Passive Damping Characterization of Parabolic Composite Reflectors with Hybrid PZT-Coated Layers

Abstract

Passive vibration damping of smart structural systems can be obtained using thin hybrid layers of visco-elastic Magnetostrictive powders as per the literature survey. Although these materials can be used for damping of thin flexible structural systems, they have some practical limitations in the domain of microwave antenna applications. This is due to, Electro-Magnetic Interference (EMI) and Electro-Magnetic Coupling (EMC) issues at higher transmit and receive radio frequencies. In this article, an attempt has been made to investigate the use of thin layers of highly sensitive ferroelectrically soft piezo electric ceramic material powders in lieu of Magnetostrictive powders for passive vibration damping effects. This investigation is on Carbon Fiber Reinforced Plastic (CFRP) and Glass Fiber Reinforced Plastic (GFRP) composite materials at ambient temperature for microwave antenna applications. Piezo ceramic hybrid polymeric coatings on parabolic reflectors have been envisaged to prevent EMI interference for antenna applications. At the same time these coatings are investigated experimentally and numerically in the passive vibration domain for energy dissipation due to their viscoelastic behavior and their electro-elastic coupling phenomena. Strain dependent material damping in the thin piezoceramic passive layers is a nonlinear behavior. To facilitate a simple proof of concept exercise at present, the nonlinear effects and hysteresis have been ignored in the Finite Element Analysis (FEA). FE model with piezo layer has been generated in ATILA, a software for modeling smart structures and structural systems for piezo coated reflector for undamped free vibration analysis. However, the material hysteresis losses and nonlinearities of the smart materials have not been considered in the model to simplify the proof of concept exercise. Moreover, damping increase due to epoxy and interactions between epoxy and PZT powder have not been investigated presently in this article. A 0.3 m diameter CFRP parabolic reflector along with a 0.7 m diameter. GFRP reflector has been developed using thin hybrid piezoceramic coating on the convex side of the reflector. As a corollary to the investigation, from the practical utility point of view, for piezo-coated structural elements in microwave antenna domain; efforts have also been put in the direction of studying the EMI/EMC by experimental investigations. The piezo-coated antenna feed support (spars) made up of Plasma activated Teflon (which is dielectric and Radio Frequency (RF) transparent) along with piezo-coated reflectors have been electrically tested with an intention of investigating the improvement of antenna efficiency due to reduction of RF blockage. Usually, conventional composite/metal spars are used and they cause RF blockage and reduce efficiency for some typical Radio Frequencies. The thin hybrid layers of these ceramic materials when coated on composite substrates have yielded benefits in passive vibration damping domain. Experimental damping investigations have shown an effective increase in modal damping at resonant frequencies with an added advantage of marginal change in stiffness for the coated composite specimens with a negligible weight penalty at ambient temperature. The 0.7 m diameter parabolic reflector made up of GFRP with thin hybrid piezoceramic coating has been tested at Compact Antenna Test Facility (CATF) at SAC/ISRO Ahmedabad, India and practically no EMI/EMC interface issues have been reported at 11.6 GHz transmit (Ku band) frequencies for Prime Fed (PF) type reflectors. The encouraging results have been observed w.r.t. the increased passive damping by putting thin hybrid piezo layer on one side of composite reflector substrates at resonant frequencies. Additional advantage observed is that it is without EMI interference and results in improved efficiency of microwave reflectors due to reduced blockage by using piezo powder-coated almost RF transparent Teflon spars. This may make the present investigation a possible candidate for RF applications in future for microwave antennas. It may also help in micro-vibrations control of futuristic spacecraft reflectors in orbit for today's sophisticated Earth observation satellites with improved pointing accuracies and resolutions.

Keywords

PZT (Lead Zirconate Titanate) patches EMI magnetostrictive powders CFRP KFRP damping oberst vibrating beam technique.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agrawal, B.N. and Treanor, K.E. 1999. ``Shape Control of a Beam Using Piezoelectric Actuators,'' Smart Materials Structure, pp. 729-740, printed in the UK.

Allaei, D. 1994. ``Vibration and Noise Control in Civil Structures by Smart Design,'' In: 2nd European Conference on Smart Structure and Materials, Glasgow, Scotland, 12-14, Oct 1994, SPIE, Vol. 2361, pp. 198-201.

American Standard Test Method - Designation ASTM E-756-98 1998. Measuring Vibration Damping Properties of Materials.

