.

32.

Schon, D.A. (1983). The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action New York: Basic Books.

33.

Schuerman, J.R. (1992). Expert systems and ordinary research as sources for practice guidance In A. J. Grasso & I. Epstein (Eds.). Research utilization in the social services (pp. 265-279). New York: Haworth.

34.

Scott, D. (1990). Practice wisdom: The neglected source of practice research Social Work, 35, 564-568.

35.

Thomas, E.J. (1984). Designing interventions for the helping professions Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

36.

Wilson, T.D. , & Brekke, E. (1994). Mental contamination and mental correction: Unwanted influences on judgment and evaluation Psychological Bulletin , 116, 117-142.