Between universalism and targeting: Exploring policy pathways for an Australian Basic Income

Abstract

Despite growing interest in proposals for a universal basic income, little advance has been made in implementation. Here we explore policy options for an Australian Basic Income. Our analysis responds to concerns that Basic Income is both too expensive and too radical a departure from existing welfare state structures to be a feasible policy option. Drawing on policy and Basic Income scholarship we identify changes to Australia’s current means-tested benefits structures that move substantially towards Basic Income while remaining consistent with historic policy norms, which we call ‘affluence testing’. Using microsimulation we explore fiscal and distributional trade-offs associated with the implementation of an affluence-tested Basic Income. Our results suggest Basic Income has the potential to significantly reduce inequality and poverty while also requiring taxes to rise substantially. Placing these trade-offs in international context we find the policy would reduce inequality to levels similar to Nordic welfare states while increasing overall taxation to approximately the OECD average.

JEL Codes: I3, H2, H5

Keywords

Basic income fiscal policy income distribution social policy taxation/taxation system/taxation policy welfare state

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackerman

Alstott

Van Parijs

(2006) Redesigning Distribution. Madison, WI: Real Utopias Project.

Adkins

Ylöstalo

(2020) Experimenting with wellbeing: Basic Income, immaterial labour and changing forms of productivity. Critical Sociology. Epub ahead of print 9 July. DOI: 10.1177/0896920520940011.

Arthur

(2016) Basic Income: A Radical Idea Enters the Mainstream. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Department of Parliamentary Services, Parliamentary Library.

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (1999) Special article – Casual employment. ABS Catalogue Number 6203.0, Canberra, ACT, Australian: Bureau of Statistics.

Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN) (2016) The Basic Income Earth Network’s definition of basic income since the GA 2016. Basic Income Earth Network. Available at: https://basicincome.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Basic-Income-definition-longer-explanation-1.pdf (accessed 7 September 2020).

Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN) (2019) What is basic income? Basic Income Earth Network. Available at: https://basicincome.org/basic-income/ (accessed 20 May 2020).

Beggs

(2015) Inflation and the Making of Australian Macroeconomic Policy, 1945–85. London: Springer.

Brady

Bostic

(2015) Paradoxes of social policy: welfare transfers, relative poverty, and redistribution preferences. American Sociological Review 80(2): 268–298.

Bryan

Rafferty

(2018) Risking Together: How Finance Is Dominating Everyday Life in Australia. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Sydney University Press.

10.

Campbell

Burgess

(2018) Patchy progress? Two decades of research on precariousness and precarious work in Australia. Labour & Industry 28(1): 48–67.

11.

Carney

Stanford

(2018) The Dimensions of Insecure Work: A Factbook. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Centre for Future Work.

12.

Castles

(1985) The Working Class and Welfare: Reflections on the Political Development of the Welfare State in Australia and New Zealand, 1890-1980. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.

13.

Commonwealth of Australia (2019) Budget Paper No 1 – Budget strategy and outlook. Available at: https://budget.gov.au/2019-20/content/documents.htm (accessed 10 September 2020).

14.

Cowan

(2017) Ubi–Universal Basic Income Is an Unbelievably Bad Idea. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Centre for Independent Studies.

15.

Dawkins

Johnson

Scutella

, et al. (1998) Towards a negative income tax system for Australia. Australian Economic Review 31(3): 237–257.

16.

De Wispelaere

Noguera

(2012) On the political feasibility of universal basic income: an analytic framework. In: Caputo

(ed.) Basic Income Guarantee and Politics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 17–38.

17.

De Wispelaere

Halmetoja

Pulkka

(2018) The rise (and fall) of the basic income experiment in Finland. CESifo Forum 19(3): 15–19.

18.

Dean

(2020) Is this the beginning of a Universal Basic Income? Yahoo! Finance, 10 April. Available at: https://au.finance.yahoo.com/news/will-coronavirus-force-australia-to-have-permanent-ubi-202657769.html (accessed 26 May 2020).

19.

Esping-Andersen

(1999) Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies. New York: Oxford University Press.

20.

Fisher

Zhu

(2019) The effect of changing financial incentives on repartnering. The Economic Journal 129(623): 2833–2866.

21.

Fraser

Gordon

(1994) A genealogy of dependency: tracing a keyword of the US welfare state. Signs 19(2): 309–336.

22.

Friedman

(1968) The case for the negative income tax: a view from the right. In: Bunzel

(ed.) Issues of American Public Policy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, pp. 111–120.

23.

Friedman

(1982) Capitalism and Freedom. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.

24.

