Most prior research on religion and crime focuses on predictors of criminal behavior and neglects victimization. Studies of religion and victimization generally examine religion-based hate crimes. We present a theory of religion-based victimization drawing on routine activities theory, emphasizing how particular religious beliefs and practices may increase one’s vulnerability to predatory crime victimization due to opportunity, not hate. We draw on newspaper reports and secondary data to illustrate our theoretical propositions.
AdamczykAFreilichJDKimC (2017) Religion and crime: a systematic review and assessment of next steps. Sociology of Religion78(2): 192–232.
3.
ArnoldRKeaneCBaronS (2005) Assessing the risk of victimization through epidemiological concepts: an alternative analytic strategy applied to routine activities theory. Canadian Review of Sociology & Anthropology42(3): 345–364.
4.
BaierCJWrightBRE (2001) If you love me, keep my commandments: a meta-analysis of the effect of religion on crime. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency38(1): 3–21.
5.
BartkowskiJPHowellFMLaiS-C (2002) Spatial variations in church burnings: the social ecology of victimized communities in the south. Rural Sociology67(4): 578–602.
6.
BennettRR (1991) Development and crime: a cross‐national, time‐series analysis of competing models. The Sociological Quarterly32(3): 343–363.
7.
BournsWWrightWD (2004) A study of church vulnerability to violence: implications for law enforcement. Journal of Criminal Justice32(2): 151–157.
8.
BrantinghamPLBrantinghamPJ (1995) Criminality of place: crime generators and crime attractors. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research3(3): 5–26.
9.
ByersBD (2008) Amish victimization and offending: a rural subculture’s experiences and responses to crime and justice. Journal of Rural Social Sciences23: 27.
10.
ByersBDCriderBW (2002) Hate crimes against the Amish: a qualitative analysis of bias motivation using routine activities theory. Deviant Behavior23(2): 115–148.
11.
ByersBJonesJA (2007) The impact of the terrorist attacks of 9/11 on anti-Islamic hate crime. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice5(1): 43–56.
12.
CherryP (1998) Jews Work to Rebuild Police Links: Careful Contacts that Were Established between Orthodox Jews and MUC Police were Lost with Reorganization of Police Stations. Now, they’re Talking Again to Stop Sabbath Burglaries. Final edition. Montreal, QC: The Gazette.
13.
ChitwoodDDWeissMLLeukefeldCG (2008) A systematic review of recent literature on religiosity and substance use. Journal of Drug Issues38(3): 653–688.
14.
CohenLEFelsonM (1979) Social change and crime rate trends: a routine activity approach. American Sociological Review44: 588–608.
15.
CohenLEKlugelJRLandKC (1981) Social inequality and predatory criminal victimization: an exposition and test of a formal theory. American Sociological Review46: 505–524.
16.
ConradB (2017) Southern Hillsdale County Plagued by Unusual Rise in Number of Burglaries. The Hillsdale Collegian. Hillsdale, MI: Hillsdale College.
17.
CorcoranKEScheitleCPHudnallEB (2019) Organizational activities and property-crime victimization. The Sociological Quarterly61(1): 164–186.
18.
CorcoranKESteinREColyerCJ, et al. (2021) Familial ties, location of occupation, and congregational exit in geographically-based congregations: a case study of the Amish. Review of Religious Research63: 245–268.
19.
CullenB (1988) Father and Son Accused in Sabbath Silver Thefts. Washington, DC: United Press International.
20.
DiamondE (2000) And I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
21.
DishaICavendishJCKingRD (2011) Historical events and spaces of hate: hate crimes against Arabs and Muslims in post-9/11 America. Social Problems58(1): 21–46.
22.
DonnermeyerJ (2024) The crime experiences of the Amish. The Journal of Plain Anabaptist Communities4(1): 23–48.
DuncanEJ (2008) The positive effects of legalizing polygamy: ‘love is a many splendored thing’. Duke Journal of Gender Law & Policy15(2): 315–338.
25.
DundesA (2002) The Shabbat Elevator and Other Sabbath Subterfuges: An Unorthodox Essay on Circumventing Custom and Jewish Character. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
26.
EbaughHRFO’BrienJChafetzJS (2000) The social ecology of residential patterns and membership in immigrant congregations. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion39(1): 107–116.
27.
