Objective: Many professions use some form of internship in professional education. Social work has utilized field instruction throughout much of its history. Recently, the Council on Social Work Education (CSWE) designated field instruction as social work’s signature pedagogy. A systematic review was undertaken to examine evidence related to this designation. Method: Twenty-five primary databases, three grey literature sources, a research university library (for monographs and collections) were searched in addition to a survey of the invisible colleges and hand searching of journals. The goal was to uncover quantitative studies of social work field instruction in the United States. Results: None of the studies that passed the initial review and were acquired for full examination met the inclusion criteria, precluding a meta-analytic integration. Conclusion: The assertion that field instruction is the signature pedagogy of social work would be more credible if supported by stronger evidence.
Abbott, E. ( 1942). Social welfare and professional education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. (1931 section reprinted in 1942 volume).
2.
Arkava, M.L., & Brennen, E.C. ( 1976). Competency-based education: Evaluation and curriculum issues. New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
3.
Baird, B.N. ( 2008). The internship, practicum and field placement handbook: A guide for the helping professions (5th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/ Prentice Hall.
4.
Bloom, T. ( 1963). First presentation. In Council on Social Work Education (Ed.), The future of field instruction: Agency-school commitment and communication (pp. 1-9). New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
5.
Bogo, M. ( 2005). Field instruction in social work: A review of the research literature. The Clinical Supervisor, 25, 3-19.
6.
Bogo, M., & Vayda, E. ( 1987). The practice of field instruction in social work: Theory and process. Toronto, ON: University of Toronto Press.
7.
Bogo, M., & Vayda, E. ( 1998). The practice of field instruction in social work: Theory and process (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
8.
Campbell Collaboration. (2001). Campbell systematic reviews: Guidelines for the preparation of review protocols (Version 1.0). Retrieved from Campbell Collaboration Website: http://www.campbellcollaboration.org/resources/guidelines/review_protocol_guidelines.php
9.
Caspi, J. ( 1997). The task centered model for field instruction ( Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from UMI Dissertation Publishing/ ProQuest (Order Number: 9728782).
10.
Caspi, J., & Reid, W.J. ( 2002). Educational supervision in social work. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
11.
Clare, M. ( 2001). Thinking systemically about fieldwork education- A third way. Australian Social Work, 54, 53-66.
12.
Cochrane Collaboration. (2002). The handsearcher training manual. Retrieved from http://apps1.jhsph.edu/cochrane/NSresourceshandsearch.htm
13.
Cooper, H. ( 2010). Research synthesis and meta-analysis: A step by step approach (4th ed.). Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
14.
Council on Social Work Education. (1963). The future for field instruction: Agency-school commitment and communication . New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
15.
Council on Social Work Education. (2008a). Strengthening the profession of social work: Leadership in research, career advancement, and education. Retrieved from http://www.cswe.org/File.aspx?id=14136
16.
Council on Social Work Education. (2008b). Educational policy and accreditation standards. Retrieved from http://www.cswe.org/NR/rdonlyres/2A81732E-1776-4175-AC42-65974E96BE66/0/2008EducationalPolicyandAccreditationStandards.pdf
17.
Cuzzi, L.C., Holden, G., Chernack, P., Rutter, S., & Rosenberg, G. ( 1997). Evaluating social work field instruction: Rotations versus year-long placements. Research on Social Work Practice, 7, 402- 414.
18.
Cuzzi, L.C., Holden, G., Rutter, S., Rosenberg, G., & Chernack, P. ( 1996). A pilot study of fieldwork rotations vs. year long placements for social work students in a public hospital. Social Work in Health Care, 24, 73-91.
19.
Dalgleish, K.B., Kane, R.A., & McNamara, J.J. (1976). Rotating social work students within a medical center. Health & Social Work, 1, 166-171.
20.
Faith, G.B. ( 1953). The professional school and the social agency. In R. Wessel & G. Faith (Eds.), Professional education based in practice (pp. 97-170). Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania School of Social Work .
21.
Feinstein, A.R., & Cicchetti, D.V. (1990). High agreement but low kappa: I. The problems of two paradoxes. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 43, 543-549.
22.
Feldman, R.A. ( 2009). Reinventing social work accreditation: Write on!Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 124-126.
23.
Felkner, W.J. ( 2009). Poor rigor and political obduracy: Which is the horse and which is the cart in social work education?Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 121-123.
24.
Gambrill, E. ( 2007). Transparency as the route to evidence-informed professional education, Research on Social Work Practice, 17, 553-560.
25.
Garthwait, C.L. ( 2005). The social work practicum: A guidebook and workbook for students (3rd ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson/Allyn & Bacon .
26.
Glassman, U., & Robbins, V.C. ( 2007). To the editor. Journal of Social Work Education, 43, 161-163.
27.
Green, S., Higgins, J.P.T., Schunemann, H.J., & Becker, L. ( 2007). Response to paper by Lang A, Edwards N, and Fleiszer A. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 60, 598-599.
28.
Haffey, M., & Starr, R. ( 1988). Designing a work-study program: Where social service employment meets professional education. New York, NY: The Lois and Samuel Silberman Fund.