Gentilini

Grosh

(2020) UBI as social assistance: comparative models and instruments. In: Gentilini

Grosh

Rigolini

, et al (eds) Exploring Universal Basic Income: A Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence and Practices. Washington, DC: World Bank, pp. 73–98.

25.

Hacker

(2006) The Great Risk Shift: The Assault on American Jobs, Families, Health Care and Retirement. Cambridge, MA: Polity Press.

26.

Harvey

(2006) The relative cost of a universal basic income and a negative income tax. Basic Income Studies 1(2): 6.

27.

Honkanen

(2014) Basic income and negative income tax: a comparison with a simulation model. Basic Income Studies 9(1–2): 119–135.

28.

Hoynes

Rothstein

(2019) Universal Basic Income in the US and advanced countries. NBER working paper no. 25538, Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

29.

Humphreys

(2005) Reform 30/30: Rebuilding Australia’s Tax and Welfare Systems. Perspectives on Tax Reform 10(10). Sydney, NSW, Australia: Centre for Independent Studies.

30.

Ingles

(2000) Rationalising the interaction of tax and social security: Part II: Fundamental reform options. Discussion paper no. 424. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Centre for Economic Policy Research.

31.

Ingles

Phillips

Stewart

(2019) A basic income for Australia? Exploring rationale, design, distribution and cost. Working paper no. 8-2019. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Centre for Social Research and Methods.

32.

Kesper

Elvery

Spraggon

(2019) Budget 2019: where every dollar comes from, and how it’s spent. ABC News. Available at: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-04-03/federal-budget-2019-sliced-and-diced-interactive/10959808#spending/breakdown/2020/other-purposes (accessed 20 May 2020).

33.

Korpi

Palme

(1998) The paradox of redistribution and strategies of equality: welfare state institutions, inequality, and poverty in the Western countries. American Sociological Review 63(5): 661–687.

34.

Langmore

Quiggin

(1994) Work for All: Full Employment in the Nineties. Melbourne, VIC: Melbourne University Press.

35.

Lefèbvre

(2007) The redistributive effects of pension systems in Europe: A survey of evidence. Working paper 457, Luxemburg Income Studies, Working Paper Series. Available at: http://www.lisdatacenter.org/wps/liswps/457.pdf (accessed 7 September 2020).

36.

McDonald

Marston

(2005) Workfare as welfare: governing unemployment in the advanced liberal state. Critical Social Policy 25(3): 374–401.

37.

McFarland

(2018) Overview of current basic income related experiments. Basic Income News. Available at: https://basicincome.org/news/2017/10/overview-of-current-basic-income-related-experiments-october-2017/ (accessed 20 May 2020).

38.

McKnight

(2015) A fresh look at an old question: Is pro-poor targeting of cash transfers more effective than universal systems at reducing inequality and poverty? ImPRovE working paper no. 15/14. Antwerp: Herman Deleeck Centre for Social Policy – University of Antwerp.

39.

Martinelli

(2017) Assessing the case for a Universal Basic Income in the UK. IPR Policy Brief September 2017. Bath: Institute for Policy Research, University of Bath.

40.

Martinelli

(2019) A basic income trilemma: affordability, adequacy, and the advantages of universal and unconditional welfare. Journal of Social Policy 49(3): 461–482.

41.

Marx

Salanauskaite

Verbist

(2013) The paradox of redistribution revisited: And that it may rest in peace? IZA discussion paper no 7414. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2276306 (accessed 20 May 2020).

42.

Meade

(1993) Liberty, Equality and Efficiency: Apologia Pro Agathotopia Mea. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

43.

Mestan

(2014) Paternalism in Australian welfare policy. Australian Journal of Social Issues 49(1): 3–22.

44.

Moffatt

(2004) The idea of a negative income tax: past, present, and future. Focus 23(2): 1–8.

45.

Office for National Statistics (ONS) (2020) Gross Domestic Product at Market Prices: Current Price: Seasonally Adjusted £m. London: Office for National Statistics.

46.

Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2017) Basic income as a policy option: Can it add up? Policy Brief on the Future of Work. Paris: OECD Publishing. Available at: https://www.oecd.org/els/emp/Basic-Income-Policy-Option-2017.pdf (accessed 7 September 2020).

47.

Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2019a) Budgeting and Public Expenditures in OECD Countries 2019. Paris: OECD Publishing.

48.

Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2019b) OECD.Stat database. Available at: https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=IDD (accessed 19 September 2020).

49.

Ortiz-Ospina

Roser

(2016) Taxation. Ourworldindata.org. Available at: https://ourworldindata.org/taxation (accessed 7 September 2020).

50.

Paine

(2000) Agrarian justice [1797]. In: Kuklick

(ed.) Paine: Political Writings. Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 319–338.