Andoh, F. , Washington, G. , Yoon, H.-S. and Utkin, V. 2004. ``Efficient Shape Control of Distributed Reflectors with Discrete Piezoelectric Actuators,'' Journal of Intelligent Material Systems & Structures, 15:3-15.

Bhattacharya, B. 1997. ``Studies on the Dynamics and Control of Smart Laminated Composite Beams and Plates,'' PhD Thesis, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India, 1997 .

Bhattacharya, B. , Vidyashankar, B.R. , Patsias, S. and Tomlinson, G.R. 2000. ``Active and Passive Vibration Control of Flexible Structures using a Combination of Magnetostrictive and Ferro-magnetic Alloys,'' Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Seffield, UK.

Breitbach, E.J. , Lammering, R. , Melcher, J. and Nitzsche, F. 1994. ``Smart Structures Research in Aerospace Engineering (Invited paper),'' In: 2nd European Conference on Smart Structures and Materials', Glasgow, Scotland, 12-14, 1994, SPIE, Vol. 2361, pp. 11-18.

Chen, S.H. , Yao, G.F. and Lian, H.D. 2001. ``A New Piezoelectric Shell Element and its Applications in Static Shape Control,'' Structural Engineering and Mechanics , 12(5):491-506.

Chong, K.P. , Liu, S.C. and Li, J.C. 1990. ``Intelligent Structures,'' In: Proceedings of the International Workshop on Intelligent Structures', Taipei, Taiwan, 23-26 July 1990.

10.

Collin, R.E. 1985. Antenna And Radio Wave Propagation, Mc Graw-Hill, New York.

11.

Datashvili, L. , Nathrath, N. , Lang, M. , Baier, H. , Fasold, D. , Pellegrino, S. , Soykasap, O. , Kueh, A. , Mangenot, C. and Santiago-Prowald, J. 2002. ``New Concepts And Reflecting Materials For Space Borne Large Deployable Reflector Antennas'', www.llb.mw.tum.de/download/43_lang_final.pdf-2444k

12.

Davidson, R. 1990. ``The Current Status and Future Prospects of Smart Composites,'' In: Proceedings ESA Symposium, Advanced Engineering Materials Department Interface, AEA Technology, Harwell Oxon, Oxll URA, pp. 429-436.

13.

Dittrich, K.W. 2000. ``Multifunctional Structures for Aerospace Applications,'' Dornier Luftfahrt Gmbh, P. O. Box 1303, D-7990, Fredrichshafen.

14.

Divakaran, R.M. , Sunilkumar, G. , Unnikrishnan, V.P. , Atmaram, S. and Rath, A.K. 1998. ``Development of Conical Metallic Honeycomb Sandwich Structures for Launch Vehicle Applications,'' IE (I) Journal -AS , 78:34-37.

15.

Ernst, T. , Lang, M. , Lori, M. , Schoppinger, C. and Santiago-Prowald, J. 2005. ``Highly Stable Q/V Band Reflector Material Trade-off and Thermo-Elastic Analysis'' In: Proceedings of 28th ESA Antenna Workshop on Space Antenna Systems and Technologies, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, May 2005.

16.

Ganguli, A. , Jhawar, S. and Seshu, P. 2002. ``Shape Control of Curved Beams Using Piezoelectric Actuators, '' In: Proceedings of ISSS-SPIE 2002, December 12-14, 2002, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India, pp. 247-254.

17.

Garba, J.A. , Wada, B.K. et al. 1991. `Adaptive Structures For Precision Controlled Large Space Systems', In: Proceedings International Conference, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, The Netherlands, 24-26 April 1991 (ESA SP - 321, Oct 1991).

18.

Gupta, V.K. , Seshu, P. and Issac, K.K. 2004. ``Finite Element and Experimental Investigation of Piezoelectric Actuated Smart Shells,'' AIAA Journal, 42:2112-2123.

19.

Hwang, W.-S. and Park, H.C. 1993. ``Finite Element Modeling & Piezoelectric Sensors and Actuators,'' AIAA Journal, 31(5): 537-542.

20.

International Vehicle Recommended Practice - SAE J1637, 1998. ``Laboratory Measurement of the Composite Vibration Damping Properties of Materials on a Supporting Steel Bar''.

21.

Jpa Nasa. 1993 ``Piezoelectrically Adjustable Array of Antenna Reflectors,'' In: NASA Tech Brief , 17(8):19-33.

22.

Krishna Murty, A.V. , Anjanappa, M. , Wu, Y. , Bhattacharya, B. and Bhat, M.S. 1998

``Vibration Suppression of Laminated Composite Beams Using Embedded Magnetostrictive Layers,''

IE (I) Journal -AS , 78:38-44.

