Competency Is Not Guaranteed by the Letters That Follow Your Name: A Response to My Critics

Abstract

This article is a formal response to those that authored critiques of the author1's research. Each author has provided a thoughtful and critical perspective highlighting the perceived merits and demerits of the research questions posed, theoretical assumptions underlying the inquiry, study design and methodology, and interpretations garnered from summarized findings. In the end, no sound evidence was presented that refutes suggestions that the educational background of child welfare workers is a poor predictive variable of their performance. Regardless, taken together, the insights and criticisms of my colleagues provide other researchers with a foundation for better answering the questions the authors pose. These include questions about the efficacy of Title IV-E educational programs, what factors are predicative of competent child welfare practice, the means and mechanisms by which practice and worker competency is evaluated, and who has a right or privilege to receive specialized child welfare education and training.

Keywords

child welfare workers child welfare services performance evaluations social workers professional comparisons competency-based practice

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ary, D. , Jacobs, L. , & Razqavieh, A. (2002). Introduction to research in education. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson.%

Briar-Lawson, K. , & Wiesen, M. (1999). Effective partnership models between the state agencies, the university, and community service providers. In 1999 Child Welfare Training Symposium: Changing paradigms of child welfare practice: Responding to opportunities and challenges (pp. 73-86). Washington, DC: U.S. Children's Bureau.

Bureau of Labor Statistics , U.S. Department of Labor. (2006). Occupational outlook handbook, 2006-07 edition. Social Workers. Retrieved on March 21, 2006, from http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos060.htm%

Cahalane, H., & Sites, E.W. (2004). Is it hot or cold? The climate of child welfare employee retention. Unpublished manuscript, University of Pittsburgh.%

California Social Work Education Center . (2005). California Social Work Education Center: Background. Retrieved on March 17, 2006, from http://www.dmh.cahwnet.gov/mhpc/docs/Social_Work_Education_Proposal.pdf%23search=‘CalSWEC%20budget’

Campbell, D. T. , & Stanley, J. C. (1963). Experimental and quasi experimental designs for research. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.%

Center for Health Workforce Studies & Center for Workforce Studies . (2006). Licensed Social Workers in the U.S., 2004.Washington, DC: National Association of Social Workers.%

Cheung, M. , Taylor, T. , & Vohra-Gupta, S. (2006). National survey of IV-E stipends & paybacks. Retrieved on March 15, 2006, from http://www.uh.edu/ocp/cwep_title_IVE.htm

Clark, E. J. (2003). Written testimony of Elizabeth J. Clark, ExecutiveDirector National Association of Social Workers for the Human Resources Subcommittee, U.S. Committee on Ways and Means. Retrieved on January 5, 2005, from https://www.socialworkers.org/advocacy/issues/child_welfare.asp

10.

Clark, S. (2003). The California collaboration: A competency-based child welfare curriculum project for master's social workers. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 7(1/2), 135-157.

11.

Costin, L. , Karger, H. , & Stoesz, D. (1996). The politics of child abuse in America. New York: Oxford University Press.%

12.

Dickinson, N. (2006). Commentary on “Do social workers make better child welfare workers than non-social workers?” by Robin Perry. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 431-433%

13.

Dickinson, N. D. , & Perry, R. E. (2002). Factors influencing the retention of specially educated public child welfare workers. Evaluation Research In Child Welfare 15(3/4), 89-103.

14.

Ellett, A. J. (2006). Broad study but narrow question: A friendly critique of Perry's article. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 406-411

15.

Ellett, A. J. , Ellett, C. D. , & Rugutt, J. K. (2003). A study of personal and organizational factors contributing to employee retention and turnover in child welfare in Georgia. Athens: University of Georgia School of Social Work.

16.

Fox, S. , Burnham, D. , Barbee, A. P. , & Yankeelov, P. A. (2000). School to work—Social work that is: Maximizing agency/university partnerships in preparing public child welfare workers. Journal of the National Staff Development and Training Association 1(1), 13-20.

17.

Fox, S. R. , Miller, V. P. , & Barbee, A. P. (2003). Finding and keeping child welfare workers: Effective use of Title IV-E training funds. Journal of Human Behavior and the Social Environment 7(1/2), 67-81.%

18.

Government Accountability Office . (2003). Child welfare: HHS could play a greater role in helping child welfare agencies recruit and retain staff (GAO-03-357). Washington, DC: Author.%

19.