EckJEChaineySCameronJG, et al. (2005) Mapping Crime: Understanding Hot Spots. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
FelsonM (1998) Crime and Everyday Life. 2nd edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
30.
FisherBSWilkesARP (2003) A tale of two ivory towers: a comparative analysis of victimization rates and risks between university students in the United States and England. British Journal of Criminology43(3): 526–545.
31.
FisherBSSloanJJCullenFT, et al. (1998) Crime in the ivory tower: the level and sources of student victimization. Criminology36(3): 671–709.
32.
HarrisonB (2002) Sabbath Burglars Targeted Jews: Cops. New York, NY: The New York Post.
HirschiTStarkR (1969) Hellfire and delinquency. Social Problems17(2): 202–213.
35.
HooberJMIII (1999) 3 Held for Church-Time Break-Ins at Local Farms. Lancaster, PA: Lancaster New Era.
36.
HurstCEMcConnellDL (2010) An Amish Paradox: Diversity and Change in the World’s Largest Amish Community. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press. Young Center books in anabaptist and pietist studies.
37.
IannacconeLR (1994) Why strict churches are strong. American Journal of Sociology99(5): 1180–1211.
38.
Intelligencer Journal Staff (1999) Maryland men get 5-10 years for Amish burglaries. Intelligencer Journal.
39.
JohnsonBRLiSDLarsonDB, et al. (2000) A systematic review of the religiosity and delinquency literature. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice16(1): 32–52.
40.
KaufmanSBNinerH (2019) Muslim victimization in the contemporary US: clarifying the racialization thesis. Critical Criminology27(3): 485–502.
41.
KeaneCArnoldR (1996) Examining the relationship between criminal victimization and accidents: a routine activities approach. Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue canadienne de sociologie33(4): 457–479.
KennedyLWFordeDR (1990) Routine activities and crime: an analysis of victimization in Canada. Criminology28(1): 137–152.
44.
KraybillDB (2001) The Riddle of Amish Culture. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
45.
LitvakSKivivuoriJKaakinenM (2024) Preventing religion-based hate crime victimization among youth: a systematic review of personal, collective, and policy responses. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse25(5): 3696–3712.
46.
LynchJP (1987) Routine activity and victimization at work. Journal of Quantitative Criminology3: 283–300.
47.
McCordESRatcliffeJHGarciaRM, et al. (2007) Nonresidential crime attractors and generators elevate perceived neighborhood crime and incivilities. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency44(3): 295–320.
48.
MichalkoG (2004) Tourism eclipsed by crime: the vulnerability of foreign tourists in Hungary. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing15(2–3): 159–172.
49.
MietheTDDrassKA (1999) Exploring the social contest of instrumental and expressive homicides: an application of qualitative comparative analysis. Journal of Quantitative Criminology15: 1–21.
50.
MietheTDMcDowallD (1993) Contextual effects in models of criminal victimization. Social Forces71(3): 741–759.
51.
MietheTDMeierRF (1990) Opportunity, choice, and criminal victimization: a test of a theoretical model. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency27: 243–266.
52.
MietheTDMeierRF (1994) Crime and its Social Context: Toward an Integrated Theory of Offenders, Victims, and Situations. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
53.
MurrayRKSwattML (2013) Disaggregating the relationship between schools and crime: a spatial analysis. Crime & Delinquency59(2): 163–190.
54.
MythenGWalklateSKhanF (2009) ‘I’m a Muslim, but I’m not a terrorist’: victimization, risky identities and the performance of safety. British Journal of Criminology49(6): 736–754.
55.
NolanJJIIIAkiyamaYBerhanuS (2002) The hate crime statistics act of 1990: developing a method for measuring the occurrence of hate violence. American Behavioral Scientist46(1): 136–153.
56.
NolanJJIIIMcDevittJCroninS, et al. (2004) Learning to see hate crimes: a framework for understanding and clarifying ambiguities in bias crime classification. Criminal Justice Studies17(1): 91–105.
57.
NoltSM (2016) The Amish: A Concise Introduction. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
58.
OjedokunUAOduoyeOO (2020) Property theft in places of worship in Osogbo City, Nigeria. Crime, Law and Social Change73(4): 475–490.
59.
OsborneSPRadnorZStrokoschK (2016) Co-Production and the Co-Creation of Value in Public Services: a suitable case for treatment?Public Management Review18(5): 639–653.