29.
Hannes, K., Claes, L., & the Belgian Campbell Group. ( 2007). Learn to read and write systematic reviews: The Belgian Campbell Group. Research on Social Work Practice, 17, 748-753.
30.
Holden, G., & Barker, K.M. ( 1990). Potential for technological dependency: An example. Social Work Research and Abstracts, 26, 35-36.
31.
Holden, G., Barker, K., Covert-Vail, L., Rosenberg, G., & Cohen, S.A. ( 2008). Does social work abstracts work?Research on Social Work Practice, 18, 487-499.
32.
Holden, G., Barker, K., Covert-Vail, L., Rosenberg, G., & Cohen S.A. ( 2009). Social work abstracts fails again. Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 715-721.
33.
Homonoff, E. ( 2008). The heart of social work: Best practitioners rise to challenges in field instruction. The Clinical Supervisor, 27, 135- 169.
34.
Hopewell, S., Clarke, M., Lefebvre, C., & Westby, M. ( 2002). A comparison of handsearching versus MEDLINE searching to identify reports of randomized controlled trials. Statistics in Medicine, 21, 1625-1634.
35.
Ivry, J., Lawrence, F.P., Damon-Rodriguez, J., & Robbins, V.C. ( 2005). Fieldwork rotation: A model for educating social work students for geriatric social work practice. Journal of Social Work Education, 4, 407-425.
36.
Jamtvedt, G., Johansen, M., Vist, G., Reinar, L.M., von Mehren, S., & Nordheim, L. ( 2007). Empty reviews in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews-How long do they stay empty?Paper presented at the XV Cochrane Colloquium; 2007 Oct 23-27. Abstract retrieved from http://cmr.cochrane.org/?CRGReportID=11315&printable=1
37.
Jarman-Rohde, L., McFall, J., Kolar, P., & Strom, G. ( 1997). The changing context of social work practice: Implications and recommendations for social work educators. Journal of Social Work Education, 33, 29-46.
38.
Jarman-Rohde, L., & Tropman, J.E. ( 1993). The social work practicum as service learning. In J. Galura & J. Howard (Eds.), Praxis I: A faculty casebook on community service learning (pp. 173- 180). Ann Arbor, MI: OCSL Press.
39.
Jenkins, L.E., & Sheafor, B.W. ( 1982). An overview of social work field instruction. In B. W. Sheafor & L. E. Jenkins (Eds.), Quality field instruction in social work: Program development and maintenance (pp. 3-19). New York, NY: Longman.
40.
Jones, B.L. ( 1969). Current patterns in field instruction in graduate social work education. New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
41.
Kadushin, A.E. ( 1991). Introduction. In D. Schneck , B. Grossman, & U. Glassman (Eds.), Field education in social work: Contemporary issues and trends (pp. 11-12). Dubuque, IO: Kendall Hunt.
42.
Kemp, B.E., & Brustman, M.J. (1997). Social policy research: Comparison and analysis of CD-ROM resources. Social Work Research , 21, 111-120.
43.
Kuppens, S., Holden, G., Barker, K., & Rosenberg, G. (IN PRESS). A Kappa related decision: K, Y, G or AC1. Social Work Research.
44.
Lang, A., & Edwards, N. ( 2005). Perils of systematic reviews. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 172, 855.
45.
Lang, A., Edwards, N., & Fleiszer, A. ( 2007). Empty systematic reviews: Hidden perils and lessons learned . Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 60, 595-597.
46.
Lee, P.R., Kenworthy, M.E., Ivins, S., Neustaedter, E., Honsberger, J., & Regensburg, J. (1931). Mental hygiene and social work. New York, NY: The Commonwealth Fund.
47.
Levy, C.S. ( 1981). Social work education 1898-1955. Washington, DC: NASW.
48.
Littell, J.H., Corcoran, J., & Pillai, V. ( 2008). Systematic reviews and meta-analysis. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
49.
Lowenberg, F. ( 1972). Time and quality in graduate social work education. New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
50.
Madaus, G.F., & Stufflebeam, D.L. (2000). Program evaluation: A historical overview. In D. L. Stufflebeam, G. F. Madaus, & T. Kellaghan (Eds.), Evaluation models: Viewpoints on educational and human services evaluation (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic.
51.
Manis, F. ( 1979). Openness in social work field instruction: Stance and form guidelines. Goleta, CA: Kimberly Press.
52.
Mendelsohn, H.N. ( 1984). Social work online. Database, 7, 36-49. Mendelsohn, H.N. (1986). Searching social work abstracts: A review. Database, 9, 22-27.
53.
Midgley, J. ( 2009). Comments on ‘‘Reinventing social work education.’’Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 119-120.
54.
Mohan, B. ( 2009). Rejoinder to ‘‘Reinventing social work education.’’Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 116-118.
55.