51.

Painter

Thoung

(2015) Creative Citizen, Creative State: The Principled and Pragmatic Case for a Universal Basic Income. London: RSA (Royal Society for the encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce).

52.

Peck

(2001) Workfare States. New York: Guilford Press.

53.

Peetz

(2006) Brave New Workplace: How Individual Contracts Are Changing Our Jobs. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.

54.

Phillips

(2018) Research note: Modelling a Basic Income for Australia – Simple example of a universal pension funded by increased personal income taxation. CSRM research note no. 2/2018. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian National University.

55.

Pierson

(1998) Irresistible forces, immovable objects: post-industrial welfare states confront permanent austerity. Journal of European Social Policy 5(4): 539–560.

56.

Piketty

(2020) Capital and Ideology. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

57.

PolicyMod (2019) Modelling For Affluence-Tested Basic Income Scenarios. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Centre for Social Research and Methods, Australian National University.

58.

Raise the Rate (2019) About raise the rate. Available at: https://raisetherate.org.au/about/ (accessed 7 September 2020).

59.

Reed

Lansley

(2016) Universal Basic Income: An Idea Whose Time has Come? London: Compass.

60.

Spies-Butcher

(2020) Advancing universalism in neoliberal times? Basic income, workfare and the politics of conditionality. Critical Sociology 46(4–5): 589–603.

61.

Spies-Butcher

Henderson

(2019) Stepping stones to an Australian basic income. In: Klein

Mays

Dunlop

(eds) Implementing a Basic Income in Australia. Exploring the Basic Income Guarantee. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 163–178.

62.

Standing

(2017) Basic Income: And How We Can Make It Happen. London: Penguin Books.

63.

Stanford

(2019) A turning point for labour market policy in Australia. Economic and Labour Relations Review 30(2): 177–199.

64.

Stern

(2016) Raising the Floor: How a Universal Basic Income Can Renew Our Economy and Rebuild the American Dream. New York: Public Affairs.

65.

Susskind

(2020) A World without Work: Technology, Automation, and How We Should Respond. London: Allen Lane.

66.

The Independent (2020) Why more than 500 political figures and academics globally have called for universal basic income in the fight against coronavirus. The Independent, 18 March. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/letters/coronavirus-universal-basic-income-ubi-poverty-economy-business-migrants-a9408846.html (accessed 26 May 2020).

67.

Tobin

Pechman

Mieszkowski

(1967) Is a negative income tax practical? The Yale Law Journal 27(1): 1–27.

68.

Torry

(2020) Evaluation of a Recovery Basic Income, and of a sustainable revenue neutral Citizen’s Basic Income, with an appendix relating to different Universal Credit rollout scenarios. Euromod working paper series EM 07/20. Available at: https://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/research/publications/working-papers/euromod/em7-20.pdf (accessed 7 September 2020).

69.

US Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) (2020) Table 1.17.5. Gross domestic product, gross domestic income, and other major NIPA aggregates. Available at: https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?reqid=19&step=2#reqid=19&step=2&isuri=1&1921=survey (accessed 16 September).

70.

Van Lancker

Van Mechelen

(2015) Universalism under siege? Exploring the association between targeting, child benefits and child poverty across 26 countries. Social Science Research 50: 60–75.

71.

Whiteford

(2017) Trends in income inequality in Australia. Australian Quarterly 88(3): 30–36.

72.

Whiteford

Heron

(2018) Dealing with non-standard work in a general revenue financed social protection system – the case of Australia. In: OECD (ed.) The Future of Social Protection: What Works for Non-Standard Workers? Available at: https://www.oecd.org/social/Future-of-social-protection.pdf (accessed 7 September 2020).

73.

Widerquist

Noguera

Vanderborght

, et al. (eds) (2013) Basic Income: An Anthology of Contemporary Research. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.

74.

Wilson

Ebert

(2013) Precarious work: Economic, sociological and political perspectives. Economic and Labour Relations Review 24(3): 263–278.

75.

Wilson

Spies-Butcher

Stebbing

, et al. (2013) Wage earners’ welfare after economic reform: refurbishing, retrenching or hollowing out social protection in Australia and New Zealand. Social Policy and Administration 47(6): 623–646.

76.

Yang

(2019) The War on Normal People: The Truth about America’s Disappearing Jobs and Why Universal Basic Income Is Our Future. New York: Hachette Book Group.

77.

Yeend

(2009) Reforms to Pensions. Budget Review 2009/10: Welfare Payments. Canberra: Australian Parliamentary Library. Available at: https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/pubs/rp/BudgetReview200910/WelfarePensionReforms (accessed 20 May 2020).