23.

Krishna Murthy, A.V. , Tamil Mani, K. , Subramaniyam, P. , et al, ``Smart Antenna Demonstration Model,'' Centre for Airborne systems, Belur, Yemlur (P.O.). Bangalore- 560037, SPIE 96, p. 3, Souvenir of Abstracts Bangalore- IISc.

24.

Lang, M. , Baier, H. and Ernst, T. 2004. ``High Precision Thin Shell Reflectors - Design Concepts, Structural Optimization And Shape Adjustment Technique'', www.llb.mw.tum.de/download/43_lang_final.pdf-2444k

25.

Lerch, R. 2000. ``CAE Tools for Piezoelectric Sensors,'' International Journal of Computer Applications in Technology, pp. 191-197.

26.

Mathur, A.C. , Munjal, B.S. and Purohit, D.S. 1994. ``SATCOM Antennas - A Futuristic mechanical Approach,'' In: Proceedings of APSYM CUSAT 94, Department of electronics Nov. 17-19, 1994, Cochin, pp. 303-306.

27.

Munjal, B.S. 2006. ``Finite Element Analysis of Smart Skin Spacecraft Reflectors using Smart/Intelligent Materials and Smart Structural Systems,'' PhD Thesis Submitted to Gujarat University, Ahmedabad, India.

28.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. and Sarma, P.V.B.A.S. 2002. ``Piezo Actuated Parabolic Aluminum Reflectors - A Shape Deformation Investigation'', In: National Conference on Smart Structures and MEMS Systems for Aerospace Applications, Research Centre Imarat (RCI), Vigyanakancha, Hyderabad, Session 6, AB50, 1-2 December 2006.

29.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. and Sarma, P.V.B.A.S. 2004. ``Graphite and Kevlar Composites with Thin Piezoceramic Powder (SP4 & SP-5A) Coatings using RF Plasma Etching Technique for vibration Damping Benefits,'' Plasma Processing Update, Golden Jubilee Issue, July 2006, pp. 41-42.

30.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. , Mathur, A.C. and Sarma, P.V.B.A.S. 2005. ``Finite Element & Experimental Shape Studies of Parabolic Antenna Reflectors using Discreet Piezoelectric Actuators,'' Session XIX (19th) Mechanical Design of Antennas Session, In: International Conference on Antennas Technology (ICAT-2005), Feb 23-24 2005, Space Applications Centre, ISRO, Ahmedabad.

31.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. and Sarma, P.V.B.A.S. 2006. ``An Experimental Investigation of Composite Loss Factor for CFRP/GFRP Laminates with Smart Material Coatings at Ambient Temperature'', National Conference on Current Trends in Technology (NUCONE-2006), Nov. 30 to Dec. 2, 2006), pp. 49-53.

32.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. and Sarma, P.V.B.A.S. 2007. ``Surface Activation of Hydrophobic Graphite Composite Laminates by RF Plasma Etching for Piezoceramic Powder Coated Spacecraft Reflector,'' In: Proceedings of the CASST-2007 Symposium IISc Bangalore, Jan 18-20, 2007.

33.

Munjal, B.S. , Trivedi, H.V. and Sarma, P.V.B. A.S. 2007. ``Vibration Damping on Graphite and Kevlar Composites using Piezoceramic Powder Coatings: A Review,'' The Shock and Vibration Digest, 39(1):3-18.

34.

Newnham, R.E. 1993. Smart, Very Smart and Intelligent Materials, MRS Bulletin/April 1993.

35.

Scragg, J. 1990. ``Development of Intelligent Structures'', In: Proc. ESA Symposium, Space Applications of Advanced Structural Material, Noordwijk (NL), 21-23 March 1990.

36.

Stevens, T. 1991. ``Structures Get Smart,'' Materials Engineering, Oct 1991, pp. 18-30.

37.

Tan, L.T. and Pellegrino, S. 2002. ``Stiffened Springback Reflectors'' In: 25th ESA Antenna Workshop on Satellite Antenna Technology, 18-20 September 2002, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, pp. 755-762.

38.

Washington, G. 2004. ``Design, Modeling and Development of Precision Apertures,'' Intelligent Structures and Systems Laboratory, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210-1107.

39.

Yoon, H.-S. and Washington, G. 1998. ``Piezoceramic Actuated Aperture Antennae,'' Smart Structure, pp. 537-542, printed in UK.