60.
RomanCG (2004) Schools, Neighborhoods, and Violence: Crime within the Daily Routines of Youth. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
61.
SalmiVKiviuoriJLehtiM (2015) Public disorder and business crime victimization in the retail sector. Security Journal28(4): 410–424.
62.
ScheitleCP (2016) Crimes occurring at places of worship: an analysis of 2012 newspaper reports. International Review of Victimology22(1): 65–74.
63.
ScheitleCP (2018) Religious congregations’ experiences with, fears of, and preparations for crime: results from a national survey. Review of Religious Research60(1): 95–113.
64.
ScheitleCPHansmannM (2016) Religion-related hate crimes: data, trends, and limitations. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion55(4): 859–873.
65.
ScheitleCPUlmerJT (2018) Profane concerns in sacred spaces: the challenges and consequences of implementing security measures in religious congregations. Journal of Applied Security Research13(1): 29–44.
66.
SchererHLReynsBW (2019) Visible disabilities and risk of interpersonal victimization. In: BerryB (ed) Appearance Bias and Crime. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 243–255.
67.
SchreckCJBurekMWClark-MillerJ (2007) He sends rain upon the wicked: a panel study of the influence of religiosity on violent victimization. Journal of Interpersonal Violence22(7): 872–893.
SouleSAVan DykeN (1999) Black Church Arson in the United States, 1989-1996. Ethnic and Racial Studies22(4): 724–742.
70.
StarkRFinkeR (2000) Acts of Faith: Explaining the Human Side of Religion. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
71.
StaubliSKivivuoriJ (2017) Youth crime victimization and religion: observations from Finland and Switzerland. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention18(2): 200–209.
72.
SteinRE (2010) The utility of country structure: a cross-national multilevel analysis of property and violent victimization. International Criminal Justice Review20(1): 35–55.
73.
The Associated Press State & Local Wire (2004) Amish targeted in series of burglaries in northeast Ohio. Middlefield, OH: The Associated Press State & Local Wire.
74.
The Guardian Staff (1987) Burglaries Overshadow the Sabbath. London: The Guardian.
75.
ThomasH (2004) Trial Begins in 2002 Bremen Burglary; 23-Year-Old Accused of Breaking into Amish Home as Family Attended Church. South Bend, IN: South Bend Tribune.
76.
TilleyNWebbJ (1994) Burglary Reduction: Findings from Safer Cities Schemes. Crime Prevention Unit Paper 51. London: Home Office.
77.
UlmerJTScheitleCP (2020) Religious congregations and crime incidents: opportunity and bias. Journal of Crime and Justice43(2): 193–211.
78.
VerburgS (2016) String of Sunday Break-Ins Targets Wisconsin’s Amish in Four Counties. Madison, WI: The Daily Cardinal.
79.
WeaverAJFlannellyKJStrockAL (2004) A review of research on the effects of religion on adolescent tobacco use published between 1990 and 2003. Adolescence40(160): 761–776.
80.
Wilcox RountreePLandKC (1996) Burglary victimization, perceptions of crime risk, and routine activities: a multilevel analysis across Seattle neighborhoods and census tracts. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency33: 146–180.
81.
Wilcox RountreePLandKCMietheTD (1994) Macro-micro integration in the study of victimization: a hierarchical logistic model analysis across Seattle neighborhoods. Criminology32: 387–414.
WilsonMM (2014) Hate Crime Victimization, 2004–2012 - Statistical Tables. NCJ 244409. Department of Justice: Bureau of Justice Statistics. Available at: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hcv0412st.pdf (accessed 15 May 2021).
84.
WittmerJ (1971) Cultural violence and twentieth century progress. Practical Anthropology18(4): 146–155.
85.
WoodsJB (2009) Taking the “hate” out of hate crimes: applying unfair advantage theory to justify the enhanced punishment of opportunistic bias crimes. UCLA Law Review56(2): 489–541.
86.
YeungJWChanY-CLeeBLK (2009) Youth religiosity and substance use: a meta-analysis from 1995 to 2007. Psychological Reports105(1): 255–266.
87.
ZavalaEMunizCN (2022) The influence of religious involvement on intimate partner violence victimization via routine activities theory. Journal of Interpersonal Violence37(3–4): 1133–1157.