Montgomery, P., Hopewell, S., Shepard, L., & Yaffe, J. ( 2010). How empty are empty reviews? Developing guidelines for the discussion of excluded studies. Retrieved from Campbell Collaboration website: http://www.cochrane.org/intranet/awards-scholarships-funding-initiatives/funding-initiatives/opportunities-fund/opportunitie
56.
National Association of Social Work. (2006 ). Social Work Abstracts PLUS (NASW Vol. Id: SWAB0004, SP-0113-0040). Washington, DC: NASW.
57.
Pierce, D. ( 2008). Field education in the 2008 EPAS: Implications for the field director’s role. Richmond, VA: Council on Social Work Education.
58.
Raskin, M.S. ( 1989). Empirical studies in field instruction. New York: Haworth Press.
59.
Raskin, M., Skolnick, L., & Wayne, J. ( 1991). An international perspective of field instruction. Journal of Social Work Education, 27, 258-70.
60.
Rehr, H., & Caroff, P. ( 1986). A new model in academic-practice partnership: Multi-instructor and institutional collaboration in social work. Lexington, MA: Ginn Press.
61.
Robbins, V.C., Robbins, S.P., Jacobs, S., & Alpert, S. ( 2009). The signature pedagogy: Defining, measuring and operationalizing competencies in field education. Handout prepared for Council on Social Work Education /APM, San Antonio , November 7, 2009. Retrieved from first author’s website http://www.susanrobbins.com/Field%20Handouts%20for%20CSWE-APM.doc
62.
Rosenblatt, A., Welter, M., & Wojciechowski, S. (1976). The Adelphi experiment: Accelerating social work education. New York, NY: Council on Social Work Education.
63.
Rothstein, H.R., Turner, H.M., & Lavenberg, J.G. (2004). The Campbell Collaboration Information Retrieval Policy Brief. Retrieved from Campbell Collaboration website http://www.campbellcollaboration.org/artman2/uploads/1/Information_Retrieval_Policy_Brief.pdf
64.
Rubin, A. ( 2008). Practitioners guide to using research for evidence-based practice. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
65.
Schlosser, R.W., & Sigafoos, J. ( 2009). Empty reviews and evidence based practice. Evidence-based Communication Assessment and Intervention, 3, 1-3.
66.
Schneck, D., Grossman, B., & Glassman, U. ( 1991). Field education in social work: Contemporary issues and trends. Dubuque, IO: Kendall Hunt .
67.
Shatz, E.O. ( 1989). Preface. In M. Raskin (Ed.), Empirical studies in field instruction (pp. xxv-xxvii). New York, NY: Haworth Press.
68.
Sheafor, B., & Jenkins, L., (1982). Quality field instruction in social work. New York, NY: Longman.
69.
Shek, D.T.L. ( 2008). Comprehensiveness of Social Work Abstracts as a database for researchers and practitioners. Research on Social Work Practice, 18, 500-506.
70.
Shulman, L. ( 1992). Interactional supervision. Washington, DC: NASW Press.
71.
Shulman, L.S. ( 2005). Signature pedagogies in the professions. Daedulus, 134, 52-59.
72.
Sowers, K.M., & Dulmus, C.N. ( 2009). Social work education: Status quo or change?Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 114-115.
73.
Spencer, A., & McDonald, C. ( 1998). Omissions and commissions: An analysis of professional field education literature. Australian Social Work, 51, 9-18.
74.
Stoesz, D., & Karger, H. ( 2009a). Reinventing social work accreditation. Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 104-111.
75.
Stoesz, D., & Karger, H. ( 2009b). Social work education in wonder-land: Stoesz and Karger reply. Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 131-133.
76.
Stoesz, D., Karger, H., & Carrilio, T. ( 2010). A dream deferred: How social work education lost its way and what can be done. New Brunswick, NJ: Aldine Transaction.
77.
Taylor, B.J., Dempster, M., & Donnelly, M. ( 2003). Hidden gems: Systematically searching electronic databases for research publications for social work and social care. British Journal of Social Work, 33, 423-439.
78.
Taylor, B.J., McCaughern, E., Dempster, M., & Donnelly, M. ( 2006). Systematic searching on the AgeInfo database. Bristol, UK: Social Care Institute for Excellence.
79.
Taylor, B., Wylie, E., Dempster, M., & Donnelly, M. ( 2007). Systematically retrieving research: A case study evaluating seven databases. Research on Social Work Practice, 17, 697-706.
80.
Thomlison, B., & Corcoran, K. ( 2008). The evidence-based internship: A field manual. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
81.
Thyer, B.A. ( 2009). The CSWE and social work accreditation: Not guilty on all charges. Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 127-130.
82.
Watkins, J.M. ( 2009). Response to Stoesz and Karger’s article, ‘‘Reinventing social work accreditation.’’Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 112-113.
83.
Wayne, J., Bogo, M., & Raskin, M. ( 2006). The need for radical change in field education. Journal of Social Work Education, 42, 161-169.
84.
Wayne, J., Bogo, M., & Raskin, M. ( 2007). The authors respond. Journal of Social Work Education, 43, 163-164.
85.
Wessel, R., & Faith, G.B. ( 1953). Professional education based in practice. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania School of Social Work.