Grossman, B. , Laughlin, S. , & Specht, H. (1992). Building the commitment of social work education to publicly sponsored social services: The California model. In K. Briar , V. Hansen , & N. Harris (Eds.), New partnerships: Proceedings from the national public welfare training symposium 1991. Miami, FL: Florida International University.

20.

Holosko, M. J. (2006). Why don't social workers make better child welfare workers than non-social workers? Research on Social Work Practice 16, 426-430.

21.

Hopkins, K. M. , Murdock, N. R. , & Rudolph, C. S. (1999). Impact of university-agency partnerships in child welfare on organizations, workers, and work activities. Child Welfare 78, 749-773.

22.

Hughes, R. C. , & Baird, C. (2006). B.A.s are B.S. in child welfare: Did anybody learn anything? Research on Social Work Practice 16, 434-437.

23.

Jones, L. (2002). A follow-up of a Title IV-E program's graduates' retention rates in a public child welfare agency. Evaluation Research in Child Welfare 15(3/4), 39-51.

24.

Jones, L. , & Okamura, A. (2000). Re-professionalizing child welfare services: An evaluation of a IV-E training program. Research in Social Work Practice 10, 607-621.

25.

Kadushin, A. , & Harkness, D. (2002). Supervision in social work, chapter 8, evaluation. New York: Columbia University Press.%

26.

Lieberman, A. A. , & Levy, M. M. (2006). The (mis)measurement of job performance in child welfare using (non)experimental design. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 417-418.

27.

Mathias, C. (2006). We should really get on with it: An argument for not assuming social workers make better child welfare workers than non-social workers. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 424-425.

28.

McCarthy, M. L. (2006). The context and process for performance evaluations: Necessary preconditions for the use of performance evaluations as a measure of performance—A critique of Perry. Research on Social Work Practice, 16, 419-423.

29.

McDonald, J. , & McCarthy, B. (1999). Effective partnership models between the state agencies, community, the university and community service providers. In 1999 child welfare training symposium: Changing paradigms of child welfare practice: Responding to opportunities and challenges (pp. 43-72). Washington DC: U. S. Children's Bureau.

30.

National Association of Social Workers . (2004a). Fact sheet: Title IV-E child welfare training program. Retrieved on January 20, 2005, from https://www.socialworkers.org/advocacy/updates/2003/081204a.asp%

31.

National Association of Social Workers . (2004b). The case for retaining the Title IV-E child welfare training program. Retrieved on March 1, 2005, from https://www.socialworkers.org/advocacy/updates/2003/081204b.asp%

32.

National Association of Social Workers. (n.d.) . About NASW. Retrieved March 17, 2006, from http://www.naswdc.org/nasw/default.asp

33.

Perry, R. (2004). Factors influencing MSW students' interest in public child welfare. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 10, 1-31.

34.

Perry, R. (2006). Do social workers make better child welfare workers than non-social workers? Research on Social Work Practice 16, 392-405.

35.

Rosenthal, J. A. , & Waters, E. (2004, July). Retention and performance in public child welfare in Oklahoma: Focus on the child welfare professional enhancement program graduates. Paper presented at Weaving Resources for Better Child Welfare Outcomes Conference, Santa Fe, NM.

36.

Rycus, J. S. , & Hughes, R. C. (1998). Field guide to child welfare. Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America.

37.

U.S. General Accounting Office . (2003, March). HHS could play a greater role in helping child welfare agencies recruit and retain staff (GAO-03-357). Washington, DC: Author.

38.

Whitaker, T. , & Clark, E. J. (2006). Social workers in child welfare: Ready for duty. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 412-413.%

39.

Zlotnik, J. (1993). Social work education and public human services: Developing partnerships. Alexandria, VA: Council on Social Work Education.

40.

Zlotnik, J. (2002). Preparing social workers for child welfare practice: Lessons from an historical review of the literature. Journal of Health & Social Policy 15(3/4), 5-22.

41.

Zlotnik, J. (2003). The use of Title IV-E training funds for social work education: An historical perspective. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 7, 5-20.

42.

Zlotnik, J. L. (2006). No simple answers to a complex question: A response to Perry. Research on Social Work Practice 16, 414-416.%

43.

Zlotnik, J. L. , & Cornelius, L. (2000). Preparing social work students for child welfare careers: The use of Title IV-E training funds in social work education. Journal of Baccalaureate Social Work 5(2), 1-14.